Thread: Purgatory: Syria and the U.K. Parliament Board: Limbo / Ship of Fools.


To visit this thread, use this URL:
http://forum.ship-of-fools.com/cgi-bin/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic;f=11;t=001303

Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
I thought this was worth a separate thread.

This article gives some of the background.

Historically, the other smaller parties have been opposed to any extension of the bombing so Cameron probably needs some Labour support. It looks as though he may have persuaded a majority in the Labour Shadow Cabinet.

Has he also persuaded Shipmates? What might all this mean for the Labour Party and the Corbyn leadership? Some big questions there. I'd be interested in your opinions.

[ 16. May 2016, 08:12: Message edited by: Barnabas62 ]
 
Posted by Dave W. (# 8765) on :
 
I'm puzzled - why does he need Labour, or any other party? I thought the Conservatives just won an absolute majority; is this sort of thing usually a free vote, so that he needs replacements for expected Conservative defectors?
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
Ultimately the enemy is jihadist islam, and that's an idea. Daesh are simply one of the manifestations of that idea. It's possible to defeat Daesh with bombs and bullets (though, probably not by airstrikes alone), but bombs and bullets can't defeat an idea. Even more so when part of that idea is that non-Islamic powers will attempt to defeat Islam using military force. Continuously gifting jaihadist islamicists with proof that they are right is not a particularly effective way of proving them wrong!
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Dave W.:
I'm puzzled - why does he need Labour, or any other party? I thought the Conservatives just won an absolute majority; is this sort of thing usually a free vote, so that he needs replacements for expected Conservative defectors?

He's expecting a lot of Conservatives to vote against air strikes in Syria, he had a lot last time it went to the vote. So, he needs Labour support to reach a majority. I think he could technically force his MPs to support him, but he's seeking to establish unquestionable Parliamentary support so a free vote would be better for that, cross party support and a large majority even better.
 
Posted by Arethosemyfeet (# 17047) on :
 
Bombing thousands of innocent people is not an appropriate response to the shooting of dozens of innocent people. It will not improve the situation in Syria. It will not reduce the likelihood of attacks outside Syria. It might make people feel better for a while. "Doing something" usually feels good, regardless of the consequences. People ought to listen to Jeremy Corbyn on this one: he's got a strong track record of being right in this area.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
In terms of UK politics. Cameron's presentation of the case was effective. He adopted a completely different approach to Tony Blai when the latter was making the case for going into Iraq. As well as persuading many in the Labour Shafow Cabinet (including, significantly, Shadow Foreign Secretary Hillary Benn) he has won over some of the doubters and anti votes In his own party.

I'm no DC fan but I think it was one of his best speeches in the House. Amongst other parts of his case, he made the point that since IS do not respect the Syrian border and have in effect annexed part of Syria, there seems no logic in the House accepting the bombing of IS targets in Iraq (which it already has) but not Syria. That's pretty hard to argue against except by arguing against any military intervention against IS in the region. And he responded calmly and respectfully to Jeremy Corbyn's probing questions.

In terms of necessary vote winning he's probably already done enough. Since JC has always voted his conscience on such matters in the past and since an insistence on unanimous Shadow Cabinet support seems likely to cause several resignations, he seems to have no option but to allow a free vote for Labour MPs. I think that Corbyn still represents the majority view amongst Labour supporters in the UK. But Paris and its implications may be changing opinions.

Hillary Benn describes Cameron's arguments as 'compelling'. That's a remarkable statement from the Shadow Foreign Secretary, a man who has earned a lot of respect within the Labour Party for his previous service.

My instincts are that, despite all this, JC may be right both in principle and in practice. But I found much of what Cameron said to be compelling as well.
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
The difference between Iraq and Syria is boots on the ground.

In Iraq the air strikes are in support of the Iraqi government in their fight against Daesh. There is no suggestion that air strikes in Syria will be in support of the Syrian government in their fight against Daesh, instead there was mention of 70,000 moderate fighters - presumably the National Coalition and Kurdish rebels, who are also engaged in a war against the Syrian government and getting bombed by the Russians.

The argument that it's just an extension of the operations in Iraq would be much stronger if a) operations in Iraq were making significant headway and b) there was a significant military force on the ground in Syria. The Iraqi army may not be the best equipped or trained, but they are better equipped and trained than the rebels in Syria and are also not engaged in other actions (including dodging Russian bombs). If they can't make significant headway against Daesh, why should we expect that the same tactic will work in Syria?
 
Posted by Baptist Trainfan (# 15128) on :
 
I heard quite a large chunk of the speech on Radio 4 and, although I am still highly dubious about military action, I think that Barnabas has reported it very accurately.
 
Posted by Doc Tor (# 9748) on :
 
I was attempting to explain the situation to my kids last night, and tried to get them to work out who we're supposed to be bombing.

Assad. He ran a brutal police state, and since the war started, he's slaughtered his way through his own civilian population.

Daesh. They run a brutal Sunni theocratic state, slaughtering their way through their own civilian population.

Hezbollah. They're on Assad's side as a Shia paramilitary force, but they're a known terrorist organisation with strong links to Iran.

Kurds. While we all tend to think of the Kurds as friendly peshmurga irregulars defending their homes against the ravages of Assad and Daesh, Turkey's experience with the PKK tells another story. And Turkey is our NATO ally. And do we honestly think that the territory seized by Iraqi Kurds in Syria - nothing short of an invasion - will be handed back?

Al-Nusra. Technically still an arm of al-Qaeda, but composed mainly of Syrian Sunnis. They started off fighting Assad, but have branched out into attacking both Daesh and the Kurds (the latter allegedly supported by Turkey).

Free Syrian Army. Who?

From where I am, that looks like a big bag of Nope.
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
Despite a serious shake to my pacifist convictions, I still conclude that retaliation from the French pain is unlikely to give the result we all want - ie the banishment of IS.

First, we can't even agree on who exactly the enemy is. The French ambassador on the radio earlier seemed to be open to the possibility of co-operating with the Syrian regime army. The Russians are clearly bombing anyone who is a threat to Assads forces. The British-USAmerican-Whoeverelse coalition a while ago saw Assad as the threat, today seem ambivalent about him.

Second we can't see a real end point. Say raise the IS strongholds to the ground. Are the militants going to respect national boundaries and give up? What happens if they move some place else? Are we giving carte blanche permission for the military to blow them up wherever they go (eg in Lebanon even Turkey..?)

Third, bombing targets in the Middle East is unlikely to stop terrorists in Belgium and France. How are we imagining that this would work?

Fourth, bombing from a great height is not going to save the lives of Christians and other minorities suffering under IS, it is just going to kill them more quickly.

Fifth, this is my fucking taxmoney you are spending, Cameron. You can't fund hospitals and old people's homes, but you can fund £millions on another war in the Middle East? Prat.

Sixth, there are plenty of other Western countries who seem to manage not to get into expensive military campaigns every few years. Why can't we be like them? Why have we got to be the ones who shell out money for perceptual war?

I don't trust you, I don't trust your cronies. No, you don't go on this desperate unwinnable military campaign in my name.
 
Posted by Ricardus (# 8757) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doc Tor:

Kurds. While we all tend to think of the Kurds as friendly peshmurga irregulars defending their homes against the ravages of Assad and Daesh, Turkey's experience with the PKK tells another story. And Turkey is our NATO ally. And do we honestly think that the territory seized by Iraqi Kurds in Syria - nothing short of an invasion - will be handed back?

My understanding was that even in Iraq the Kurds are reluctant to fight outside of what they consider to be Kurdish territory. If so, they aren't likely to want to be 'our' boots on the ground for the non-Kurdish parts of Syria.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
Doc Tor's position is pretty much the one Dennis Skinner adopted. "It's an unholy mess and we should stay out of it".

In practice that means "let the winner emerge and deal with whoever that will be". A classic old fashioned Foreign Office stance. But of course Hillary Benn knows that. So I think the considered diplomatic view must be that IS represents an exception. Intervention looks a crappy option but non intervention looks even crappier.

I'm guessing that on the basis of current security information, IS cannot be allowed to grow stronger because of the strategic danger this represents. Hence the present view.
 
Posted by chris stiles (# 12641) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Ricardus:
My understanding was that even in Iraq the Kurds are reluctant to fight outside of what they consider to be Kurdish territory. If so, they aren't likely to want to be 'our' boots on the ground for the non-Kurdish parts of Syria.

This also applies to a large extent to the FSA - whose primary aim is overthrowing Assad - so unclear how willing they are likely to be to take on ISIS. Leaving aside for a moment the probably ludicrous claim that there are 70K of them.

Unlike Barnabas I didn't find DC particularly convincing. I've long thought that people think his speaking is more effective than it is because of the particular cadences he adopts. Imagine reading the same words and the spell disappears.
 
Posted by Doc Tor (# 9748) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
Intervention looks a crappy option but non intervention looks even crappier.

If this is the case, then a further argument needs to be made: why should the UK intervene in what is essentially another outbreak of Sunni/Shia communal violence, aided and abetted by the Gulf states on one hand, and Iran on the other?

Wouldn't it be far better for both them and us to facilitate peace talks between Assad/Hezbollah/Iran, ISIS/Saudi Arabia/Qatar, and Kurds/Iraq, while remaining neutral?
 
Posted by LeRoc (# 3216) on :
 
quote:
Barnabas62: Intervention looks a crappy option but non intervention looks even crappier.
This assumes there is only one way to intervene.
 
Posted by Anglican't (# 15292) on :
 
How might the UK go about facilitating peace talks involving the Islamic State?
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doc Tor:
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
Intervention looks a crappy option but non intervention looks even crappier.

If this is the case, then a further argument needs to be made: why should the UK intervene in what is essentially another outbreak of Sunni/Shia communal violence, aided and abetted by the Gulf states on one hand, and Iran on the other?

Wouldn't it be far better for both them and us to facilitate peace talks between Assad/Hezbollah/Iran, ISIS/Saudi Arabia/Qatar, and Kurds/Iraq, while remaining neutral?

Yes, I thought that Cameron glossed over a lot of stuff, and some of his arguments smacked of a sexed up dossier.

For example, the 70, 000 friendly fighters, who are just waiting the go-ahead to fight IS. Really?

Any talk of a peace deal has to face the fact that Russia (and Hezbollah) are trying to destroy rebel forces, so that Assad can expand his territory.

So is this what peace means? Hezbollah destroying Sunni villages? This is what gives IS an attraction to some Sunni tribes, after all.

Meanwhile the Saudis continue to bomb Yemen, and Turkey bombs the Kurds. It's like a mad surreal fantasy film, Mad Max meets Dr Strangelove.

I suppose it's good for Cameron's prestige, unless it goes pear-shaped.
 
Posted by chris stiles (# 12641) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by quetzalcoatl:

For example, the 70, 000 friendly fighters, who are just waiting the go-ahead to fight IS. Really?

Furthermore, those possibly hypothetical 70K fighters are part of a group (the FSA) which has in the past allied with ISIS to fight the Kurds:

http://in.mobile.reuters.com/article/idINL5N0HM3M220130926
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
Here is a possible peace deal - smash the Sunni villages, which have been harbouring IS, then the Syrian army and Hezbollah move north, killing everything in their path. What could go wrong?
 
Posted by L'organist (# 17338) on :
 
posted by Anglican't
quote:
How might the UK go about facilitating peace talks involving the Islamic State?
There is no way the UK, or anyone else, can "facilitate" anything with the daesh; its quaintly Brit and CofE of you to suggest it but it really isn't an option.

In the arab world the suggestion was floated at the end of 2014 that Saudi Arabia or one of the more conservative gulf states might act as a broker but the answer came straight back that, after the kuffar west,Israel, Shia and other "wrong" muslim sects, the Saudis were in the firing line because of the perceived way of life of its ruling family and what daesh sees (correctly in some instances) as the commercialisation of the Haj and the holy sites in Mecca and Medina.

The daesh believe that their caliphate is the one true expression of islam - which is, of course, a way of life rather than a religion - and that everywhere and everyone else is impure and to either be wiped out or, if they're already Sunni, made to repent and conform to the daesh view of islam.

I don't get this view from the semi-vaccuum of UK news outlets but from speaking to arab and Iranian friends: the Iranians, in particular, are very worried about the emergence of daesh which they (IMO correctly) see as a global threat. With the increasingly radicalised Pakistani population, Iran is right in the middle of daesh and one of its most likely sources of supporters and troops, if they make an appeal to their fellow muslims to help fight the great Satan of the US, Russia and the west. Death holds no fears for the daesh and they view the possible coming of Armageddon with enthusiasm. If you require evidence of this, look no further than the name they have chosen for their online magazine: Dabiq, which is the sight of the islamic Armageddon. And in real life they're getting very close to gaining possession of Dabiq.

[ 27. November 2015, 11:00: Message edited by: L'organist ]
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
I'm pretty sure that Cameron has avoided sexing up like the plague. He's seen Blair's poisonous legacy and won't want that. The real problem in risk evaluation, as usual, is the extent to which you can stick the information in the public domain. That issue is always double-edged.

LeRoc, what form of non-military intervention did you have in mind? The UN resolution talked about 'all possible means'. IS is an insurrection, not a country.
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
I think it's correct that Iran is politically very concerned about IS. However, their proxy force in this fight is Hezbollah, and I think that the prospect of Hezbollah fighters advancing on Sunni villages and tribes will produce mass panic, and mass recruitment to IS.

Isn't this a danger with Cameron's position? He is suggesting pouring more violence into a very complex situation with unpredictable consequences.

After all, Al Qaeda appeared to be demolished in Iraq, but various political events ended up with Sunni tribes turning to IS, partly as a defence against - Iranian backed militias.
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
Aren't the bombs for public opinion? Two years ago, Cameron wanted to bomb Assad, now the other side. We need to be seen to be doing something - FFS, just bomb somebody.
 
Posted by Sioni Sais (# 5713) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by LeRoc:
quote:
Barnabas62: Intervention looks a crappy option but non intervention looks even crappier.
This assumes there is only one way to intervene.
Moreover, if we do intervene on who's behalf do we do so, and against whom? This is as messy as Somalia back in the 'nineties and a lot worse than the Lebanon from 1975 onwards. In the latter there were some political stances that occassionally made negotiation possible.

In Syria we haven't got that. The two bodies with de facto credibility are Syria under Assad and Daesh. Everyone else, especially western air forces, are bit part players.

AFAICS the air strikes ordered by President Hollande were gestures of revenge and those Cameron wants to carry out are no better (or worse). If we go ahead then "Bomb Daesh" isn't enough. There has to be an objective beyond bodies, ruins and yet more people fleeing the region. Russia at least does appear to have some kind of strategy, even if we don't like it.
 
Posted by Doc Tor (# 9748) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Anglican't:
How might the UK go about facilitating peace talks involving the Islamic State?

Through the UN.

I agree that, at this stage, it's all a bit unlikely. But it's actually more likely than being able to pick a side in this fight who aren't utterly repugnant, the result of which is going to bite us in the arse within a couple of years and mean we have to do the whole thing again.

Whatever happens, we're never going to 'win'. We can defeat Daesh militarily, and then all their fighters disperse across the ME and Europe. We can support the Kurds' annexation of northern Iraq, Syria and southern Turkey. We can back Assad and let him butcher every Sunni left in Syria. We can back the al-Qaeda affiliate, al-Nusra and hope they take out Assad. We can let Daesh wipe out the FSA and the Kurds.

Or we can bomb them all. We have the capability to do that.
 
Posted by Anglican't (# 15292) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by L'organist:
posted by Anglican't
quote:
How might the UK go about facilitating peace talks involving the Islamic State?
There is no way the UK, or anyone else, can "facilitate" anything with the daesh; its quaintly Brit and CofE of you to suggest it but it really isn't an option.

Sorry, to be clear, I was replying to this comment:

quote:
Originally posted by Doc Tor:
Wouldn't it be far better for both them and us to facilitate peace talks between Assad/Hezbollah/Iran, ISIS/Saudi Arabia/Qatar, and Kurds/Iraq, while remaining neutral?

But another post got in the way and that might have confused things. I agree, I can't see how we could (hence the question).
 
Posted by Sioni Sais (# 5713) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doc Tor:


Or we can bomb them all. We have the capability to do that.

We, the British, don't. Although there are over a hundred Tornadoes on the RAF's strength maybe twenty are combat ready. They really are getting on now and the new Typhoon jets aren't fully bombing capable yet.

I think there are just eight Tornadoes at RAF Akrotiri, on Cyprus, which is a few minutes from the targets. The MoD recently changed the published stats regarding serviceability and anything that can be pushed into the air by robbing parts from other aircraft is deemed fit for service. The problem is that you run out of planes to rob parts from very quickly.
 
Posted by Marvin the Martian (# 4360) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doc Tor:
quote:
Originally posted by Anglican't:
How might the UK go about facilitating peace talks involving the Islamic State?

Through the UN.
ISIS don't recognise the UN, national borders or peace treaties, as to do so would be to admit to there being an authority other than Allah.

Their doctrine is such that they literally cannot enter into peace talks. By their own definition, the moment they enter such talks they lose their legitimacy as a caliphate.
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doc Tor:
quote:
Originally posted by Anglican't:
How might the UK go about facilitating peace talks involving the Islamic State?

Through the UN.

I agree that, at this stage, it's all a bit unlikely. But it's actually more likely than being able to pick a side in this fight who aren't utterly repugnant, the result of which is going to bite us in the arse within a couple of years and mean we have to do the whole thing again.

Whatever happens, we're never going to 'win'. We can defeat Daesh militarily, and then all their fighters disperse across the ME and Europe. We can support the Kurds' annexation of northern Iraq, Syria and southern Turkey. We can back Assad and let him butcher every Sunni left in Syria. We can back the al-Qaeda affiliate, al-Nusra and hope they take out Assad. We can let Daesh wipe out the FSA and the Kurds.

Or we can bomb them all. We have the capability to do that.

There are rumours of US backing for al-Nusra, I suppose it's a bit like Afghanistan.

I get the impression of a truck driving along a rocky road, loaded with gelignite, and Cameron thought, hallo, I can add to that, let's toss some more gelignite in. But it's Churchillian!
 
Posted by Enoch (# 14322) on :
 
To summarise from Wikipaedia these are the preconditions to make a war just.
quote:

1. The damage inflicted by the aggressor on the nation or community of nations must be lasting, grave, and certain;

2. All other means of putting an end to it must have been shown to be impractical or ineffective;

3. There must be serious prospects of success;

4. The use of arms must not produce evils and disorders graver than the evil to be eliminated (the power of modern means of destruction weighs very heavily in evaluating this condition).

Even those who don't accept the theology have to accept the wisdom of those preconditions.

At the moment even with Daesh, or whatever it calls itself this week, only two of those preconditions, 1 and 2 have been met. 3 and 4 have not, and are not likely to be.

Yes, we all want to stick up for the French. But the reaction so far has been 'Something must be done - so we must do something, anything'.

The only faction in Syria that has anything to be said in its justification is the Kurds, who have a more or less unanswerable claim that they should be given their own country. But nobody is going to support them because the Turks are in NATO and the Persians are too dangerous to upset.

There are no free, democratic good guys who stand for the Arab Spring. It is an illusion that there ever were, and there certainly aren't now.

Assad's regime, heavy and oppressive though it originally was, was better than anything that has emerged anywhere in Syria since. But does it rule over an enclave of normality now? No. Unfortunately, the more the civil war has progressed, the more it's in hock to bloodthirsty thugs like all the other factions.

Dropping lots of bombs from a great height may give us the good feeling that we are avenging the French, but what is it capable of achieving? When, in recent years, has it delivered any result? It did a lot of damage in Serbia. It destroyed some bridges and it killed people. But did it contribute in any way at all to the fact that things are good there now? No it didn't.

So that doesn't meet test 3, and never will. There's next to no likelihood that it will meet test 4 either. It just makes our politicians feel good. 'Something must be done'; so 'we have done something'.

Perhaps 90 years ago, tests 3 and 4 could have been met by a joint force of 'civilised nations' going in, pacifying the area and setting up a colonial regime there under a League of Nations Mandate. O, but, except for the mandate, our leaders did that in Iraq. That is the delusion our leaders are under. Iraq is proof that the days for that sort of thing are long past.

The French and us should have learnt that in 1956. The US should have learnt that in 1975. The Russians should have learnt that in 1989.

Tests 3 and 4 can only be met if there's a local faction on the ground that one can support to win, who with that sort of support are likely to be able to deliver the re-creation of a civilised state. Unpalatable though this might be, the Russians have at least been consistently realistic in backing the Syrian government. I realise that is distasteful to most of the West, and that they have not been doing this for altruistic reasons. Alas, though the time when that might have been a just about hopeful solution is long past. Under the pressure of civil war, the Syrian government has become too nasty. Besides, it doesn't appear to have much prospect of winning.

Daesh is so repulsive that, for all the human unacceptability that would involve, its destruction and eradication could perhaps meet test 4, but only if it was total. Otherwise, it would be like giving bacteria only enough antibiotics to enable them to become resistant to them. Anyway, there isn't a way of doing that which meets test 3.

So what option is there that would be capable of meeting test 3 and 4. If there is one, I can't see it. So if I was an MP, I would vote no.
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Marvin the Martian:
quote:
Originally posted by Doc Tor:
quote:
Originally posted by Anglican't:
How might the UK go about facilitating peace talks involving the Islamic State?

Through the UN.
ISIS don't recognise the UN, national borders or peace treaties, as to do so would be to admit to there being an authority other than Allah.

Their doctrine is such that they literally cannot enter into peace talks. By their own definition, the moment they enter such talks they lose their legitimacy as a caliphate.

But the Sunni tribes currently supporting IS, are probably amenable to various inducements to renounce them. This happened in Iraq with al Qaeda, who were defeated by the Awakening.

Of course, the Iraqui govt then fucked up, leading to the tribes turning to IS.

But I would guess that the IS power base is fragile - trouble is, faced with the prospect of the Syrian army and Hezbollah on the rampage, IS will seem necessary as a defence.
 
Posted by Sioni Sais (# 5713) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by quetzalcoatl:

I get the impression of a truck driving along a rocky road, loaded with gelignite, and Cameron thought, hallo, I can add to that, let's toss some more gelignite in. But it's Churchillian!

Let's not have anything even remotely "Churchillian" within a thousand miles of Turkey. Remember Gallipoli was his idea.
 
Posted by Doc Tor (# 9748) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Marvin the Martian:
Their doctrine is such that they literally cannot enter into peace talks. By their own definition, the moment they enter such talks they lose their legitimacy as a caliphate.

Everyone comes to the table in the end. In the meantime, Daesh are just one of the protagonists. There are other factions we can talk to, including our alleged allies in the Gulf.
 
Posted by Boogie (# 13538) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Enoch:
So if I was an MP, I would vote no.

So would I.

What are the chances Cameron will get this through?
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Boogie:
quote:
Originally posted by Enoch:
So if I was an MP, I would vote no.

So would I.

What are the chances Cameron will get this through?

Looking promising. Right wing Labourites have fond memories of Blair, and '45 minutes', how can they resist Cameron and '70,000 friendly fighters waiting for us in Syria'?
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doc Tor:
quote:
Originally posted by Marvin the Martian:
Their doctrine is such that they literally cannot enter into peace talks. By their own definition, the moment they enter such talks they lose their legitimacy as a caliphate.

Everyone comes to the table in the end. In the meantime, Daesh are just one of the protagonists. There are other factions we can talk to, including our alleged allies in the Gulf.
The US did plenty of negotiations with Sunni tribes and leaders in Iraq, and it paid off for a while, with the Awakening. Alas, the Iraqui govt had a stupid, hence IS seemed very attractive to the tribes. The danger is, it could happen all over again, if Russia releases the Syrian army and Hezbollah.
 
Posted by Sioni Sais (# 5713) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by quetzalcoatl:
quote:
Originally posted by Boogie:
quote:
Originally posted by Enoch:
So if I was an MP, I would vote no.

So would I.

What are the chances Cameron will get this through?

Looking promising. Right wing Labourites have fond memories of Blair, and '45 minutes', how can they resist Cameron and '70,000 friendly fighters waiting for us in Syria'?
If Cameron thinks he has any influence over those "70,000 friendly fighters" he is a dangerous fool (I'm trying not to be Hellish here).
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
Yeah, but would Churchill have done?
 
Posted by Pottage (# 9529) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doc Tor:
quote:
Originally posted by Marvin the Martian:
Their doctrine is such that they literally cannot enter into peace talks. By their own definition, the moment they enter such talks they lose their legitimacy as a caliphate.

Everyone comes to the table in the end. In the meantime, Daesh are just one of the protagonists. There are other factions we can talk to, including our alleged allies in the Gulf.
IS may be an exception to the notion that everyone will negotiate in the end, even if we were prepared just to stick the UN mandate for action on the shelf and do noting for an indeterminate time whilst someone (who?) tries to engage them in discussion.

They don't recognise the UN, or the sovereignty or authority of any state or institution (Muslim or otherwise), or the moral worth of anyone who doesn't share their aims and subscribe very precisely to their own brand of Islam. As a group their principal aim is to convert, kill or enslave everyone else on earth, or die trying. As individuals, they don't take prisoners (slaves, yes, sometimes), nor do they expect to surrender.

They draw their strength, and to quite a large extent their ability to recruit, from the fact of having declared their caliphate and held on to it in the face of opposition from the rest of the world. As long as they continue to hold their territory, and within their land are able to exhibit the trappings of statehood, their ability to recruit fighters and supporters will remain.

That's what makes it supportable to attack them on all fronts, in cyberspace, economically and by degrading their strength and eating away at their territory in any way possible, even without a clear idea of how that will end. Creating a grand alliance of ground forces from across the world to sweep them away at whatever cost is not possible, whereas supporting the Kurds, the Iraqi government and, potentially, some of the Syrian factions (probably far fewer than 70,000 strong, to be sure) are all possible courses of action. An air campaign is also possible. Conducting that campaign in Iraqi territory but not Syrian is perverse. IS don't recognise the border, nor indeed do many of the other people who live (or sadly in most cases, lived) in that area.
 
Posted by Sioni Sais (# 5713) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by quetzalcoatl:
Yeah, but would Churchill have done?

(re influence over 70,000 "friendly fighters")

Churchill is NOT a good precedent, especially in that region. We could find this "friendliness" very short-lived.
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
An interesting point about troop numbers, there are estimates that the US had 170, 000 troops in Iraq, and struggled against an insurgency probably smaller than IS.

Of course, IS may well not fight in house to house fashion, but may retreat in guerilla fashion. There are reports already that most have left Raqqa.

Don't worry, Dave knows where they are.
 
Posted by lowlands_boy (# 12497) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Pottage:
<snip>
They don't recognise the UN, or the sovereignty or authority of any state or institution (Muslim or otherwise), or the moral worth of anyone who doesn't share their aims and subscribe very precisely to their own brand of Islam. As a group their principal aim is to convert, kill or enslave everyone else on earth, or die trying. As individuals, they don't take prisoners (slaves, yes, sometimes), nor do they expect to surrender.
</snip>

I've also read that they intend to expand their territory to all land that they perceive to be allotted to Muslims. They also say that the west suffer retaliation because of their attacks on Muslims.

So, if we just leave them to it, what happens? Apart from to the oil supply, obviously....
 
Posted by Doc Tor (# 9748) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by lowlands_boy:
So, if we just leave them to it, what happens? Apart from to the oil supply, obviously....

That's an interesting question. And since we buy oil from the Saudis, we'll buy it from Daesh.
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
A cynical view is that Cameron knows that British bombing won't make any difference, he knows that the 70,000 friendly fighters are a mirage, but he wants bombing as a symbolic act and to give prestige to the UK govt. I suppose that's normal politics really, but you can't be too honest about it.
 
Posted by hatless (# 3365) on :
 
Other than the argument that we should join in with France and others, I'm still waiting to hear a reason to bomb Syria. Politicians, most recently Tom Watson, say they believe there is an imminent security threat to this country as if that was a reason, but it's several steps short as far as I can see.

How is bombing Syria going to prevent an attack?

Why is there no discussion of alternatives?

I seem to be in the presence of people making a choice from a menu, asking each other what they are going to have, and wondering what the choice they make will look like to others. Reasons? Arguments? Evaluating options? Nowhere in sight.
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
Some politicians are sincere, but I think there is a lot of fake stuff going on. Bombing won't solve a thing, there are no serious ground troops, but we must do something! Public opinion demands it, (but does it?).

We could bomb Brussels.

[ 27. November 2015, 15:51: Message edited by: quetzalcoatl ]
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
Alternatively, Cameron wants to be at the big boys' meetings, but to get in, you need a military hard-on. Whether or not it actually does anything is irrelevant. Fake it.
 
Posted by alienfromzog (# 5327) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doc Tor:
I was attempting to explain the situation to my kids last night, and tried to get them to work out who we're supposed to be bombing.

Assad. He ran a brutal police state, and since the war started, he's slaughtered his way through his own civilian population.

Daesh. They run a brutal Sunni theocratic state, slaughtering their way through their own civilian population.

Hezbollah. They're on Assad's side as a Shia paramilitary force, but they're a known terrorist organisation with strong links to Iran.

Kurds. While we all tend to think of the Kurds as friendly peshmurga irregulars defending their homes against the ravages of Assad and Daesh, Turkey's experience with the PKK tells another story. And Turkey is our NATO ally. And do we honestly think that the territory seized by Iraqi Kurds in Syria - nothing short of an invasion - will be handed back?

Al-Nusra. Technically still an arm of al-Qaeda, but composed mainly of Syrian Sunnis. They started off fighting Assad, but have branched out into attacking both Daesh and the Kurds (the latter allegedly supported by Turkey).

Free Syrian Army. Who?

From where I am, that looks like a big bag of Nope.

Good analysis. Did you spot the irony here, that in these terms the invasion of Iraq makes much more sense?

Aim: To remove Saddam Hussein.
Plan: Invade Iraq and remove Saddam.

Job done. Now, you may have noticed I've stepped over the legality and wisdom issues here, but you see my point.

Syria:
Aim: To stop horrible things happening
Plan: Drop bombs and hope that the least worst side wins.

BTW, Alan's point above about how IS (or whichever term you prefer) can turn any Western attack into a recruitment drive by characterising it as an attack on Islam is critical. For me the great mistake in Iraq was not going in (I think that ulitmately some sort of confrontation would have happened eventually... I don't expect this view to be popular). The mistake was having no credible plan for what next. In fact, having a plan that was woefully inadequate and down-right stupid.

Syria is even worse because, even the initial idea has no credible acheivable end point.

I do think a lot of this is macho posturing by DC.

The logic seems to be this:

1. This is terrible something must be done
2. This [bombing] is something
Therefore we must do this.[bombing].

I won't bother to deconstruct that here.

The other issue for me is the absolute obsession we in the west have with air-strikes. I know why, it minimises the risk to our own people. I'm all for not putting our service men and women in danger but. But, the collateral damage that we do not avoid is many dead civilians. There is a moral difference between them who deliberately kill civilians and us who only do it accidently. However, the gap is much, much, much smaller than we keep telling ourselves it is.

So my problems with this plan is 1)It's pretty shaking morally- unless we are really very specific in our targetting and 2)it is completely ridiculous strategically. I'm not saying we shouldn't use our military against terrorist organisations, just that we need a good plan rather than an idiotic one.

AFZ
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
Yes, basically there is no plan. The idea of 70, 000 friendly fighters is so absurd, that no-one is taking it seriously, especially in Syria. Friendly fighters tend to disappear with their weapons to join the militants.

I think Cameron knows there is no plan, but he's good at faking. Or is he?
 
Posted by Albertus (# 13356) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Enoch:
...if there's a local faction on the ground that one can support to win, who with that sort of support are likely to be able to deliver the re-creation of a civilised state. Unpalatable though this might be, the Russians have at least been consistently realistic in backing the Syrian government. I realise that is distasteful to most of the West, and that they have not been doing this for altruistic reasons. Alas, though the time when that might have been a just about hopeful solution is long past. Under the pressure of civil war, the Syrian government has become too nasty. Besides, it doesn't appear to have much prospect of winning...

Yup. With the luxury of hindsight, even if we weren't actually going to support the Syrian government (why BTW do the BBC etc always call it 'the regime'? Whatever we think of it, it's still the recognised government of Syria, isn't it?)when the rebellion started back in 2011, we should have stayed aside and not given any suipport to the rebels. I hope, though not with muich confidence, that we've now learned that some kind of effective government in place is almost always to be preferred to the alternative, unless the alternative is very well organised and well resourced and well thought through and in general likely to succeed in establishing itself as an effective government quickly.
 
Posted by Enoch (# 14322) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Albertus:
Yup. With the luxury of hindsight, even if we weren't actually going to support the Syrian government (why BTW do the BBC etc always call it 'the regime'? Whatever we think of it, it's still the recognised government of Syria, isn't it?)when the rebellion started back in 2011, we should have stayed aside and not given any suipport to the rebels. I hope, though not with muich confidence, that we've now learned that some kind of effective government in place is almost always to be preferred to the alternative, unless the alternative is very well organised and well resourced and well thought through and in general likely to succeed in establishing itself as an effective government quickly.

Not quite the luxury of hindsight. I was saying that right from the start. But I don't move in the sort of circles where my opinion has much value.
 
Posted by chris stiles (# 12641) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Albertus:

Yup. With the luxury of hindsight, even if we weren't actually going to support the Syrian government (why BTW do the BBC etc always call it 'the regime'?

Since you invoke hindsight; afaict the only intervention in the Middle East that has actually 'worked' (and we still don't know the end game), is the time 'we' helped the Bahrani regime crush reform movement over there whilst it was in its infancy.

In any other area of government, if a policy had this kind of track record of failure we'd consider anyone suggesting it to be deluded or a dangerous lunatic.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Anglican't:
How might the UK go about facilitating peace talks involving the Islamic State?

Well at the begining of the Afghan war people went on about the how the brutality of the Taliban meaning we couldn't negotiate with them. Eventually we did, how was that negotiation achieved and can we learn anything from it ?
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
Chatham house commentator on radio 4 today was agreeing with the estimate of 70,000 fighters whoare non-ISIS non-Assad being in Syria - but not as a coherent armed force. Which is, I think, and important difference with Iraq.

As regards what ISIS believes - it is worth bearing in mind that many of the foot soldiers have not joined because they are salafi extremists but for entirely different reasons. Ultimately this disconnect may be the fault line that can be used to break ISIS.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
I strongly recommend reading this:

http://www.thenation.com/article/what-i-discovered-from-interviewing-isis-prisoners/
 
Posted by Stetson (# 9597) on :
 
Albertus wrote:

quote:
(why BTW do the BBC etc always call it 'the regime'? Whatever we think of it, it's still the recognised government of Syria, isn't it?)
Well, if that were the criteria, than the word "regime" could probably be retired from political discussion, since almost every government that wears the label is a recognized one.

Which might be a good thing, as "regime" is one of those words that people use to make themselves sound objective, when they're really trying to pass a moral judgement. The authoritarian thugs we like are a government; the ones we don't are a regime.

I agree it was a stupid idea to align with opponents of the Assad government.

[ 27. November 2015, 19:49: Message edited by: Stetson ]
 
Posted by Enoch (# 14322) on :
 
Even if they do exist, and I heard that commentator, I thought nothing he said was anything more than plausible wishful thinking by someone who had sympathies with one faction in the area.

But even if what he said had been true, not-being-Assad and not-being-ISIS doesn't make you somebody any sane person would want to support or see succeed. The Taliban, Hezbollah, Al Qaeda and Hamas all pass both those tests. So for that matter, would both Janjaweed and the Khmer Rouge, though fortunately those aren't active in that part of the world.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
I agree with you entirely.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
Interestingly, Corbyn has just emailed the labour membership canvassing their views on Syria.
 
Posted by Firenze (# 619) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doublethink.:
Interestingly, Corbyn has just emailed the labour membership canvassing their views on Syria.

And I have replied exhorting him to stick to his guns (so to speak). I had already emailed my MP asking him to support the Leader.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
And Deputy Labour Leader Tom Watson agrees with Hillary Benn about the 'compelling case'.

JC is not a mandated delegate, Doublethink. He's a party leader with a mandate to lead. I'm not impressed with the decision to email the membership. It's all Lombard Street to a China orange that the membership will back his stance as they did in principle when they elected him. Why does he need a further confirmation? And when he gets it, what will he do with it that he can't already do? Show the likes of Benn and Watson the door? That's not the way you lead a parliamentary party in a representative democracy. Representatives are not delegates.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
Indeed, but I suspect he wants to counteract the narrative that the voters have turned on a dime and suddenly want a war.

Also, he is getting shafted by the plp. I have responded to the canvas but also contacted my mp - to support the statement that mp has already made saying he will vote against.

What I would like is a free vote, in which the majority of labour mps (and the house as a whole) vote against.
 
Posted by Martin60 (# 368) on :
 
Posted on Facebook Doublethink, superb.
 
Posted by hatless (# 3365) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
And Deputy Labour Leader Tom Watson agrees with Hillary Benn about the 'compelling case'.

I wonder what it is.

I wonder why neither of them has told us what the compelling case is.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by hatless:
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
And Deputy Labour Leader Tom Watson agrees with Hillary Benn about the 'compelling case'.

I wonder what it is.

I wonder why neither of them has told us what the compelling case is.

Cameron's case and his response to questions is summarised well here

I'm not surprised that neither Tom Watson nor Hillary Benn have not yet gone into detail in public over why they find the case compelling. But I have no doubt that the arguments were rehearsed in the subsequent 2 hour Shadow Cabinet meeting,

The Shadow Cabinet members left that meeting agreeing to think things over and meet again to try and find a response which they could sign up to collectively. That might still happen. Until that possibility is exhausted, I don't expect Benn or Watson to go into detail. They would want to save that either for the debate on a future House resolution or the prior abandonment by the Shadow Cabinet of the search for an agreed position.

And that is why Corbyn's appeal to the membership over the heads of the Shadow Cabinet has got him into further difficulty with the plp. He clearly did not win over his Shadow Cabinet to his position but has acted unilaterally before Shadow Cabinet discussions were exhausted.

My guess is that he judged that he was bound to lose in the further discussion and so struck first. That's not the way to look after collective Shadow Cabinet responsibility nor build confidence in his ability to lead the plp in the House. I think he acted precipitantly. I think he will pay for it.
 
Posted by hatless (# 3365) on :
 
There is obviously a battle between Corbyn and the PLP, and his canvassing of membership opinion can be seen as an over the heads tactic. But it is his one really good weapon, and it is what he has consistently done on all issues since his election.

I personally think it's a useful reminder to Benn, Watson and the other more traditional Labour MPs that they shouldn't forget that it was their brand of Tory-lite Labour that got them stuffed at the election.

The inability of Benn and Watson to give any reasons for wanting to support the Tory line of doing something, anything, is because, in my opinion, they are still doing the old thing of saying things that they hope will sound good.

I don't think it's Benn and Watson who are the pragmatists here. They are the strike a pose people, hoping to say what people might like to hear. As we slide towards war we need a very careful examination of arguments, not sly hints and posturing.

Cameron's case, as far as I can see is a big dollop of the 'something must be done' fallacy. There is a threat, lets hit some foreign folks. There is no realisation that the threat is largely internal, that anti-Western groups have already operated under a variety of umbrellas - al Qaeda, the Taliban, the Gadaffi's government, etc. - and should ISIS (or is that Islamic State or ISIL or daesh?) be defeated it will be little more than a name change.

And then Cameron analyses the situation in Syria and says that air support, skipping over the issue of which side we support, will work rather as it does in Iraq, although clearly not as successfully as there. Wow!

What about alternatives? I am not convinced that the economic squeeze on ISIS is happening. I am not convinced that the influence of othe Arab and other Islamic nations has been exerted fully.

And how about something really radical? How about a listening process! How about creating a platform for Islamic thinkers, political, religious and academic, to debate. How about a Western leaders visibly listening and learning from young Muslim men at home and abroad?

How many bombs would a statement from a Western leader that some of the Islamic critiques of the West have a point be worth? How much de-radicalising would be achieved by figures in Western society and our society as a whole listening to the voices of the unhappy and alienated? What mileage might there be in looking away from Syria and helping Islam to produce, I'm not sure where, one truly democratic, peaceful, prosperous model Islamic nation that could be an example and a witness to the world?
 
Posted by Baptist Trainfan (# 15128) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by hatless:
Cameron's case, as far as I can see is a big dollop of the 'something must be done' fallacy. There is a threat, lets hit some foreign folks. ...

And how about something really radical? How about a listening process! How about creating a platform for Islamic thinkers, political, religious and academic, to debate. How about a Western leaders visibly listening and learning from young Muslim men at home and abroad?

Yes. One has to understand what drives people to take the positions they hold - however abhorrent they may seem to us. Bombing them is only going to increase their senses of injustice or whatever. Having said that, like most Fundamentalists they are hardly amenable to reasoned debate.

[ 28. November 2015, 08:48: Message edited by: Baptist Trainfan ]
 
Posted by Enoch (# 14322) on :
 
This demonstrates the nonsense about assuming everyone believes a package. Some people do. One can predict what Nigel Farrage, George Monbiot or Jeremy Corbyn will think about virtually anything, without needing to wait until they've spouted.

I disagree with Corbyn on virtually everything. He represents many of the things I detest most in politicians. But on this one, he and I would vote the same way, though almost certainly for completely different reasons.


Anyway, the reason why Corbyn has written round the party members because he wants to bully his parliamentary party into knuckling under.

Either way, it's exposed a rift in the Labour Party which the rest of us have assumed was bound to happen sooner rather than later ever since Corbyn won the leadership role. If you don't let the parliamentary party choose who's going to lead them, what do you do if this results in the party members imposing on them a leader they can't work with and don't respect? And what does it mean when the MPs, elected only a few months ago, with all the effort and support of their local parties, now seem to be so out of kilter with what their party has suddenly decided they want in stead?
 
Posted by chris stiles (# 12641) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by hatless:

Cameron's case, as far as I can see is a big dollop of the 'something must be done' fallacy. There is a threat, lets hit some foreign folks.

And then Cameron analyses the situation in Syria and says that air support, skipping over the issue of which side we support, will work rather as it does in Iraq, although clearly not as successfully as there. Wow!

For an example of the kind of arguments deployed by the pro-bombing side, take a look at this article by Robin Lustig - who would presumably class himself as a realist:

http://lustigletter.blogspot.co.uk/2015/11/syria-why-i-am-reluctant-bomber.html

He admits that IS can't be defeated militarily. He concedes that the UK contribution would be tiny at best (especially at a time when the existing air forces frequently can't find targets to bomb), but nevertheless concludes that we should bomb the areas in which ISIS are operational anyway.

To be clear, the total numbers of active ISIS fighters is small relative to the civilian population of those areas in which they are active. Every time we do this we ensure that there are more pictures of dead babies circulating the broader middle east. I'm not sure strikes from the air are likely to achieve the kinds of aims that are being claimed.

On the topic of the PLP, one of the things the shadow cabinet had allegedly gone away to do was to consult with their constituents. I'm not entirely sure that there is a majority in this country in favor of military action.

[ 28. November 2015, 09:00: Message edited by: chris stiles ]
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
I don't understand that reasoning. Bombing Syria is not going to stop IS, but we should do it anyway. Oookay then.
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by hatless:
What mileage might there be in looking away from Syria and helping Islam to produce, I'm not sure where, one truly democratic, peaceful, prosperous model Islamic nation that could be an example and a witness to the world?

Tunisia is already a democracy. Morocco is a kingdom, but the current monarch is a social reformer although he's yet to turn over most of his authority to the elected parliament. Albania is recovering from communist government, but is now a fully fledged democracy in line for EU membership in due course. Further afield, Indonesia and Malaysia are moderate Islamic majority democracies.

None of them are perfect countries free of all religious strife. But, I'll challenge you to find any perfect nation. The UK certainly isn't without it's problems and troubled history.
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by chris stiles:
On the topic of the PLP, one of the things the shadow cabinet had allegedly gone away to do was to consult with their constituents. I'm not entirely sure that there is a majority in this country in favor of military action.

Which is also what Corbyn has done, except he's included the members of the party that elected him leader within his constituency as well as those who elected him MP. Which is fair enough, he holds that elected position to lead the Labour party not drag them kicking and screaming to somewhere they don't want to go.
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
And, in related news ...
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
I wouldn't even joke about blowing up Hopkins - nasty, pantomime witch that she is.

Personally I'd rather take heed of the inspired bit of passive aggression that invites her onto a panel and then in unison the audience turns to ignore her.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
It's Corbyn's Shadow Cabinet. Their appointments represent his first leadership decisions. He has to persuade them or coerce them or overrule them by authority first. So far as collective responsibility goes, it's up to them first. Including whether they stay or go. I'm a life long Labour supporter. This is an unholy mess.
 
Posted by L'organist (# 17338) on :
 
posted by doublethink
quote:
Interestingly, Corbyn has just emailed the labour membership canvassing their views on Syria.
And that sums up Jezza and why he is the wrong person in the wrong job.

He was elected as Leader - the clue is in the title. Either he is convinced of the virtues and correctness of his stance on Syria or he isn't: if convinced he has no need to 'consult' the paid-up members of the Labour Party.

Of course, we all know why he's done it: (a) because he realises that he's unlikely to carry the members of the PLP with him; and (b) its yet another sign that he is still firmly wedded to the ideal of political process he espoused as a schoolboy, and which has remained unchanged by either time or maturity.

To be blunt, there is little to be gained by bombing either Syria or Iraq: the only way to root out the daesh is through the hard slog of boots on the ground.

The problem is that unless it is done by fellow muslims then there will always be a constituency in the region who view any action by the 'west' against daesh as the jackbooting of crusader neo-imperialists. There are two credible armies in the region: those of Turkey and Israel, but Turkey is unlikely to do anything unless it feels its own border under direct threat, and even then they will be equally concerned to smash the PKK at the same time. As for letting the Israelis get involved ...

If Mr Corbyn is indeed serious about doing something constructive he should be promoting the cause of stopping the spread of Wahhabism from Saudi Arabia and speaking to people - such as the academics of the Al-Azhar university in Cairo - who might be prepared and able to mount arguments to persuade the Saudi royal family to reign in their fanatical clerics. The fact that JC is entirely silent on this shows how little grasp he has of the real politics behind the situation.
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by L'organist:
posted by doublethink
quote:
Interestingly, Corbyn has just emailed the labour membership canvassing their views on Syria.
And that sums up Jezza and why he is the wrong person in the wrong job.

He was elected as Leader - the clue is in the title.

Whereas, I would say that that is exactly why he's the right person in the right job. He's leader of the Labour Party, not dictator of the Labour Party. He has made his case against airstrikes, he has asked the party to follow him. If the party are not convinced then he's in a difficult position. Of course, as I've yet to see a convincing argument for bombing Daesh in Syria (least of all talk of a mythical army of 70,000 fighters - which, even if they exist, is inadequate to the task even with air support) I can't see Corbyn having difficulty convincing his party of his views.

Although my preference would be for Cameron, Corbyn, Robertson and Farron to issue a joint statement that this is an issue too important for party politics, that it would be a free vote, and instruct all MPs to canvass opinions from their constituents and consider the views expressed by all sides to make a decision they consider to be in the best interests of their constituents, the country and the international community.
 
Posted by Martin60 (# 368) on :
 
I've told Jeremy he MUST stay. Not resign under any circumstances. He MUST continue to be the voice of God, I'm sure and hope, he does NOT believe in, for a moment. And he must continue to do the impossible. Lead a parliamentary party that very mainly disagrees with him. Keep them AND his constantly proclaimed principles in tension together. He's the reason I joined the party and will leave it. Hilary and Tom and Chukwu aren't good enough. Diane and John are, but that's because they agree with Jeremy. Without Jeremy's lead as an apostle and prophet, the Party is gutted, heartless. He MUST stay and MUST submit to cabinet consensus under sufferance if necessary. But he MUST stay. Or Her Majesty will have no Most Loyal Opposition.

If Jeremy is taken out in a party coup, the flicker of Sonshine will go out of British public life. There is NONE in the publically perceived church. There is from the bottom up but the top can't see that far down. I was at a men's breakfast this morning, run by a former counter-terrorist officer, sitting next to a former DI. The wonderful main speaker was a transformed British Resistance and WORSE terrorist. Last night the soup kitchen was run by a still Tory former Hell's Angel enforcer. They are ALL totally against war.

My kinsman is selling a false prospectus, like Blair, based on a false dichotomy: we are NOT subcontracting our defence by refusing to bomb Raqqa, by weeping with Hollande but not accompanying him in that.

God bless Jeremy. And David therefore. And the RAF. And ISIS.

And it could all be swept out of our hands and get VERY scary indeed around Latakia.

(The problem is quadruple thinking Islamizing TURKEY. Therefore the CIA, the Saudis and therefore, of course, even though no they DIDN'T bring down the Twin Towers, Israel. All opposing an increasingly impotent, wounded and therefore more dangerous Russia. Anyone would think there's a Devil.)
 
Posted by Ariel (# 58) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by L'organist:
To be blunt, there is little to be gained by bombing either Syria or Iraq: the only way to root out the daesh is through the hard slog of boots on the ground.

The problem is that unless it is done by fellow muslims then there will always be a constituency in the region who view any action by the 'west' against daesh as the jackbooting of crusader neo-imperialists.

Precisely. We're already involved in bombing Iraq, and Daesh don't recognize borders. Air raids on Syria are a logical extension of ongoing operations, which may remove a few more buildings but won't help that much ultimately. It needs, as you said, boots on the ground: a force composed of professional soldiers from several countries.

That is no light matter and not something that should be done without very careful consideration (it's one of those "damned if you do, damned if you don't" decisions) but I can't see any other way of making it work.

As for Corbyn - send him back to the back-benches where he belongs. The man's clearly out of his depth, he won't improve with time, and he doesn't have what it takes to lead. I hope the MPs who disagree won't resign; it would just open the way for him to fill the vacancies with more people in his own mould.
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
At the moment there are airstrikes against Daesh in Iraq with ground troops from the Iraqi army. The progress at pushing Daesh back is very slow, with a far larger and better trained and equipped army on the ground than the "70,000 fighters" supposedly in Syria. At present, if military operations against Daesh are required, then it makes more sense to support the operations in Iraq. Daesh don't care about borders, so defeats in Iraq or Syria will be the same to them. We can fight Daesh that way without getting further into the mess in Syria. And, Cameron may not even need Commons support to do that as he already has a vote in favour of air strikes there.
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
And, as for Corbyn - so far everything he's done since his election as Labour leader has made him seem an even better leader than before. I like his approach of stating his views clearly, and sticking to them, while trying to build a consensus (even though occasionally that may be a consensus to do something he personally disagrees with). I suppose the only question is whether that approach is suitable to making instant decisions in a crisis, but there hasn't been the need for a leader of the Opposition to do that for as long as I can remember, and even though the PM has occasionally done that I don't recall an occasion when it was essential - possibly some operational matters crossed the PMs desk as the 7/7 attacks happened.
 
Posted by Martin60 (# 368) on :
 
[Smile] Alan. Where two or three of us ... [Smile]
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Martin60:
[Smile] Alan. Where two or three of us ... [Smile]

Which makes zero sense given there are several just here who believe equal and opposite things.
 
Posted by Martin60 (# 368) on :
 
Whatever you say mr cheesy.
 
Posted by Enoch (# 14322) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Martin60:
I've told Jeremy he MUST stay. ...

So that's where he takes his instructions from. I had been wondering.
 
Posted by Ariel (# 58) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Alan Cresswell:
And, as for Corbyn - so far everything he's done since his election as Labour leader has made him seem an even better leader than before.

Thank you Alan, you've made me laugh on a dismal November evening. Don't let him change (that includes those disastrous shirts). I'm quite enjoying all the anecdotes that come up on pretty much a daily basis.

[Two face]
 
Posted by Enoch (# 14322) on :
 
Tangent alert
Back on Corbyn again, there's an important point nobody seems to be making.

Unlike members of local Labour Parties, who get there by paying their subs, the members of the PLP have all been elected. Once in the Commons, they do not represent the Labour Party. They represent all their constituents INCLUDING THE ONES WHO VOTED FOR SOMEONE ELSE. That is important.

As it happens, on this particular issue, nobody really knows what the public at large thinks. Cameron doesn't. He daren't ask or even do the research, because he suspects that most of them do not want to go to war in the Middle East yet again. Nor does the PLP. Nor for that matter do Corbyn or a lot of the new members of the Labour Party, because fundamental to their collective view of the world is that only their own activists have opinions that are worth listening to. The rest of us don't matter. We are irrelevant, the political equivalent of the unelect. When they use the word 'democratic'. that's what they mean. They've meant that since the 1970s.
 
Posted by TurquoiseTastic (# 8978) on :
 
But they represent them by exercising judgement on their behalf, not by reflecting their opinion on every matter. They are representatives, not delegates.
 
Posted by Martin60 (# 368) on :
 
Well he did ask, Enoch.

[ 28. November 2015, 17:36: Message edited by: Martin60 ]
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
I believe the labour mps have been exhorted to go and speak to their constituents - and one would hope that constituents with strong views on the issue will contact their mps.
 
Posted by chris stiles (# 12641) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Enoch:

The rest of us don't matter. We are irrelevant, the political equivalent of the unelect. When they use the word 'democratic'. that's what they mean. They've meant that since the 1970s.

[Roll Eyes]

Whereas the Tories believe they were born to rule and therefore ignore the opinions of everyone. They've done so since the 1770s.
 
Posted by Touchstone (# 3560) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Ariel:
quote:
Originally posted by Alan Cresswell:
And, as for Corbyn - so far everything he's done since his election as Labour leader has made him seem an even better leader than before.

Thank you Alan, you've made me laugh on a dismal November evening. Don't let him change (that includes those disastrous shirts). I'm quite enjoying all the anecdotes that come up on pretty much a daily basis.

[Two face]

Just you wait until Cameron steps down and the grassroots Tory party elects Jacob Rees-Mogg as his successor...it could happen.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
hatless

I see that there is going to be a meeting of the Parliamentary Labour Party on Monday and Hilary Benn will be speaking. So we will no doubt find out why he found Cameron's case compelling. I think your characterisation of his reasons - of lack of them - was at best premature. He's a serious man, not given to posturing. I'm not so familiar with Tom Watson but I think we will hear his reasoning as well.

The annoyance of many Labour MPs over Corbyn's email consultation seems perfectly understandable to me. I guess I can see its value as a tactic. But there is something ironic in Corbyn of all people seeking to dragoon the opinions of MPs in this way. Using the pressure of the opinions of the party activists to cow Cabinet dissent was a Thatcherite tactic. Of course, she didn't do email consultation, she knew she didn't need to. But if you sow that wind you eventually reap a whirlwind. TBH I thought he would be more collegiate. His whirlwind may come much sooner than Mrs T's did.

Link to a Huff Post article.

(late edit to clarify and include link)

[ 29. November 2015, 08:20: Message edited by: Barnabas62 ]
 
Posted by chris stiles (# 12641) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:

Using the pressure of the opinions of the party activists to cow Cabinet dissent was a Thatcherite tactic. Of course, she didn't do email consultation, she knew she didn't need to. But if you sow that wind you eventually reap a whirlwind. TBH I thought he would be more collegiate. His whirlwind may come much sooner than Mrs T's did.

I think your point would have much more weight if we hadn't been treated over the last few months to an extended tantrum by the 'Anyone but Corbyn' contingent in the Labour party - plus their media associates - who have been fairly voluble in stating their red lines well in advance in order to try and provoke a fight.
 
Posted by Martin60 (# 368) on :
 
All's fair in love and WAR B62.
 
Posted by Ariel (# 58) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
Using the pressure of the opinions of the party activists to cow Cabinet dissent was a Thatcherite tactic. Of course, she didn't do email consultation, she knew she didn't need to. But if you sow that wind you eventually reap a whirlwind. TBH I thought he would be more collegiate. His whirlwind may come much sooner than Mrs T's did.

Comrade Corbyn has always seemed like the iron fist in the tatty corduroy glove to me, someone who knows exactly what he wants to do, and is just biding his time because he's in the public eye and wants to court approval. He's had to compromise on a lot so far but the impression I get is that it's been done through gritted teeth. The email thing is one of the small hints that give me pause for thought (that and the grim, unsmiling pictures of him usually taken against a smouldering red background don't help to soften his image either). I may be misjudging him, after all I've never met him, but that's how he comes across to me.

quote:
Originally posted by Touchstone:
Just you wait until Cameron steps down and the grassroots Tory party elects Jacob Rees-Mogg as his successor...it could happen.

More likely the uncharismatic George Osborne or the wonderfully individual Boris Johnson. Oh well, at least Boris is a cheery sort.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
Yeah, Boris is really jolly http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2009/mar/29/boris-johnson-channel-4
 
Posted by Ariel (# 58) on :
 
Oh well, I suppose it will be George then. Ho hum.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
Thats been in the public domain for years, but apparently doesn't matter to a lot of tories - Boris is etonian+oxbridge and wears a suit, that seems to be enough.

[ 29. November 2015, 11:32: Message edited by: Doublethink. ]
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
Wierdly, even the spectator is admitting Corbyn may have a point. (In a damning with extremely faint praise kind of way.)

http://new.spectator.co.uk/2015/11/jeremy-corbyn-is-more-sensible-about-syria-than-david-cameron/

[ 29. November 2015, 11:40: Message edited by: Doublethink. ]
 
Posted by chris stiles (# 12641) on :
 
Of course, Cameron has a majority. He also has the DUP with him. There are a number of independently minded Tories who are likely to vote against a motion which is why a majority is in doubt; and somehow in the media this is all about the Labour party.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
And I note the party conference vote on Syria is being largely ignored, its not like Corbyn is magicing his position from thin air.
 
Posted by hatless (# 3365) on :
 
Barnabas, perhaps I am being unfair to Benn and Watson. Maybe they just haven't had the time to explain, yet, but is that good enough?

I think that an escalation of military violence needs powerful justification. The vagueness of Benn and Watson suggests they don't agree.
 
Posted by fletcher christian (# 13919) on :
 
I'm really struggling to get my head around the logic that suggests it is ok to carpet bomb a country that has terrorists in it, but not ok to do so to part of your own country that has terrorists in it that wreaked a far worse havoc for over twenty-five years.
 
Posted by TurquoiseTastic (# 8978) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doublethink.:
Wierdly, even the spectator is admitting Corbyn may have a point. (In a damning with extremely faint praise kind of way.)

http://new.spectator.co.uk/2015/11/jeremy-corbyn-is-more-sensible-about-syria-than-david-cameron/

It's not really weird. There's substantial right-wing opposition to intervention - UKIP do not like it and nor do the more isolationist Conservatives. The reason Cameron is trying to convince Labour MPs to support him is that he can't rely on total Conservative support - he didn't get it in 2013, after all.

By and large it's the centre who want to bomb and the wings that don't.

On a separate point - those who are criticising Cameron's inconsistency (last time wanting to bomb Assad, now ISIS) are most unfair. You could argue that he has been vindicated - perhaps, had Assad been removed promptly in 2013, the non-ISIS opposition would have been able to seize control and the current nightmare would have been averted. Having been prevented in this, he is now trying to oppose ISIS without actually supporting Assad (immoral) or attacking Assad (unwise, given Russia's policy). I guess he hopes that if ISIS is weakened enough, the remaining sides will be rational enough to make a peace deal. Unlikely, dangerous, messy, unethical maybe, but hardly cynical or contemptible.

If he were a real realpolitik cynic he'd either a) join the Russians and support Assad or b) do nothing at all.

It all confirms me in my oft-stated view that most politicians are unusually principled and noble, much more so than the general public.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
Do you not think if we had bombed Assad it would simply resulted in the current civil war between a smaller number of non-state actors who were just somewhat more powerful ?

(I don't think the non-isis opposition were sufficiently united in themselves to act together to take power.)

[ 29. November 2015, 13:25: Message edited by: Doublethink. ]
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
I think the bombing of Libya, and the subsequent chaos, has made many people wary of removing Assad. On the other hand, the Russian tactic of bombing Sunni rebel groups carries its own dangers - if the Syrian army and Hezbollah are released, to head north, and slaughter dissidents, the Sunni tribes may well panic, and flock into the embrace of IS.

I don't really understand Cameron's arguments at various points - bombing doesn't work; the rebel groups he cites as possible ground troops, seem unreliable, and some of them are being bombed by Russia; there seems to be no plan going forward. This is the Iraq scenario - invade and then think of a plan later. Too late.

I suppose it's 'we must do something'.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
Flashback https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2013/08/29/9-questions-about-syria-you-were-too-embarrassed-to-ask/
 
Posted by rolyn (# 16840) on :
 
Well yeah, the general public pays the politicians their wages to be more principled than they are.

Wait til we,ve had some co-ordinated attacks in Britain's cities, then ask the general public what should be done to IS centres of activity. Public opinion tends to follow mob principles and is largely devoid of logic. Had the Paris attacks not happened then I sure many would still be burning tea lights for that poor misunderstood fellow who was droned the day before.
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by rolyn:
Well yeah, the general public pays the politicians their wages to be more principled than they are.

Wait til we,ve had some co-ordinated attacks in Britain's cities, then ask the general public what should be done to IS centres of activity. Public opinion tends to follow mob principles and is largely devoid of logic. Had the Paris attacks not happened then I sure many would still be burning tea lights for that poor misunderstood fellow who was droned the day before.

I think the first point is correct. IS want to ratchet up the violence, so an atrocity in London would probably bring about intense bombing of Raqqa and other towns.

Result? Thousands of civilian deaths, more refugees, and the defection of some Sunni rebel groups to IS.

Of course, this may be incorrect, but that's the trouble - predicting stuff in the Middle East is a mug's game. For example, Al Qaeda were destroyed in Iraq - who would have predicted a new resurgence of violent Islamism? Actually, I think a few experts did, on the basis of the political vacuum existing in Iraq.

It's the politics that's very difficult now. How do you reconstruct Iraq and Syria? In Iraq, it went badly wrong. In Libya, there were small-scale attempts, not very successful.
 
Posted by Martin60 (# 368) on :
 
I trust the CPS will have sufficient evidence to charge Johnson for at least conspiracy to commit ABH.

But as it was reported 6 years ago, I doubt it.

[ 29. November 2015, 14:23: Message edited by: Martin60 ]
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by rolyn:
Well yeah, the general public pays the politicians their wages to be more principled than they are.

Wait til we,ve had some co-ordinated attacks in Britain's cities, then ask the general public what should be done to IS centres of activity. Public opinion tends to follow mob principles and is largely devoid of logic. Had the Paris attacks not happened then I sure many would still be burning tea lights for that poor misunderstood fellow who was droned the day before.

That is an excellent argument for making peace and conflict studies a compulsory subject in secondary schools, democracy is greatly helped by having informed voters.
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
The obvious solution in Syria is a kind of partition, as has happened (de facto) in Iraq. The Kurds keep their territory in the north, Assad's people in the south, the Sunni in the centre.

Of course, the problem is, would it hold? Everybody has to give up something - Assad has to stop wanting the whole of Syria, and the Sunni let go of total revenge on Assad, Hezbollah go home. It's possible, but a long way off.
 
Posted by chris stiles (# 12641) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by quetzalcoatl:
The obvious solution in Syria is a kind of partition, as has happened (de facto) in Iraq.

Partition has a history of being preceded by genocide and/or ethnic cleansing. I would not be so sanguine as to suggest it as a solution.
 
Posted by Dafyd (# 5549) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by chris stiles:
I would not be so sanguine as to suggest it as a solution.

Pun intended?
 
Posted by rolyn (# 16840) on :
 
There is a fundamental problem in offering a political solution to a group clearly consumed with it's own rage, namely that it wouldn't know what a political solution was if it bite their arse. However any fool can also see that all the macho talk of utterly Destroying Islamic violent extremism with bombs, bullets and incarceration is equally farcical.

As with all conflicts it's case of carry on until we're all so heartily sick of it someone somewhere signs a piece of paper and it's over. What it will take to bring that about, and whether it will cause a wider conflict in the process, really is anyone's guess at present.
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
Yes, I don't think we are going to destroy Islamism, and not even violent Islamism.

After all, Nasser wrestled with it (and flirted with it) in the 50s and 60s, and there were several assassination attempts on him, and he tortured and executed some Islamists.

They were often heavily repressed by the secular regimes, and in a sense, they have surged up from the hidden depths, with a fierce sense of revenge and entitlement.

Who knows - we might learn to live with them in a contained area, but we won't destroy them. And we may face some Islamist governments, although not of the IS type.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
@ chris styles

The Thatcherite parallel is not exact of course. And I'm not denying the existence of an implacable anti-Corbyn group. But a collegiate approach would strengthen JC's hand within the plp. As I said earlier, my instinct is that Corbyn may well be right that an extension of bombing could very well be counter productive. In terms of international politics, that doesn't rule out joining the French as requested. In terms of domestic plp politics, there is no harm in stating his personal view but that should be coupled with a willingness to listen to his Shadow Cabinet. After all, he picked them. That's the collegiate approach.
 
Posted by Martin60 (# 368) on :
 
Aye. Have to agree B62.
 
Posted by Ariel (# 58) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
In terms of domestic plp politics, there is no harm in stating his personal view but that should be coupled with a willingness to listen to his Shadow Cabinet. After all, he picked them. That's the collegiate approach.

He did pick them but I'm wondering whether he's holding out for them to resign in anger, so he can get rid of some more malcontents.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
Well, the Monday plp meeting may clear up a lot of this. At least it provides an opportunity to get as many people as possible on the same page. This is a test of JC's leadership skills. He could still come up trumps.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
http://uk.reuters.com/article/2015/11/29/uk-mideast-crisis-usa-military-idUKKBN0TI0UM20151129

This may become moot quite quickly - mission creep anyone ?
 
Posted by Dave W. (# 8765) on :
 
Both McCain and Graham have been calling for ground troops for a long time. I don't see any particular reason why their chances of getting their way should have increased; Obama's still skeptical, Graham's flirting with 0% in the polls, and no other Republican candidate appears to think calling for large numbers of troops is an attractive position.
 
Posted by L'organist (# 17338) on :
 
posted by Barnabas62
quote:
Well, the Monday plp meeting may clear up a lot of this. At least it provides an opportunity to get as many people as possible on the same page. This is a test of JC's leadership skills. He could still come up trumps.
I don't know that it will clear up anything.

Len McCluskey has come out with a threatening statement saying that MPs should be careful of their position. Nice to know that the brothers (this big brother in particular) are as wedded to the ideals of free speech, free thought and democracy as ever.

As has been pointed out, MPs represent not only their party but also their constituents who didn't vote for them.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
What polling there currently is, suggests that there isn't a majority in the UK for bombing Syria.

E.g. http://uk.reuters.com/article/2015/11/29/uk-mideast-crisis-usa-military-idUKKBN0TI0UM20151129

Even if it has fluctuated over the last couple of days, there certainly isn't a decisive majority.

[ 30. November 2015, 07:30: Message edited by: Doublethink. ]
 
Posted by Ariel (# 58) on :
 
Interestingly, anyone can fill in this form and tell the Labour Party their views on Syria. As journalists have already noted, it doesn't say you have to be a member of the party, so whatever results this provides will not be based purely on the opinions of Labour members. It's also open to people with more than one email address or who are minded to spoof theirs. Nice one.
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
If they are wanting views from the people of Britain rather than just their members then that should give them those as well.
 
Posted by Ariel (# 58) on :
 
My understanding is it's supposed to be part of the membership survey.
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
Well, they'll just have to try and filter out non-member responses then. If they have a lot of abusive responses then maybe they'll need to be more careful to allow members only to respond to future calls for opinions.

I would hope that they would take the opinions of others into consideration though.
 
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on :
 
L'organist:
quote:
As has been pointed out, MPs represent not only their party but also their constituents who didn't vote for them.
Yes, and it would be nice if *all* MPs remembered this, not just the Labour ones.

Or are you suggesting the Tories never make use of the Party whips? I find that very difficult to believe. Cameron is only going to allow a free vote because most of his party agrees with him on this issue. There are as many divisions in the Tory party as there are in Labour; they're just not on public display.
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
The problem is that the Westminster Parliamentary system is not designed to be "whipped" - in practice local constituents elect an individual rather than a party - so for a long period there were no "parties" at Westminster at all.

The secondary problem is that the elected member is supposed to be voting on the issues on his conscience, so has no obligation to do what the whips tell him to do, nor has any obligation to ask or follow what the majority of his/her constituents want.

Of course, if the MP has not done what the majority of constituents wanted during the life of the parliament, the expectation is that he will not be re-elected. And if he annoys his political party enough, they'll withdraw the whip and re-election as an independent will become essentially impossible.

So to underline the main point: there is nothing constitutionally which says that the MP should take account of constituents. But there is also nothing to say that he shouldn't. At the end of the day, he/she needs to vote on his conscience, how he comes to that conclusion is up to him/her own problem.

So, by extension, there is no obligation on the Labour leader to listen to the populous on any contentious issue, but there is no reason not to.
 
Posted by Doc Tor (# 9748) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by L'organist:
Len McCluskey has come out with a threatening statement saying that MPs should be careful of their position. Nice to know that the brothers (this big brother in particular) are as wedded to the ideals of free speech, free thought and democracy as ever.

Well, isn't this a bit of sophistry? Why not tell us that Len McCluskey has warned Labour MPs not to stage an anti-democratic coup against the elected-by-an-overwhelming-majority leader of the Labour party instead, or doesn't that fit your narrative?
 
Posted by Ariel (# 58) on :
 
The "overwhelming majority" is a bit dodgy, given that anyone could register for £3 to vote whether they agreed with Labour or not. I doubt very much that if proper procedures had been followed he really would have had a mandate, or at least half as much of one as he has.

Anyhow, fingers crossed he'll be deposed before long, and this will all be history.
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
He was elected by a very clear majority of those eligible to vote. That you disagree with the eligibility criteria does nothing to change that.

Besides, if those people who paid their £3 and voted for him did so to somehow destroy Labour then in doing so they've elected the best Labour leader since John Smith.
 
Posted by chris stiles (# 12641) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Ariel:
The "overwhelming majority" is a bit dodgy, given that anyone could register for £3 to vote whether they agreed with Labour or not.

Even if you discount the £3 supporters - many of whom have since become members - he still received a majority. You are clutching at straws.
 
Posted by Ariel (# 58) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Alan Cresswell:
Besides, if those people who paid their £3 and voted for him did so to somehow destroy Labour then in doing so they've elected the best Labour leader since John Smith.

Why do you think this man is a good thing?
 
Posted by Doc Tor (# 9748) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Ariel:
The "overwhelming majority" is a bit dodgy

I'd hope that any democratically-elected leader would enjoy your support, if only for the 'democratically elected' bit.

Cameron's a complete arse, but he's still 'my' Prime Minister, because that's what the rules say. If I organised a coup against him via anti-democratic means, I'd be in the wrong.

This is not difficult to understand.
 
Posted by Pottage (# 9529) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doublethink.:
What polling there currently is, suggests that there isn't a majority in the UK for bombing Syria.

E.g. http://uk.reuters.com/article/2015/11/29/uk-mideast-crisis-usa-military-idUKKBN0TI0UM20151129

Even if it has fluctuated over the last couple of days, there certainly isn't a decisive majority.

That may not be the link you intended to give, as the linked article appears to be about the arguments for deployment of US ground forces.

I don't think much faith can be placed in online surveys, but this YouGov Survey is the most recent actual polling I could find. They interviewed 1,659 UK adults on 23/4 November. The mandate for supporting air strikes in Syria was comparable to Jeremy Corbyn's mandate to lead the Labour Party: 59% of all voters supported this, including 52% of Labour Party voters. There is no age band, no region of the UK, and no political affiliation within which they did not find that a majority of British voters are in favour of the position advocated by the Government and supported by the United Nations.
 
Posted by Sioni Sais (# 5713) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doc Tor:
quote:
Originally posted by Ariel:
The "overwhelming majority" is a bit dodgy

I'd hope that any democratically-elected leader would enjoy your support, if only for the 'democratically elected' bit.

Cameron's a complete arse, but he's still 'my' Prime Minister, because that's what the rules say. If I organised a coup against him via anti-democratic means, I'd be in the wrong.

This is not difficult to understand.

Unless you are Her Majesty the Queen, he's not "your" Prime Minister. He's her PM, and we are her subjects. Any authority he has is derived from that and we shouldn't forget it.
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Ariel:
quote:
Originally posted by Alan Cresswell:
Besides, if those people who paid their £3 and voted for him did so to somehow destroy Labour then in doing so they've elected the best Labour leader since John Smith.

Why do you think this man is a good thing?
What's not to like?

I probably expressed my views on the Corbyn threads. But, in his favour is he's a visionary, he's spent his political career on the sidelines, pointing in a different direction from his party declaring "the promised land is over here, you're going the wrong way". Possibly only the late, great Tony Benn was more prophetic in trying to call his party in the direction of justice and equality for the country. He's a man of principles, he may consult the public frequently, but he's never gone to pick the policies he will support on the basis of what focus groups tell him will be popular. He's a socialist, absolutely wonderful to get to see a socialist in a position of influence. I hope to see him as PM, or at least (since he is getting on a bit) to encourage enough other socialists in his party to keep the Labour party on the right path so his successor takes over number 10.
 
Posted by Doc Tor (# 9748) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Sioni Sais:
Unless you are Her Majesty the Queen, he's not "your" Prime Minister. He's her PM, and we are her subjects. Any authority he has is derived from that and we shouldn't forget it.

Colloquially.

He is more 'my' Prime Minister than she is 'my' Queen, simply because he's gone through a democratic process. However flawed you believe that process to be, it's not so broken (yet) as to justify a popular uprising.
 
Posted by Touchstone (# 3560) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Alan Cresswell:
quote:
Originally posted by Ariel:
quote:
Originally posted by Alan Cresswell:
Besides, if those people who paid their £3 and voted for him did so to somehow destroy Labour then in doing so they've elected the best Labour leader since John Smith.

Why do you think this man is a good thing?
What's not to like?


Gives all the top shadow jobs to men.

Makes a major speech on foreign policy without consulting or even informing his shadow foreign secretary.

Appoints one of his cronies to review defence policy without consulting or even informing his shadow defence secretary.

Is an apologist for Putin’s imperial aggression; has appeared on propaganda TV shows for Russia, which invades its neighbours and persecutes gays, and also Iran, which executes gays.

Apparently sees a moral equivalence between 9/11 and the assassination of bin Laden, and has associated with every variety of women-hating, queer-bashing, Jew-baiting jihadi, holocaust denier and 9/11 conspiracy theorist.

Having said all that, I agree with him on Syria, on the whole..
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
Yet another Corbyn-bashing thread! Good grief, they sneak in everywhere at the moment. Only the other day, at Waitrose, as the check-out woman gave me my receipt, she whispered, 'his tie's not straight'. Cheek.
 
Posted by Ariel (# 58) on :
 
Thanks for this interesting clarification, Alan. What you see as definite pluses are things that give me pause for thought and ring alarm bells, so I guess we won't agree any time soon, but interesting to see where someone else is coming from.

I'm still not convinced that Corbyn is popular. He may be popular with the hard left, militants, trade unionists (and unions should not be allowed to influence a political party IMO), and inexperienced young people who don't remember the old days of Labour and think he's refreshingly different and rebellious. But I doubt the rest of the country will share their view.

I also think that being an idealist is actually a mark of being unsuitable to be in a position of responsibility where you have to make decisions that affect people's lives. In my experience idealists tend to have starry-eyed notions that they can often be inflexible about, they fail to notice details or take account of human nature or the reality on the ground in their pursuit of their favourite ideology, and they can be hopeless with budgets. By all means let them bounce ideas off people who can test them for feasibility, but personally I wouldn't put any visionary or idealist in charge of anything until they have demonstrated at least a reasonable level of common sense and practicality first.

[ 30. November 2015, 12:19: Message edited by: Ariel ]
 
Posted by Touchstone (# 3560) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by quetzalcoatl:
Yet another Corbyn-bashing thread! Good grief, they sneak in everywhere at the moment. Only the other day, at Waitrose, as the check-out woman gave me my receipt, she whispered, 'his tie's not straight'. Cheek.

On this particular issue, despite disliking him intensely for the reasons stated above, I agree with him, as I have said. I would therefore suggest that my support on this issue counts for more than that of the starry-eyed corbynistas who agree with him on everything because he's, like, toadly amazing...
 
Posted by Enoch (# 14322) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doc Tor:
I'd hope that any democratically-elected leader would enjoy your support, if only for the 'democratically elected' bit.

Cameron's a complete arse, but he's still 'my' Prime Minister, because that's what the rules say. If I organised a coup against him via anti-democratic means, I'd be in the wrong.

This is not difficult to understand.

Sorry, but that's a non sequitur in reverse. Is there such a thing as a non preceditur? It's also complete rubbish. Otherwise why and how do we have an official opposition.

Yes, staging a coup is waging war on the Queen's government. It is therefore treason and wrong. But that doesn't mean we're all obliged to support our democratically elected leader, whatever he or she might do.
 
Posted by Sioni Sais (# 5713) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Ariel:


I'm still not convinced that Corbyn is popular. He may be popular with the hard left, militants, trade unionists (and unions should not be allowed to influence a political party IMO), and inexperienced young people who don't remember the old days of Labour and think he's refreshingly different and rebellious. But I doubt the rest of the country will share their view.


If trade unions should not be allowed to influence political parties, who the hell should? We have at least one party that pushes the interest of corporate business, ahead of the interest of individuals and, at times, the nation too.

At least the Labour started out, quite openly as being sponsored by trade unions. It has drifted from there but Corbyn might manage to haul it back on track.
 
Posted by Ariel (# 58) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Sioni Sais:
If trade unions should not be allowed to influence political parties, who the hell should?

I don't see why any external organization should be allowed to influence political parties. Regardless of how much they may be willing to donate.
 
Posted by Touchstone (# 3560) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Ariel:
quote:
Originally posted by Sioni Sais:
If trade unions should not be allowed to influence political parties, who the hell should?

I don't see why any external organization should be allowed to influence political parties. Regardless of how much they may be willing to donate.
Maybe they shouldn't be allowed to, but in the real world they do. Difficult to see how it could be stopped, unless donations (other than members' subs) were banned altogether.

A political party that was not influenced by anyone at all would be a totalitarian state, surely?
 
Posted by Doc Tor (# 9748) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Enoch:
But that doesn't mean we're all obliged to support our democratically elected leader, whatever he or she might do.

In a straight-up fight between democratic and anti-democratic forces, you'd better be choosing the democratic ones. Unless you're so tired of voting, you never want to have to do it again, of course.

As much as I hate Cameron's party and policies, I acknowledge the process that put them in power was legitimate.
 
Posted by Doc Tor (# 9748) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Ariel:
quote:
Originally posted by Sioni Sais:
If trade unions should not be allowed to influence political parties, who the hell should?

I don't see why any external organization should be allowed to influence political parties. Regardless of how much they may be willing to donate.
So you're lumping in mass movement organisations like trade unions (6.4 million members) with private companies and wealthy individuals? That's a false equivalence and a half...
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doc Tor:
quote:
Originally posted by Enoch:
But that doesn't mean we're all obliged to support our democratically elected leader, whatever he or she might do.

In a straight-up fight between democratic and anti-democratic forces, you'd better be choosing the democratic ones. Unless you're so tired of voting, you never want to have to do it again, of course.

As much as I hate Cameron's party and policies, I acknowledge the process that put them in power was legitimate.

Yes, you have to hold to that, unless society is really going through one of its periods of Gotterdammerung, which are fortunately infrequent. These were the arguments over Charles I, weren't they? How could you oppose the king in the field of battle? Well, normally, you wouldn't.
 
Posted by Ariel (# 58) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Touchstone:
A political party that was not influenced by anyone at all would be a totalitarian state, surely?

Not necessarily. I just don't think that external organizations who may have their own agendas should form a pressure group on a political party to get that party dancing to their own tune.
 
Posted by Doc Tor (# 9748) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Ariel:
quote:
Originally posted by Touchstone:
A political party that was not influenced by anyone at all would be a totalitarian state, surely?

Not necessarily. I just don't think that external organizations who may have their own agendas should form a pressure group on a political party to get that party dancing to their own tune.
You do know that the trades union movement gave birth to the Labour party, right?
 
Posted by Ariel (# 58) on :
 
Yes. That's one reason why I won't support it.
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
I think every thread should have an anti-Corbyn sub-thread. For example:

Discuss the putative Johannine community, with reference to Corbyn's anti-semitic friends.

Is the ontological argument vitiated by Corbyn's clothes?

Is the Q document clarified by reference to the rules and regs of the Labour Party (Private Members' Bills subsection)?
 
Posted by Sioni Sais (# 5713) on :
 
Political parties have to come from somewhere. IIRC the Conservatives came out of protectionist business interests while the Liberals from free-trade business interests. Labour home territory is organised labour. In more modern times there's a large slice of the Green/Ecology movement that is bitterly opposed to business interests.

UKIP seems mostly to provide a home to people booted out of the Conservatives while the BNP and Britain First are more interested in putting the boot in.
 
Posted by Brenda Clough (# 18061) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by quetzalcoatl:
I think every thread should have an anti-Corbyn sub-thread. For example:

Discuss the putative Johannine community, with reference to Corbyn's anti-semitic friends.

Is the ontological argument vitiated by Corbyn's clothes?

Is the Q document clarified by reference to the rules and regs of the Labour Party (Private Members' Bills subsection)?

Surely this is Quotes material!
[Killing me]
 
Posted by lowlands_boy (# 12497) on :
 
Anyway, vaguely back on topic, Corbyn is reported to be going to allow a free vote for Labour MPs on the Syria question.

Equally vaguely on topic, should MPs who don't agree with Corbyn all get the boot?
 
Posted by Sioni Sais (# 5713) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by lowlands_boy:
Anyway, vaguely back on topic, Corbyn is reported to be going to allow a free vote for Labour MPs on the Syria question.

Equally vaguely on topic, should MPs who don't agree with Corbyn all get the boot?

I hope not, having allowed a free vote, but I would like to see those in favour of going to war put boots on and go there, in harm's way.

I suppose that makes me an idealist too.
 
Posted by Doc Tor (# 9748) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Ariel:
Yes. That's one reason why I won't support it.

But the reason you won't support it is also reason not to support any political party anywhere, ever. Which strikes me as foolish, but each to his own.
 
Posted by Pottage (# 9529) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by lowlands_boy:
Anyway, vaguely back on topic, Corbyn is reported to be going to allow a free vote for Labour MPs on the Syria question.

Equally vaguely on topic, should MPs who don't agree with Corbyn all get the boot?

You'd like to think that Jeremy Corbyn of all people would be inclined to respect rather than vilify MPs whose voting is motivated by their conscience rather than the dictates of their party's whips' office.
 
Posted by Ariel (# 58) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doc Tor:
But the reason you won't support it is also reason not to support any political party anywhere, ever. Which strikes me as foolish, but each to his own.

I know they haven't all had noble origins. I can live with that, but I would have qualms about voting for any party which has an ongoing long-term relationship with external organizations who expect to call the shots.

OTOH women fought bitterly to get other women the vote, knowing this. And my choice of vote isn't made with 100% happiness about voting for the perfect party, depressingly, it's usually voting for what I perceive at that particular time to be the least worst option.

quote:
Originally posted by lowlands_boy:
Anyway, vaguely back on topic, Corbyn is reported to be going to allow a free vote for Labour MPs on the Syria question.

Big of him.
 
Posted by Enoch (# 14322) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Sioni Sais:
Political parties have to come from somewhere. IIRC the Conservatives came out of protectionist business interests while the Liberals from free-trade business interests. Labour home territory is organised labour. In more modern times there's a large slice of the Green/Ecology movement that is bitterly opposed to business interests.

UKIP seems mostly to provide a home to people booted out of the Conservatives while the BNP and Britain First are more interested in putting the boot in.

Not quite. It's relatively recent that the Conservatives became associated with business. Leaving aside the aftermath of 1689, by the C19, the Tories⇾Conservatives were seen as representing the landed interest, and the Whigs⇾Liberals the urban and commercial ones. It's really only since the 1880s when the Liberal Unionists switched to partially supporting the Conservatives, or even the 1920s when the nutcracker effect of our electoral system left the business side of the Liberals with no home to go to, that there's been an association of the Conservatives with business.

More generally, the notion that a political party isn't going to be linked with the interest groups that support it, or that this shouldn't happen, is batty. Even more batty is the notion that it's all right for the party I support to be linked with its interest groups, but it's corrupt that the parties which other people support should be.

The more appropriate reaction is to say that because party X is too tied up with interest group Y, and because I regard interest group Y's influence as pernicious, I will vote consistently for candidates of a party other than X
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
Pottage, do you have an actual example of Jeremy Corbyn vilifying these people ?

[ 30. November 2015, 18:21: Message edited by: Doublethink. ]
 
Posted by Doc Tor (# 9748) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Ariel:
I know they haven't all had noble origins. I can live with that, but I would have qualms about voting for any party which has an ongoing long-term relationship with external organizations who expect to call the shots.

I am genuinely struggling to understand your thought processes.

You find fault with a spontaneous, grass-roots movement of ordinary working people who rise up and demand better conditions and better pay from their wealthy overlords, forming their own political party - there being none to represent their views - to fight democratically for their cause.

Yet, on the other hand, the party of privilege and wealth, funded by wealthy, unaccountable patrons, actively working for the public woe, seem to gets a pass.

If you don't think there are conflicts of interest between oil, arms, health and security firms and government policy, behold, my bridge which I wish to sell you.
 
Posted by Ariel (# 58) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doc Tor:
I am genuinely struggling to understand your thought processes.

And I am equally bemused by yours. Still, the world's a big enough place for people to be able to disagree and move on.
 
Posted by Marvin the Martian (# 4360) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Pottage:
quote:
Originally posted by lowlands_boy:
Anyway, vaguely back on topic, Corbyn is reported to be going to allow a free vote for Labour MPs on the Syria question.

Equally vaguely on topic, should MPs who don't agree with Corbyn all get the boot?

You'd like to think that Jeremy Corbyn of all people would be inclined to respect rather than vilify MPs whose voting is motivated by their conscience rather than the dictates of their party's whips' office.
Not at all - like most socialists he only values voting by conscience if the conscience in question agrees with him.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
Well, it is to be a free vote. From the stories after the Shadow Cabinet meeting, the key factors which determined that decision were

a) that a whipped vote would lead to the resignations of several Shadow Cabinet members

b) that between 70 and 100 Labour MPs wished to vote in favour of bombing, despite any present or future deselection consequences. That information was provided by the Labour Whips.

It appears that JC did not get his own way at the Shadow Cabinet meeting. It seems that he was forced to accept a free vote, which is a bit ironical, really. I suppose a substantial debate in the House later this week may lead to some minds being changed. Also, I wouldn't be surprised if some of those in favour of bombing came under more intense pressure from their local Labour parties and other voices.

But the real lesson is this one. Don't tell representatives that they must be delegates. It gets up their noses. For what it is worth, here is an account of the motion and the debate in September this year. Conference motions are advisory, not binding. Attempts to make them binding are basically in conflict with the constitutional position that MPs are representatives, not delegates. In this case, the attacks in Paris post-dated the conference motion. And it is, classically, the case that representatives have to take into account both the opinions of conferences and developing events. Which is why policy and its development are the prerogative of the plp in general and the Shadow Cabinet in particular.

Of course there may be consequences at future conferences and in local constituencies if MPs are seen to depart from the strongly expressed opinions recorded at conferences. But that's not new.
 
Posted by chris stiles (# 12641) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Ariel:
quote:
Originally posted by Doc Tor:
I am genuinely struggling to understand your thought processes.

And I am equally bemused by yours. Still, the world's a big enough place for people to be able to disagree and move on.
His point is that if you think it wrong for external bodies to influence political parties, then you apply that principle rather unevenly.
 
Posted by Gee D (# 13815) on :
 
ISTM that by sending the email to all members of the Labour Party, Corbyn acknowledged that he does not have much support in his parliamentary executive. His latest, that members should have a free vote, is an acknowledgement that he does not have much support in the plp either.

Neither is a good position for the leader of the party in the Commons. I don't consider it much good for the UK either, as it effectively removes opposition to the Government from Parliament.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
But the risk of a terrorist attack pre Paris is the same as post Paris.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
Vote confirmed for Wednesday.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doublethink.:
Pottage, do you have an actual example of Jeremy Corbyn vilifying these people ?

Likewise Marvin ?
 
Posted by Marvin the Martian (# 4360) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doublethink.:
quote:
Originally posted by Doublethink.:
Pottage, do you have an actual example of Jeremy Corbyn vilifying these people ?

Likewise Marvin ?
Hm?
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
You agreed with pottage - I was asking either of you for an example of Corbyn "vilifying" labour mps who don't agree with his position.
 
Posted by Pottage (# 9529) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doublethink.:
Pottage, do you have an actual example of Jeremy Corbyn vilifying these people ?

You're right of course. It is his immediate supporters who do that in public; I should have been more specific.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doublethink.:
But the risk of a terrorist attack pre Paris is the same as post Paris.

Sure, but the cost of not supporting the French has changed. EU politics interlock with defence politics. Cameron may well see Hollande as a supporter of Schengen modifications now. The French government's reaction to the Paris outrages is entirely understandable. A lack of UK support might not be so easily forgiven. Even if both Hollande and Cameron, privately, are on the same sceptical page over the real effects of a bombing extension, Hollande doesn't really have much choice over giving it a try.

I'm sure that appears both speculative and messy, but I'd be surprised if such considerations aren't going on as well. Alliances have costs.
 
Posted by Enoch (# 14322) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
Sure, but the cost of not supporting the French has changed. EU politics interlock with defence politics. Cameron may well see Hollande as a supporter of Schengen modifications now. The French government's reaction to the Paris outrages is entirely understandable. A lack of UK support might not be so easily forgiven. Even if both Hollande and Cameron, privately, are on the same sceptical page over the real effects of a bombing extension, Hollande doesn't really have much choice over giving it a try.

I'm sure that appears both speculative and messy, but I'd be surprised if such considerations aren't going on as well. Alliances have costs.

As I've said before, if I were an MP I'd vote against, but Barnabas 62, that may be a pretty fair description of what's actually going on.
 
Posted by chris stiles (# 12641) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
Sure, but the cost of not supporting the French has changed. EU politics interlock with defence politics. Cameron may well see Hollande as a supporter of Schengen modifications now.

Which is essentially saying that the civilians of Raqqa have to be sacrificed for our own good.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
That all depends on the accuracy of the attacks. I'm not sure that the civilians of Raqqa are all that safe under IS. Are you?

Is it any real surprise that leaders of countries sometimes have to think the unthinkable when considering the defence of themselves and their allies? They do not always have the luxury of adopting purist positions. It's easy to forget that.
 
Posted by hatless (# 3365) on :
 
I can understand France reacting to the Paris outrage in a gut way, feeling the need to do something strong and emphatic. I can understand the UK feeling a need to align with France. We face the same threats, and besides, we need to build a sense of partnership to reform the EU. But this is far short of a justification for extending our war into Syria.

Bombing somewhere else is not defending the UK. It's not thinking the unthinkable, it's giving in to the predictable knee-jerk of retaliation.

The unthinkable, or the apparently unthinkable, is the listening project, the opening of dialogue, giving the discontents more peaceful avenues to express their convictions. That might reduce the threat here and in the Middle East. But the truth is that there is no defence against assault weapons in a stadium, cafe, concert hall, shopping centre, camp site, school or cinema. Bombing somewhere else is as useless as giving all the 'good guys' hand guns.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
I wonder why the French can't see the wisdom of that, hatless. What do you reckon? Is Hollande just stupid?
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
I don't think Hollande is stupid, nor is Cameron for that matter. There are domestic political conditions that make a quick and highly visible response attractive, especially so in France. And, pictures of aircraft launching for operations in Syria on the TV and in newspapers are highly visible, footage of smart bombs hitting their target more so.

I'm not sure conducting international relations entirely for domestic political advantage is the best option internationally (it may be good domestically), especially when one of the factors under consideration is taking the wind out of far right nationalists. Although a few aircraft flying over Syria dropping the occasional bomb may be the lesser of two evils if it prevents Le Pen and her thugs levering more power and enacting barbaric policies against immigrants and refugees.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Pottage:
quote:
Originally posted by Doublethink.:
Pottage, do you have an actual example of Jeremy Corbyn vilifying these people ?

You're right of course. It is his immediate supporters who do that in public; I should have been more specific.
So twitter trolls (whom every political party has some residue of) and Ken Livingstone, whom he immediately jumped on and required to apologise.

[ 01. December 2015, 02:04: Message edited by: Doublethink. ]
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
I don't think it is just about domestic political advantage, Alan. Containing and degrading the military and paramilitary forces which IS uses so ruthlessly is a reasonable objective in the interests of self defence. Of course you are quite right to point to both the the dubious military benefits and the political value of the 'show of force'. I'd forgotten the odious le Pen factor.

Politics and international affairs can often seem such dirty and despicable pursuits. All of the black and whites can become very grey in the world of the 'least bad' options.

What was it Morpheus said in 'The Matrix'? Welcome to the Real World. Wrestling with implacable hatred and violence does not appear to give leaders of governments much scope for loving their enemies.
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
Containing and degrading the military and paramilitary forces which IS uses so ruthlessly is a reasonable objective in the interests of self defence.

If the use of airpower can demonstrably reduce the military forces of Daesh with minimal collatoral damage then that would be of benefit to the defence of civilians in Syria. It would still require boots on the ground, and this mythical 70,000 rebel fighters, even if they exist and can be relied upon to engage Daesh, is likely to be woefully inadequate for the job.

That wouldn't do one iota to increase our security against terrorist attacks. Because, we aren't facing terrorists trained and equipped in the Daesh 'caliphate', the terrorists we'll be facing aren't in Syria where our bombs could kill them before they can come here to attack us. The terrorists we face are already here, living within our own cities. They are inspired by Daesh, they have brought into the radical philosophy of jihadism, many may seek to join Daesh in Syria but most will be unable to do so and will find ways of carrying the fight to the people of Britain.
 
Posted by Martin60 (# 368) on :
 
Which will only "steel our resolve" ... sigh.

The way 7/7 (and Livingstone was RIGHT of course, as we all knew at the time) did ...
 
Posted by hatless (# 3365) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
I wonder why the French can't see the wisdom of that, hatless. What do you reckon? Is Hollande just stupid?

People hate to feel weak. I hate feeling weak, exposed and vulnerable. I like to feel in control, secure and powerful.

Attacks on your capital city make a nation, its government and its president feel powerless and humiliated. What is the point of having your military, your nuclear weapons, your trained forces if people can not only kill as they please, but in so doing demonstrate the nakedness of the state, however large the epaulettes of its generals.

So you feel a desperate need to reverse the monstrous overthrow of the workd's order. You want your planes to fly, your bombs to explode, and your generals to silence all sniggers.

I see nothing more intelligent than this at work in Hollande. It's very strong, though. It's very hard to acknowledge that we are unsafe, that world always has been and always will be a dangerous place, and that peace only comes through vulnerability.

Benn was on Today, and still hasn't found an argument. Twice he asserted that we are at risk, but he never offered any reason why bombing Syria would avert it. We are at risk of a flu epidemic, but it doesn't make bombing Syria a good idea.
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Alan Cresswell:
If the use of airpower can demonstrably reduce the military forces of Daesh with minimal collatoral damage then that would be of benefit to the defence of civilians in Syria. It would still require boots on the ground, and this mythical 70,000 rebel fighters, even if they exist and can be relied upon to engage Daesh, is likely to be woefully inadequate for the job.

I saw a snippet of a news channel report yesterday with an anonymous activist phoning in from Raqqa. According to the activist, there was a demonstrable difference between Russian and French strikes - with the latter only hitting paramilitary instillations, the former only hitting civilians.

The question is therefore how we'd know that "our" missile strikes were more accurate than those of the Russians. I don't believe we would.

[ 01. December 2015, 07:51: Message edited by: mr cheesy ]
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
hatless, IS claimed credit for the Paris attacks, calling them "the first of the storm". That is sufficient justification for a military attack on their assets where they can be found. The issue of effectiveness is secondary to the justification in principle.

Alan, I don't think that potential or actual terrorists in the UK are necessarily perfectly controlled by IS, neither are they completely independent. Training and resourcing cost money and require trainers and quartermasters. I thought the link was the ideology but that doesn't seem to have been the case with all of the Paris terrorists. There is a coalition of the angry and the violent at work across borders and I suspect there are various motivations at work which draw people into these forms of responses.

[ 01. December 2015, 08:48: Message edited by: Barnabas62 ]
 
Posted by betjemaniac (# 17618) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by mr cheesy:
quote:
Originally posted by Alan Cresswell:
If the use of airpower can demonstrably reduce the military forces of Daesh with minimal collatoral damage then that would be of benefit to the defence of civilians in Syria. It would still require boots on the ground, and this mythical 70,000 rebel fighters, even if they exist and can be relied upon to engage Daesh, is likely to be woefully inadequate for the job.

I saw a snippet of a news channel report yesterday with an anonymous activist phoning in from Raqqa. According to the activist, there was a demonstrable difference between Russian and French strikes - with the latter only hitting paramilitary instillations, the former only hitting civilians.

The question is therefore how we'd know that "our" missile strikes were more accurate than those of the Russians. I don't believe we would.

Surely there's a subtext there though - in terms of what they're "trying" to hit in the first place?

If that's genuinely true that the French strikes are qualitatively different to the Russian ones, then it ought to be fairly easy to put yourself in the first camp rather than the second *if you want to.*

IME Russian kit is quite good - some of it as good or better than what the French (or us in the UK) have got.

Like I say, *if* it's true, then it's going to come down to who's doing the targeting, what they're aiming at in the first place, and what their ROE are.
 
Posted by itsarumdo (# 18174) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by hatless:
...
Benn was on Today, and still hasn't found an argument. Twice he asserted that we are at risk, but he never offered any reason why bombing Syria would avert it. We are at risk of a flu epidemic, but it doesn't make bombing Syria a good idea.

... and both would invoke spooky action at a distance

It strikes me that we are more at risk in the future if we inadvertently kill off a few civilian family members, in our haste to be seen to have big cojones. ISIS and its ilk gain new groundtroops and suicide bombers whenever the west knee-jerks.
 
Posted by Doc Tor (# 9748) on :
 
You have today to write to your MP and let them know your views. I wrote to mine last night, urging him to vote no, but whatever your opinion, if you have time to type a message on this thread, you have time to drop your MP a short email. That is all.
 
Posted by hatless (# 3365) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
hatless, IS claimed credit for the Paris attacks, calling them "the first of the storm". That is sufficient justification for a military attack on their assets where they can be found. The issue of effectiveness is secondary to the justification in principle.

Really? Isn't effectiveness the only justification? In just war theory it is. Are we to hit any self-declared enemy?

And what is this word assets doing? Isn't it politician speak to hide the fact we mean killing people?
 
Posted by chris stiles (# 12641) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:

That is sufficient justification for a military attack on their assets where they can be found. The issue of effectiveness is secondary to the justification in principle.

Sure, but that is a consideration merely in the abstract - in the real world there is collateral damage.

When 'we' hit a school/hospital/whatever by accident and footage of dead (sunni) babies goes out across the Arab world, is that likely to increase or decrease support for ISIS and their ilk?
 
Posted by Pottage (# 9529) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doublethink.:
quote:
Originally posted by Pottage:
quote:
Originally posted by Doublethink.:
Pottage, do you have an actual example of Jeremy Corbyn vilifying these people ?

You're right of course. It is his immediate supporters who do that in public; I should have been more specific.
So twitter trolls (whom every political party has some residue of) and Ken Livingstone, whom he immediately jumped on and required to apologise.
Let's agree to differ about Livingstone, Abbott, McCluskey and those other immediate supporters of Jeremy Corbyn whose statements are reported to have been perceived by the MPs to whom they were directed as being threatening and bullying. I accept the possibility that none of these friends and allies may be speaking for Corbyn on any of these occasions.
 
Posted by Marvin the Martian (# 4360) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doublethink.:
You agreed with pottage - I was asking either of you for an example of Corbyn "vilifying" labour mps who don't agree with his position.

The only evidence I need for what I actually said is the fact that he clearly thinks principled disagreement with your party leadership's position is fine when he's the one disagreeing, but not when he's the one deciding the party leadership's position.
 
Posted by Enoch (# 14322) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
... The issue of effectiveness is secondary to the justification in principle. ...

Up to a point Lord Barnabas.

In classic just war doctrine, it is step number 3. It comes after the the war having to have a just cause. But however justifiable the war may be in abstract principle, it has to pass all four test to be just. Even if the war may be potentially just 'in principle' it is not just if it won't be effective.

If Isis could be splatted, then it would be difficult to argue that attacking them at the moment would not be just - indeed, a service to humanity as a whole. If .... .

That's the reason why I'd vote no. It's not like the Falklands, which was just on tests 1, 2 and 4, but a big risk on 3. We took the risk. That was a legitimate decision. Fortunately, it paid off.

On this one, though, there's no direct connection between what's proposed and delivering the desirable result. Indeed, short of dropping a small nuclear weapon on Raqqa, which would be a total failure on 4, and without UN unanimity would not even pass step 1, there's no action anybody could take that appears to be capable of delivering the desirable result.
 
Posted by agingjb (# 16555) on :
 
Given that Cameron's government has a majority in the House of Commons, I cannot see the relevance of the votes of the other parties. Of course if Cameron cannot rely on the votes of his own party then surely that is of far more significance than how the opposition votes,
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by agingjb:
Given that Cameron's government has a majority in the House of Commons, I cannot see the relevance of the votes of the other parties. Of course if Cameron cannot rely on the votes of his own party then surely that is of far more significance than how the opposition votes,

Aside from the fact he has a majority of 17 and the last vote 30 tories voted against, so he'll probably need some votes from other parties to gain a majority if most of those rebels vote against again.

More importantly, Cameron is smart enough to know that he needs the clear support of the British people, and that would be shown by an overwhelming vote in favour of action in Syria with cross party support. A small majority in favour may be enough to technically authorise action, but on such an important issue he doesn't want to be exposed to the consequences when everything goes pear shaped - as it will, we will see images of civilians killed by British bombs, we won't see a rapid collapse of Daesh as "the 70,000" overwhelm Daesh controlled territory after precision bombs kill all the Daesh fighters, and we will see further terrorist attacks in western Europe (or, hopefully, foiled attempts).
 
Posted by lowlands_boy (# 12497) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by agingjb:
Given that Cameron's government has a majority in the House of Commons, I cannot see the relevance of the votes of the other parties. Of course if Cameron cannot rely on the votes of his own party then surely that is of far more significance than how the opposition votes,

I think the general idea is that going to war ought to be a matter of general consensus by the majority of the commons, not delivered by a party whip.

I've just read some more quotes from Ken Livingstone from a Radio 4 interview this morning, in which he said that in order to sort the problem out, we need to arrange occupation in the way we occupied Germany after the war.

Perhaps Afghanistan is a more accurate thing to try and compare occupation with, rather than Germany?
 
Posted by Pottage (# 9529) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Enoch:

In classic just war doctrine, it is step number 3. It comes after the the war having to have a just cause. But however justifiable the war may be in abstract principle, it has to pass all four test to be just. Even if the war may be potentially just 'in principle' it is not just if it won't be effective.

If Isis could be splatted, then it would be difficult to argue that attacking them at the moment would not be just - indeed, a service to humanity as a whole. If .... .

That's the reason why I'd vote no. It's not like the Falklands, which was just on tests 1, 2 and 4, but a big risk on 3. We took the risk. That was a legitimate decision. Fortunately, it paid off.

On this one, though, there's no direct connection between what's proposed and delivering the desirable result. Indeed, short of dropping a small nuclear weapon on Raqqa, which would be a total failure on 4, and without UN unanimity would not even pass step 1, there's no action anybody could take that appears to be capable of delivering the desirable result.

I think there could be an argument to be made for compliance with parts 3 and 4 of the test.

On point 3 "serious prospects for success" don't need to attend every individual element of a just war. Every individual assault or action need not be capable in itself of delivering outright success. If targeted bombing could cause material damage to IS's infrastructure and detract from the status it claims from simply existing as a self-declared caliphate functioning as a viable state in the face of all opposition, then it will contribute to success.

Bombing will need to be supported by other means. Many of those may not require a Parliamentary vote, such as attacks on IS's funds, recruiting, resourcing etc. Some potentially might, such as providing logistics, training, weapons or other aid to support a ground war conducted by third parties. Others plainly would (if they were in contemplation), such as contributing UK forces to a ground assault.

Point 4 is a question of fact and degree. Individual bombing missions would not be justifiable if, despite modern targeting and sophisticated weaponry, the perceived risk of causing damage to non-combatants outweighed the value of the target. But that doesn't mean we necessarily need to deprive ourselves altogether of the ability to bomb targets where it is believed that test 4 can be passed.
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Pottage:
If targeted bombing could cause material damage to IS's infrastructure and detract from the status it claims from simply existing as a self-declared caliphate functioning as a viable state in the face of all opposition, then it will contribute to success.

On that logic, anything that makes for a functioning government would be a valid target. A modern state requires electricity, so we'll take out power stations and transmission hubs, and consider the lack of power at hospitals a regrettable side effect. A modern state cares for the sick, so we don't need to worry about those hospitals without power, because they're targets too. How about education? Provision of clean water and food? The logic of that position very rapidly ends in absurdity.
 
Posted by Pottage (# 9529) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Alan Cresswell:
quote:
Originally posted by Pottage:
If targeted bombing could cause material damage to IS's infrastructure and detract from the status it claims from simply existing as a self-declared caliphate functioning as a viable state in the face of all opposition, then it will contribute to success.

On that logic, anything that makes for a functioning government would be a valid target. A modern state requires electricity, so we'll take out power stations and transmission hubs, and consider the lack of power at hospitals a regrettable side effect. A modern state cares for the sick, so we don't need to worry about those hospitals without power, because they're targets too. How about education? Provision of clean water and food? The logic of that position very rapidly ends in absurdity.
That would almost certainly fail limb 4 of the test though.
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
Who's going to be counting limbs though? Except for the limbs of children blown off by British bombs. Plenty of people will be counting those, each one of them will be testimony to our brutality.
 
Posted by Karl: Liberal Backslider (# 76) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Ariel:
quote:
Originally posted by Touchstone:
A political party that was not influenced by anyone at all would be a totalitarian state, surely?

Not necessarily. I just don't think that external organizations who may have their own agendas should form a pressure group on a political party to get that party dancing to their own tune.
Well that's the Tories out of the question then. More business interests both overtly and covertly influencing them than you could shake a Colliery Band Baton at.
 
Posted by Karl: Liberal Backslider (# 76) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Enoch:
Indeed, short of dropping a small nuclear weapon on Raqqa, which would be a total failure on 4...

/Tangent Any use of nuclear weapons would fail test 4 under all and any circumstances. For that reason, I have never understood why people who supposedly accept just war theory are not card carrying members of CND.

But it's like that reference to Morpheus' comment about loving enemies above innit? Christian principles are great until they actually might cost you something, then everyone starts equivocating and finding reasons to go diametrically against them.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
Enoch has me right. I was actually thinking of the just war criteria as described here.

To use language which I loathe; zero "collateral damage" is not an absolute 'jus in bello' (right conduct within war) requirement.

[Edited to provide translation of Latin]

[ 01. December 2015, 17:49: Message edited by: Barnabas62 ]
 
Posted by chris stiles (# 12641) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
Enoch has me right. I was actually thinking of the just war criteria as described here.

Absent any attempt to tackle sources of funding and ideology what is the probability of success.

At the moment all the vote proves is that there are some people for whom the acceptable number of civilian lifes they are willing to expend to prove a political point is greater than zero.
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
Cameron said something interesting, and Dan Jarvis has repeated it. This is that air-strikes in Iraq have worked, since IS territory has been 'retaken'.

Presumably, 'retaken' means that the Iraqui army has recaptured some territory, and maybe also some of the militias in Iraq.

Cameron is presumably saying that the same can happen in Syria, but he is being very vague about this. There are the fabled 70, 000 fighters, who despite being bombed by Russia, and fighting the Syrian army and Hezbollah, will be able to turn, and fight IS.

Of course, it could happen. It just strikes me as rather a suppositional foundation for war.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by chris stiles:
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
Enoch has me right. I was actually thinking of the just war criteria as described here.

Absent any attempt to tackle sources of funding and ideology what is the probability of success.

At the moment all the vote proves is that there are some people for whom the acceptable number of civilian lifes they are willing to expend to prove a political point is greater than zero.

I think that assumes zero additional degrading of IS capabilities as a result of the extension of bombing. There's a difference between being sceptical about that and knowing it for sure. The government has military advice and assessments to the contrary. That gives them reason to assert a military benefit from the extension of air strikes.

Of course it remains to be seen whether that is true. Your assumption may be right, but you don't know that for sure. I don't think Cameron wants to support Hollande purely for political reasons, though I've no doubt some of that is getting factored in.
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
Apparently those who vote against air-strikes tomorrow are "terrorist sympathisers" according to Cameron.

[brick wall]
 
Posted by chris stiles (# 12641) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:

There's a difference between being sceptical about that and knowing it for sure. The government has military advice and assessments to the contrary.

As they did for every previous intervention - military assessments that they don't seem to be able to explicate to anyone else in a way that makes logical sense.
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
I think that assumes zero additional degrading of IS capabilities as a result of the extension of bombing. There's a difference between being sceptical about that and knowing it for sure. The government has military advice and assessments to the contrary. That gives them reason to assert a military benefit from the extension of air strikes.

If the military had a history of bombing military targets without significant collateral deaths of civilians, well maybe we could believe them on this.

But they don't. Why should we believe that they'd do any better than the Americans, who have a lot more experience and still manage to take out hospitals?
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
chris styles, mr cheesy

Of course there are grounds for scepticism. No doubt we'll hear all about them in the House debate. I'm sceptical - I've said so twice.

Here's the motion. Whether MP's support it or not seems to me to depend on whether that word "accordingly" can be reasonably applied to the extension of air strikes.
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by quetzalcoatl:
Cameron said something interesting, and Dan Jarvis has repeated it. This is that air-strikes in Iraq have worked, since IS territory has been 'retaken'.

Yes, the Iraqi army (numbering 800,000) equipped by substantial US investment and training, supported by US special forces have managed to recapture one city after an operation lasting several months.

That is, of course, compelling evidence that an unspecified force of 70,000 poorly trained and armed fighters will be able to recapture Syrian territory after UK bombs have softened up the Daesh positions. [Roll Eyes]
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
chris styles, mr cheesy

Of course there are grounds for scepticism. No doubt we'll hear all about them in the House debate. I'm sceptical - I've said so twice.

Here's the motion. Whether MP's support it or not seems to me to depend on whether that word "accordingly" can be reasonably applied to the extension of air strikes.

Grounds for skepticism, but not grounds to say that the airstrikes are a) unlikely to achieve the aims and b) will likely make things worse for the victims and c) may just be a propaganda coup for whichever militant group gets hold of the videos of dying children..?

In fact, what good could actually come out of this? What would the best scenario be?

Bombing looks increasingly like madness. If it was anyone else (say Turkey launching carpet-bombing of Kurdish regions after the lasted attacks on Istanbul), I'd think many would think that a bad reaction - but somehow we feel compelled to respond in this way after the attack on Paris.

The most sensible move would surely be to choke off the routes of funding for IS, cut weapons and oil etc. But no, that's all lilly-livered IS-supporting apologist clap-trap, what we really need to do is bomb and to hell with any civilians who get in the way.

There may be a "just war", but this just ain't it.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
Cameron made a mistake last night if his remarks re 'terrorist sympathisers' at a private meeting of Tory MPs have been reported correctly. He moved from playing the ball to playing the man, from respect to disrespect. I think it will cost him votes today.

And I think that's a two sided coin. Borrowing a phrase from the West Wing, does the motion represent "a proportionate response" following Paris? Rather than some kind of disproportional 'gut reaction' strike back? That's what our elected representatives are going to decide today. Cameron's reported mistake could make this a closer call than forecast. Unusually, the quality of the arguments, rather than business as usual arm-twisting, might even decide this.

[ 02. December 2015, 09:12: Message edited by: Barnabas62 ]
 
Posted by Boogie (# 13538) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
Cameron made a mistake last night if his remarks re 'terrorist sympathisers' at a private meeting of Tory MPs have been reported correctly. He moved from playing the ball to playing the man, from respect to disrespect. I think it will cost him votes today.

I very much hope so.
 
Posted by Humble Servant (# 18391) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
Cameron made a mistake last night if his remarks re 'terrorist sympathisers' at a private meeting of Tory MPs have been reported correctly. He moved from playing the ball to playing the man, from respect to disrespect. I think it will cost him votes today.


I think this kind of talk could endanger our nation. The argument has been made that western bombing of Arab countries drives more "moderate" Arabs to support terrorists. I think the same effect could come into play with rhetoric. How far does he have to go before supporting terrorism is more palatable than supporting this arrogant country with its arrogant PM? Time for a regime change!
 
Posted by Pottage (# 9529) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
Cameron made a mistake last night if his remarks re 'terrorist sympathisers' at a private meeting of Tory MPs have been reported correctly. He moved from playing the ball to playing the man, from respect to disrespect. I think it will cost him votes today.

I agree. Norman Smith at the BBC is reporting that Cameron will mend fences when he speaks.

This is the second political error of judgement from Cameron, after the assertions of 70,000 moderate locals on the ground. That might, possibly, be true in a strictly technical sense, but not in the sense that he intended people to take it, of there being effective irregular forces able to take advantage of air strikes by taking ground from IS in the way that Kurdish forces have done in Iraq. I assume the government will be doing some "clarifying" of that during the debate too.
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Alan Cresswell:
quote:
Originally posted by quetzalcoatl:
Cameron said something interesting, and Dan Jarvis has repeated it. This is that air-strikes in Iraq have worked, since IS territory has been 'retaken'.

Yes, the Iraqi army (numbering 800,000) equipped by substantial US investment and training, supported by US special forces have managed to recapture one city after an operation lasting several months.

That is, of course, compelling evidence that an unspecified force of 70,000 poorly trained and armed fighters will be able to recapture Syrian territory after UK bombs have softened up the Daesh positions. [Roll Eyes]

Well, Cameron's thesis strikes me as flimsy and illogical. But that probably won't matter, since in politics you can go a long way with verbiage of a certain kind. I think quite a lot of people think, that we must be seen to be doing something. Image and status count for a lot.

But the actuality on the ground will probably be very different, as in Iraq. It's interesting that Al Qaeda were defeated in Iraq, but IS came back. How would Cameron explain that? Answer: he doesn't need to.
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Pottage:
the assertions of 70,000 moderate locals on the ground. That might, possibly, be true in a strictly technical sense, but not in the sense that he intended people to take it, of there being effective irregular forces able to take advantage of air strikes by taking ground from IS in the way that Kurdish forces have done in Iraq.

Which would mean recapturing very small areas of territory, with forces in the 10s of thousand supplied and trained (and supported by) US special forces on the ground. And, generally taking territory that was traditionally Kurdish or considered to be Kurdish by many Kurds. In the case of Sinjar also with the support of highly motivated Yazidis seeking revenge for the murder of 5000 Yazidi civilians by Daesh.
 
Posted by Ricardus (# 8757) on :
 
The BBC has an article analysing the possible 70,000 moderates. The problem is that most of these moderate factions are inside larger alliances whose stronger members are not at all moderate.

It does make the point that the 70,000 excludes the Kurds, but I thought that was because the Kurds are reluctant to fight outside of Kurdish areas.
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
FWIW, Cameron just claimed in the debate that the 70,000 did not include "fundamentalists" who are fighting IS but "we could not work with".

He says the 70,000 are from the FSA, albeit that they are not "ideal partners".
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
I don't think that Cameron will elaborate on the bombing in Iraq, as the differences are startling. In Iraq, there is a central government; there are large numbers of govt troops; there isn't a civil war; and there are not huge numbers of refugees.

Military action in Syria is quite different; I would say, a huge gamble, which could go horribly wrong. Still, Cameron will have the right image with other leaders.

I see that he is thrashing about on the 70, 000 rebels fighters, but it doesn't really matter. He has it in the bag anyway. Tories + Blairites, will win it.
 
Posted by Pottage (# 9529) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Alan Cresswell:
quote:
Originally posted by Pottage:
the assertions of 70,000 moderate locals on the ground. That might, possibly, be true in a strictly technical sense, but not in the sense that he intended people to take it, of there being effective irregular forces able to take advantage of air strikes by taking ground from IS in the way that Kurdish forces have done in Iraq.

Which would mean recapturing very small areas of territory, with forces in the 10s of thousand supplied and trained (and supported by) US special forces on the ground. And, generally taking territory that was traditionally Kurdish or considered to be Kurdish by many Kurds. In the case of Sinjar also with the support of highly motivated Yazidis seeking revenge for the murder of 5000 Yazidi civilians by Daesh.
Yes, I assume that's how the government imagines it too in reality, although translated to be relevant to the Syrian context. No Yazidis for instance, but some other groups (Assyrians, Turkomen, Armenians) are present in Syria with comparable motivation of which a few may be groups the West could be seen to work with. But this picture is not entirely consistent with the way the "70,000 fighters" references were spun, not least because many of these people are far more heavily invested in fighting Assad than IS (or Daesh, which seems to be the UK Government's officially sanctioned name for the Bad Guys, as from today).

Hence my characterising those earlier references as a political error of judgement by Cameron comparable to the "terrorist sympathisers" remark, for which he has so far been reluctant to apologise.
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
Yes, the "70,000" is pure spin. The intention is to suggest a large fighting force, it's about the size of the Territorial Army and half the size of the UKs regular armed forces. So, if it was a force trained and equipped to the level of a regular army, and could operate in a coordinated manner it would be a substantial force. But, it's facing a Daesh military estimated at 80-100,000 (some estimates upto 200,000) with over half that number in Syria. No sane military commander enters a battle without a significant numerical advantage. Putin is talkign of sending in 150,000 troops, which is the right sort of number of trained soldiers for a coordinated ground operation. Possibly still on the small side though.
 
Posted by Boogie (# 13538) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by quetzalcoatl:

Still, Cameron will have the right image with other leaders.

That's what it's all about, I'm sure.
 
Posted by Doc Tor (# 9748) on :
 
As we get to lunchtime, it seems to me that:

No one believes that bombing alone will have a significant effect on Daesh.

No one believes that the 70,000 figure is anything but fiction.

No one believes that, if we asked the Kurds or the FSA or al-Nusra to stop fighting Assad, that they'd do that.

No one believes that, if we asked Assad and Hezbollah to stop fighting the Kurds, the FSA or al-Nusra, they'd do that.

If Cameron had come to the dispatch box suggesting we "nuke the site from orbit. It's the only way to be sure", he'd actually have a more credible plan than the one he's currently proposing.
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
Cameron doesn't need a credible plan. After all, every time military action is taken in the Middle East, it's based on wishful thinking, and sexed up dossiers, and this is no different.

As to why large numbers of MPs want to believe Cameron's thesis, that goes to gullibility, fading imperial ambition, and keeping up appearances.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by quetzalcoatl:

As to why large numbers of MPs want to believe Cameron's thesis, that goes to gullibility, fading imperial ambition, and keeping up appearances.

I wouldn't have thought so on the Labour side at least given this list.

DC's opener was effective. He didn't apologise for the terrorist sympathy slur, but he acknowledged that a vote against could be an honourable vote. JC's response was not his finest hour. I think he muffed the opportunity provided by DC's mistake. Since he was going to duck on Iraq, challenging DC to apologise eventually backfired. I think he and his advisors should have seen that coming. Angus Robertson, for the SNP, did better.

With the Liberals and the DUP voting with the government and the way the debate has gone, the government motion now looks certain to pass.

[ 02. December 2015, 14:34: Message edited by: Barnabas62 ]
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
It all reminds me of the joke in therapy, that the cure makes you worse. I mean, that the West's idea that it has solutions to various problems in the Middle East, tends to make the problems worse, and also creates new ones. Still, we can't stop now, just one more fix.
 
Posted by Enoch (# 14322) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doc Tor:
As we get to lunchtime, it seems to me that:

No one believes that bombing alone will have a significant effect on Daesh.

No one believes that the 70,000 figure is anything but fiction.

No one believes that, if we asked the Kurds or the FSA or al-Nusra to stop fighting Assad, that they'd do that.

No one believes that, if we asked Assad and Hezbollah to stop fighting the Kurds, the FSA or al-Nusra, they'd do that.

If Cameron had come to the dispatch box suggesting we "nuke the site from orbit. It's the only way to be sure", he'd actually have a more credible plan than the one he's currently proposing.

That summarises what I already thought weeks ago, and is why if I were an MP, I'd vote No. Just in case anyone shipmate didn't realise I was being sarcastic when I referred to a small nuclear bomb, I'd also vote No to the second option.

quote:
Originally posted by quetzalcoatl
It all reminds me of the joke in therapy, that the cure makes you worse. I mean, that the West's idea that it has solutions to various problems in the Middle East, tends to make the problems worse, and also creates new ones. Still, we can't stop now, just one more fix.

It also reminds me of the joke about the therapist and the lightbulb - 'the lightbulb must really want to change'.

It's rightly no longer viable or acceptable to treat the Middle East as a suitable place for a colonial mandate, whether by the West or by returning it to the Turks. So any permanent change for the better there has to come from within its own culture. Nothing will stick if outsiders, whether us, the US, the Russians or anybody else try to dabble in the region even to achieve solutions which are self evidently worth it from where we are, but which aren't home grown and indigenous.

The Daeth is home grown and indigenous. So is the Ba'ath. The latter is not acceptable to enough people within the area any longer and has made itself less acceptable by the way it has held onto power. The scenes when Baghdad fell suggest that whatever else we might conclude, it had lost acceptability there too.

We all hope the Daeth isn't acceptable either. Nor, though, has anything been that anyone in the West, or for that matter Russia, has tried to prop up in Iraq or Afghanistan. There's nothing that looks like emerging in the area that is remotely viable except for Kurdistan for the Kurds - which of course nobody will support. That will not just upset the Turks who we want to keep on side. It also will diminish the authority still further - if such is possible - of any ineffectual government the west is trying to prop up in Iraq.

Of course there's also a Kurdish area in Iran as well. So supporting the Kurds upsets another power in the area. Although for understandable reasons the US doesn't like Iran that is a regime that is undeniably effective, home grown and indigenous .
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
And poor old Syria has become an arena for proxy forces, I've lost count of how many. US, Russia, Iran, UK, France, Germany, Turkey, Saudis, I suppose China is missing.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
I am disappointed in Archbishop Welby.
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
The Bishop of Coventry seemed rather less in favour of war than the Archbish.
 
Posted by Gamaliel (# 812) on :
 
Welby is a big pal of Canon Andrew White in Baghdad who has long been an advocate of more military action against ISIS ... or Daesh as we must now call them.

As far as I understand it, the term Daesh is a synonym for ISIS oe ISIL in Arabic - but Alex Salmond suggested that it is used in an ironic or mocking way - can anyone shed any light on that?
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/why-isis-hate-being-called-daesh-whats-correct-name-worlds-most-dangerous-terrorists-1531506

It is an accurate acronym of the arabic but sounds insulting. Like referreing to a (fictional) group called The Western Armed Theological Shocktroop as the TWATS.
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
Huh, I don't know - let me google that for you.
 
Posted by Anglican't (# 15292) on :
 
This Hilary Benn. He's good isn't he?
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
He is good at rhetoric. But still completely wrong.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
Vote in about 5 min.
 
Posted by Martin60 (# 368) on :
 
Along with most of parliament. Very clever of Hilary to invoke Fascism. I just hope Jeremy can survive as leader. He'll be vindicated, as he already is, regardless of course.
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
That was just the amendment - the nays had it.
 
Posted by Ariel (# 58) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Anglican't:
This Hilary Benn. He's good isn't he?

Cracking speech [Overused] some very pertinent points there. Margaret Beckett was good too.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
Of course IS are exactly not facist, as they are not nationalist. That is one of the reasons why they are so expansionist.
 
Posted by Martin60 (# 368) on :
 
Aye, a great speech. And wrong.
 
Posted by lowlands_boy (# 12497) on :
 
Wonder what his dad would have thought...
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
Well, that was depressing.

(Majority of 174 for air strikes.)

[ 02. December 2015, 21:33: Message edited by: Doublethink. ]
 
Posted by Anglican't (# 15292) on :
 
A clear result, though.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
Yes, very clear, I think we will live to regret it though.

[ 02. December 2015, 21:33: Message edited by: Doublethink. ]
 
Posted by Anglican't (# 15292) on :
 
This time yesterday I was ambivalent if slightly sceptical. I've changed my mind over the last 24 hours.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
What is your thinking on the matter ?
 
Posted by Anglican't (# 15292) on :
 
In no particular order:

-France has asked for help. We have a duty towards our close ally.
-Air power has succeeded in pushing back IS in Iraq. (They were at the gates of Baghdad not so long ago.)
-If we're going to bomb a land cruiser in the Iraqi desert for sound reasons, why stop if it crosses a border that for all practical purposes doesn't exist?
-there's UN backing.
-I'm more persuaded that these apparent 70,000-odd fighters exist.
 
Posted by Martin60 (# 368) on :
 
10 years ago I'd have been elated. And angry that we were doing so little, so late.

Now I'm just sad. The Kingdom is a step further away. I'm so proud of Jeremy.
 
Posted by Doc Tor (# 9748) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doublethink.:
Yes, very clear, I think we will live to regret it though.

Well, some of us might. Some of them might too.
 
Posted by fletcher christian (# 13919) on :
 
Does it have to be passed by the House of Lords?
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
FWIW

Originally posted by Anglican't:
In no particular order:

-France has asked for help. We have a duty towards our close ally.

I believe that places a duty on us to do something effective.
-Air power has succeeded in pushing back IS in Iraq. (They were at the gates of Baghdad not so long ago.)
I would argue there are much stronger and more coherent ground forces in Iraq, fighting mostly just one enemy. So the circumstances are sunstantially different.
-If we're going to bomb a land cruiser in the Iraqi desert for sound reasons, why stop if it crosses a border that for all practical purposes doesn't exist?
Essentially because a) the circumstances on the ground are very different, and b) mission creep to a ground war is much, much more likely.
there's UN backing.
I won't disagree on that, though I think "all means" could justify different kinds of actions.

-I'm more persuaded that these apparent 70,000-odd fighters exist.

I really am not.

There is something deeply surreal about watching over six hundred people debate passionately over an action that they *all* acknowledge will not, fundamentally, work. In that, this is not going to be a game changer, is not going to end the war or defeat IS etc. Killing for symbolism, is - at best - extremely problematic.

[ 02. December 2015, 21:58: Message edited by: Doublethink. ]
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by fletcher christian:
Does it have to be passed by the House of Lords?

No
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by lowlands_boy:
Wonder what his dad would have thought...

Tony Benn would have been proud of Hilary - and would probably have disagreed with him.

Also, I say this with some regret. The case against the extension of military actions was not put coherently by Jeremy Corbyn. The SNP reps did rather better.

The best speeches in favour of the resolution came from Margaret Beckett and Hilary Benn. In terms of Parliamentary performance, Hilary Benn played Jeremy Corbyn off the park. Opinions may differ about how much of that was rhetorical skill and how much was force of argument.

This was an important occasion for Jeremy Corbyn. I reckon he muffed it and is weaker as a result. Even if he is right on the issue (and that may indeed still prove to be the case), one of the key tests of party political leadership is the ability to be inspirational on big occasions. On that score, he really didn't do very well today.
 
Posted by Anglican't (# 15292) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doublethink.:
There is something deeply surreal about watching over six hundred people debate passionately over an action that they *all* acknowledge will not, fundamentally, work. In that, this is not going to be a game changer, is not going to end the war or defeat IS etc. Killing for symbolism, is - at best - extremely problematic.

Well, yes, I can see that we are not going to be decisive, particularly when we compare ourselves to the French and US commitment. But if we are still to be a front-rank power (and I believe that we should) then I think this is something we should be part of.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
What do you mean by a front rank power ?
 
Posted by Anglican't (# 15292) on :
 
A major world power. A world leader. That sort of thing.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
So we"d be killing for status then ? But why ? The empire is over and we are simply not going to become a superpower this century if ever again.
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
So, in a couple of days I get on a plane to come home, to a country that has clearly demonstrated that it's run by barbarians. A nation where our representatives can't find the money to adequately fund our health service and support the disabled in our midst, but is willing to throw money so that our airforce can kill children in Syria.

At least I only have a couple of hours in Heathrow, probably not long enough to become unclean from the filth of the Westmonster government before I head to the more civilised nation north of Hadrians Wall.
 
Posted by Gamaliel (# 812) on :
 
I can't see how much practical difference it will make - we're talking what 8 to 12 jets in the first instance - and however accurate their munitions it's not as if Daesh will sit there and wait to be hit.

Compare that to 69 Russian planes hitting anyone in opposition to Assad.

Sooner or later there's got to be some kind of negotiated solution - but I don't see stability anywhere in the region from here on in.

My immediate concern is that the RAF will be under pressure to deliver an early goal - it might be an 'own' one if they cause follateral damage. We aren't twlking WW2 or Vietnam style carpet-bombing but we are talking about civilian areas.

Even if successful, will ISIS cells continue to operate elsrwhere? I think so - perhaps not in as co-ordinated a way as the Paris attacks but you don't need more than a few nutters with Kalashnikovs or suicide gests.

Not sure where things go next ... but I was expecting the 'ayes' to have it.
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
I would love it if the UK was a world leader, a leader in demonstrating justice, peace, hospitality to those in need, to working towards ending the injustices that fuel war around the world. But, instead we're just the pet dog following the US into the latest ill-considered scheme to further destabilise the nations of the world and kill more children.
 
Posted by Martin60 (# 368) on :
 
Proud as I am of atheist Jeremy and his understated, rational 'performance' up against the deliberate, pathetic, false dichotomy of Cameron's about sub-contracting our defense - not in MY name - I'm so ashamed of my denomination's top man over Christ: 'The Just War criteria have to my mind been met.', Constantinian Welby today in the Lords.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
IS already has 3000 fighters in Sirte, Libya.

I wonder where IS fighters from Syria might go if, by some miracle as yet unforeseen, the over 70 different 'moderate' military factions morph into a cohesive army and drive them out of the area ?
 
Posted by Martin60 (# 368) on :
 
They've nowhere to go Doublethink. They cannot be defeated as no one really wants to engage with them militarily and therefore politically, let alone by loving them, which is the only way to permanently disarm them.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
FYI http://blogs.new.spectator.co.uk/2015/12/full-text-of-hilary-benns-extraordinary-speech-in-favour-of-syria-airstrikes/

It is a very good speech, but it doesn't really add any information to the debate that we have not already discussed on this thread. Invoking facism is, I think, inaccurate and somewhat misleading as to the circumstances under discussion.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Alan Cresswell:
So, in a couple of days I get on a plane to come home, to a country that has clearly demonstrated that it's run by barbarians.

Hilary Benn identified who the real barbarians are. We just have the 'misfortune' to live in a representative democracy. I heard one of the "Stop the War" campaign leaders say about the vote. "It may be the voice of Parliament, but it's not the voice of the British people". I winced at his arrogance and ignorance.

quote:
At least I only have a couple of hours in Heathrow, probably not long enough to become unclean from the filth of the Westmonster government before I head to the more civilised nation north of Hadrians Wall.
I do think the SNP made a better fist of presenting the anti-bombing position. They are firmly holding the "old Labour" ground in Scotland and today's vote will have provided further consolidation.

The Conservative rebels also presented the anti-bombing case well; particularly John Baron.

[ 02. December 2015, 23:02: Message edited by: Barnabas62 ]
 
Posted by Alan Cresswell (# 31) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
Hilary Benn identified who the real barbarians are. We just have the 'misfortune' to live in a representative democracy.

Identifying Daesh as barbarians is hardly a great point. I'm not sure anyone, except for Daesh themselves and a very small minority of sympathisers, would disagree. But, just because we are faced with (a very small number of) barbarians at the gate (the other end of the continent) doesn't mean we should turn into barbarians ourselves. We need to rise above using the weapon of the enemy, none of us can wield it.
 
Posted by lowlands_boy (# 12497) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
quote:
Originally posted by Alan Cresswell:
So, in a couple of days I get on a plane to come home, to a country that has clearly demonstrated that it's run by barbarians.

Hilary Benn identified who the real barbarians are. We just have the 'misfortune' to live in a representative democracy. I heard one of the "Stop the War" campaign leaders say about the vote. "It may be the voice of Parliament, but it's not the voice of the British people". I winced at his arrogance and ignorance.

quote:
At least I only have a couple of hours in Heathrow, probably not long enough to become unclean from the filth of the Westmonster government before I head to the more civilised nation north of Hadrians Wall.
I do think the SNP made a better fist of presenting the anti-bombing position. They are firmly holding the "old Labour" ground in Scotland and today's vote will have provided further consolidation.

The Conservative rebels also presented the anti-bombing case well; particularly John Baron.

Ex footballer Stan Collymoore reported last night that he had cut up his Labour membership card (having apparently only rejoined a couple of months ago, presumably as a Corbyn fan). He then tweeted to ask if an English man could join the SNP. Followed by another tweet showing that he had.

Back to that thread we had on whether the SNP could give birth to a new party?
 
Posted by Boogie (# 13538) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Alan Cresswell:
I would love it if the UK was a world leader, a leader in demonstrating justice, peace, hospitality to those in need, to working towards ending the injustices that fuel war around the world. But, instead we're just the pet dog following the US into the latest ill-considered scheme to further destabilise the nations of the world and kill more children.

Agreed.

[Tear]
 
Posted by Baptist Trainfan (# 15128) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Alan Cresswell:
I would love it if the UK was a world leader, a leader in demonstrating justice, peace, hospitality to those in need, to working towards ending the injustices that fuel war around the world. But, instead we're just the pet dog following the US into the latest ill-considered scheme to further destabilise the nations of the world and kill more children.

You are a man after my own heart, Alan.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
Does that make France a US lapdog too? I agree with Alan Cresswell about 99.9% of the time. But I don't think yesterday's vote result had much to do with a lapdog response to US pressure. The internationalist desire to support France and its socialist President, following the evil attack by an evil movement, had a lot more to do with 66 Labour MPs voting Aye on the main motion than any US sycophancy.

[ 03. December 2015, 09:26: Message edited by: Barnabas62 ]
 
Posted by Ariel (# 58) on :
 
Well, Hilary Benn has now received death threats. Charming. There's nothing quite like militant peace protestors who are prepared to kill people who don't want peace.

I thought his performance was outstanding. Intelligent, articulate, passionate, he looked like a leader in waiting to me. Pity he's on the wrong side [Biased]
 
Posted by Gamaliel (# 812) on :
 
I find myself torn on this one as I don't see anything particularly 'barbaric' about bombing oil-well heads that supply ISIS.

Obviously, I wouldn't tone down the rhetoric if I woke up this morning to hear that the RAF and France had flattened Raqqaa and killed hundreds of people.

I remain nervous about the wisdom of an apparent air-strikes only approach - and if we want to cut off funding to ISSIS we really ought to be putting pressure - through sanctions etc - against whoever it is who is buying their oil - although it might be embarrassing to the coalition to identify who that is - and you can't tell me that we don't know ...

If Putin's right and it's Erdogan, among others - then there are serious questions to he asked - although it suits Putin of course to blame the Turks.

Meanwhile, as much as I remain nervous about the current strategy - or apparent lack of it - I am hoping against hope thst the RAF can confine themselves - as far as possible - to hitting ISIS installations, vehicles and infrastructure.

That's a tall order in the crowded air-space over Syria and when trying to hit targets in cities.

With ISIS in Libya and elsewhere, hitting targets in Iraq and Syria won't stop them carrying out terrorist attacks - but it would stop them expanding their territory in Syria and Iraq and carrying out the bestial atrocities we've seen against the Yazidis, Christians and other Muslims.

You can't defeat a warped ideology simply by bombing it, though. There has to be a longer term hearts and minds thing. That's a lot harder.

I'm all for peace, love and understanding - but what would 'loving ISIS' look like on the ground? Smiling indulgently as they rape Yazidi women and girls and murder those they consider too old to be sex-slaves? Allow them to levy a tax on Christians or compel other Muslims to kowtow to their warped, apocalyptic fundamentalism?

I'm not confident that these 70,000 moderates could form a coherent force - and one MP put their numbers as low as 15,000 during yesterday's debate.

Nor am I confident that even if Assad stood down tomorrow they would stop fighting against whoever replaced him.

That leaves me with a terrible dilemma. The only thing I can hope for now is that the much-vaunted precision accuracy of the RAF missiles holds good.

Forget the 'front-rank nation' schtick. Both US and Russian commentators have dismissed the British contribution as 'token' at best. However, if, if, if please God if, civilian casualties can be kept to a minimum then there still might, just might be a glimmer of hope.
 
Posted by fletcher christian (# 13919) on :
 
How strange and tragic it must be to be living in Syria this morning and wake up to the news that your country will be bombed by yet another foreign power. And we wonder why they all seem to be on the move.
 
Posted by Baptist Trainfan (# 15128) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Ariel:
He looked like a leader in waiting to me. Pity he's on the wrong side [Biased]

Oh, I don't think the SNP would want to have him.
 
Posted by Gamaliel (# 812) on :
 
Sure, which is why bringing the civil war to an end must be a priority.

Cameron wanted to do that in 2013 by bombing Assad. Russia seem to want to do that now by bombing anyone who isn't Assad. We sem to want to do it by bombing ISIS and working with anyone who isn't Assad.

I don't know what the solution is - but sooner or later the talking has to start.

In some ways, military action against ISIS is 'easier' than similar action against other jihadist groups as they have territory and an above-ground infrastructure. It doesn't solve the problem though.

Jihadism is like a hydra. Cut off one head - or if it lops one of it's own - others grow in its place. We're talking generations of hard work on all sides to sort that out.

I'm nervous about what happens next and agree with other posters that the SNP performed well in yesterday's debate but I refuse to join Alan's condemnation of the rest of the UK as 'barbaric'.

That is overly emotive in my view. At least at this stage.
 
Posted by Mr Clingford (# 7961) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Anglican't:
A major world power. A world leader. That sort of thing.

I, like Doublethink, wish you to expand on what you mean. Alan has provided one interpretation - what do you think?
 
Posted by L'organist (# 17338) on :
 
Hilary Benn's speech will, I think, come to be seen as one of the great parliamentary speeches of our time. It showed, moreover, that in Hilary Parliament has a Benn who is a thoughtful and principled politician: that comparison with his 'leader' was remarkable.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Ariel:
Well, Hilary Benn has now received death threats. Charming. There's nothing quite like militant peace protestors who are prepared to kill people who don't want peace.

I'm sure that Hilary Benn and many others in the House know that they have painted big targets on themselves by the way they spoke and voted. I'm also sure they are robust enough to bat off twitter-feed dogpiling. That comes with the territory these days. Populist mobocracy is not representative democracy but it surprises me how many folks really don't understand the principles of representative democracy. And why it is the worst system in the world apart from all the others.

Even more seriously, this article re Daesh might give you another insight into the real difficulties all those who used the term Daesh now face. I may have missed it, but I think Jeremy Corbyn avoided using the term at all yesterday. Here is a telling quote.
quote:
IS threatened "to cut the tongue of anyone who publicly used the acronym Daesh, instead of referring to the group by its full name", the Associated Press wrote in September 2014.
How safe walking the streets will any MP be who used the term 'Daesh'? I should think the police and security services now have yet another headache to reckon with.

[ 03. December 2015, 10:45: Message edited by: Barnabas62 ]
 
Posted by Gamaliel (# 812) on :
 
I suspect they've got that headache already, Barnabas62.

As unsavoury as I find the prospect of further military action the point is that anyone of us has a target on ourselves as far as ISIS/Daesh are concerned.

What had the people enjoying a night-out in Paris done to deserve getting shot? Or people sunning themselves on a Tunisian beach?

Yes, of course there's a risk of politicians getting assassinated as a result of decisions made in Parliament.

What are they supposed to do? Not make any controversial or unpopular decisions lest someone take a pot shot at them?

[Confused]

I'm sorry ... but I really don't see the moral equivalence of the RAF bombing ISIS run oil well-heads in Syria and terrorists attacking people indiscriminately in the street. I don't. I really don't.

That doesn't make me complicit with 'child-killers' and the bombing of civilians any more than it makes those who opposed the PM in Parliament yesterday a 'terrorist sympathiser' - and Cameron was a prize numpty for making that comment - and even more so for not withdrawing it or apologising for it.

I suspect the reference to death-threats wasn't to ISIS targeting politicians but death-threats for well-meaning peaceniks ... and let's face it, some peace activists can be remarkably belligerent in their approach.

Now, I don't expect the vast majority of anti-war activists to approve of death-threats ... of course they don't.

But let's face it, there are some nutters on the left and the more 'alternative' side just as there are on the right and the 'establishment' side.

On balance, yes, I think this does ratchet up the threat of increasing radicalism and the increased likelihood of attacks on UK targets - both political, military and security services personnel and on the general public.

But that threat is already there. Make no mistake about that. I don't believe for one moment that MI5 and the security services are exaggerating when they say they've foiled 7 terrorist plots against the UK over this last year alone.

I'm uncomfortable with military action for a whole range of reasons - but I certainly don't believe that the UK is descending into 'barbarity' as a result of this decision.

Yes, if we were deliberately targetting civilians and randomly carpet-bombing Syrian cities then that would be the case - but unpalatable as I find any form of bombing we're not talking about 'Bomber Harris' style attacks here on the level of Allied bombing of the Ruhr or Dresden in WW2.

On the issue of Jeremy Corbyn and his party - did anyone see Alan Johnson's barbed attack on his party leader during the debate?

I'm surprised that didn't get more coverage ... he went straight for the jugular.

I'm not saying he was right or wrong to do so - but there are clearly deep, deep divisions in the Labour Party that are beginning to become even more apparent than they have been so far.
 
Posted by Gamaliel (# 812) on :
 
Sorry, I meant 'death-threats FROM well-meaning peaceniks'.

Yes, I meant that. I've got a lot of time for peace lobbyists and activists, but we have to acknowledge that there are some pretty wild and woolly ones.

I don't take those sort of threats particularly seriously ...

Besides, anyone who issues such a threat puts themselves at risk of being traced and arrested for it ...

If there have been death-threats against Hilary Benn they'll have come from some fringe loonies of some kind.

I'm sufficiently impressed by Corbyn to distance him from that sort of thing - but there are some nasty people around the fringes of the Labour left just as there are equally nasty people on the extreme Tory right.

A plague on both their houses.
 
Posted by Boogie (# 13538) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by L'organist:
Hilary Benn's speech will, I think, come to be seen as one of the great parliamentary speeches of our time. It showed, moreover, that in Hilary Parliament has a Benn who is a thoughtful and principled politician: that comparison with his 'leader' was remarkable.

He spoke brilliantly. What a shame he was wrong. My wish is for Benn's delivery with Corbyn's worldview, ideas and beliefs.

No chance [Frown]
 
Posted by lowlands_boy (# 12497) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Boogie:
quote:
Originally posted by L'organist:
Hilary Benn's speech will, I think, come to be seen as one of the great parliamentary speeches of our time. It showed, moreover, that in Hilary Parliament has a Benn who is a thoughtful and principled politician: that comparison with his 'leader' was remarkable.

He spoke brilliantly. What a shame he was wrong. My wish is for Benn's delivery with Corbyn's worldview, ideas and beliefs.

No chance [Frown]

I think that was his father wasn't it?
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Boogie:
quote:
Originally posted by L'organist:
Hilary Benn's speech will, I think, come to be seen as one of the great parliamentary speeches of our time. It showed, moreover, that in Hilary Parliament has a Benn who is a thoughtful and principled politician: that comparison with his 'leader' was remarkable.

He spoke brilliantly. What a shame he was wrong. My wish is for Benn's delivery with Corbyn's worldview, ideas and beliefs.

No chance [Frown]

I wish he hadn't referred to the International Brigades in Spain, that made me feel a bit sick.
 
Posted by la vie en rouge (# 10688) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Baptist Trainfan:
quote:
Originally posted by Ariel:
He looked like a leader in waiting to me. Pity he's on the wrong side [Biased]

Oh, I don't think the SNP would want to have him.
On the radio the other morning Hillary Benn strenuously denied that he was interested in the Labour leadership job.

On this basis, I predict that he will be Leader of Her Majesty’s opposition within the year. [Biased]
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
The problem is that every single phrase Hilary Benn used in his speech is complete bollocks.

Here is a link to the text in case you want to refer to it.

First he makes comments about the slur on the nay side. Not about anything. 0 points.

Next he says some people have made good speeches. Not about anything. 0 points.

Next he says the carnage in Paris could have happened in London. True, but not clear how bombing Syria would make any difference. Half a point.

Next he says there is a UN Security Council mandate. Which is true, except as was stated in the Lord's debate, that only gives legal cover up to the bounds of humanitarian law. And also, of course, several permanent members of the SC are not getting involved in bombing (China), and one is bombing the allies of the other (Russia) whilst the others support the allies of those fighting their allies (USA, France, UK). Not therefore a very strong point. Another half a point.

Then he talks about Vienna, as if Assad is prepared to negotiate about leaving Syria. He isn't. Not a point.

Then he says gay people are being thrown off buildings. Which is true. But again, not clear how bombing is going to do anything other than kill more exploited people in the IS controlled area who are not allowed to leave. Not a point.

Then he talks about the bombing of the plane and the terrorist attacks on tourists. By this logic, we'd be bombing Russia for the Ukraine plane bombing. Not a point.

Then he asks whether in terms of national security we can stand aside. Well, yes we can. Like various other countries who are not getting involved.

Then he says airstrikes have halted Daesh in Iraq. OK, that might be true. But then the situation in Iraq is not the same as in Syria. Not therefore relevant.

Then he comes up with some mumbo-jumbo about the 70,000 ground troops. Nobody believes this number means anything. As was stated in the debate, we've all heard these kinds of claims before, but when it comes to it there are never ever the numbers of supportive troops on the ground. Never. Point disproven by history.

Then he says that the Kurdish leader has said that airstrikes have helped. OK, but this doesn't really help much given that Turkey, our allies, see the Kurds as more of an enemy than Daesh/IS. One could also point to lots of people who say that airstrikes are making things worse - who may or may not be believable, depending on your own point of view.

Then he says the enemy is fascist. Which is probably inaccurate, but we know what he means. But this is also irrelevant: by this reasoning, Saudi is a fascist regime. Who is suggesting to bomb them?

Then he says some guff about the need to stand up to evil. Which nobody can disagree with, obviously - but clearly the question is whether an expensive bombing campaign launched largely because the French are reacting to the pain of a terrorist attack will actually achieve as much as - say - dealing with the bank accounts, the funding, the oil movements, the antiquities smuggling and the other ways that IS gets money. This is not a proven point.

This speech was 15 minutes of emotional rhetoric with about 1 decent point. The rest was total waffle.
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
Yeah, but the Tories liked it.
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by quetzalcoatl:
Yeah, but the Tories liked it.

The sad part is that so much of our politics and legal system is based on the ability of people trained in rhetoric to give speeches that sound impressive but contain no checkable content. The "truth" seems to go out of the window when someone with a slightly cracked voice stands up and says a bunch of things without reading it from a bit of paper.

Woopie do. Best speech we've ever heard.
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
I think people were impressed because it was a better pro-war speech than Cameron's. But Cameron tends to go to pieces in situations like this, and his grasp of detail, such as the 70, 000 friendly fighters, gets foggy. Mind you, as mr cheesy has pointed out, Benn made some weird points, e.g. on the border between Iraq and Syria.

[ 03. December 2015, 11:47: Message edited by: quetzalcoatl ]
 
Posted by lowlands_boy (# 12497) on :
 
Or as John McDonnell put it this morning, he was very impressed with Benn's speech, that reminded him of Blair making the case for Iraq. And he always worries that the best oratory makes for the biggest mistakes.
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
I thought that Benn's chances of becoming leader are now precisely zero.

Still, it was possibly the best pro-war speech since Blair's.
 
Posted by Gamaliel (# 812) on :
 
Yes, I heard him say that and in principle believe that to be the case ... oratory has got us into some pretty fine messes ...

I'd be all in favour of freezing assets, disrupting the trade in antiquities and other forms of fund-raising that ISIS/Daesh go in for ... but whether we like it or not, we are already bombing ISIS targets in Iraq. Sure, things have gone up a gear now we're bombing within the Syrian borders - but I'm not sure if the chance of collateral damage is any greater in one 'theatre' over against the other.

If it's wrong to bomb within Syria then surely it must be wrong of us to bomb ISIS targets in Iraq?

Mr cheesy's comparison with the downing of the passenger plane over Ukraine, apparently by Russian backed rebels using Russian-sourced equipment is pertinent ... but it's not a like-for-like comparison ... unless it could be proven that the Russians fired the missile themselves.

Sure, Russia is backing the rebels in that part of Ukraine but I'm sure they were no more in favour of downing a passenger jet than we would have been ...

No, what we are dealing with in the case of ISIS is an organisation that is pulling the trigger itself, that is wielding the butcher's knives, that is raped, enslaving, killing and torturing - and which is spreading it's warped ideology across disaffected Islamic youth.

Ok, so bombing them doesn't necessarily resolve that problem - at least not in and of itself - but it could, just could, erode their capacity to launch attacks and incursions on the scale we've seen - not so much the terrorist attacks as the capture of towns and regions and the subjecting them to a brutal, fundamentalist 'caliphate' theocracy ...

Stemming the terrorist aspect is going to take a lot longer and be a lot more complicated ... and somehow bringing the civil war in Syria is going to have to feature somewhere.

How the heck we tackle/deal with ISIS in Libya and elsewhere is another issue - but we have to start where we are. It's a bit like the old story of the Irish chap giving directions, 'Well, I wouldn't start from here ...'

But 'here' is where we are. Railing against the illegal invasion of Iraq or the Tories or the non-Corbynite Labour MPs might make us feel better by sounding off in righteous anger - but it doesn't get us very far.

No, bombing within the Syrian borders isn't a magic bullet, it's not going to make everything ok - it could make things worse - but it's where we are. We're committed to it now. My hope is that it doesn't last long and that there'll be some kind of stomach across all the countries involved to address the wider issues without the usual point-scoring, sabre-rattling and posturing that goes on at a real-politik level ... but I'm not holding my breath.

Yes, go after the accounts of those who buy oil from ISIS. Name and shame them, even if that causes diplomatic blushes. Tackle them in their wallet. Rather that than bombing - but bombing it is ... so if that's the way it is then we have to go with that - with the hope that they take out the right targets and not the wrong ones ... but that's an awful, awful risk ...
 
Posted by Pottage (# 9529) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by mr cheesy:
Then he says some guff about the need to stand up to evil. Which nobody can disagree with, obviously - but clearly the question is whether an expensive bombing campaign launched largely because the French are reacting to the pain of a terrorist attack will actually achieve as much as - say - dealing with the bank accounts, the funding, the oil movements, the antiquities smuggling and the other ways that IS gets money. This is not a proven point.

Is there any suggestion that bombing IS targets throughout the territory they have laid claim to rather than just in part of it (which is what was authorised) will replace whatever would otherwise be done to target them in other ways: attacking their bank accounts and their sales of oil and smuggled antiquities, curtailing their flow of volunteers, taking down their propaganda, challenging their narrative amongst those likely to be susceptible to it etc? It seemed to me that it was implicit in everyone's arguments on both sides of the debate that all of this good stuff would continue, regardless of the bombing mandate.
 
Posted by Humble Servant (# 18391) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Pottage:
curtailing their flow of volunteers

Well bombing will certainly do the opposite of that. Every civilian killed is another family of willing volunteers for ISIS. Has ISIS bombing of Paris curtailed the number of advocates of war in Syria?
 
Posted by Pottage (# 9529) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Humble Servant:
quote:
Originally posted by Pottage:
curtailing their flow of volunteers

Well bombing will certainly do the opposite of that. Every civilian killed is another family of willing volunteers for ISIS. Has ISIS bombing of Paris curtailed the number of advocates of war in Syria?
Yes, that's a risk. Sadly there aren't possible courses of action that are free from risk. Even doing nothing at all has consequences. After all, IS aren't looking to kill us because of what we've done, but because of what we are. As the Shia, Yazidi, Christian and Kurdish populations of both Iraq and Syria can confirm. Those of them who can still be reached for comment.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
mr cheesy, I'd like to pick you up on a couple of points from your analysis of Hilary Benn's speech.
quote:
The problem is that every single phrase Hilary Benn used in his speech is complete bollocks.
The first sentence asserts a conclusion which you seek to prove.

quote:
This speech was 15 minutes of emotional rhetoric with about 1 decent point. The rest was total waffle.
The last sentence asserts that the presentation was not complete bollocks.

Which is it? A speech devoid of any sensible content. Or a speech with marginal sensible content? Or did you just realise while writing the post that "complete bollocks" didn't stand up even to your own subjective analysis of content?

It was a subjective analysis, wasn't it? You recognise that point a couple of times.
quote:
Then he says that the Kurdish leader has said that airstrikes have helped. OK, but this doesn't really help much given that Turkey, our allies, see the Kurds as more of an enemy than Daesh/IS. One could also point to lots of people who say that airstrikes are making things worse - who may or may not be believable, depending on your own point of view.
Of course it depends on your point of view! It's about a balanced judgment of conflicting evidence. Good people can disagree without calling "bollocks".

quote:
Then he says some guff about the need to stand up to evil. Which nobody can disagree with, obviously - but clearly the question is whether an expensive bombing campaign launched largely because the French are reacting to the pain of a terrorist attack will actually achieve as much as - say - dealing with the bank accounts, the funding, the oil movements, the antiquities smuggling and the other ways that IS gets money. This is not a proven point.
Guff is of course loaded language to demean what was said. That's a rhetorical flourish also. But you finish up with "This is not a proven point". Of course it isn't. It isn't a disproven point either. Again good people can disagree about what constitutes balanced judgment without calling "bollocks".

In passing, I note without enthusiasm the following argument by John McDonnell

quote:
Shadow chancellor John McDonnell has compared Hilary Benn's well received Commons speech advocating airstrikes against Isis in Syria to Tony Blair's pre-Iraq War speech in 2003.

"I thought Hilary, his oratory was great. It reminded me of Tony Blair’s speech taking us into the Iraq War and I’m always anxious about the greatest oratory is going to lead us to the greatest mistakes as well," he said.

Source; Huffington Post article

That's really playing the man, rather than the ball. No analysis anywhere in sight. Instead its this; "Let's assert first that it was just the power of the rhetoric then remind ourselves of another occasion. Then let's tar Benn with the "Bliar" brush." I smell sour grapes.

This from Jess Phillips, Labour MP for Birmingham Yardley (who voted against the motion) strikes me as a much better response.

[ 03. December 2015, 13:04: Message edited by: Barnabas62 ]
 
Posted by chris stiles (# 12641) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Gamaliel:

If it's wrong to bomb within Syria then surely it must be wrong of us to bomb ISIS targets in Iraq?

In Iraq bombing is largely happening in support of the Iraqi Army - i.e targeting is being done in support of ground forces, and from intelligence provided by ground forces in some cases.

This isn't the case in Syria. One you've hit the obvious military sites there isn't much else to do that won't involve hitting civilians as collateral. There were reports - prior to Britain joining this effort - of planes coming back with bombs because they couldn't find targets to hit.
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
The first sentence asserts a conclusion which you seek to prove.

Correct, I've been to rhetorician school too - you state your conclusion, you state the reasons for getting to the conclusion and then you state the conclusion again.

quote:
The last sentence asserts that the presentation was not complete bollocks.
Right. For avoidance of doubt, let me state that half a point and half a point does not add up to a point. He had no points.

quote:
Which is it? A speech devoid of any sensible content. Or a speech with marginal sensible content? Or did you just realise while writing the post that "complete bollocks" didn't stand up even to your own subjective analysis of content?
I'm obviously not using the same book of cynical phrases that you are used to using. Let me repeat: none of his statements held up to any scrutiny in my opinion. You are, of course, free to believe otherwise.

quote:
It was a subjective analysis, wasn't it? You recognise that point a couple of times.
Well, I'm not sure asking for evidence - and showing that none has actually been given - of statements is, in fact, subjective.

But, OK, if you like - the fact that I think the man was talking total shite was subjective. You are free to believe he is talking slight shite, talking sense or the Queen's inerrant brother, if you like. I'd rather stick to thinking about whether his rhetoric has any basis in fact, thanks all the same.


quote:
Of course it depends on your point of view! It's about a balanced judgment of conflicting evidence. Good people can disagree without calling "bollocks".
It was fairly clear that Mr Benn thought that quoting the Kurdish leader was some kind of knock-out blow for his argument. I don't believe it is - having heard a range of quotes on the subject from the messages that have somehow emerged from Raqqa, from the Russians, from the Syrian regime, from a bunch of other people - it is clear that one could find equal-and-opposite phrases to quote. Therefore this is not any kind of knock-out blow in argument.

Incidentally, I didn't say anything about Mr Benn personally, I just said his speech was bollocks. You are free to believe differently.

quote:
Guff is of course loaded language to demean what was said. That's a rhetorical flourish also. But you finish up with "This is not a proven point". Of course it isn't. It isn't a disproven point either. Again good people can disagree about what constitutes balanced judgment without calling "bollocks".
As above.

quote:
In passing, I note without enthusiasm the following argument by John McDonhell

quote:
Shadow chancellor John McDonnell has compared Hilary Benn's well received Commons speech advocating airstrikes against Isis in Syria to Tony Blair's pre-Iraq War speech in 2003.

"I thought Hilary, his oratory was great. It reminded me of Tony Blair’s speech taking us into the Iraq War and I’m always anxious about the greatest oratory is going to lead us to the greatest mistakes as well," he said.

Source; Huffington Post article

That's really playing the man, rather than the ball. No analysis anywhere in sight. Instead its this; "Let's assert first that it was just the power of the rhetoric then remind ourselves of another occasion. Then let's tar Benn with the "Bliar" brush." I smell sour grapes.

Nope. I'm not sure why, but you seem unable to see a difference between attacking an argument and attacking the person.

Let me spell it out for you: claiming that someone is an apologist for IS is attacking the man. Saying that the speech he just made which so many are claiming was the best since 1945 is, by definition, not.

quote:
This from Jess Phillips, Labour MP for Birmingham Yardley (who voted against the motion) strikes me as a much better response.
That's nice.
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:

This from Jess Phillips, Labour MP for Birmingham Yardley (who voted against the motion) strikes me as a much better response.

On this, I'd say that a politician who does not understand the consequences of standing on a point of conscience should not be a politician. A party is free to deselect a sitting MP, just as consistuents are free to vote them out.

If you, as an MP, decide to make a stand on an issue that does not have overwhelming support locally, then that's all well-and-good, but as the system is set up you have to live with the consequences: which could including deselection and losing your seat. Deal.

[ 03. December 2015, 13:14: Message edited by: mr cheesy ]
 
Posted by Gamaliel (# 812) on :
 
Sure - which is surely better than them dropping them anyway, irrespective of whether there are targets or not ...?

But I take the point you're making - it's hard to see which ground troops the air strikes in Syria are meant to support ... Assad's? Any of the 100 or so factions on the rebel side?

I appreciate it's tricky. One would hope, though, that if there are insufficient ISIS targets for the RAF and other coalition air forces to strike, then they'd call off the air strikes - rather than going through with them as a matter of course or - as Russia appears to be doing, bombing ISIS targets and any other target that isn't Assad's forces.

I'm uncomfortable with the whole situation but I can't say I'm upset by ISIS oil-wells being hit - provided that could be done without collateral damage if at all possible.

I'm not a hawk. I'm largely a pacifist but I'm not a total pacifist - I do think there are occasions when force is necessary and in the case of ISIS I believe the line to have been crossed long ago. If there were no ISIS bases in Syria we wouldn't be having this discussion ... we'd presumably (most of us) be concerned - but broadly in favour - of limited action to hold back ISIS in Iraq.

The trouble is, Iraq's in a mess (of our making) and its own forces crumpled very quickly when put under pressure by ISIS. Sure, air strikes aren't the best thing to do but they have helped contain ISIS in Iraq - in support of the Kurdish peshmerga and others.

Unless we conclude that there is no case whatsoever for some kind of military response against ISIS by France, the UK, US, Russia or anyone else from outside the region, then what are the alternatives?

It can't be a one-shop-stop solution. There has to be action against the funding of ISIS in some way - and also the long, hard slog to prevent their toxic ideology from spreading.

What other military options might there be? Send in SAS style snatch-squads to take out the leaders? Large scale Russian invasion with hundreds of thousands of boots on the ground and the prospect of another Afghanistan?

There's no obvious neat solution. If there was someone would have come up with it by now.
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Gamaliel:

It can't be a one-shop-stop solution. There has to be action against the funding of ISIS in some way - and also the long, hard slog to prevent their toxic ideology from spreading.

During the debate, many MPs asked for evidence that these kinds of actions (bank accounts, oil, etc) have been undertaken. And nobody could provide any.

Yes, it is all very well to say now "OK, listen this bombing will be undertaken in co-ordination with various other activities to choke off IS funds.." but the reality appears to be that very little of these former activities have been done. Perhaps because, as others have said (by MPs during the debate and on this bulletin board), we might find a few skeletons in that particular cupboard if we looked hard enough.

Past performance in conflict shows that we're prepared to spend £multimillions on dropping a few bombs and £pennies on reconstruction. Because, y'know, we live in a military-industrial-political world where we actually need to have regular wars to keep everyone employed.

Yes, I do really believe that.
 
Posted by Gamaliel (# 812) on :
 
I've often heard that argument, mr cheesy, particularly from people in the US of both left-wing and right-wing persuasions ... I'm not sure I buy into it ...

It seems rather too neat. 'The Government and Powers That Be are out to shaft us - that's why they bring us to the brink of WW3 and mutual mass destruction ... in order to feather their own nests and support the military-business combine ...'

It's an argument that suits both right-wing libertarians as well as those who consider themselves cuddly lefties. But hey ...

Similarly, Hilary Benn has been accused of supporting the bombing simply as a way of undermining Corbyn and enhancing his own career.

Whatever his reasons might have been I'm not so cynical as to believe that Benn would advocate killing people simply to further his own self-interest ... I can be cynical, but I'm not that cynical ...

I've also seen it suggested that whilst France is brokering necessary Russian and Iranian support for the Vienna talks - with a view towards ending the Syrian civil war in some way - the West is treading carefully in terms of the obvious sensitivity involved.

However, I've also seen it suggested that it's more than that - and involves a lack of transparency about Sunni financial support for ISIS among individuals in the Gulf States and among some of the West's allies in the region. The finger points to some of the Gulf States in this respect.

I confess myself to be ambivalent about the Syrian/Iraqi border issue - as ISIS clearly operates across it as if it didn't exist. Arguably, the extension of bombing across that border is marginal militarily - but it is significant politically.

What happens next? It's going to be messy whatever happens. But is anyone realistically saying that there is some kind of simple, clear-cut solution that doesn't involve force or military action in any way, shape or form?

Of course, military intervention doesn't in and of itself defeat ideologies like that of ISIS ... combating that will take time, effort and years and years of patience ...

On the issue of embargoes, sanctions and other means of stemming the funding of ISIS - yes, nobody in the debate was able to outline any measures in that direction and that's a woeful omission.

I'm squeamish about military action, I really am ... but what are the chances of persuading/nailing those individuals (or systems/governments) which are apparently supporting ISIS financially to do so without resorting to some kind of military threat there too - sooner or later?

Do we bomb ISIS bases in Syria or do we bomb Riyadh or Ankara or Dubai, perhaps, because there are individuals there who trade with ISIS?

Where do we draw the line?
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
Sort of interesting that an "exclusive" interview had Hilary Benn on 15 November 2015 (yes, that is a few weeks ago) saying that the "Government should drop plans for a new House of Commons vote authorising military attacks in Syria to concentrate on peace talks and providing humanitarian support for refugees."

A lot of things happen in a couple of weeks, I guess.
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
In that vein, it is quite interesting what Philip Hammond is quoted (in the Mail, mark you) as saying in September 2014

‘Let me be clear – Britain will not be taking part in any air strikes in Syria. We have already had that discussion in our parliament last year and we won’t be revisiting that position.’

Have things really changed with respect to IS between September 2014 and now?
 
Posted by betjemaniac (# 17618) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by mr cheesy:
In that vein, it is quite interesting what Philip Hammond is quoted (in the Mail, mark you) as saying in September 2014

‘Let me be clear – Britain will not be taking part in any air strikes in Syria. We have already had that discussion in our parliament last year and we won’t be revisiting that position.’

Have things really changed with respect to IS between September 2014 and now?

Without getting down off the fence as to if it's a good idea or not, since September 2014 the UK has had a general election (so technically we now have a different parliament to 2013 and 2014). Over the same time period ISIS have (not exhaustive):

blown up a Russian airliner
massacred over 100 people in Paris
massacred multiple Britons (and others) on a Tunisian beach

Alongside this, Russia and France have piled into the conflict.

I can see why things might just be worth revisiting (even if the decision had been taken to do nothing differently) given all that.

The big thing since Mr Benn's quote is of course Paris.

[ 03. December 2015, 15:34: Message edited by: betjemaniac ]
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by betjemaniac:
Without getting down off the fence as to if it's a good idea or not, since September 2014 the UK has had a general election (so technically we now have a different parliament to 2013 and 2014). Over the same time period ISIS have (not exhaustive):

blown up a Russian airliner
massacred over 100 people in Paris
massacred multiple Britons (and others) on a Tunisian beach

Alongside this, Russia and France have piled into the conflict.

Yes, that's all true. But I don't think it follows that therefore there was more call for attacking IS today than there was in 2014.


quote:
The big thing since Mr Benn's quote is of course Paris.
I could be reading it incorrectly, but I think the text makes it clear the interview was conducted since the Paris attacks.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
mr cheesy

I didn't say you were playing the man. You were asserting your opinions about his speech, which is fair game.

As it happens, I don't think Benn's speech was all rhetoric. It's a fact that France's socialist government has asked for help. It's a fact that Labour is, historically, an internationalist party. It's a fact that Karwan Jamal Tahir wrote the words that Benn read out about the effectiveness of air strikes and the fictional nature of the Iraq/Syrian border so far as the Daesh are concerned. Benn simply used those facts in support of his argument. Others in the debate used them the other way.

Clearly your mileage varies, but this from Jess Phillips struck a real chord with me.

quote:
What I am certain of is that those who are so certain that they are right are certainly not as clever or good as they think they are.
I'm an old guy, and maybe an increasingly old-fashioned guy, but this from the beginning of Hilary Benn's speech speaks to me much louder that his conclusions.

quote:
Before I respond to the debate, I would like to say this directly to the Prime Minister: Although my right honourable friend the Leader of the Opposition and I will walk into different division lobbies tonight, I am proud to speak from the same Despatch Box as him. My right honourable friend is not a terrorist sympathiser, he is an honest, a principled, a decent and a good man and I think the Prime Minister must now regret what he said yesterday and his failure to do what he should have done today, which is simply to say ‘I am sorry’.

Now Mr Speaker, we have had an intense and impassioned debate and rightly so, given the clear and present threat from Daesh, the gravity of the decision that rests upon the shoulders and the conscience of every single one of us and the lives we hold in our hands tonight. And whatever we decision we reach, I hope we will treat one another with respect.

So far as John McDonnell's comments are concerned, they would have got him a pass from me as a Purg Host if he and Benn were Shipmates. So in Ship's terms, what he said was not the equivalent of a Commandment 3 offence.

But as a long term observer of political life in this country (not a Host in this discussion forum) I'm sure he was playing the man, rather than the ball in terms of RL politics.

Benn is the news today. Nobody really thought he had that sort of speech in him. By reputation, he's a rather diffident, serious, earnest and courteous man. Not too different from Jeremy Corbyn in that respect. In House of Commons speechifying terms, he is a rhetorical lower order batsman who hit a six out of the ground. In sharp contrast to his leader, who really did not have a good day. Something clearly had to be done about that.

What McDonnell came up with was something like this. "You can't trust a man who has great rhetorical skills - just look at Bliar". That's called guilt by association isn't it, given Tony Blair's current status as demon. Of course you can argue that I'm just being cynical, but that's what I saw.

[ 03. December 2015, 15:47: Message edited by: Barnabas62 ]
 
Posted by betjemaniac (# 17618) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by mr cheesy:
quote:
Originally posted by betjemaniac:
Without getting down off the fence as to if it's a good idea or not, since September 2014 the UK has had a general election (so technically we now have a different parliament to 2013 and 2014). Over the same time period ISIS have (not exhaustive):

blown up a Russian airliner
massacred over 100 people in Paris
massacred multiple Britons (and others) on a Tunisian beach

Alongside this, Russia and France have piled into the conflict.

Yes, that's all true. But I don't think it follows that therefore there was more call for attacking IS today than there was in 2014.


quote:
The big thing since Mr Benn's quote is of course Paris.
I could be reading it incorrectly, but I think the text makes it clear the interview was conducted since the Paris attacks.

no, I think that's the chronology in my head being slightly off - you're right. OTOH, there are an awful lot of other things in that article which I rather think he might row back from now - particularly his "hailing" of Corbyn. That suggests 4 options to me (YMMV):

1) he's a complete opportunist
2) he believed it when he said it
3) almost everything he said in the interview was taking the party line at the time
4) what he's seen of decision making since November 15th within the Corbyn bunker/shadow cabinet has convinced him he was wrong at the time

I think the truth is probably somewhere between 2,3,and 4, with 4 probably the most likely. That's just gut feel though.

[ 03. December 2015, 15:51: Message edited by: betjemaniac ]
 
Posted by Gamaliel (# 812) on :
 
Yes, mr cheesy, I had noticed that Benn had changed his tune since that interview with The Independent - I would have provided a link to it myself to balance out my earlier comments if I hadn't been dashing around and posting at the same time ...

People do change their minds - but granted from November 15th until now isn't a great deal of time to go through a paradigm shift ...

I'm not sure about a lot of this - but like Barnabas62 I wouldn't dismiss Benn's speech as purely rhetorical - nor, I suspect, did it swing the balance from a 'nay' to an 'aye' in favour of bombing within Syria - although I wouldn't be surprised if it convinced a few waverers within his own and other parties or those tempted to abstain.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
I heard that Benn's speech may have persuaded around 15 Labour undecideds to join the Ayes. So you're quite right. It didn't materially affect the result. A comfortable majority became a very comfortable majority.

There was low farce on the Daily Politics programme today, during which a member of the Socialist Workers Party attacked a Labour MP for being Blairite because he protested about some of the deselection moves being made (by her and others). Apparently she had joined the Labour Party to vote for JC so had at least for the time being dual party membership. What made it funny was that she assumed he'd voted for the motion when he had voted against it!

I had a good laugh, but her language and approach were very reminiscent of the Militant Tendency infiltration approach which almost killed the Labour Party a couple of decades ago. Up til then I hadn't really got on board the 'mixed bag' dimension of those who joined the party before the vote on the leader.
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
I wonder how many Western politicians realize that you can destroy IS physically, but they will come back again and again, until the political issue of Sunni representation is solved.

In both countries, the Sunni tribes and groups keep moving towards extremism, because they feel shut out. Al Qaeda were destroyed in Iraq, and the tribes helped in this, but then again the Iraqui govt shut the tribes out, and some of them turned towards IS.

Of course, Assad has no intention of giving them any kind of political autonomy.

You can kill every IS member, but they will regenerate, until this is solved.
 
Posted by Ariel (# 58) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Barnabas62:
I had a good laugh, but her language and approach were very reminiscent of the Militant Tendency infiltration approach which almost killed the Labour Party a couple of decades ago. Up til then I hadn't really got on board the 'mixed bag' dimension of those who joined the party before the vote on the leader.

Someone else was making a similar point in one of the news sources this morning. I think it was with reference to Momentum, which he said was increasingly beginning to resemble the Militant Tendency.
 
Posted by agingjb (# 16555) on :
 
Apparently there were 66 Labour MPs who supported the Cameron line, and they are being told they have no place in the Corbyn Labour party.

I remember the Gang of Four, who never become much more than about the Gang of 20. But they came close, and probably only the intervention of General Pinochet stopped them.

This could be the Gang of 66. One sufficient atrocity and they could end up, without much enthusiasm on any side, a bigger and more effective gang - although, FPTP being what it is. a Tory one-party state will still likely see me out.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
agingjb

Well, there will be pressure but since one of those who would be deselected (Tom Watson) is the elected Deputy Leader of the Labour Party, you can pretty much guarantee that something else will happen.

There was another media farce this evening. Adam Boulton (Sky News) interviewed a spokesperson for Left Unity, a group which has used social media to list all MPs who voted for the motion, and have urged local constituency parties to deselect those MPs.

It turned out that the spokesperson was not a member of the Labour Party, but was a supporter of Corbyn's views. She seemed to have a limited understanding of MPs' constituency responsibilities or the difference between representatives and delegates. She sounded pretty 'Militant Tendency' as well. The only polls that mattered were the ones that supported her viewpoint. She seemed not to appreciate the significance of the decision to allow a free vote. All in all it was a pretty bizarre performance.

Clearly a good deal of fun can be had with this, but there is a serious dimension as well. Some of the social media and other means of intimidation has been bad enough to justify reference to the police.

I think Jeremy Corbyn and Tom Watson are acting together to put a stop to abuse and intimidation. That's good. The Labour Party has enough problems at present. It really doesn't need these kinds of 'help' from some of its self-declared 'friends'. It's up to the local constituency parties to form their views in accordance with their constitutional responsibilities and freedoms. That's also a part of the processes of representative democracy.

[ 03. December 2015, 21:11: Message edited by: Barnabas62 ]
 
Posted by chris stiles (# 12641) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by quetzalcoatl:
I wonder how many Western politicians realize that you can destroy IS physically, but they will come back again and again, until the political issue of Sunni representation is solved.

I do not think this is true. Iraq's government is largely Sunni yet ISIS exists in Iraq.

There are a number of problems across a lot of the Arab World that allow ISIS to exist. Weak and authoritarian governments, Governments and states being coterminous, regional loyalties being stronger than national ones, and the export of extreme forms of Islam from Saudi that tend to set the agenda elsewhere.
 
Posted by Martin60 (# 368) on :
 
How is that possible when the population is 65% Shia?
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
There is a clear overlap between this thread and the one on hypocrisy.

This one has probably reached the end of its natural life with the vote having been taken. It seems reasonable to allow a bit of time for post-vote reflection; meanwhile I'll consult with other Purg Hosts not as involved in this thread as I've been over the best course of action. Meanwhile, feel free to carry on discussing the post vote ramifications here.

Barnabas62
Purgatory Host
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
Meanwhile ....

This looks like a decent move.

I don't think it's possible in practice to stop social media dogpiling. There are some fringe body non-party-member Militant Tendency types out there who have decided to flex their social media freedoms in pretty appalling ways. With "friends" like that, who needs enemies?

All the more reason, therefore, to establish decent standards of conduct by party members. Leadership disapproval needs to be clear and ongoing.
 
Posted by Sioni Sais (# 5713) on :
 
I participate in a couple of Leftist FB sites and some of the posts have been appalling. On our Hell board they would have had the Hellhosts asking whether they should be allowed. Lots have been passionate and a few have been reasoned, cool and calm. About 90% in the "passionate" zone I'd say.

Some of the abuse, but not a lot, has been worse than what was said by the Prime Minister in the House of Commons, but no one expects him to apologise. He, ministers and other members of both houses should set an example first.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Sioni Sais:


Some of the abuse, but not a lot, has been worse than what was said by the Prime Minister in the House of Commons, but no one expects him to apologise.

I did. I think he will live to regret that he didn't.

quote:
He, ministers and other members of both houses should set an example first.
Too right. And a similar argument applies to Labour re some of its "friends". Different circumstances, different responses, but I still remember Neil Kinnock's confrontation of Militant Tendency. I think it saved the Labour Party.
 
Posted by Doublethink. (# 1984) on :
 
I am pleased with Tom Watson's suggestion. I think Corbyn has also been very clear in his condemnation.

It certainly isn't unique to Labour, the conservatives are still dealing with the fallout of that young activist's death - which is thought to have been due in part to bullying from within the party. Whilst the Lib dems have had significant issues over allegations of sexual harrassment.

I think social media are exposing elements of political culture that have been around for a long time - and I think that exposure may lead to it being better addressed.

[ 04. December 2015, 10:57: Message edited by: Doublethink. ]
 
Posted by Enoch (# 14322) on :
 
It's a very like the two sides in Northern Ireland. The other lot, be they the Provos or various loyalist groups of plug-uglies, are terrorist savages, beyond the pale of humanity, blowers-up of babies etc.

Of course some of our lot go a bit too far, but they're still our boys. It's understandable since they feel so strongly about the cause - which of course, unlike the other lot's, is a good one. And anyway, even if we don't like some of what they do, we've got to stick up for them because they're on our side. Anyway, if we don't, nobody else will, and there's got to be some sort of threat to maintain group loyalty.
 
Posted by mr cheesy (# 3330) on :
 
Telling that the academics at the War Studies department of King's College London are calling this Britain's stupidest war.
 
Posted by quetzalcoatl (# 16740) on :
 
Most wars are stupid, but recent wars in the Middle East have put military solutions before political ones, with predictable ghastly results.

Syria is now such a criss-cross of proxy forces, that it's difficult to predict what any action will lead to.

For example, Russia seems to want Assad to rule Syria again, but this could set off a Sunni uprising, which would make IS look quite mild, and could spread across the whole region.

I guess in the background, they are trying to negotiate some kind of withdrawal by Assad - but followed by what? Extremism will flourish in such situations, and military action can easily exacerbate it.

I don't think politicians think that far ahead.
 
Posted by Enoch (# 14322) on :
 
There's no prospect of a political solution from outside the region. Alas at the moment theres no very obvious place from which one within the region appears to be likely to emerge apart from the truly horrible nightmare of the Daesh taking over the lot and imposing on it their Islamic version of North Korea.

Nor is there any point in the well-meaning talking about working for peace if the people they'd need to work with are totally determined that they don't want to be facilitated.
 
Posted by Barnabas62 (# 9110) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Doublethink.:

I think social media are exposing elements of political culture that have been around for a long time - and I think that exposure may lead to it being better addressed.

Yes. The Big Issue may be the future of representative democracy in the communication age. The ease and rapidity of mass communication and mass response seems to give the option of greater levels of consultation with all voters than have been possible up to now.
 
Posted by Sioni Sais (# 5713) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by mr cheesy:
Telling that the academics at the War Studies department of King's College London are calling this Britain's stupidest war.

I'll give that argument more credit when it isn't the current war, because the current war is at best uncertain.

If the professionals at RUSI give an opinion, that will be worth a read. In any case the competition for "Britain's stupidest war" is pretty stiff. The three Afghan wars in the 19th century were all pretty bad, many aspects of the Zulu and Boer wars were hardly better. Mind you, had we lost a carrier in the South Atlantic in 1982 that would have been a military disaster and subsequent events would have been very different.
 
Posted by rolyn (# 16840) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by quetzalcoatl:
Most wars are stupid, but recent wars in the Middle East have put military solutions before political ones, with predictable ghastly results.

Syria is now such a criss-cross of proxy forces, that it's difficult to predict what any action will lead to. ....
....I don't think politicians think that far ahead.

Putting a brutally cynical overview on this whole predicament I would say the West, (and Russia if their willing to fall in), are seeking to gain control over the oil bearing areas . It may well be a continuous task to keep anti-democracy fighters at bay these areas until the oil's gone. It might even be possible to buy them off one day when warfare and martyrdom has fallen out of fashion.
One thing's pretty certain, this is going on for decades. The ME is awash with arms and our dependency on oil is such that military activity is a price worth paying. The collateral damage at home will fall where it falls.
 
Posted by Martin60 (# 368) on :
 
Russia isn't interested in oil except in containing the wealth generated by its proselytizing enemies, Sunni Islam, owning it.

95% of the Soviet empire is being Salafized by Saudi money. By the time the oil runs out Arabized Turkestan threatening Russia and China and India through Pakistan will be a fait accompli. India will have Bangladesh, drowning due to India's exponential coal consumption, to contend with.

The have-nots will all have Islam.

10,000 years.
 
Posted by itsarumdo (# 18174) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Humble Servant:
quote:
Originally posted by Pottage:
curtailing their flow of volunteers

Well bombing will certainly do the opposite of that. Every civilian killed is another family of willing volunteers for ISIS. Has ISIS bombing of Paris curtailed the number of advocates of war in Syria?
I get the uncomfortable feeling from comments by Syrians that ISIS has been allowed to expand and directly assisted by Assad as a way to win his own war - he seems to have a policy of depopulating the country so that only his own supporters remain. As each small group falls, it will eventually be between him and ISIS, and the west/russia will not allow ISIS to win.

As said above, every single civilian death as a result of western bombing is a potential recruiting call for ISIS/A Quaeda et al. And even the mere presence of western and russian intervention is also a recruiting poster for them.
 
Posted by Stetson (# 9597) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by itsarumdo:
quote:
Originally posted by Humble Servant:
quote:
Originally posted by Pottage:
curtailing their flow of volunteers

Well bombing will certainly do the opposite of that. Every civilian killed is another family of willing volunteers for ISIS. Has ISIS bombing of Paris curtailed the number of advocates of war in Syria?
I get the uncomfortable feeling from comments by Syrians that ISIS has been allowed to expand and directly assisted by Assad as a way to win his own war - he seems to have a policy of depopulating the country so that only his own supporters remain. As each small group falls, it will eventually be between him and ISIS, and the west/russia will not allow ISIS to win.

As said above, every single civilian death as a result of western bombing is a potential recruiting call for ISIS/A Quaeda et al. And even the mere presence of western and russian intervention is also a recruiting poster for them.

I dunno. Assad would have to be COMPLETELY INDIFFERENT to the well-being of his own Alawite religious group, to allow ISIS, which hates their guts and would probably like to kill all of them(along with Shiites generally) a free hand in grabbing territory. Much less to give them outright assistance.

That would be like Obama helping the KKK to take over major American cities and start lynching black people, in order to get sympathy from the world.

[ 06. December 2015, 14:09: Message edited by: Stetson ]
 
Posted by Enoch (# 14322) on :
 
I'm with Stetson on this one. I've heard Syrian groups being interviewed in the UK in the last few days who say what Itsarumdo has cited them as saying. However, I suspect they've got their own particular kite to fly, and that's the way they are putting their case.

That case is that their enemy is the Assad/Baathist regime. They think the Daesh has alarmed the West so much, which was anti the Assad/Baathist regime, that it is now about to change its collective mind on that. That's a fair worry for them to have. We might be. From where we are, that might even be unavoidable. But it doesn't mean they are objective or the sort of people we want to be persuaded by.

Even right back when the civil war started in Syria, a lot of these groups were fairly committed to a strongly Islamist world view, Islamist rather than Alawist or Baathist. This was clear from what European based volunteers were not saying when they were being interviewed on television here. The Daesh is so extreme that one can be what most of the rest of us would regard as fairly extreme but still regard the Daesh as a potential enemy.
 
Posted by chris stiles (# 12641) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Enoch:
I'm with Stetson on this one. I've heard Syrian groups being interviewed in the UK in the last few days who say what Itsarumdo has cited them as saying. However, I suspect they've got their own particular kite to fly, and that's the way they are putting their case.

I tend to agree. I think part of it is a case of regional (to Syria) priorities.

[The government seems to be intent of keeping an enclave along the coast at the very least - and are supported in this by Russian air strikes.]
 
Posted by itsarumdo (# 18174) on :
 
Well, somehow they have managed to sell oil. Lots of it. Difficult for a landlocked region without somebody's cooperation.
 
Posted by Ricardus (# 8757) on :
 
The US State Department has been making similar claims to itsarumdo...

[Cross-posted]

[ 06. December 2015, 19:12: Message edited by: Ricardus ]
 
Posted by chris stiles (# 12641) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by itsarumdo:
Well, somehow they have managed to sell oil. Lots of it. Difficult for a landlocked region without somebody's cooperation.

Well, we know that they ship oil via Turkey - which they have a direct border to.
 


© Ship of Fools 2016

Powered by Infopop Corporation
UBB.classicTM 6.5.0