Thread: Children with special needs Board: Oblivion / Ship of Fools.
To visit this thread, use this URL:
http://forum.ship-of-fools.com/cgi-bin/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic;f=70;t=026118
Posted by Niminypiminy (# 15489) on
:
Do any other shippies have a child/children with special needs?
If you have, and you'd like a thread where you could moan and whinge (I seem to need to do a lot of that), ask advice, share experiences and even good news, then this might be it.
I've got two children, the elder of whom has Asperger Syndrome. We're all going through a hard time at the moment, although as things have been better in the past I have to trust they will be better again.
I know a couple of parents of children with AS in RL and having people who know what parenting a child with special needs is like is a life-saver. Having that support here too would mean a lot to me.
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
There are a bunch of Shippies with special-needs kids. In fact, we used to have a private board, but it fell into disuse.
A special thread here might be helpful. I'd be happy to participate.
Posted by Niminypiminy (# 15489) on
:
Excellent!
Posted by Japes (# 5358) on
:
I don't have children, but I do work with children and teenagers with a whole range of special needs. I'd be happy to join in from that point of view.
Posted by Zacchaeus (# 14454) on
:
Mine might have grown up and left home but they still have special needs...
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Zacchaeus:
Mine might have grown up and left home but they still have special needs...
Some of mine are all grown up, some aren't.
And all grown up sometimes (not always, but sometimes) looks different for someone with special needs.
Posted by Welease Woderwick (# 10424) on
:
Has this thread got a future? It was started and a few folks seemed keen then I found it on Page 5.
Posted by Niminypiminy (# 15489) on
:
It's my fault, I let it languish, having started it up in a rush of enthusiasm.
I used to post on another forum which was dedicated to children with special needs, but it was dominated by parents who couldn't see past their own children's situation, and whose lives were dedicated to their children's special needs.
While my son's condition shapes my life in particular ways, it isn't the whole of it, and I don't feel that he is the most disadvantaged person in the whole world. So now I don't visit that forum. But it does help to talk to people in a similar situation sometimes, so I started the thread.
But it may be that this isn't the time and place -- if not maybe the thread should go.
Posted by busyknitter (# 2501) on
:
I'll be happy to play. My younger son is autistic, severe end of the spectrum.
Posted by Welease Woderwick (# 10424) on
:
I think we're happy for the thread to be here if it keeps moving - I don't mean racing, though sometimes it might then it will slow down again. I think it is a useful thing to have around.
Posted by Smudgie (# 2716) on
:
I too work with children with a wide range of special needs / disabilities / complex health needs. While I cannot talk about my work here, this is a thread which I will find interesting. Before my current job I worked for 20 years as a mainstream school teacher with particular interest in special needs and for part of that time was SENCO (for my sins!)
I also have a son, no longer at home, with severe Attachment Disorder.
Posted by Curiosity killed ... (# 11770) on
:
I'm another one with an interest in special needs having worked in special needs for most of my working life and with a daughter with dyslexia / specific learning difficulties (educational psychologist assessed several times over).
Posted by Boogie (# 13538) on
:
My eldest son has ADHD - not grown up and doing well, but I still worry about him (of course!)
Posted by PeteC (# 10422) on
:
If there is new need for It's not Holland,perhaps a petition to Simon (together with some filthy lucre, and the name of a volunteer host) could be of some benefit.
I believe the old board is archived, but it could be resurrected.
closing parentheses - gah.
[ 08. September 2012, 09:35: Message edited by: PeteC ]
Posted by comet (# 10353) on
:
if this thread gets legs, I'll be following. Technically, the only real special needs person in my family is probably me*; but my youngest is becoming more and more eccentric as he grows and I'm finding myself challenged in all new ways. I will take all of the ideas I can get.
*perhaps my kids can join in and commiserate about bringing up mama.
Posted by Boogie (# 13538) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Boogie:
My eldest son has ADHD - not grown up and doing well, but I still worry about him (of course!)
Oooops - NOW grown up, not not
Posted by Niminypiminy (# 15489) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Boogie:
quote:
Originally posted by Boogie:
My eldest son has ADHD - not grown up and doing well, but I still worry about him (of course!)
Oooops - NOW grown up, not not
Oh, I like the idea of being not grown up and doing well!
My elder son has autism/asperger syndrome. He's just - yesterday - had his ninth birthday. He's such a sweetheart and yet I've sometimes wondered how I will survive his childhood. And whether the whole family can ever not be absolutely dominated by him and his needs.
But anyway, he's also lovely, and looking at him today singing along to Thin Lizzy's greatest hits (current obsession) on his new mp3 player, my heart aches with love for him.
Posted by North East Quine (# 13049) on
:
One of my godsons has autism and ADHD; I don't want to discuss him on this thread, but I will be interested to read what others post. The ADHD has a bigger negative impact on him than the autism, I think.
Posted by birdie (# 2173) on
:
How did I miss this?
Both my kids have disabilities. My son, 7, has spina bifida , and my daughter, 4, has CHARGE syndrome , which is a rare one.
They're both on the milder end of the possible outcomes for their conditions, but life is very full of hospitals, therapies, surgery, and carrying out medical procedures at home on a daily basis which most people think only happen in hospital...
Life with them is bonkers, exhausting, terrifying and wonderful. I couldn't imagine it any other way.
Posted by Enigma (# 16158) on
:
I guess I was once a child with special needs. My needs were met thanks to my parents, family and friends who treated me as normal even though I am not.
Now I am just me..................trying to work out which category I would be in Paralympics ---- not sporty more musical would be the one!!
For all you parents with unusual children - just treat them as usual - it worked for me anyway!
Posted by Loveheart (# 12249) on
:
Both my son and I have Asperger Syndrome. He is nearly 11, and is SO excited over his birthday, he is fit to burst! I am trying to pin him down on what we are going to do, but he keeps having meltdowns at the suggestions "you are totally ruining my birthday" (things being ruined he has learned from his non-Aspie older sister). Have been firm with him, but we do need to make arrangements, so will be pinning him down later (not literally, well unless he gets too over excited).
He really really wants a Nerf gun, but I am a bit eek about this, we don't really do guns, and the thought of him let loose with one is a bit argh. Suggested other alternatives, but it has to be a nerf dart gun!
Posted by Curiosity killed ... (# 11770) on
:
Boys are pretty keen on guns. We had no guns as a policy at the pre-school groups I worked in, and the boys built guns out of stickle bricks, Lego and/or any other construction toys. You could "misunderstand" and provide him with a Nerf water blaster which would get cold and miserable very quickly or spud gun which fires potato pellets, which are probably less dangerous things. Or you could just give him what he wants, but ban its use inside, outside only. His friends are going to be bored of guns quite quickly so whatever happens this is going to be a short-lived phase.
Posted by Enigma (# 16158) on
:
Got a friend with a son with autism. Both brilliant. When did the term dis-ability start? We all are unique!!
Posted by Loveheart (# 12249) on
:
Thanks. If I choose to misunderstand, it might get thrown across the room! He already has a water pistol. But I met someone on holiday, her aspie son had one, just without the darts, so that is a possibility, and less damp than one that squirts water!
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Enigma:
For all you parents with unusual children - just treat them as usual - it worked for me anyway!
Thank you for the encouragement, Enigma. Some of us have children, though, whose needs can't be met if we "just treat them as usual." Unless you define "as usual" to include regular blood glucose testing and dietary restrictions for the child with Type I diabetes, or physical therapy and occupational therapy for the child with severe fine motor impairments, or instruction in Braille and the use of a cane for a child who is blind, or, well, any of a number of other unusual things that some children need, but most don't.
That's often what's hardest about being a parent of a child with special needs. You want to treat them like typical children. And in some ways and at some times, you can. But the reason that they're considered to have special needs is that they genuinely, truly have needs that other children don't have.
Posted by Caissa (# 16710) on
:
Our oldest sone (15) has AS and our youngest child is mildly on the Spectrum.
Posted by PeteC (# 10422) on
:
Is anyone interested in starting up again It's not Holland? I would be willing to host, but I cannot, at this point pony up the starting fee.
If you are willing to discuss in public, that's ok too!
Posted by Niminypiminy (# 15489) on
:
What is the starting up fee?
Some things are fine in public, but it might be that it would be easier to talk freely in private.
Posted by PeteC (# 10422) on
:
Not sure anymore. It's a yearly fee; might be 50 pounds, if I recall correctly. Split among 10 or so people or more, a small cost.
PM Simon for details.
Posted by Curiosity killed ... (# 11770) on
:
It's here - up to 25 members, £65 / $100, 25-50 members £95 / $150 and etc.
Posted by PeteC (# 10422) on
:
And if you are oversubscribed, the money may be put forward for the next year. But someone has to contact Simon for permission - these are his Boards, after all.
Posted by Enigma (# 16158) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Josephine:
quote:
Originally posted by Enigma:
For all you parents with unusual children - just treat them as usual - it worked for me anyway!
Thank you for the encouragement, Enigma. Some of us have children, though, whose needs can't be met if we "just treat them as usual." Unless you define "as usual" to include regular blood glucose testing and dietary restrictions for the child with Type I diabetes, or physical therapy and occupational therapy for the child with severe fine motor impairments, or instruction in Braille and the use of a cane for a child who is blind, or, well, any of a number of other unusual things that some children need, but most don't.
That's often what's hardest about being a parent of a child with special needs. You want to treat them like typical children. And in some ways and at some times, you can. But the reason that they're considered to have special needs is that they genuinely, truly have needs that other children don't have.
Yes I agree J completely -- all of that. But still usual for them. I think sometimes it's harder for the parents. But I'm not one so .....
Posted by Qestia (# 717) on
:
My oldest (just 7) was just diagnosed with ADHD. He's been in speech and occupational therapy for years. He's an amazing brilliant creative enthusiastic kid, but increasing becoming oppositional and defiant about the smallest diagreements. He's always been intense, but I feel things are getting worse, or got worse over the summer when we were not doing a lot of the therapies that happen only during the school year. Hopefully this fall will show improvement, as we add all those back in (plus karate), as I'm hesitant to medicate a 7 year old developing brain, it's very exhausting being his parent and not letting his issues overwhelm the rest of the family (he has a little sister). In short I'd love to join the group.
Posted by Niminypiminy (# 15489) on
:
Excellent!
What do people think about bringing back the It's not Holland private board? If you would like to (and/or would/could contribute to the fee) could you PM me ?
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Qestia:
He's an amazing brilliant creative enthusiastic kid, but increasing becoming oppositional and defiant about the smallest diagreements. He's always been intense, but I feel things are getting worse, or got worse over the summer
Are you familiar with the book, The Explosive Child? It is the best book out there for helping parents manage children who are oppositional and defiant. No blame, no shame, just a focus on identifying missing skills and then teaching those skills, and on identifying and solving problems.
An excellent resource for parents of twice-exceptional children (i.e., children that are both cognitively gifted and disabled in some way) is the GT-Special listserv.
Posted by Smudgie (# 2716) on
:
On the subject of the private board, I joined initially but, as I sort of expected, I hardly looked at it. Between my mail and FB and the Ship and the Wibsite (must get back into reading that more often), I have enough pages to keep my interest and know that I won't look at anything else, especially as my interest in the subject it not at the forefront of my mind. So personally I would rather discussion were on the public board, even though it might reduce my ability to speak openly.
But that's just me... and my need for a place to discuss the more personal side of parenting is not great.
Posted by Qestia (# 717) on
:
Thanks, Josephine-- I'll check out both of those. I'm agnostic on the private board-- maybe we should just see how it goes with this thread first.
Posted by MSHB (# 9228) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Loveheart:
Both my son and I have Asperger Syndrome.
I'm another parent with AS (Asperger's syndrome). None of my children have AS, although one has inherited my difficulties with sound sensitivity. I grew up before AS was recognised and I wasn't diagnosed until middle aged. In fact, the Ship played a role in that.
Reading some of the posts here reminds me of how, as a child, I would be fixated on a particular gift or activity for my birthday, and would end up in tears (meltdown) if it didn't happen. As my parents are no longer alive, I cannot ask them how "bad" it was from their perspective.
But there was no "special ed" back then. Unless something extreme happened, you just struggled on. I was depressed and anxious during high school, but no one picked it up. I really hope that nowadays people are much more aware of teenagers with AS. I needed intervention of some kind, but didn't get it until my twenties, when I was floundering at university.
So even "mild" cases - someone with AS who goes on to have a career and marriage - may need a significant amount of help during their teens and twenties. I am really grateful for the help I did receive.
Posted by Niminypiminy (# 15489) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Josephine:
quote:
Originally posted by Qestia:
He's an amazing brilliant creative enthusiastic kid, but increasing becoming oppositional and defiant about the smallest diagreements. He's always been intense, but I feel things are getting worse, or got worse over the summer
Are you familiar with the book, The Explosive Child? It is the best book out there for helping parents manage children who are oppositional and defiant. No blame, no shame, just a focus on identifying missing skills and then teaching those skills, and on identifying and solving problems.
An excellent resource for parents of twice-exceptional children (i.e., children that are both cognitively gifted and disabled in some way) is the GT-Special listserv.
I also have an oppositional and defiant child. I haven't got The Explosive Child (it was on my list and then I forgot about it, so thank you to Josephine for reminding me!). We have been working on compromise this summer (helping my son to see that we can both have bit, though not all of what we want). It's slow progress, but when he is calm he is now more open to the idea of 'doing a deal' (I say to him, 'I'll do a deal with you, man cub'), in which we trade things we want.
It's really, really slow work teaching those missing skills. And we still get into terrible scenes where he is backed into a corner and refuses to give up on what he wants -- even if it would be unpleasant or dangerous for him. Sometimes the only way through it is to agree ('OK, nimlet1, you use the razor-edged cleaver to cut yourself a piece of cheese'), because then he will back down. But that's quite a hairy strategy, and in the long term, he needs to be able to get out of the corner. I can't see police, for example, being willing to say something like this.
Posted by Niminypiminy (# 15489) on
:
(excuse double post -- but this is a different topic)
It seems like there isn't a great enthusiasm at the moment for reviving the It's not Holland private board. But let's not rule it out for ever -- there may be a time when it wants or needs to come back.
Posted by Loveheart (# 12249) on
:
For those of us in the UK, can I just say how helpful I've found the organisation SIBS, for helping siblings? They've given me lots of useful advice, and are helping me to help support my lovely daughter who gets a bit left out sometimes.
Posted by Goar (# 3939) on
:
Hit the wrong button and stumbled into SoF by accident after 4 years of ship leave. So pleased and comforted to see everyone still here. Especially you folks from This is not Holland.
My reading list for special needs kids is growing. My mother recommended The Explosive Child because it has helped my sister in her dealings with my 8-yo Nephew who is very explosive and has been diagnosed with OCD and has some Tourrette's symptoms.
Suusan and I are now reading The Out of Sync Child while we seek diagnosis for our our third child.
She and I have four boys ages 3yo Quatro, 4yo Tigger, 5yo Floppy Headed Night Owl, & 7yo Señor Frog. Lately our main parenting concern is getting 4-yo Tigger diagnosed properly. We have known for ages that something is off. Especially on the gross motor skill front. Quatro is 18 months younger than Tigger and usually learns new physical skills far before Tigger (turning door knobs, jumping, holding a pen, eating neatly, personal toilet hygeine, carrying his plate etc). He is four and all these things are still very challenging for him. We never had to teach any of the other kids how to open a door, how to put on socks, how to pull up your underwear. They just did it. With Tigger we have to go over these things and practice over and over and over again. And at 4 he still can't do them with ease or consistently without help.
Two years ago we took Tigger for an evaluation but were told there was no diagnosis because at that time cognitively Tigger was bright but just barely in time to qualify for normal range on gross and fine motor skills. I wondered if the "in-system" health care providers are there to keep you from getting your insurance companies' money. We then did a year of out-of-pocket OT which seemed to help at first before plateauing.
Every so often our hopes are lifted. Tigger is the most patient and persistent kid I have met. He does not give up. He loves baseball and at three would go outside on the patio and watch his body trying to throw a ball in the reflection of the sliding glass door. He is trying to imitate the motion of a pitchers fully wind up. Eventually he got to where he could throw a ball - but he HAS to do a full pitcher's wind up now to accomplish it with any success. Oddity of oddities, he has taught himself to ride a bike. Our 5 yo Night Owl accomplished this first even before the 6 yo. So Santa delivered a no-pedal balance push bike for the family. 6 yo will not do anything he cannot shine at, so the balance bike sat unused for two weeks. Tigger decided to pick it up. Outside he went where he fell over and over and over again. Eventually he learned to ride a pedal bicycle before 6yo Señor Frog.
This fall Tigger started pre-K and within a week we had a call from the teacher asking us about Tigger. He doesn't understand where his body stops and the world begins. Patting a classmate on the back is a real effort and he cannot properly guage his strength so he unintentionally causes pain, or pokes someone in the eye. The teacher supportively suggested another evaluation by a professional that works with the school frequently. We are so pleased to here a teacher tell us we are not crazy and that this needs to be addressed.
I am worried and distraught by the fact that at home we have always accepted and worked with him as he is. We have been patiently pushing him and he is persistent. But last week he bit another child and I am worried that his innocence and cheerful demeanor will be destroyed by the social anxieties he may face. It is really upsetting me.
Any suggestions or links you have on navigating the diagnosis and treatment plan phase would be appreciate. I believe he has some form of sensory integration disorder or mild cerebral palsy, but we'd now really like to get to the bottom of this.
Oh, MSHB, if you wouldn't mind sharing here or in a PM how you went about Asperger's diagnosis as an adult, I would appreciate it, as I have been meaning for years to look into this for myself - but I can't seem to make it in for routine physical.
Posted by Doublethink (# 1984) on
:
Dyspraxia perhaps ?
Posted by Curiosity killed ... (# 11770) on
:
That sounds fairly bad dyspraxia as that one goes. I managed to control my daughter's dyspraxia (paediatrican diagnosed, honest guv) by taking her to toddler gym and on up until she was 8 or 9. I was told that I'd pretty much provided the therapy that the paediatrician would have done. She was never going to be that brilliant a gymnast but she did end up "passing as normal" for co-ordination.
Have you done eye tests? Check he can actually see and judge distances? Start with the simple.
Posted by Goar (# 3939) on
:
Thanks for your thoughts.
I read the link you sent and yes dyspraxia is spot on. We had heard of dyspraxia last round of battle and had thought he'd be diagnosed but instead were told that he was "at the low range of normal". It is interesting that it has comorbidity with other traits I suspect our family exhibits.
It's at times like this I wish we still lived in London rather than the land of gators. I think the healthcare system there is much better for someone in Tigger's shoes - more likely to straightforwardly diagnose. Maybe I am just suffering from a case of "the grass is greener" syndrome. - BUT THIS IS NOT HOLLAND.
We have taken him to a developmental opthamologist who gave him the all clear on that front. Navigating steps was delayed and is now still awkward so we worried about depth perception.
So far we have had to wing it. Hopefully this go round the developmental psychologist evaluating him last week and this week will be able to provide a diagnosis or refer us to someone who can give us a diagnosis and a treatment plan. Otherwise I will be back here grateful to have a place to vent.
Posted by Curiosity killed ... (# 11770) on
:
I've seen that lack of depth perception in nystagmus - what is he like with construction toys?
Posted by Doublethink (# 1984) on
:
I think that would have been picked up by the opthalmologist.
Dyspraxia is a developmental disorder, it is more likely to be evident when the child is a little older - so it doesn't surprise me it wasn't picked up earlier. It just may not have been diagnosable at that point.
Posted by Goar (# 3939) on
:
One of his brothers is a lego nut, but I've never really seen Tigger play with them. I asked Suusan and she says he doesn't ever play with them if there's another option (and there almost always is).
Posted by Goar (# 3939) on
:
Also, on the Nerf Gun discussion. We have them but we have an "only aim at targets" rule where "people are NOT targets". This rule is flagrantly violated.
Posted by Goar (# 3939) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Doublethink:
Dyspraxia is a developmental disorder, it is more likely to be evident when the child is a little older - so it doesn't surprise me it wasn't picked up earlier. It just may not have been diagnosable at that point.
Very good to know.
Oh, and why the question about construction toys? I assumed you meant building blocks and such rather than Tonka trucks.
Posted by Curiosity killed ... (# 11770) on
:
Because that's how the child, now adult, I knew with nystagmus was picked up - not being able to judge depth for stairs and construction toys being something they weren't interested in. They were registered blind.
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Curiosity killed ...:
Because that's how the child, now adult, I knew with nystagmus was picked up - not being able to judge depth for stairs and construction toys being something they weren't interested in. They were registered blind.
Littlest One's neurologist told us that a child not being interested in building toys is a Big Red Flag. The problem may be visual impairments or motor impairments (or, in the case of Littlest One, both). But it's definitely something that should be noted and followed up on.
Another red flag that we missed was that Littlest One absolutely loved swinging on the playground when he was still little enough that someone always pushed him. When he got old enough that he was expected to make himself swing, he lost interest. Except that, really, he didn't. He just didn't know how to swing. When he started seeing an occupational therapist, we learned that he couldn't swing, and started teaching him. It took a long while, a lot of direct instruction and practice. But he mastered it.
Basically, I think any time a child doesn't engage in or enjoy typical play activities, it's a good idea to figure out why not. Of course a child may just like one thing better than antoher. But if a child won't play patty-cake at an age when kids all play patty-cake, it might be that they have a problem crossing the midline, or they might they lack depth perception. If they can't stand to play "I spy" and say it's a stupid game, maybe their color perception is off. That sort of thing.
When a child has complex developmental quirks, figuring it all out can be like peeling an onion. You work through one layer, and discover there's another layer there waiting. And it can be really frustrating for parents and child alike. If the vision specialist, for example, suggests overlays on books, which will help with reading, but the child doesn't have the motor skills to manage the overlays, sometimes the vision specialist (or the parents) will decide that the child is being oppositional or uncooperative or attention-seeking. We finally figured out that we should assume that the child is doing the best he can until it's conclusively proven otherwise.
Posted by Sir Kevin (# 3492) on
:
On The Archers, the Tuckers are waiting for a baby with Down's Syndrome to be born. It will be interesting to see how this story develops. We used to be members of a service club and spent some time with special needs kids at the local community center. Downs kids seem to be always happy and appear to age slowly.
Posted by Goar (# 3939) on
:
I have an uncle with Down's who has been a hugely positive influence on my extended family. I am grateful that my grandparents did not follow the advice of medical professionals in 1953 who suggested that they not hold him and send him to an institution.
Posted by Bronwyn (# 52) on
:
This time last year my daughter was diagnosed with fragile x syndrome which has been a real hurdle for us and the extended family.
Posted by Niminypiminy (# 15489) on
:
Josephine, that's an incredibly perceptive post about toys and typical activities. When nimlet1 was little I bought him all sorts of small world and imaginative play toys ( tea sets and the like)' which he wouldn't play with. And I used to see other toddlers brm-brming their toy cars around and wonder tearfully where I had gone wrong.
If I had only known at the time that these were red flags the history of the next few years might have been very different.
Posted by Goar (# 3939) on
:
for Bronwyn's daughter, Bronwyn and the whole family
quote:
Originally posted by Josephine:
Littlest One's neurologist told us that a child not being interested in building toys is a Big Red Flag.
Yes thanks Josephine for sharing your experience in this.
Posted by birdie (# 2173) on
:
Thanks also for the recommendations of The Explosive Child. It's made me feel slightly better in that I don't feel so much that Groover's behaviour is as off the scale as I'd worried.
However his explosive behaviour at the moment is causing us real problems. As I type, he is at the end (I hope) of an hour-long explosion over going to bed. I am determined to try the solutions from the book but I feel so beaten down by it all at the moment I can't see anything working. His response to any attempt to talk about the situations that prompt explosions is pretty much to explode again. Or, when asked the 'what's up?' question, to respond with 'I'm not telling you!' or 'it's none of your business!' which leaves me feeling pretty helpless.
He only explodes at home, and only when both parents are present, which adds up to us feeling it's probably somehow us that's the problem.
Posted by Curiosity killed ... (# 11770) on
:
No, it's far more likely that it's something else that's the problem and he feels safe to explode that emotion at home. He's had a lot of changes to deal with recently with your move and his school move. And he's no longer with that peer group that grew up with him and know him as him, but see him as this interloper who's different - before he has any differences to deal with.
When mine wasn't coping at about the same age I worked out she needed a lot of quiet time at home to give her space to just be and not have to deal with people she wasn't sure of or necessarily comfortable with all the time. And that made home (whichever home it was at the time - we moved a lot when she was younger) a safe place to be.
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by birdie:
His response to any attempt to talk about the situations that prompt explosions is pretty much to explode again. Or, when asked the 'what's up?' question, to respond with 'I'm not telling you!' or 'it's none of your business!' which leaves me feeling pretty helpless.
Has he ever had an evaluation for language processing skills by a speech and language pathologist? Littlest One* used to do the same thing. It turned out that he had dysphasia -- almost like the word-finding difficulties someone might have after they've had stroke. Most people didn't notice it, because he was very bright, and had an enormous vocabulary, so, when he was feeling good, he could usually substitute a word, or talk around it, or find some other way to communicate his ideas.
When he was anxious or upset, though, all his "workarounds" for his dysphasia would go away. Things that are hard get harder when you're stressed. So talking with him about things that were hard for him often didn't go well. And answering questions was something that he found particularly difficult. Things he could tell you if you just let him talk, he couldn't say if you asked him.
That made collaborative problem-solving really difficult. We'd used it successfully with his older brother, so we understood how it was supposed to work. With him, we had to modify the approach. We would have to put the words in his mouth. Instead of asking him, "what's up?" we'd have to suggest our best guess of what might be up, and ask him if we got it right. Often, we had to do problem-solving in small sessions. One or two guesses, then stop until the next day. Otherwise, he'd get too worked up.
He worked with a SLP for about three years, and that made a tremendous difference. He still becomes dysphasic from time to time, but it's not as bad as it used to be. And we can do problem-solving with him, and ask him what he thinks, and it works. Most of the time.
* I really need to come up with something else to call him. He's not so little any more!
Posted by birdie (# 2173) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Curiosity killed ...:
No, it's far more likely that it's something else that's the problem and he feels safe to explode that emotion at home.
I know that really - I was just feeling a bit overwhelmed when I wrote that! I'm also grateful that he's not exploding anywhere else - if he was like it in school it would hamper the process of making new friends and settling in.
Josephine, you've given me a lot to ponder. Groover is very articulate and has a massive vocabulary, but I have noticed word-finding difficulties occasionally so you might be on to something. Thanks.
Posted by Lyda*Rose (# 4544) on
:
Birdie: quote:
However his explosive behaviour at the moment is causing us real problems. As I type, he is at the end (I hope) of an hour-long explosion over going to bed.
My guess is that it is a mix of feeling safe at home to express his stress and a successful strategy for feeling a bit more in control of his world, although he looks totally out of control to us. After all he did get out of going to bed for an hour; at some level that's probably satisfying.
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by birdie:
Josephine, you've given me a lot to ponder. Groover is very articulate and has a massive vocabulary, but I have noticed word-finding difficulties occasionally so you might be on to something. Thanks.
If you decide you need to have his language skills evaluated, you might want to make sure the SLP who sees him has lots of experience evaluating children with significant neurological impairments. Two different school-based SLPs told us that Littlest One had no difficulties, except that he was uncooperative or oppositional for parts of the evaluations. (The parts he couldn't do. Imagine that.) I think they were just snowed by his vocabulary and by his general level of knowledge. And, of course, most of their work is with kids who have problems with articulation. They really didn't have the experience to recognize what was going on with Littlest One.
On the other hand, the hospital-based SLP who works exclusively with kids with neurological impairments (brain injury, strokes, cerebral palsy, etc.) saw the word-finding problems immediately. She was fabulous.
Posted by Smudgie (# 2716) on
:
I've just come in from a drop-in workshop provided by the National Autistic Society with an excellent speaker. Special Help 4 Special Needs is his website - isn't it lovely when you find a speaker who will actually answer specific questions with actual suggestions! I learned a lot.
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
Getting very frustrated with a teacher of LL who thinks he is autistic and is pushing us to get him diagnosed and send her paperwork to officialize it. I don't think she knows autism from a hole in the ground and LL fails the major criteria. But until I produce an official medical opinion she's got me pegged as an obstructive parent in denial--and this at our first meeting.
She has i think been putting her head together with the school counselor who is still wet behind the ears new graduate and said "educational autism" to me last year--i think because he has difficulty with reading some social cues. But he has none of the rest of it--no rigidity of outlook, an extremely wide range of interests, a great pleasure in pretend play and in social interaction, and a strong desire for cuddles.
Posted by Qestia (# 717) on
:
Lambchopped I think your instincts are correct. Is a diagnosis of some sort necessary to get LL help with any issues he has? My son has been getting services through the public schools for years with no official diagnosis (though he has one now, ADHD, I still have not shared that with the school). Still, one of his weaknesses is also social cues/pragmatic speech and so twice a week he works with the school speech therapist on those skills.
I did wonder at times if my son was on the spectrum due to his sometimes endless monologues on topic du jour, lack of eye contact, the social cues thing--but during his evaluation this summer the doctors confirmed that his imagination, ability to interact with peers and adults, and flexibility ruled that out pretty decisively.
[ 28. September 2012, 16:30: Message edited by: Qestia ]
Posted by CuppaT (# 10523) on
:
I'll certainly look up the book The Explosive Child, too. Thanks. My youngest son, 8, has Tourette Syndrome. His tics vary, and come and go, but the rages can be awful sometimes, and violent at their worst, only once. We also have gotten used to counselors and psychiatrists and nutritionists. Most days are ok, but some are downright difficult for the whole family. It was worse before we figured it out (when he was about 5) and got help and started understanding him and his need to tic. But balancing his needs and the rest of our needs for sanity and cleanliness (the spitting tic) is sometimes difficult.
Posted by comet (# 10353) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Lamb Chopped:
Getting very frustrated with a teacher of LL who thinks he is autistic and is pushing us to get him diagnosed and send her paperwork to officialize it. I don't think she knows autism from a hole in the ground and LL fails the major criteria. But until I produce an official medical opinion she's got me pegged as an obstructive parent in denial--and this at our first meeting.
She has i think been putting her head together with the school counselor who is still wet behind the ears new graduate and said "educational autism" to me last year--i think because he has difficulty with reading some social cues. But he has none of the rest of it--no rigidity of outlook, an extremely wide range of interests, a great pleasure in pretend play and in social interaction, and a strong desire for cuddles.
whoa whoa whoa! I went through this when Chasee#2 was in elementary school. turns out, it's illegal in this state for a teacher/admin/counsellor etc to "armchair diagnose" and pressure you into treatment. look into it in your area.
Please remember that YOU are the parent. YOU are the authority. if you have done enough homework and are comfortable that your child does not need medical intervention, so be it. Sometimes, the good parents are the obstructionist ones. Tell her, FIRMLY, that you have done your research and are comfortable that your child does not need the medical intervention. then shut down the rest of the conversation. you are the final word.
the reality is, every kid has their quirks. every kid is going to develop in different ways and at different rates. some have issues that need medical intervention. some, like mine, are just eccentric and have no need of drugs or other treatment. Teachers need to do their very best within their ability to meet each kid where he or she is at that time. If they try to treat each kid as if that kid needs to fit some clonish standard, they are doing all the kids a disservice. plus, they should know better.
and, remember to have some faith in yourself. situations like this can leave you, as the parent, feeling very insecure in your abilities and wondering if you're doing right by your kid.
Do right by your kid. then turn off the judgements and have faith in yourself.
Posted by Evangeline (# 7002) on
:
quote:
Is a diagnosis of some sort necessary to get LL help with any issues he has? My son has been getting services through the public schools for years with no official diagnosis (though he has one now, ADHD, I still have not shared that with the school).
In some areas, like mine, for example, you do need a diagnosis of disability to qualify for any special services eg learning support officer, speech or behaviour therapy in schools. In addition, for some problems, early, specific intervention is extremely beneficial so I don't think that pressure for a diagnosis, is in all situations, unreasonable.
THis is not the case for ALL situations but there are cases where an official diagnosis which of course includes a diagnosis that your child is well within "normal limits" of IQ, behaviour etc etc is beneficial and to be preferred to teachers labelling your child or even having interventions that may not be suitable for your child's condition or lack thereof, based on the teacher's idea of what is right or sadly, sometimes what makes the teacher's life easier. THe key is getting a suitably qualified expert to do the assessment.
Posted by Curiosity killed ... (# 11770) on
:
Lamb Chopped, how does diagnosis work with you?
Here we get referrals to a paediatrician and/or educational psychologist, who test variously depending on age and draw conclusions. They may make recommendations.
As a school professional, I had parents coming to me asking if I agreed with their concerns, or me going to parents saying I was a bit worried about their child. Mostly the parents were incredibly relieved someone else was worried and trying to get something done or pushing the school to get something done when we didn't think the problems were that big in the scheme of things. But we wouldn't have gone to the parents unless we were really concerned about the student - usually on behaviour grounds. I tended to pick up on low achieving students too, in the hope that the difficulties being flagged up might suggest other ways of helping. But we had one family where we could see the concerning behaviour patterns and learning difficulties in the boys getting worse as you went down the family. The youngest was performing at a very low level, the lowest in the school year group, and wouldn't communicate with teachers or students - he communicated through another student, which didn't do that student much good either. The parents refused any help or assessment and we had to get parental permission to intervene.
You can pay for private educational psychologist reports. Schools here tend to regard them with suspicion as paying for what you want to get. Specific reports from dyslexia specialists tend to be regarded with even more suspicion (I regard them with suspicion, because they come with an agenda).
An Ed Psych report is a good start for getting exam concessions for example - extra time, a reader, a scribe. They have to be redone regularly to still be current. The one from school ran out while my daughter was at university and she had to be assessed by the university Ed Psych. Would it be worth getting something like that done to show the teacher?
Posted by Daffodil (# 13164) on
:
As an occasional lurker on the ship I popped in searching for theological debate, and spotted this thread.
"Hello! " to anyone who knows me from other Christian websites or 365, and "hello" to anyone who doesn't know me!
I have a teenager with autism and will try and remember to return to read updates on this thread.
I think I remember asking about the 'Holland' thread when I first registered here several years ago, and was told that you had to have over a certain number of posts to join in. I don't know if that still applies. If so, and that was a route chosen, then it would exclude people like me and other 'quiet' browsers from participation.
Posted by PeteC (# 10422) on
:
Private boards have a minimum number of posts required, However, it is irrelevant in this case since It's not Holland died in 2008.
I am pleased that so many people are now discussing special needs on the public boards. That is a great shift since I came aboard.
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
Thank you, everybody, for such great and thoughtful posts. My son has no academic issues to speak of, it's all social--and his issues there are mainly of the "you're a nerd, therefore we don't like you" type. Which certain adults at his school seem to think should be handled by changing LL. Which pisses me off.
I would very much like to get him into something where he could learn in very practical ways how to handle things like a) joining in a game that is already in progress on the playground, b) dealing with bullying and teasing, c) coping with the fact that his classmates would rather play videogames than invent stuff, and probably come from bookless homes. (Yes, I'm snide and bitter too, but this is really getting my goat.) I'm not really sure where I can find something like this, though--or if it even exists.
I was very like LL when I was small, but learned to conform under the pressure of a) an alcoholic and scary parent, and b) getting beat up by schoolmates. LL is mocked but not under that same degree of pressure, and I wouldn't wish it on him--but maybe that's what it takes to force one of our kind to learn protective camouflage?
So I'm not really sure what services beyond the abovementioned LL would need, or could use. Maybe a little OT for mild dyspraxia, but I can do a lot of that at home. His grades run in the A to A+ range in all subjects, so not tutoring. I'm fairly sure his IQ is in the genius range, as for both parents (not that I'm telling him that). He does have a mild stutter at times, that would be good to work on...
His English teacher stopped me today to hassle me about his paperwork again. She really really REALLY wants him slotted into the public school special ed system. I'm feeling highly antagonistic toward her and am tempted to clout her upside the head with my PhD. See how petty I am?
So as far as a diagnosis goes, I'm really more interested in getting various crap ruled out (in order to shut up the school) than in getting him diagnosed as anything in particular. My family self-diagnosis has always been "we're just weird," which we are mostly pretty content with, and keeps us from either getting too full of ourselves, or conversely thinking that we are damaged freaks.
Comet, you are absolutely right, she should not be playing the freaking armchair diagnostician on us. But she IS, and my child IS on scholarship, and making an overt enemy of the principal's wife would make our lives even more difficult (unless we moved him to a different school, which would cost him friends he dearly loves as well as presenting us with a whole new set of adjustment issues). So I'm trying to navigate between the rock and the hard place here.
Forgive me for being so longwinded. Bottom line is, my gut instinct is that LL is a normal child of an uncommon type. He is bookish, creative, too bright for his own good, somewhat clumsy, friendly, over-anxious to please, and endearing. He is, in short, a swan tripping over his own wings. And he's getting nibbled to death by ducks.
I wanna make duck pie. But I think I'm going to have to get an official (non)diagnosis to do it.
Grrrrrrrrrr.
[ 02. October 2012, 00:43: Message edited by: Lamb Chopped ]
Posted by comet (# 10353) on
:
your kid sounds just like my youngest. all three of my kids are eccentric in similar ways; the difference with Chasee#3 is that he isn't into the social game. the other two are gregarious as hell. He'd rather read a book. luckily his test scores are so off the charts that the teachers aren't trying to pigeonhole him; they're too busy trying to meet his academic needs. (the joys of a small village school - lots of individual attention, though it's still been difficult) and, now that he's a bit older he handles the social aspect better, though he still doesn't like it.
I'm not sure what guidance to give you beyond what I already said - stick to your guns and remember who's the final authority in his education and upbringing.
Posted by Curiosity killed ... (# 11770) on
:
Sounds like mine too. Lamb Chopped. When I worried about mine socially (and the effects of the dyslexia) we did see the paediatrician and were referred to the local CAMHS (Child and Mental Health Services) that assessed her. Yep, definitely genius level - MENSA if she could be bothered. No, can't suggest anything other than relaxation therapy - which she loathed, she said it made her switch off the hyper-alertness she was using to cope. The other "helpful" comment from CAMHS was that life wasn't going to be much fun at ordinary school level, it would get better at university level when she'd find more peers (geeks?) to relate to. Thanks a bunch, guys.
A friend said helpfully at the time that he hadn't socialised with his peer group when he was younger. He'd been into cricket and had been socialising with adults from very young. So we went looking for things we both enjoyed doing (she was too young to do it on her own) - archaeology, conservation. She took part in a dig at 16, ended up helping the volunteer surveyor map the site and showed the adults how to when he wasn't around.
She also reckoned school was to achieve the qualifications she needed to go on and gritted her teeth through most of it.
We have primary school materials to teach these sorts of social skills - under the SEAL (social and emotional aspects of learning) strand. Although the students who really act out tend to get priority.
Secondary school where I worked, we had fortnightly social skills afternoons for the group we had on the autism spectrum. All ages, but teaching them ways to join in games, how to use a bus, or a shop - social skills taught explicitly. Mind you, lunchtimes there was a safe supervised room and most of them were to be found in there playing trumps card games together most days.
Going back to my daughter, the stuff she's enjoying socially now are role playing games and walking groups. Although she's playing her own games with the rpg - working out how to break the game master's plans without breaking the game for everyone else. (He reckons it keeps it interesting and allows repeats because the games don't work out the same way twice, but she has be aware of the others involved).
Posted by Boogie (# 13538) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Daffodil:
"Hello! " to anyone who knows me from other Christian websites or 365, and "hello" to anyone who doesn't know me!
Welcome to the Ship Daffy <huge wave> (not of the ocean type!) Great to have you aboard!
I was talking to our SEN Co-ordinator today. We agreed that the biggest task any teacher of any child has is finding the line between support and challenge - then treading it carefully.
This is true whether the child has SEN or not. SO much goes undiagnosed, in my experience, that we need to have the mindset that ALL children have special needs and deal with them as individuals, not labelled groups.
Posted by busyknitter (# 2501) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Daffodil:
As an occasional lurker on the ship I popped in searching for theological debate, and spotted this thread.
"Hello! " to anyone who knows me from other Christian websites or 365, and "hello" to anyone who doesn't know me!
I have a teenager with autism and will try and remember to return to read updates on this thread.
<waves to Daffodil> Hi there, and welcome to the Ship.
My youngest also has autism. He is a couple of years away from teenagerhood and we are nervously aware that our stable, if rather wacky status quo may soon disappear in a puff of hormones.
![[Ultra confused]](graemlins/confused2.gif)
[ 02. October 2012, 12:11: Message edited by: busyknitter ]
Posted by Niminypiminy (# 15489) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Lamb Chopped:
Thank you, everybody, for such great and thoughtful posts. My son has no academic issues to speak of, it's all social--and his issues there are mainly of the "you're a nerd, therefore we don't like you" type. Which certain adults at his school seem to think should be handled by changing LL. Which pisses me off.
I would very much like to get him into something where he could learn in very practical ways how to handle things like a) joining in a game that is already in progress on the playground, b) dealing with bullying and teasing, c) coping with the fact that his classmates would rather play videogames than invent stuff, and probably come from bookless homes. (Yes, I'm snide and bitter too, but this is really getting my goat.) I'm not really sure where I can find something like this, though--or if it even exists.
LC, my son has had help of the kind that you wish for LL, at his mainstream state UK school. They have a programme of social skills support for children who need it.
But he needs it because he has Asperger Syndrome, and it's not just that he needs a bit of help and then he will be able to be his geeky self, and anyway he's a genius, but because he will always need more help and support, and will always have difficulties -- even though he is the bravest person I have ever met, and handles his difficulties with amazing valour -- and he's not a genius either. He does ok, even well academically, but he struggles with a lot of things about being taught, like accepting that he has to practice, and that you can't get everything right first time. That makes learning hard, on top of having considerable social difficulties in and outside of the classroom.
I suppose this is a way of saying that for those of us who have gone through the -- very tough -- process of accepting that your child has special needs, it can be sometimes hard to hear about these brilliant, geeky children who are special only because they're a little bit different from the norm. That isn't to say that I don't know how hard it can be to parent one of those (my other son falls into that category). But it isn't the same kind of hard as with my elder son (the one with AS). I guess this is me being bitter now, because one of the things that is hard about parenting a child who does have a diagnosis is that you don't have the consolations that come with saying 'well, he's just a little bit different'.
Anyway, my experience (which is in the UK, and I am aware there are differences in the way things are handled in other countries) is that a diagnosis is extremely hard to get -- people fight for years to have confirmed by a professional what they already know themselves. And they do it because it's the key to getting their child the help she or he needs. So from my perspective, a diagnosis isn't quite the scary thing that it looks like from the other side of the fence. But it also sounds as if, if you were in the UK (which I know you're not), you wouldn't be staring a diagnosis in the face anyway
[ 02. October 2012, 13:39: Message edited by: Niminypiminy ]
Posted by Nick Tamen (# 15164) on
:
Another parent of a child with Aspergers and ADHD here. He was diagnosed with ADHD at age 7 and with Aspergers's the day before his 8th birithday (yes, I remember the exact day), though at that point the diagnosis was really confirmation of what we had suspected for some time. He turns 15 in a few days.
He has been fortunate that we live somewhere there are many services available, that he has been in schools that, for the most part, provided very good support and that he has (again, for the most part) had very supportive teachers.
He's a freshman in high school now, and we've seen a real shift in him over the last 6 months or so. There have been a number of things at work, we think, but at least in part, this seems to have come from a surprising awakening of real self-awareness. He not only can see where his challenges are and what he wishes were different, especially in the social realm, but he believes that he can do something about them. It's interesting to watch -- it's like we can see his brain working overtime to catch up developmentally. What we've all noticed is that he just plain seems happier and more willing to put himself out there. We are very thankful!
Lamb Chopped, I wonder if you need to have a conversation with your child's principal and/or with the someone in your school system who is responsible for special ed/special needs. Something like that might be what's needed to help the teacher see that she needs to back off.
Posted by mertide (# 4500) on
:
Lamb Chopped: If the main issue is that your son is shy and socially awkward at times, perhaps you could see what sort of local clubs he might enjoy where he gets to spend time socializing with other boys his own age that might share other common interests. Also, if he's being bullied, sometimes developing physical confidence can make him less obviously a target.
Have you looked at Cub scouts (I understand in the US those clubs are often sponsored by churches), sports (soccer, little athletics, swim club, martial arts, baseball) music groups (choir, bands). I'm sure you can think of other groups he might enjoy, that would give him a chance to meet other congenial boys and make friends (and maybe get a posse together at school).
Social skills are learned, not innate, and lots of practice with his peers in safe fun activities could make a big difference to his next years. My youngest is probably mildly Aspergers (high functioning engineer) but got through his social awkwardness on the back of playing Rugby, and also trumpet in a band. When he got to Uni, he suddenly found himself with 200 guys just like himself, but in school he needed encouragement to get out of his head and into the world.
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Niminypiminy:
But he needs it because he has Asperger Syndrome, and it's not just that he needs a bit of help and then he will be able to be his geeky self, and anyway he's a genius, but because he will always need more help and support, and will always have difficulties -- even though he is the bravest person I have ever met, and handles his difficulties with amazing valour -- and he's not a genius either. He does ok, even well academically, but he struggles with a lot of things about being taught, like accepting that he has to practice, and that you can't get everything right first time. That makes learning hard, on top of having considerable social difficulties in and outside of the classroom.
I suppose this is a way of saying that for those of us who have gone through the -- very tough -- process of accepting that your child has special needs, it can be sometimes hard to hear about these brilliant, geeky children who are special only because they're a little bit different from the norm. That isn't to say that I don't know how hard it can be to parent one of those (my other son falls into that category). But it isn't the same kind of hard as with my elder son (the one with AS). I guess this is me being bitter now, because one of the things that is hard about parenting a child who does have a diagnosis is that you don't have the consolations that come with saying 'well, he's just a little bit different'.
Look, this kind of hurts. I am very well aware of our blessings in not having an even more difficult situation to deal with--but that doesn't make the situation we DO have, any easier. I am watching LL for signs of the same depression I had at his age, for the same reasons--and I was suicidal. So the stakes here are a bit high too.
Would you prefer I take myself and my son out of the thread? I will, if you wish. And not come back until we've got a diagnosis that is good enough.
Posted by Curiosity killed ... (# 11770) on
:
Lamb Chopped - I empathise with the depression bit - and that's what I hoped I wasn't dealing with.
Posted by busyknitter (# 2501) on
:
Oh crumbs, I'm sure that's not what niminypiminy meant LC. And AFAIAC this this thread is not only for shipmates who can present a diagnostic certificate at the door.
Over the years I have come across many, many children and young people who for a variety of reasons have no diagnosis but have autistic traits or quirks - call them what you will.
It seems to me that in some ways these young people (and their parents) can suffer much more than severly autistic kids like my son, who doesn't know he's different and is mostly happy in his own world.
Anxiety and depression amongst children and teenagers at the higher functioning end of the spectrum is sadly all too common and also frequently misunderstood by education and health services. It sounds like you are right to keep your radar on the alert for signs of problems.
Posted by Curiosity killed ... (# 11770) on
:
And depression continues to be common amongst adults with higher functioning ASD too - thinking of a neighbour who isn't coping.
Posted by Boogie (# 13538) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by busyknitter:
Over the years I have come across many, many children and young people who for a variety of reasons have no diagnosis but have autistic traits or quirks - call them what you will.
Absolutely. The same is true for ADHD, dyslexia, dyspraxia, fragile X and many other conditions and Specific Leaning Dificulties.
I have been teaching for 35 years and I can honestly say that every class has had children who displayed traits but had no diagnosis.
(This is true of adults too, of course, as none of these conditions magically disappear one we reach 18)
Posted by Caissa (# 16710) on
:
Our oldest son with AS is really struggling with Math in grade 10. Last night we tried to work on factoring and he was clearly not getting it, mentally shutting down and then had a meltdown which prevented him from doing his comparatively easy English homework. He went to bed at 8. He has got so much negative self-talk that he can't get beyond it to try and see the material. We have a meeting with his Math teacher tomorrow morning.
Our son was diagnosed prior to kindergarten. He received the best all-round student award in k and grade 2. It has been painful, to say the least, to watch him go from that to struggling academically in high school. Despite having a diagnose for 10 years I often find myself sliping into the denial phase.
Posted by Niminypiminy (# 15489) on
:
LC, I tried to PM you with an apology, but your PM box was full. I'll try to send it again another time.
I too worry about depression and suicidal thoughts. Nimlet1 first said 'I want to kill myself' when he was 7.
Caissa, I know what you mean about 'mental shutting down' and not being able to be helped. Last night Nimlet1 wanted to do some cooking -- all fine, except that he cannot accept that cooking is something with rules, and you can't just make up what's in your head without knowing the basics. The result was a huge meltdown and then a huge mess (he also has dyspraxia which means that when cooking stuff goes everywhere), and complete exhaustion all round.
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
Look, I'm sorry too. Don't worry about it.
I'm just so incredibly frustrated because of people pontificating (see: teacher, counselor) who don't know what the fuck they're dealing with (counselor = new grad) and who, by the simple act of notifying me that there are problems, expect me to somehow magically Make Them All Go Away. Which isn't possible short of withdrawing the kid from school. And then get all righteous on me about how "LL was embarrassing himself today" or "you really need to know that other children are being disturbed by his tics." Uh no, I really don't need to know that, you have told me so umpteen times already, and short of wrapping him in duct tape before I drop him off at school, I don't see how you expect me to stop the difficulty from 30 miles away. It's you who's handling the seating arrangements in the classroom, who's present when the humming begins, who has the responsibility for making an attempt (however unsuccessful) to teach other children to tolerate minor annoyances from one another. What am I supposed to do, beat him?
I'm so tired of being made to feel inadequate and ashamed of my own obviously deficient parenting.
Now I've got to find a way to get this bloody piece of paper (which is going to cost us beaucoup dollars in medical costs) and which isn't going to fix anything anyway. Its only value will be to roll up and beat idiots over the head with. And that's what I'm in a mood to do, so I suppose it will be worth it.
Posted by Goar (# 3939) on
:
Welcome, Dafodil!
Praying through this thread. May God's grace pour into all of us as we deal with these challenges.
We are in the midst of some testing for Tigger and had a bit of good news. The educational psychologist has not finished her evaluation but on Monday she told Suusan that Tigger tested at genius level in his verbal IQ.
I found this shocking because he "failed" two out of four speech and language tests last week! Turns out he has exceptional comprehension and vocabulary but has difficulty forming words. He "gets it" and processes well but has to work hard to physically mouth the response. Often he opts for peaceful silence. His brothers never stop talking.
His OT will start again soon and we will start looking into SLP interventions. Feels like we're starting to move in the right direction.
[ 04. October 2012, 03:01: Message edited by: Goar ]
Posted by comet (# 10353) on
:
Ms Lamby - I've got a nice long message for you twiddling it's thumbs on my desktop. please tidy out your PM box; or, if you prefer, send me your email address. I think I have some strategies that might help.
deep breaths, sister!
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
Ooooh, strategies. Just what I need. I've flushed (well, some haven't gone down) so I hope there'll be room...
Posted by amber. (# 11142) on
:
Very close now to the point where autism stops having 'higher functioning' or 'Asperger syndrome' categories. It'll all just be 'autism spectrum' from early next year (new DSM V). Plenty of good research showing that it was the higher functioning people who end up with the greatest number of difficulties, not least because people think we can cope.
In the UK, the work I'm doing as an Adviser to the Government APPGA, schools, etc means that there should be much better access to sensible help and support for families, fairly soon. Fingers crossed.
Meantime, huge huge numbers of families are still wading through heck in school systems that were never designed to handle many special educational needs, and especially not set up for autism.
We'll get there. I hope.
If it's any consolation, our own fine lad (lower foothills of the autism spectrum, dyspraxia, short term memory difficulties, dyslexia) strugged through all sorts of obstacles with us....and went on to be school Prefect, play national level rugby, and is now at Uni (heavily supported) studying psychology and counselling.
Was it worth the 19 year of heck to get him there? Yup.
Posted by Ruudy (# 3939) on
:
While it was nice that Tigger (our 4 year old Rudlet with signs of serious dyspraxia) tested high on the verbal comprehension, we received last week the results from the educational psychologist evaluation, and it was painful reading Tigger's percentiles in space/proprioception, gross and fine motor skills, and speech. The report makes clear that these root delays are now causing him to lag in other areas as well.
I have long wanted someone to take us seriously and help us find out what is going on. But reading the psychologist's comments and seeing the numbers on paper was depressing. She made some phone calls and got us in to see a pediatric neurologist on Monday.
Have you been to a pediatric neurologist? Was there any advice you received in advance that you'd like to pass on? I will google and do some research online to prepare, but would also appreciate any thoughts or suggestions you have in advance of this appointment.
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Ruudy:
Have you been to a pediatric neurologist? Was there any advice you received in advance that you'd like to pass on? I will google and do some research online to prepare, but would also appreciate any thoughts or suggestions you have in advance of this appointment.
Yep, we've done pediatric neurologists. Several of them, in fact. One was useless, one was worse than useless, and two were wonderful.
Keep in mind that many pediatric neurologists are really subspecialists -- they mostly do epilepsy, or mitrochondrial disorders, or whatever it is that they do. If your child doesn't fit their box, they might tell you that your child doesn't have X, Y, or Z, and think that they've done their job. Be ready to follow up with "Well, if it's not X, Y, or Z, what is it that's causing these difficulties? If you can't figure it out, can you refer us to someone who can?"
If they try to blame the child's difficulties on a psychiatric diagnosis, or on bad parenting, leave, and don't go back. A neurologist is not an expert on psychiatric disorders. A child can have both neurological and psychiatric difficulties, and one can contribute to the other, so if you're dealing with both, you need a larger team that works well together. (That's not to say that even an excellent parent can't learn new tricks for helping their child with special needs. And if you end up wanting information about assembling a team to work with you and your child, send me a PM.)
The neurologist probably can't tell you up front what exactly they're going to do to evaluate your child. If they're good, often the results on one test will suggest what test to do next. It's also very likely that they'll refer you to other specialists for additional testing -- an audiologist, developmental optometrist, SLP, OT, PT, and so on and so forth. The neurologist may then take all the additional reports and help you make sense of them all. Or they may not. It really varies.
You will feel overwhelmed with the reports that you get from the neurologist and any other specialists that are involved. Ideally, the reports will include practical suggestions for how you can help your child. You won't absorb it all on the first reading. And even if you could, you can't implement everything all at once. Don't try. Give yourself and your child time.
Hang in there. This phase of special-needs parenting is in many ways the hardest. You'll get through it.
Posted by Ruudy (# 3939) on
:
Thank you, Josephine. Your post was quite helpful in managing our expectations. Suusan and I read it before we went in for the appointment. We were first visited by a student doctor who came in and did some brief tests. She proceeded to inform us that Tigger had a "strength" problem for which they could recommend some dietary changes. Thanks to your post, I did not go 100% ballistic on her! I just thought "Well, it may take several tries before we find a decent neurologist."
Then the head of the practice came in. He had clearly read the reports. He set Tigger at ease and made him laugh. Asked him to do various activities and sequenced motions. He asked about diagnoses of his cousins, etc. He very quickly concluded that the problem was not strength, but in sequencing. He asked us if this made sense to us, which it did. He wrote us a script for OT, MRI and EEG that stated that Tigger has dyspraxia. He assured us that he would not leave us hanging.
The only frustrating part right now is that we have to go have all this testing done and wait for two months before our next appointment. I want to get on with this and not wait around. I have to pray for patience and know that we are getting on with some interventions like OT and SL therapy. And I can pray that Tigger will socialize well at school and not become discouraged, anxious or frustrated. He is such a kind, precious and tenacious little boy.
[ 16. October 2012, 12:52: Message edited by: Ruudy ]
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
Update: our situation is rapidly going to hell, but I have a meeting tomorrow with an uninvolved professional who I hope will be able and willing to help me make sense of all this.
Posted by Starbug (# 15917) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Lamb Chopped:
Update: our situation is rapidly going to hell, but I have a meeting tomorrow with an uninvolved professional who I hope will be able and willing to help me make sense of all this.
Posted by Ruudy (# 3939) on
:
Posted by busyknitter (# 2501) on
:
Posted by Niminypiminy (# 15489) on
:
Praying that the meeting goes well, and that it offers a way forward for the Lamb family.
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
I had the meeting. She suggests seeing a pediatric neurologist rather than the shrink the teacher and school counselor think is appropriate. Unfortunately the waiting list is months long, so we'll have to thole meanwhile. At least I have an idea of which specialty I need, which is helpful--and which simplifies the question of which insurance coverage I'll need too.
At this point there seems nothing to do but wait and pray. A special ed evaluation is in the works and I hope they know their stuff, what with that pair attempting to shove the situation in the direction of an autism diagnosis. Why they're so set on it I don't know, I'm not aware of any funding benefit to the school.
If he's got to be diagnosed with something official and medical, let it be the RIGHT diagnosis. Not the convenient or trendy one.
Posted by Taliesin (# 14017) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Doublethink:
I think that would have been picked up by the opthalmologist.
Dyspraxia is a developmental disorder, it is more likely to be evident when the child is a little older - so it doesn't surprise me it wasn't picked up earlier. It just may not have been diagnosable at that point.
And, a headteacher said dismissively to a parent, 'Dyspraxia doesn't exist, it's just a fashionable word for being clumsy.'
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Ruudy:
The only frustrating part right now is that we have to go have all this testing done and wait for two months before our next appointment. I want to get on with this and not wait around. I have to pray for patience and know that we are getting on with some interventions like OT and SL therapy.
Getting all the diagnostic stuff done can take many, many months. Sometimes a few years. Part of it is luck -- who you happen to see, what they happen to notice, what you tell them. Sometimes things that have become "normal" for you are really Big Red Flashing Warning Signs, but you don't know that, so you don't mention them.
Patience is absolutely required. And a thick skin. And lots and lots of prayers.
Which I am offering now for your family and for Lamb Chopped's family.
Posted by Qestia (# 717) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Lamb Chopped:
I had the meeting. She suggests seeing a pediatric neurologist rather than the shrink the teacher and school counselor think is appropriate. Unfortunately the waiting list is months long, so we'll have to thole meanwhile. At least I have an idea of which specialty I need, which is helpful--and which simplifies the question of which insurance coverage I'll need too.
At this point there seems nothing to do but wait and pray. A special ed evaluation is in the works and I hope they know their stuff, what with that pair attempting to shove the situation in the direction of an autism diagnosis. Why they're so set on it I don't know, I'm not aware of any funding benefit to the school.
If he's got to be diagnosed with something official and medical, let it be the RIGHT diagnosis. Not the convenient or trendy one.
I hope the fact you're on the waiting list gets the school off your back, at least. My son's diagnosis came from a very comprehensive testing at a developmental medicine center at a children's hospital. It was done by a team of a psychiatrist and a developmental pediatrician, so they looked at medical things, as well as doing behavioral screenings and extensive cognitive testing (IQ etc.). This could well work to your advantage--there's a lot of research out there showing that these quirks can just be a result of intellectual giftedness, rather than some disorder.
My son does sound similar in many ways. He's very smart, but struggles with negotiating the playground, falls out of his chair, "hoots." We're actually having a good fall with him. In addition to the speech therapy and occupational therapy he receives at school we are doing private OT, a private social skills group, and karate twice a week (and omega-3 vitamins). It's costing a lot of time and money but we've seen a lot of improvement from the summer. I've also been working with the school to make sure he has what he needs in class--fidget items, something to chew on, special cushions for the chair.
Some of these things might help your son, too.
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
Sounds lovely! I hope we can find some resources here. (another minor frustration--the school has piled on so much homework this year that I am shaking my head in disbelief. My kid gets to eat dinner and that's basically it. The rest of the afternoon and evening (till an hour after bedtime!) it's homework, homework, homework. When exactly do they expect us to fit in these hypothetical social skills classes that may or may not exist?
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
Lamb Chopped, when the school qualifies the little lamb for an IEP, you explain to them that, because of his medical needs, he has to have time for therapy, and he has to have time to rest. Therefore, his homework time must be limited to no more than X minutes per evening. Then you smile sweetly and ask them how they can best accommodate that? And then you wait.
And if they start to insist that homework is necessary, you repeat that, for medical reasons, it really isn't possible for him to do more than X minutes per evening, and tell them you're grateful for their flexibility, and ask them what, in their experience, is the best way to accommodate such a need?
They can figure out something reasonable.
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
Posted by 3rdFooter (# 9751) on
:
Josephine - That stratagem rings so true and it amazes me the circumstances where you have to use it.
When we emigrated back to this country where smallest footer had previously had a statutory statement*, the education authority wanted to put him in a mainstream school without support while they sorted their lives out.
I requested a letter absolving me from all responsibility from any health and safety issues to staff or other students from the cherub losing the plot and lashing out. Lo, and support became available.
*UK legalism entitling you to educational support
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on
:
quote:
And, a headteacher said dismissively to a parent, 'Dyspraxia doesn't exist, it's just a fashionable word for being clumsy.'
Ours thinks that Little J's migraines are psychosomatic...
Fortunately the class teacher is more sympathetic. Especially after we pointed out that when she's having an attack at home she bangs her head against the sofa cushions, so leaving her unsupervised in a darkened room at school is Probably Not A Good Idea.
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Jane R:
Ours thinks that Little J's migraines are psychosomatic...
Can you get a letter from the doctor explaining that migraine is a chronic neurological disease that is associated with significant levels of disability, and occasionally even kills?
Our youngest has developed severe chronic migraines. He has two to three migraines a week; basically, as one migraine starts to resolve, the next one cranks up. It is completely incapacitating.
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on
:
We've given them a doctor's letter, Josephine, but it just confirms the diagnosis of migraine without going into details. I am planning to do a letter about Little J's migraine symptoms, what causes it and how we are currently dealing with it (with footnotes and references) next week while we're having our half-term holiday. I don't have time to do it now as I'm catching up on work after three weeks of rolling migraines, rather like what you describe. And we've got another appointment with the specialist in November to see if the latest adjustment to her preventative medicine is working.
for you and Littlest One.
Posted by Amorya (# 2652) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Jane R:
Ours thinks that Little J's migraines are psychosomatic...
Even if they were psychosomatic, they'd still be real physical pain. People keep trying to use the word to mean "all in your mind", but it actually means a physical illness brought on by mental factors.
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on
:
Indeed. I am intending to provide an explanation of what a pyschosomatic illness is as well.
One of the things that does concern me is that she is being expected to stay in class and work as best she can during an attack. I have pointed out to the school that if she is having an attack it may be impossible for her to concentrate on her work, but as she is in the top group for reading (reading age two years above her chronological age), her writing is brilliant and she is doing reasonably well in maths I am not sure they are taking me seriously.
All of this is going in writing, though, so they can't say they haven't been warned.
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
Boss went after me regarding "too many medical appointments" on Thursday; marched straight over to HR and told them my tale of woe, and now have FMLA papers to keep the in-DUH-vidual off my back. I suspect that what's bugging him at root is that he doesn't know what the medical problem IS, and is legally not entitled to know, but he damn well intends to know anyway; and I won't tell him. So he's pressuring me.
I believe HR told him to fuck off. I hope he does.
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Jane R:
One of the things that does concern me is that she is being expected to stay in class and work as best she can during an attack.
I was reading an article about caring for kids with migraine on a migraine support site, and they actually said that kids should be in school every day, migraine or no! I couldn't believe it. In addition to the headache and light and sound sensitivity, our boy has ataxia, dysphasia, and vertigo during his migraines. He can't be at school. He can barely function at home.
Posted by Zacchaeus (# 14454) on
:
That's ridiculous - I suffered from Migraine as a child and the only thing to help, was a darkened room and sleep. I might have stayed in school or class, but I was not functioning and learning.
I used to head bang at times too, it seemed to relieve the pain momentarily.
Has the teacher considered that she and her attitude, might be part of the psycosomatic (probably spelt wrongly) causes of the migraine?
Posted by Ruudy (# 3939) on
:
For those of you with children who have had ticks, did the ticks ever just come and go? Or once there always there?
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Ruudy:
For those of you with children who have had ticks, did the ticks ever just come and go? Or once there always there?
One of ours had a throat-clearing tic for a while. It went away.
Posted by Ruudy (# 3939) on
:
Tigger frequently blows air out of his nose. It's like he's blowing his nose but without putting a tissue to it. Normally not an issue, but this week he has a runny nose and the whole thing is unpleasantly messy.
On a possibly related note, the speech evaluator said one of his problems is that he channels as much airflow through his nose as his mouth which results in some of his speech "idiosyncrasies". The director of the speech and language evaluation gave some positive news: she had never before had a four-year old score 100% in the area of repeating grammatical structures. (I heard this second hand but am looking forward to a conversation with her this week).
On an unrelated note, Tigger said the EEG he had this week was "Great." I think he enjoyed getting to stay up to the early hours of the morning playing board games with Suusan and watching videos. Apparently we won't get an appointment to look at results anytime soon unless there is something urgently wrong. So that means - more waiting...
*mini-rant/whine* Why does it seem like every kid has to have their birthday at Monkey Joe's bouncy castle place?!? Tigger is persistent but just can't keep up. Crawling up to the top to slide down is a major accomplishment. The three year-olds zoom past him, or he causes a traffic jam. He seems happy for a while before tiring of it and just wanting to go home.*mini-rant/whine over* He did seem to genuinely enjoy it for a while, and I even wonder if we should go more frequently just the two of us when it's slow there so he can get the exercise and go at his own pace.
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
Mine switches to a new tic after a few weeks. It's like a rota.
Posted by Boogie (# 13538) on
:
My youngest son had a tic - a bit like a twisty yawn. the doctor told us to mention it every time he did it to get him out of it.
It worked!
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
... though this might be counterproductive in other cases. The tics that last the longest with my son are the ones people comment on (negatively). Stress i think.
Posted by Boogie (# 13538) on
:
We were advised to make no fuss and to be positive, just to remind him when he was doing it to help him stop. Like I said, it worked.
Posted by Taliesin (# 14017) on
:
thi is interesting actually. I have a kid at school who is distressed by his tics, and people have been trying to help him in all kinds of ways. One of these was to encourage him to substitute one kind of tic (spinning on the spot) for another kind that was more acceptable (apparently) like scratching his knee.
I felt uncomfortable about this though I couldn't have told you why, and now the kid is a smouldering ball of teenage resentment who isn't responding to anything - though obviously, there is more to it than just tic reassignment. I'm going to start working with him therapeutically next week... I'll feedback in very general terms how we get on.
Posted by Gwai (# 11076) on
:
I can say that with my brother it worked to switch tics, but it was a slow process.
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
This website is a fabulous source of info on tic disorders (and much else besides).
Posted by Ruudy (# 3939) on
:
Thank you, Josephine. Very helpful site. I particularly liked the chart of common tics.
[ 30. October 2012, 14:30: Message edited by: Ruudy ]
Posted by Ruudy (# 3939) on
:
Okay.... MONOLOGUING. How do you deal with your children when they monologue?
Do you point it out? Do you feign interest? Do you keep reading your book but nod and say "mm, hmmh" every once in while? Do you interrupt? Do you interject that it is selfish and inconsiderate?
After forty minutes of facts about tigers without a single pause, do you say lovingly to your seven year old that you really couldn't give a $%^& about tigers? Or do you look them in the eye and say "Please stop talking."? What do you do when your other three young sons can't speak to you or each other and one of them becomes visibly distressed to the point of screaming?
Experience, strength, hope or resources anyone? Cause I'll take whatever I can get. I've googled this to death and am coming up empty handed.
Posted by Curiosity killed ... (# 11770) on
:
That sounds very ASD. He needs the social skills to not get murdered in life so you need to teach him this will not get him friends and influence people.
How about giving him time to talk but limit it using an hour glass? Start with a script that says, "I'm so glad you like tigers, but people can't listen for very long, you can tell me about them for as long as this hour glass (well 2 minute timer) runs?"
Suggest that he produces a scrapbook folder about his enthusiasm and shows you at the end of the day - and tell him for good practice he needs to limit it to 5 minutes, otherwise you can't take in any more?
And at other times, remind him that he has his scrapbook and that his teddies would be good to practice his 5 minutes on, because they can listen for ever, but humans can't?
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on
:
Monologuing, eh?
(I must admit, my first thought when I saw that word was 'Before I kill you, Mr Bond...')
Ahem. CK's ideas are all good. I am not an expert on this type of problem, but maybe if he struggles with allowing other people to take turns in conversations you could have a stuffed toy or a cap or something that the person whose turn it is to speak gets to hold/wear? "It's Jack's turn to speak; he's holding the elephant" Or would he think that was babyish? I've forgotten how old he is... playing boardgames might also help with learning turn-taking.
Little J is going back to the migraine clinic next week - we're not doing very well here, she had a migraine a day during the half-term holiday and has had four this week. I am sticking straws in my hair whilst trying to catch up on my work. How is Littlest One getting on, Josephine?
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on
:
Sorry, just noticed you said he was seven, so the stuffed toy idea may be a bit babyish. Not having a good day here... (wanders off to stick more straws in the hair)
[ 09. November 2012, 09:39: Message edited by: Jane R ]
Posted by Curiosity killed ... (# 11770) on
:
Jane R - has anyone said CFS/ME? Migraine like headaches can be a symptom. Normal migraines tend to give you a break between them, don't they? (Well, they do me)
Posted by mdijon (# 8520) on
:
Some unlucky people certainly do get migraines every day though.
Migraines are indeed "all in the mind" in the same way that strokes and Parkinson's disease are.
I've noticed a funny tendency for people to have limited sympathy for children complaining of pain without a visible external illness. Perhaps because children often moan about inconsequential pain and we think good parenting is teaching them to ignore it. Unfortunately for children who are really suffering this is very counter-productive.
I hope something turns out to work at the clinic.
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on
:
(to CK) It's probably not CFS/ME. In between migraines she is perfectly normal - riding, swimming and dancing in her spare time and she's just talked me into volunteering as a dog-walker for the RSPCA so she can help me take dogs for walks. Doesn't sound like chronic fatigue to me. My mother gets migraines as well; hers used to last up to three days with added vomiting, so it could be worse.
(to mdijon) I think that may be part of the problem with the headteacher. Her class teacher isn't quite so unsympathetic, but she's leaving at the end of the term and who knows what will happen after that... and it's a big class, with lots of noisy boys in it, so the chances of a small girl who goes quiet when she's not well being overlooked are quite high.
Thanks for the sympathy, both of you.
[ 09. November 2012, 13:35: Message edited by: Jane R ]
Posted by Nick Tamen (# 15164) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Ruudy:
Okay.... MONOLOGUING. How do you deal with your children when they monologue?
Ruudy, I like CK's ideas. They sound very much like what we tried and had success with. I would probably add to the script, when appropriate, directions for other cues that he needs to learn to look for: "I'd love to hear about it, but do you see that I'm reading this book/trying to help your sister get dressed/cooking/etc.? That's a signal that I can't give you my full attention right now." The go on with the timer plan.
The thing about kids with ASD is that they can learn (and need to learn) to pick up on all of these non-verbal cues. They just don't learn them at an early age by observation like most kids do; they need to be taught them.
The only other advice I can give is try to have a sense of humor about it. Believe me, I know it's hard some days, but I always found that when I could keep some sense of humor, my blood pressure was a lot better off.
Posted by mdijon (# 8520) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Nick Tamen:
"I'd love to hear about it, but do you see that I'm reading this book/trying to help your sister get dressed/cooking/etc.? That's a signal that I can't give you my full attention right now."
I've heard a father patiently explaining to his child that he knows that tigers (or whatever) are really very interesting and good to talk about, but asking his child if they can see that his sister isn't ready for school... and that he needs to help her get ready... and so is it the best time to talk about tigers? How might we tell when the best time to talk about tigers is?
It looked like a very well-rehearsed talk to me. I expect it requires a lot of patience if you have to do it very often.
Posted by Ruudy (# 3939) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Jane R:
Sorry, just noticed you said he was seven, so the stuffed toy idea may be a bit babyish. Not having a good day here... (wanders off to stick more straws in the hair)
He is seven but with three younger brothers. They have all recently taken to several stuffed toys. This is age appropriate for him right now. Thank you. Praying for you and Little J.
Thank you all for sharing. I really appreciate your insights and will try to incorporate them. My post above was intended to display a certain sense of humor about things. Reading it now, I can see my frustration coming through. While it may not sound like it, Suusan and I are patient parents but are wearing thin in some areas. Our misdirected efforts to remain patient may mean we not have given our son some direction he needs.
quote:
Originally posted by Nick Tamen:
The thing about kids with ASD is that they can learn (and need to learn) to pick up on all of these non-verbal cues. They just don't learn them at an early age by observation like most kids do; they need to be taught them.
I am encouraged to hear this.
Do any of you have books you would recommend that teach parents how to respond to ASD traits? One question I am wondering is whether we should name it to him. Is there any reason I should not just go ahead and call it "monologuing" and point it out to him? We have not hesitated to name other behaviors when they arose.
Posted by Curiosity killed ... (# 11770) on
:
ASD resources:
Do 2 learn -this has a lot of activities to teach expressions and to read social cues, social stories - I think it might even be American (which is unusual for me to use in the UK)
OAASIS UK based Aspergers and Autism support group, lots of publications on there to download - those I'm both aware of from using them - the education stuff will be difficult to transfer though.
There's also Autism Support which seems good and looks international.
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Ruudy:
Okay.... MONOLOGUING. How do you deal with your children when they monologue?
That brings back memories!
When Middle Son was in 5th grade or so, we were told that he needed to understand what monologuing was before we could really start to work on skills around it. So, the psychologist told us, every time he's monologuing, simply say, "Middle Son, you are monologuing." After a very long while (two or three months, maybe), Middle Son would stop himself during a monologue and say, "Am I monologuing?" We would say, "Yes, you are."
And that was when we started working with him on conversational strategies -- how to tell if someone is listening, or wanting to listen, how to take turns in conversation, and that sort of thing.
By the time we started working on those skills with him, the psychologist had also been doing some preliminary work with him on those skills. Gosh, that was a long time ago. I know one technique was using a "talking stick." When you're using it as a teaching tool, you sit with the child, and hold the stick, and say something and then ask a question, and hand the stick to the child. The child can then answer the question, and say something else, and hand it back. You can also use the talking stick to keep all of the sibling from going nuts because this one Won't Shut Up. It works best if you've been using it a bunch for games and low-stress times -- then if, at dinner, the Monologuer is monologuing, you can grab the talking stick, and say that everyone needs to have a turn, and give it to one of the other children. You might have to combine the talking stick with a timer at first. But it can really make a difference.
At some point, you have to teach explicitly "When I am reading a book, I do not want to talk with you about tigers," and that sort of thing.
quote:
Experience, strength, hope or resources anyone? Cause I'll take whatever I can get. I've googled this to death and am coming up empty handed.
It does get better. It really does. Middle Son is now in his twenties. He's interesting and funny and engages in appropriate conversations with people on a variety of subjects. He can even make small talk if he has to.
It was a lot of work getting to that point. But you've got lots of time.
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Jane R:
Little J is going back to the migraine clinic next week - we're not doing very well here, she had a migraine a day during the half-term holiday and has had four this week. I am sticking straws in my hair whilst trying to catch up on my work. How is Littlest One getting on, Josephine?
Could be better, could be worse. He's still not well enough to go to school.
I'd be worried about the migraine-a-day thing -- it sounds like she's on the point of changing from episodic migraine to chronic migraine. Chronic migraine is far harder to manage. Hopefully the folks at the migraine clinic will be able to help!
Does Little J have a noticeable prodrome or postdrome? For Littlest One, those phases are far more disabling than the headache part, and they don't seem to be affected much by the triptan. (For anyone not familiar with what an entire migraine episode looks like, this summary is excellent.)
We're getting a pair of FL-41 tinted glasses for Littlest One, to see if they will help. I know another chronic migraineur who loves them -- they reduced his migraines from 2 or 3 a week to 2 in 6 months. It seems worth a try.
Posted by birdie (# 2173) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Josephine:
It was a lot of work getting to that point. But you've got lots of time.
I needed to hear that just now, about lots of things! Thanks, Josephine.
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on
:
Josephine: quote:
Does Little J have a noticeable prodrome or postdrome?
Difficult to say. She seems to get very lively and excitable just before some attacks - she'll be chatting away happily or playing with her toys or singing improvised songs and suddenly, BAM - we have the aura. But it's not a reliable sign, and sometimes she's just happy and enjoying herself and we don't get a migraine afterwards. The postdrome is even more vague - sometimes she's really tired and washed out, other times it's like flicking a switch - main attack over, back to normal straightaway. This is probably one of the reasons certain persons at the school are being sceptical - they find it difficult to believe that she can be half-comatose one minute and back to normal the next.
Thanks for the tip about tinted glasses - we will ask the specialist about that tomorrow. I was wondering whether osteopathy might help as well (the osteopath who treats my bad back is also qualified as a paediatric osteopath). We've been getting our information from http://www.migraineadventure.org.uk/ which is run by a British migraine charity, but I will check out yours too - more information is always useful.
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on
:
(sorry about the double post, folks)
Ruudy: quote:
My post above was intended to display a certain sense of humor about things. Reading it now, I can see my frustration coming through.
IME you can be frustrated AND making jokes about it. The humour helps you to deal with the frustration... and thank you for the prayers.
Hope Littlest One's migraines get more manageable soon, Josephine. It must be very difficult for the rest of you as well, if he's too ill to go to school.
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Jane R:
Josephine: quote:
Does Little J have a noticeable prodrome or postdrome?
Difficult to say. <snip> This is probably one of the reasons certain persons at the school are being sceptical - they find it difficult to believe that she can be half-comatose one minute and back to normal the next.
Our neurologists have said to expect exactly that. They said that some people with migraine have a very clear, predictable, each-one-exactly-like-the-next experience, and some people have migraines that vary wildly. And if you're taking a triptan or other medication that's intended to affect the migraine in progress, you inevitably get a lot of variation, because the effect of the drug is going to depend on exactly when during the progress of the migraine you took it.
Littlest One's prodrome is mostly irritability -- so, as you can imagine, that's hard to spot in a teenager whose life has been thoroughly upended by migraine. How do you distinguish between the prodrome and ordinary irritability? We can sometimes spot the difference, but not always. If he notices it, he can take a triptan, and that will (sometimes) abort the entire migraine.
The next step in his migraine is aphasia and light and sound sensitivity. If he notices that part (which is fairly reliable), and takes the triptan, the headache phase will be a lot milder, or even entirely absent, and he'll skip straight to the postdrome.
If he doesn't notice anything until the headache starts, then all he can do is ride it out.
His postdrome includes both fatigue and extreme brain fog -- almost like dementia.
quote:
Thanks for the tip about tinted glasses - we will ask the specialist about that tomorrow. I was wondering whether osteopathy might help as well (the osteopath who treats my bad back is also qualified as a paediatric osteopath). We've been getting our information from http://www.migraineadventure.org.uk/ which is run by a British migraine charity, but I will check out yours too - more information is always useful.
And I'll look at your site! In my experience over the years, sometimes research and practice in the UK are ahead on things, and sometimes it's ahead in the US. Keeping an eye on both is helpful!
Let me know what you find out about osteopathy. We haven't looked into that yet.
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on
:
Brain fog? That rings a bell... sometimes Little J gets very angry and says things like 'I'm stupid!' when she's coming out of a migraine - though that's not saying much at the moment, she seems to be having them nearly all the time. I wonder if she's experiencing the same thing? Of course I've been telling her she's not stupid and she shouldn't say things like that about herself, but if it's a side-effect of the migraine maybe what she means is 'my brain isn't working normally at the moment'. She's usually very articulate, but her language ability seems to shut down when she's having a migraine; she can point to where it hurts but she can't describe what the pain feels like.
Osteopathy definitely works for bad backs and ordinary headaches - I've been going to an osteopath for years (when I can afford it; it's not covered on the NHS) - so it seems logical that it might help with migraine. But I'm going to check with the specialists first.
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Jane R:
Brain fog? That rings a bell... sometimes Little J gets very angry and says things like 'I'm stupid!' when she's coming out of a migraine - though that's not saying much at the moment, she seems to be having them nearly all the time. I wonder if she's experiencing the same thing? Of course I've been telling her she's not stupid and she shouldn't say things like that about herself, but if it's a side-effect of the migraine maybe what she means is 'my brain isn't working normally at the moment'.
The first time Littlest One experienced brain fog, he found it terrifying. He had been home wiht a migraine, and the attack had passed, so he thought he'd work on his math assignment before he went back to school the next day. And he couldn't do it. He couldn't figure out how to do things that he knew how to do, and should have been able to do easily. My mother had died of complications of dementia, and that's what he thought was happening to him.
Learning that it wasn't dementia, but just an ordinary part of a migraine made it far less distressing for him. It really does complicate getting back to school, though -- there's really no point in going to school as soon as an attack is over, because until the postdrome clears, he really can't do any schoolwork. He's tried, and it hasn't worked well at all. The teachers really don't understand that he can look completely normal, but not be able to answer questions or to recall things that he knows.
quote:
She's usually very articulate, but her language ability seems to shut down when she's having a migraine; she can point to where it hurts but she can't describe what the pain feels like.
Varying degrees of aphasia are also pretty typical during a migraine. For Littlest One, the aphasia lasts for pretty much the whole episode. It's worst during the attack phase, but if he comes into the kitchen and says, "Can I have a thingy? You know, a thingy in the thingy," we know to hand him his meds, and then figure out what it is that he wants to eat.
Again, for him, knowing that it's just a migraine thing makes it less distressing.
Posted by Curiosity killed ... (# 11770) on
:
(You do know brain fog, aphasia and non-epileptic seizures are all CFS/ME symptoms?)
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Curiosity killed ...:
(You do know brain fog, aphasia and non-epileptic seizures are all CFS/ME symptoms?)
I didn't know that.
What is a non-epileptic seizure?
Since CFS/ME and migraine are both diagnoses of exclusion, what are the symptoms that would tell you whether you had one, or the other, or both? Does CFS/ME include a one-sided headache? Does it include photophobia and phonophobia?
Is there any effective treatment for CFS/ME? What would be different about treating chronic migraine vs treating CFS/ME?
THanks!
Posted by Curiosity killed ... (# 11770) on
:
quote:
What is a non-epileptic seizure?
I've seen all the epileptic type seizures with CFS/ME (that's UK, US it's CFIDS) absences, grand mal, petit mal - but they were symptoms that came and went.
quote:
Since CFS/ME and migraine are both diagnoses of exclusion, what are the symptoms that would tell you whether you had one, or the other, or both? Does CFS/ME include a one-sided headache? Does it include photophobia and phonophobia?
Problems with diagnosis - the Canadian guidelines, linked on that page, give photophobia and phonophobia as symptoms. My daughter had both badly. Headaches are a frequent symptom. I would add to that, children as young as 5 have been diagnosed with CFS/ME in the UK and that because it's an umbrella diagnosis (at least 5 or 7 versions) other things tend to be swept up under that umbrella. I know some of the people who were diagnosed with CFS/ME now, several years on, have different complicated diagnoses or have had other things picked up later (like anaemia).
quote:
Is there any effective treatment for CFS/ME?
The headaches and sleep disturbance often respond to low dose amitriptyline. The NICE (National Institute for Clinical Excellence) guidelines here are disputed, basically because the research it is based on is skewed. Patient groups like pacing - starting by working out a baseline and then working up from there. The book I found useful was Darrel Ho-Yen's Better Recovery from Viral Illnesses
quote:
What would be different about treating chronic migraine vs treating CFS/ME?
Not sure how you would treat chronic migraine so can't compare.
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
Dr ( pediatric neurologist) says not enough there to give LL a medical diagnosis, though he mentioned several supportive things we could do to help him IF I can get the school to agree. They're not going to be happy with a diagnosis of weird but neurologically normal, probably bright and bored, with annoying tics when bored. In my uncharitable opinion, that's because a diagnosis of autism would have allowed them to continue blaming the victim for whatever difficulties he has, including the bullying; if he's got no formal dx, they have to consider whether some of the school systems themselves may need readjusting. And fixing systems is a bitch.
We still have to do school testing, and I expect them to slap an educational autism dx on him simply to package him safely into their system. Whatever.
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on
:
Sorry to hear you're having problems with school as well, Lamb Chopped. Hope they accept the neurologist's diagnosis. If it was me I'd kick up a stink about my child being labelled as autistic simply for the school's convenience... it does get tiring arguing with them all the time though, doesn't it?
Anyway, Little J went to the clinic today and we saw yet another doctor (we've only seen the head honcho himself once, usually it's one of the junior members of the team). He was sceptical about the benefits of tinted glasses and osteopathy - said we could try them because they won't do any harm, but there was no clinical evidence that they help either. He also prescribed her some different medicine. At the moment she's in bed with yet another attack; the school is hosting an African drumming workshop today, which is not a good place to be if you're having a migraine. Just about to phone my osteopath to see if she can give us an appointment today.
Posted by JoannaP (# 4493) on
:
[Tangent]
quote:
Originally posted by Jane R:
Anyway, Little J went to the clinic today and we saw yet another doctor (we've only seen the head honcho himself once, usually it's one of the junior members of the team).
When my mother saw the head honcho for the second time, she asked him if her annual check-ups were meant to be for her benefit or for the benefit of junior doctors. Since then, she has always seen the consultant or the registrar.
[/Tangent]
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Jane R:
Anyway, Little J went to the clinic today and we saw yet another doctor <snip> He was sceptical about the benefits of tinted glasses and osteopathy - said we could try them because they won't do any harm, but there was no clinical evidence that they help either. He also prescribed her some different medicine.
There are some research studies on the use of FL-41 tinted glasses, and some of them look to me like they're reasonably well designed. Of course, even the most supportive research doesn't suggest that they'll prevent all migraines for everyone. But then, none of the prescribed pharmaceuticals or supplements help everyone, either. We're not looking for a magic bullet. We're looking for something that will help, at least a bit. If we combine enough things that each help a bit, then maybe we'll eventually end up with a combination that allows Littlest One to be reasonably functional.
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on
:
Sorry, I didn't mean to sound as if you shouldn't try these things, Josephine - after all, I myself ignored the specialist and hauled Little J off to the osteopath this afternoon because I know from my own experience that osteopathy can help with some problems. Like you, we are getting slightly desperate here.
Posted by Nick Tamen (# 15164) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Ruudy:
Do any of you have books you would recommend that teach parents how to respond to ASD traits? One question I am wondering is whether we should name it to him. Is there any reason I should not just go ahead and call it "monologuing" and point it out to him? We have not hesitated to name other behaviors when they arose.
Ruudy, as to your first question, to be honest, the books that I found most useful were books written by adults from adult perspectives. Yes, I had to "translate" some to child/teenager, but what I found invaluable was their own descriptions of how their minds work and how they taught themselves. Two books I have particularly found helpful (and encouraging) are Be Different: My Adventures with Asperger's and My Advice for Fellow Aspergians, Misfits, Families, and Teachers by John Elder Robison and The Journal of Best Practices: A Memoir of Marriage, Asperger Syndrome, and One Man's Quest to Be a Better Husband by David Finch.
As for your second question, if you think naming things like monologuing will make sense to your son, then by all means do.
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Jane R:
Sorry, I didn't mean to sound as if you shouldn't try these things, Josephine - after all, I myself ignored the specialist and hauled Little J off to the osteopath this afternoon because I know from my own experience that osteopathy can help with some problems. Like you, we are getting slightly desperate here.
Oh, I'm sorry, Jane! I wasn't talking back to you. I was talking back to your specialist and the specialists here who haven't been able to provide the help we need. I'm just frustrated. I'm so sorry it sounded like I was taking it out on you!
Did the osteopath think he'd be able to help?
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
I am such an idiot. Following up on some of the things the doctor said, i asked LL how often he felt bored in school. Quick answer: "90% of the time."
I never asked, and he never volunteered. Gotta do something. No wonder he's ticcing so much.
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Lamb Chopped:
I am such an idiot. Following up on some of the things the doctor said, i asked LL how often he felt bored in school. Quick answer: "90% of the time."
I never asked, and he never volunteered. Gotta do something. No wonder he's ticcing so much.
If a child is bored 90% of the time, you definitely have to do something about it. But you've got to be careful -- "bored" doesn't always mean what you think it means.
We automatically think that kids are bored when their schoolwork is so easy that doing it seems pointless. And that's sometimes the problem. But not always.
They may say that they're bored when the work just doesn't make sense to them, or if the work is so difficult that attempting it seems pointless. It's easier for some kids to say, "it's boring," than to say, "I don't understand what I'm supposed to be doing" or "it's too difficult for me to do."
And kids will also call it boring when the work-to-payoff ratio is out of kilter. So if the child needs glasses, they might not realize that they can't see properly. But they know that reading is a struggle. It's a lot of work, and no fun, and none of the strategies that anyone suggests makes it any better. It's just impossible to engage with words you can't see well. So, if you don't know you can't see well, you call it boring.
There are loads of other reasons for a child to consider the schoolday boring.
And you probably realize all of that. But just in case ...
Posted by birdie (# 2173) on
:
Hugs to you LC. We have had those moments.
So frustrating not to have known before - but you have asked the question now, and you know. So that's a good thing.
Posted by Jengie Jon (# 273) on
:
I have written something and then taken it away several times. I am not a doctor, I am a migraine sufferer, the diagnosis in my case is depression migraine and at my worst I was getting them about once a week. The range of symptoms do not surprise me and I have had a fair number myself.
Jengie Jon's first rule of migraine treatment, if it works for some there is also a good chance it makes it worse for others. I am making no promises. I made this rule after cider vinegar triggered some of the most severe ones I have ever had.
These are just some of my notes on how my handling has worked.
One thing that migraine is often linked to is food/water intake. Theory suggests that a little often might be better than big meals. Long gaps seem to be pretty common trigger, including in my case I realise some childhood migraines (stomach ones so not picked up as such).
Secondly I have had cranial osteopathy and though nervous about it (see first rule) it was if anything positive. As to the lens I am not ruling them out, my father definitely has light triggered migraine.
Thirdly I find (and a small group of others have told me they also find) magnesium supplements help prevent them. Technically the only medical proven effect of magnesium is bathing in epsom salts during one has been shown to relieve it. However the complementary medicine people do suggest it but not really for children.
Fourthly I know that over sensitivity to sound means that if I am in a noisy environment too much then I can easily trigger migraine.
As a rule of thumb migraine are complex and a matter of reducing a number of elements until the sufferer is managing to handle life.
Jengie
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on
:
Well, we're trying to get enough water and food into her. It helps that she likes to eat a healthy diet anyway (prefers fruit to sweets and cake, unnatural child), but the nausea makes it hard for her to motivate herself to eat, even when she's hungry. My main concerns at the moment are exercise and sleep. She can't get to sleep when she's having an acute attack and she doesn't feel like exercising either.
The osteopath (it's a she, btw) didn't actually do much cranial work yesterday because it was too painful for Little J, but she worked on her neck, shoulders and upper back. Not sure whether it's made a difference yet... will keep you posted.
Posted by Curiosity killed ... (# 11770) on
:
Nausea recommendations (from CFS/ME experience) - ginger and peppermint can often help. We drank a lot of ginger and peppermint tea (with a bit of honey), sucking peppermints or chewing sugar free gum, a ginger biscuit, ginger beer - they all seem to help. We went through it before medications were offered, nowadays there are medications to take too.
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Curiosity killed ...:
Nausea recommendations (from CFS/ME experience) - ginger and peppermint can often help. We drank a lot of ginger and peppermint tea (with a bit of honey), sucking peppermints or chewing sugar free gum, a ginger biscuit, ginger beer - they all seem to help. We went through it before medications were offered, nowadays there are medications to take too.
Peppermint and ginger are helpful here, too, but migraineurs should be careful with sugar-free anything. Nutrasweet (aspartame) is, for some people with migraine, an extremely potent trigger.
And it's not just in sugar-free things. You have to be careful with any chewing gum or breath mints; some include both sugar and aspartame. (That one got Littlest One -- he thought Doublemint gum was safe. It isn't.) And you have to check the label on anything that says "reduced calories" or "light." Yogurt is often sweetened with aspartame.
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
Thanks, Birdie.
And Josephine--he makes straight A s without even studying. And I haven't hit a college topic yet in my tutoring (of others) that he hasn't managed to pick up.
Frankly, people, I'm scared. There doesn't seem to be much provision round here for kids who are behind on social skills and wildly ahead on mental stuff. I'd homeschool, but can't afford daycare.
ETA: I don't think I mentioned it, but it took me a month to work out that his English teacher has told special ed he can't do expressive writing--because his mother does it for him.
She put it much more delicately than that, of course, but the implication is clear when you pay attention. I guess my own social skills are not what they should be, if such an insult slid by for a month.
[ 25. November 2012, 22:30: Message edited by: Lamb Chopped ]
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on
:
Lamb Chopped: quote:
I don't think I mentioned it, but it took me a month to work out that his English teacher has told special ed he can't do expressive writing--because his mother does it for him. She put it much more delicately than that, of course, but the implication is clear when you pay attention. I guess my own social skills are not what they should be, if such an insult slid by for a month.
Honestly, what is the point of teaching our children words of more than one syllable if this is the reaction you get?
I actually logged in to say that Little J has been to the specialist optician to be tested for coloured lenses. It was amazing - she had a migraine when we went in, so bad that the optician had to turn most of the lights off in the examination room before she could bear to take her sunglasses off, and as soon as she had the right colour of lenses to look through she was fine. By the time we left the migraine had gone. PM me if you want more details, Josephine.
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
Awesome!
Posted by Ruudy (# 3939) on
:
Great news!
Posted by Moo (# 107) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Lamb Chopped:
I don't think I mentioned it, but it took me a month to work out that his English teacher has told special ed he can't do expressive writing--because his mother does it for him.
Lamb Chopped, I think you would enjoy this story about Thomas Wolfe, the author of Look Homeward, Ange.
When he arrived at the University of North Carolina as a freshman, he already had outstanding writing skills. He had also studied Latin in high school and loved it. When the Latin professor assigned a passage to be translated, Wolfe gave it everything he had. He figured out the exact meaning of the passage and put it into the best possible English prose.
The professor flunked him for not doing his own work.
The next time a translation was assigned, Wolfe used a pony and deliberately introduced errors. The professor said he was glad to see that Wolfe was doing his own work.
Moo
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
Aauuugghhhhh!!!! Yes, that sounds very familiar somehow.
He's just written a second book report for her, and I looked it over with an eye to what she'll see. Complex compound sentences with introductory phrases too--in one case three subordinate clauses, all perfectly put together--and words like "grueling," "fierce," "witnessed," "lopsided," and "chaos" (almost all spelt correctly, too!) and as perfect a thumbnail summary of Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire as I could write myself, and better than that of any but maybe three of the college freshmen I taught. Not to mention the book is 700+ pages, long, and he is now RE-reading it--for fun.
If she could put the Cruciatus Curse on me, after she reads this one, I expect I'd be writhing.
Posted by Lyda*Rose (# 4544) on
:
Time for the ol' Stanford-Binet test, methinks. If he shows his stuff in a controlled setting with a professional, there should be none of this "mom did it for him" crap.
In other words, become a virago that insists that her baby is a prodigy who deserves to be in a GATE program, and then prove to them you're right.
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on
:
You know, I was wondering about introducing deliberate spelling mistakes too. Little J is also a very fluent writer, but nobody looking at her spelling would believe a grown-up had done it for her...
But Lyda Rose's suggestion is better. Why force him to fake a limp just to conform to the teacher's expectations?
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
Yep, Stanford Binet coming up. The one they' ve already given him tops out at 160 max, which may be problematic in our family. Re the deliberate mistakes--I actually refused to correct his spelling on the essay in question, and I know for a fact there were at least three errors. What this says about the teacher I don' t quite know...
On a more poitive note, i met with his homeroom teacher yesterday and got permission to have him read in class wken bored, to stop the disruptive ticcing. And he doesn't mind if I teach my wee monster algebra et al. Even though it will only increase the boredom later. Resignedly he says, "we'll deal with it when we get there..."
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Lamb Chopped:
Yep, Stanford Binet coming up. The one they' ve already given him tops out at 160 max, which may be problematic in our family.
As far as I know, none of the currently normed IQ tests are considered reliable past 3 standard deviations from the mean (which would be 145 or 148, depending on the test), and most are not generally considered reliable past 2 SDs from the mean, even if the hard ceiling is 160. To get the number of test subjects for the norming studies that would be required isn't considered financially feasible for the testing company.
There are a few testing centers who use an old versions of the SB, which could generate scores higher than 160. But that version is based on an entirely different theory of what intelligence is. It's not comparable with current IQ tests, and there are plenty of schools that reject it on that ground. (They may also reject it because it is a very old test, test security has not been maintained on it after newer versions came out, so families have been known to get the answers in advance of the testing, and coach the child to produce an artificially high score.)
You probably already know all that. But just in case ....
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
the flip side of this is that there are ceiling problems when you use a test that doesn't reach well past what the child can do. Probably screwed no matter what we do.
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
One thing a tester can do about that problem is to use an achievement test (not an IQ test) that is intended for an older child. That would be needed in addition to the IQ test, not instead of. But they can do the IQ test, realize that there are ceiling issues, and then give an achievement test normed for older kids, to explore what the child is currently capable of doing. A lot of people use the SAT that way - you can sign a younger child up for the SAT, and then find out how they compare with high school juniors and seniors. That can be really enlightening, and many schools take that very seriously.
Posted by Ruudy (# 3939) on
:
Whew! We pulled off a successful birthday party for Tigger. What a huge sense of relief. I still remember the discussion of birthday parties from This is Not Holland. I didn't get it then. I do now.
So. we have been on a whirlwind of tests and assessments lately. School psychologist, pediatric neurologist, occupational therapist, speech and language therapist, and EEG. An MRI is scheduled for later this month. We are relieved that we are finally addressing his severe motor skill developmental delays but we're exhausted and are just now realizing that this is going to be a long haul journey.
Tigger's school psychologist diagnosed him with developmental coordination disorder (the DSM term for dyspraxia). Yes, some of you here on the ship nailed it. She said that we need to monitor him closely because if he does not show marked improvement in certain areas, it is likely that he will also be diagnosed with non-verbal learning disability in the next few years. She has been helpful in identifying his strengths as well - such as high intelligence and perseverance, and met with us and his K4 teacher to teach us interventions for both classroom and home. His teacher has been understanding and supportive. She is eager to learn from the psychologist how to accommodate him and how best to teach him. For instance, every visual lesson has to be mediated through verbal articulation. We are doing OT and speech therapy now on a weekly basis.
The cloud hanging over us right now is the need to follow up after the EEG. The psychologist's diagnosis was predicated on there not being an overriding medical diagnosis. The EEG revealed abnormal discharges on the right parietal lobe. The neurologist said this may or may not be related to his condition and they suggested either low dosage epilepsy medicine (after we get the results his MRI) or a 24-hour EEG to observe the extent of the abnormal brain activity.
I have a lot of Googling ahead of me, but if any of you with first hand experience of pediatric neurologists want to chime in, please do. Josephine, you mentioned that some neurologists focus almost exclusively on epilepsy. Epilepsy is certainly this doctor's primary focus but his practice appears also to address other issues - but we have no idea whether he does so very well.
Posted by Curiosity killed ... (# 11770) on
:
Glad that the birthday party went well, and that there's so much good news about diagnosis and support.
Posted by birdie (# 2173) on
:
I'm having trouble putting together what I want to say here, and also not sure whether to put it here or the prayer thread, but here we go.
Seems to mr b and me that the major trigger for Groover's explosions is his growing awareness that other kids don't have to go through the stuff he does. Five times each day we carry out a medical procedure with him (I'm not going into detail here) which is unpleasant and invasive, but absolutely non-negotiable. His rages are most often provoked by us saying 'c'mon, it's time for X'.
He's very angry about the whole thing. He is very angry with God for making him this way (his words), and often says he wishes he wasn't alive.
I feel helpless in the face of it.
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on
:
Ruudy
Birdie, that sounds horrible. We have a similar thing with Little J sometimes - she gets very frustrated with her migraines and says she wishes they would go away. She isn't quite at the stage of wishing she'd never been born though.
for you and Groover and Mr B.
We now have migraine headaches with added vomiting; just what you want on a Monday morning. Still, it could have been worse; it could have been on the carpet...
Posted by maryjones (# 13523) on
:
I don't know if my experience will help anybody. When I started teaching, I found I was suffering severe headaches with flashing lights and vomiting. Fearing vision problems, I went to the doctor. Classic migraine, he said and gave me some tablets. The tablets meant that I moved to vomiting stage that much faster so I gave them up.
Fast forward a few years and I woke up in sick bay. You fainted, my colleagues told me - but they told the doctor I'd had a fit. New tablets (anti-convulsant) and I've not had a migraine in the 40 years since.
My daughter is dyspraxic but can now cope with the food colouring that used to send her up the wall. If you haven't tried eliminating artificial colours from their diet, it's worth a go. Our daughter woke up without crying after a colour-free week - first time in 4 years!
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by birdie:
He's very angry about the whole thing. He is very angry with God for making him this way (his words), and often says he wishes he wasn't alive.
I feel helpless in the face of it.
I'm so sorry, birdie. That's such an awful thing for you, and awful for him. I'm sure I've asked before, but I'll ask again -- have you read "The Explosive Child" by Ross Green? It's really for dealing with kids a bit older than Groover, but it might have some strategies that would help you deal with the rages. I think the hardest part, for you, has to be that the thing that is triggering the rages is truly aversive and absolutely non-negotiable. You can't offer him any respite. It has to feel awful for all of you.
Ruudy, congratulations on the birthday party! I hope y'all get some clarity for how best to treat your little one.
Jane R, I'm sorry about the new symptoms. I hate migraine.
Maryjane, thanks for sharing your experience. The American Academy of Neurology has recently released new evidence-based guidelines for treatment of migraine. Two anti-convulsants are listed among the most effective migraine prophylactics.
Posted by Chorister (# 473) on
:
Blessings wished for Groover
Are there any self-help groups (IRL or in a safe place online) where he can meet others with the same condition, so they can meet/play/share with each other? Then he will know he's not completely alone.
And is there something wonderful he can look forward to/be given at the end of each procedure to make it (in as far as it can be) seem worthwhile?
[ 04. December 2012, 15:43: Message edited by: Chorister ]
Posted by birdie (# 2173) on
:
Thanks, everyone.
We have read The Explosive Child, and I found it very helpful in terms of feeling less hopeless, and I've taken some things from it, but I think we talked earlier about how Groover's slight word-finding difficulties (which lots of people don't believe in, because of his enormous vocabulary) make it hard to do the chatting about what's happening.
It was also very helpful in making me feel vindicated in our experience that things such as sticker charts and rewards just don't work for him. People who've had good results from reward charts seem to propose bthem as the answer to everything and don't really believe there are children out there who aren't motivated by them.
Anyway, had a meeting with the school nurse this morning and I think we have a - tentative - way forward.
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by birdie:
I think we talked earlier about how Groover's slight word-finding difficulties (which lots of people don't believe in, because of his enormous vocabulary) make it hard to do the chatting about what's happening.
I definitely understand that! Not-So-Little-Anymore has sigificant word-finding difficulties and a huge vocabulary, and it was very, very hard to get anyone to believe it. He got a great deal of help from working with a hospital-based Speech and Language Pathologist who specialized in the language part of the work. When he's got a migraine, his nouns still disappear, and if his anxiety ramps up for whatever reason, his word-finding in general becomes more difficult. But for daily life, the work with the SLP made an enormous difference.
quote:
It was also very helpful in making me feel vindicated in our experience that things such as sticker charts and rewards just don't work for him. People who've had good results from reward charts seem to propose bthem as the answer to everything and don't really believe there are children out there who aren't motivated by them.
BTDT too. The best way to explain it to doubters was explained to me by Not-So-Little's psychologist. She talked about Pavlov's dogs. Present food, ring bell, dogs salivate. Eventually ringing the bell makes them salivate, even if there's no food. They are not choosing to salivate, and they can't choose not to. Punishing them for salivating will only make them neurotic -- they will have absolutely no idea what they are being punished for, and won't be able to avoid doing it anyway. Rewarding them for not salivating won't work, either -- they won't associate the reward with the lack of salivation, and they can't control the salivation anyway. For classically conditioned behaviors, you have to avoid reward and punishment entirely, and use a completely different approach to modifying the problem behaviors.
And it helps, sometimes, to remember that, just as Pavlov helped create the salivation response, we sometimes help create the problem behaviors in our kids, too. That should help us be more patient and generous when we're trying to modify those behaviors.
[coding]
[ 11. December 2012, 01:20: Message edited by: Welease Woderwick ]
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
The glasses with the FL-41 tinted lenses arrived today. Not-So-Little is wearing them. He says they make him feel weird -- but he hasn't taken them off. So we'll see how it goes ....
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on
:
Weird in a good way, Josephine? If he's got used to having migraines all the time, maybe it feels weird when they stop?
Little J's glasses haven't arrived yet... they probably won't arrive before Christmas but I am keeping my fingers crossed.
Posted by Niminypiminy (# 15489) on
:
My copy of The Explosive Child just arrived.I sat down and read the first chapter - with tears running down my face. I haven't ever read anything that described so accurately the state of war we live in with Nimlet 1. Even if nothing else in the book is helpful, for that alone, to make me know that the situation we are in is recognisable to other people, makes it worth buying.
Thani you, Josephine, for recommending it. ![[Axe murder]](graemlins/lovedrops.gif)
[ 17. December 2012, 10:39: Message edited by: Niminypiminy ]
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Jane R:
Weird in a good way, Josephine? If he's got used to having migraines all the time, maybe it feels weird when they stop?
We're not requiring him to wear them -- he's 17, and we figure he knows what helps and what doesn't. He's had them since Friday afternoon, and he's wearing them.
And we're now at three days in a row with no migraine. I hardly dare to breathe.
Niminypiminy, I am so glad you've found the book helpful. It changed our parenting, and it changed our lives.
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on
:
Fingers crossed for Not-So-Little One, then...
Little J nearly had a migraine yesterday during the first performance of her school play; she said she found the flashes from people's cameras were making her uncomfortable. It definitely looks as if light is the trigger for her.
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
Okay, now what? Pediatric neurologist with thirty years experience says "no medical diagnosis"; English teacher and counselor both say "definitely autistic"; examiners say "very bright, affectionate, reads social cues well, great eye contact and gestures, creative, maybe or maybe not one sensory issue, no fixations or narrow interests, but has attention problems and sometimes gets in people's faces without noticing, a tad perfectionist, refuses to tell social lies--let's call it educational autism. Please sign here"--based largely on the rating of one teacher, the English teacher. Who, by the way, is threatening to refuse him gifted services if I don't agree to the autism dx. What the hell do I do now? Transfer to public school would still have him dxed autism, as the examiners are from there. I would be happy for him to get a little extra help, but I'm worried about the effects of sticking him with this label. Particularly when the neurologist disagrees.
I'm also left wondering just where the limits beween ASD and normal lie, since most of his quirks are echoed in his parents. Are we autistic, then? And how would that sort with careers spent entirely in people care, often of the most intimate and connected/relationship kind?
Posted by Doublethink (# 1984) on
:
Well, autism is believed to have a genetic basis and you are more likely to have it if a first degree relative is a scientist or engineer. So yes, *if* your child has an autistic spectrum condition there is a good chance one or other parent will have some ASD like traits.
I am confused as to why a paediatric neurologist would be an appropriate professional to diagnose (or not) an autistic spectrum disorder ? I would expect that would be more usually done by either a child clinical psychologist or a child psychiatrist.
Posted by Doublethink (# 1984) on
:
Just re-read what you said about the neurologist said more closely. Did the neurologist say that he doesn't have enough evidence to make a formal diagnosis of autism. Or there is insufficient evidence for a medical diagnosis of an abnormality of the nervous system (such as may be queried in the case of ticcing e.g. tourette's) ? Or was the communication not clear about what was being referred to ?
Re the examiners (which profession were they ?): to diagnose ASD, requires a detailed developmental history, so it is a bit dubious if it is done just on the basis of some psychometric tests. And I am sure you can't do it on the basis of the Stamford-Binet alone, that is just an intelligence test you can't assess for a specific developmental disorder with it.
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
Here AFAIK either can do it, but the neurologist is preferable (said the various special ed people) maybe because it has a clearer than usual link to the brain etc? I don't know. Maybe it's also that he/she is better equipped to rule out other clearly physical based developmental disorders, which a psychologist might not recognize? But I'm guessing.
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
Neurologist said " there's no medical diagnosis here" though he did give me the name of a tic clinic (had to take my word for it as LL for some reason refrained from ticcing during the whole visit. He put it down as "school problem" in the dx space.
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on
:
Lamb Chopped: quote:
very bright, affectionate, reads social cues well, great eye contact and gestures, creative, maybe or maybe not one sensory issue, no fixations or narrow interests, but has attention problems and sometimes gets in people's faces without noticing, a tad perfectionist, refuses to tell social lies
This sounds like me (and Little J) but not like any definition of autism I've ever read. I thought the main characteristics of that were difficulty in reading social cues and a tendency to have fixations/narrow interests?
Is agreeing to the label 'educational autism' likely to cause him problems later on?
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on
:
And call me a cynic, but this bit: quote:
based largely on the rating of one teacher, the English teacher. Who, by the way, is threatening to refuse him gifted services if I don't agree to the autism dx.
sounds like he's having problems with this one teacher... could a clash of personalities be involved here?
And is it actually legal for her to refuse him gifted services that he's qualified for, just because you refuse to let her slap a label on him?
[ 18. December 2012, 18:12: Message edited by: Jane R ]
Posted by Autenrieth Road (# 10509) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Lamb Chopped:
I'm also left wondering just where the limits beween ASD and normal lie, since most of his quirks are echoed in his parents. Are we autistic, then? And how would that sort with careers spent entirely in people care, often of the most intimate and connected/relationship kind?
I have an American friend who was just diagnosed with autism in the Netherlands, where she lives. She is 52. She is a brilliant, social, observant, talented, person, and none of us who know her would ever in a million years have guessed autism, nor would she have suspected it herself. But what she was told was that autism (in this case at least) is about a difference in processing. Non-autistic people see a whole, and then fill in the parts. Autistic people (or at least her form) see all the detail first, and then have to synthesize the whole from it.
Example: we were at the supermarket together, looking for yogurt. She was visiting me, so I knew where the yogurt case was, and walked us over. I picked out a yogurt, she picked out a yogurt, I looked at her yogurt and said "Oh, they have that kind, I want that instead!" and put mine back, hunted around the shelves until I found one like hers, and took it. What had just happened?
I had seen the general whole "yogurt case", remembered what I usually get there, looked closely just enough to find it, and taken it off the shelf.
She had seen many many different kinds of yogurts, and had to synthesize from all this detail she was seeing "ah, we're at the yogurt case" and from that deduced that the appropriate response was to choose a yogurt. But she had already seen all the detail, so from that wealth of detail she could choose precisely the kind of yogurt she wanted.
I on the other hand hadn't really seen any of that detail at all, so hadn't had the alternative of the different kind of yogurt in my mind until I saw her choice, and once I did see her choice, I still didn't know where to find it without further searching.
Another example happened a few days later. I wasn't with her then, but I think I can fill in what the experience for her might have been like. I was at the airport looking for the gate for a connecting flight. I saw a board "Arrivals." That triggered me to look a bit farther and saw "Departures." So I knew I was in the right general area. But then, confusingly, I couldn't find my flight until I made myself really slow down, stop scanning the board as a whole, and start reading each line, line by line, carefully. After about three lines I figured out how the information was organized, and then could jump to my line and find my flight.
I think for my friend it would have worked the other way: she would have seen a lot of lines of data. Then she would have had to notice the column headings, to work out that it was City, Gate, Status, Time. Along the way she might have noticed that they were alphabetical, except very oddly they were in two alphabetical sets. What's the difference between this set and that set? Then she would have figured out that one set was Arrivals and one set was Departures. Then, having figured all of that out, and knowing which set was now the Departures, she would have immediately known where to find the line for the departure to her city. And do all that while having the detailed information of 200 Arrivals and Departures swirling about in her head.
This has practically expressed itself in her life over and over and over where she learns subjects very very well, or else she does terribly in them. The reason is because until she has completely mastered the subject, everything is still details. She needs all the details before she can form the overarching picture. So if she gets tested or asked to work with the subject before she knows all the details, she can't do it. But once she gets to the point of being able to form the overarching picture, then all of a sudden she is a complete master of the subject, because her overarching picture is already filled in completely with all the essential details.
From my yogurt example, you can also see that in any new situation she needs time to orient herself to the surroundings in a particular kind of way. Me, from the other end of the store, I see the giant sign that says "yogurt" and know where to go. Her, she needs to look everywhere and get up close and detailed, and then not only that, process from "what am I looking at here? Ah, lots of kinds of yogurt" to "this is a yogurt case" to "I can get a yogurt here."
Another example of this effect is that she was taking a Dutch proficiency exam. She knows and speaks Dutch very well, but she found the exam incredibly hard, because it was a timed exam which basically consisted of a lot of questions, with every question presenting a new situation with lots of detail, asking for a detailed reply. So on every new question, she's having to shift gears from the previous situation, figure out the details of the new situation, think through all the ramifications of the new situation, think about all the places where the new situation is ambiguous, absorb all the details of what she's being asked to produce, think about all the details of where what she's being asked to produce is either ambiguous or could take an entire thesis to answer or both, and then give an answer which to her has lots of detail and implications, and try to give that answer in the very short amount of time left out of the average amount of time allowed per question if you're going to finish the whole exam.
Her autism was found as a result of testing that she was undergoing for some other reason (vocational affinity, perhaps?), and they found a faint hint of something in the results that they wanted to follow up on. My friend pointed out that the reason it showed up so faintly in the initial results is that the questions would ask things about how you process things, that can only be answered if you know how other people process things and that your way is different. For example, (I don't know if this is an exact question from the evaluation, but it's similar in nature, I think) "do you find yourself overwhelmed with details?" Well, if all your life you've processed data in this way, and found a way to manage, and have no idea other people process differently, you won't think of your thinking as being "overwhelmed with details." You may not even think of it as detail-oriented at all, since you can hardly even talk about it until you've processed all the details and emerged with a synthesis. You may be more likely to think that you're slow at learning, and have worked hard to be good at some subjects, and will answer the question "No."
I don't know if there is some distinctive Dutch use of the word autism which doesn't identically track to how we use the word here in the States, and/or if this kind of processing difference in fact is at the root of the kinds of traits that I (naively) am used to thinking of as characteristic of autism spectrum disorders. I wanted to offer this story in case it is useful to anyone here.
I will try to stay reading this thread for a while in case anyone has any questions, but I don't always read this thread, so if you have any questions and I seem unresponsive I probably just haven't seen them: please feel free to PM me.
Oh, the yogurt? Stonyfield Farm Whole Milk Vanilla.
[ 18. December 2012, 19:34: Message edited by: Autenrieth Road ]
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Jane R:
And call me a cynic, but this bit: quote:
based largely on the rating of one teacher, the English teacher. Who, by the way, is threatening to refuse him gifted services if I don't agree to the autism dx.
sounds like he's having problems with this one teacher... could a clash of personalities be involved here?
That's what it sounds like to me. If he had a developmental disorder of any kind, it would exist in every setting. It might be worse in one setting than in another, but if the only place it shows up is English class, it's not a developmental disorder. It could be a severe case of dysteachia, which is a persistent condition that usually responds to placing the student in a different class.
That said, I know a number of parents who have kids with an educational autism label, and I haven't ever heard of a downside to having the label. It is not a medical diagosis, it's a special education category. Some districts require a medical diagnosis before they'll assign a special ed category, but some don't. If you object to the category, that's a point that can be negotiated -- you might prefer Other Health Impaired. The category really doesn't matter; the thing is, the child has to be assigned one of the 13 special education categories before the child can be provided special education and related services. No category, no services.
The assigned category exists only in the child's special education records, which are not shared even with teachers. The only things teachers get are the goals, objectives, and accommodations outlined in the IEP. But there's no medical or diagnostic info there, no category information. Just "Student must have a seat near the door" or "Student requires large-print books."
As far as the legality of making gifted services contingent on special ed services, that depends entirely on which state you're in. There is no federal law regarding gifted services; some states mandate gifted identification and services, some mandate gifted identification but do not mandate services, and some have no gifted mandate at all. If your state does not mandate gifted services, there's almost nothing you can do if the school chooses not to provide your child with gifted services.
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
I was told at the meeting that they would provide all teachers with his diagnosis. Are private schools different then? By the by, they had the English teacher present without notifying me to hear all the gory intimate details.
In fairness i must say that his homeroom teacher is also concerned, though to a lesser degree and almost wholly due to the tics (which need not be ASD of course).
Posted by Chorister (# 473) on
:
No idea what it's like in America, but in Britain Private Schools operate on a 'you get what you pay for' basis. Thus it can be extremely expensive for parents to educate their Special Needs children in a Private School - not only do you have to pay the same rate as all the other parents, but for every special provision on top of that - tailored to your child and their particular needs - you have to pay again.... and again.....
It's very important that people realise that before considering educating children with Special Needs privately - best to talk with the school in depth in the initial stages before committing yourself to a place.
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Lamb Chopped:
I was told at the meeting that they would provide all teachers with his diagnosis. Are private schools different then?
Yes, private schools are different. They are required to comply with the ADA, but not with IDEA. So they have to provide accommodations (e.g., a ramp for a child in a wheelchair) if those accommodations do not change the nature of the program, but they do not have to provide special education and related services.
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
I was wondering more about the confidentiality thing.
Posted by Lamb Chopped (# 5528) on
:
Anyway... talked with Mr Lamb and we'll probably be putting him in public school next year unless things improve beyond all expectation. The main issue is the teacher--I agree with you'al who think she's grinding some sort of personal axe, though I can't really wrap my head around the idea of a teacher behaving in such a way to a child -- what's the motivation? He's a brilliant writer if I do say so myself, respectful and obedient, and it can't be me as she's only laid eyes on me three times, and started out hostile at the first meeting--WTF was that about?? I'm just not getting this. Anyway, Mr. Lamb wants to talk to the principal about her before we just take our child and disappear into the night, so to speak, but i can't figure out what to say that won't get me automatically ignored as a disgruntled parent looking for a scapegoat.
In my fantasy world (heh) we'd be able to leave him there for all classes BUT English, which I could handle perfectly well myself (I'm a licensed secondary teacher and PhD). But I'm trying to figure out how NOT to appear like a whackjob so as to get some cooperation. Any suggestions, anybody? (By the way, the reason she can unilaterally withhold gifted ed is because she is apparently the program leader--or so she gave me to understand. If she's all there is we should avoid it like the plague.)
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on
:
quote:
I agree with you'al who think she's grinding some sort of personal axe, though I can't really wrap my head around the idea of a teacher behaving in such a way to a child -- what's the motivation?
Teachers are human too. Maybe he keeps saying things that she interprets as challenges to her authority without realising what he's doing?
If you're happy with the school in every other respect I would definitely suggest talking to the principal before taking him out of there. Getting Mr Lamb involved is a good idea - it makes the point that it's not just you being Helicopter Mom...
Posted by busyknitter (# 2501) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Chorister:
No idea what it's like in America, but in Britain Private Schools operate on a 'you get what you pay for' basis. Thus it can be extremely expensive for parents to educate their Special Needs children in a Private School - not only do you have to pay the same rate as all the other parents, but for every special provision on top of that - tailored to your child and their particular needs - you have to pay again.... and again.....
It's very important that people realise that before considering educating children with Special Needs privately - best to talk with the school in depth in the initial stages before committing yourself to a place.
Actually I think it's more complicated than that and I'm sure varies from school to school.
Earlier this year I worked as short term finance officer in a private school in England. This was a mainstream school with a very high academic reputation. Both the Junior and Senior sections of the school had SENCOs employed as part of the normal school establishment and as far as I could tell, put a huge amount of effort into identifying and responding to children's additional needs as they arose.
Yes, parents had to pay for any additional assessments or therapists, for example an educational psychologist report or if any 1:1 time with a dyslexia specialist was recommended. But where it was simply a matter of adapting classroom practice to deliver an IEP, it just happened.
That kind of school wouldn't do for my autistic son as he needs a very specialist environment, but they did have pupils with aspergers, ADHD, dyspraxia, physical disabilities.
Also LEAs do fund mainstream private schools where there is a statement of special educational needs in place.
[ 19. December 2012, 15:20: Message edited by: busyknitter ]
Posted by Josephine (# 3899) on
:
Frustrated with the local school. Youngest One withdrew last semester (at the suggestion of the special ed people), because he wasn't well enough to do any schoolwork on any kind of regular basis. We all agreed he should focus on getting healthier. But he is at least somewhat healthier now, and he wants to start back with an online class, so we've asked (repeatedly) what we need to do to get him re-enrolled, and they are putting us off and ignoring us.
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on
:
Sorry to hear that, Josephine. I don't know what alternatives might be available where you are, but over here I'd be looking into the possibility of getting Little J enrolled in distance learning FE courses. Or having a go at teaching her myself with the assistance of the home education network. Or complaining to the Education Welfare Officer that the school is failing in its duty to provide her with an education.
Meanwhile in the (briefly) sunny UK, Little J is doing really well with her tinted glasses. She got them just before Christmas and hasn't had a migraine since, except occasionally when she goes swimming and those stop immediately when she puts her glasses back on after getting out of the pool. We are basically back to normal! We went to the migraine clinic again a couple of weeks ago and they said she could try coming off the drugs, so she reduced the dosage for a week and hasn't had any pills at all for the last week. Still no migraines
Posted by Welease Woderwick (# 10424) on
:
As there has been no action on this thread for some months can I assume that all problems are solved and everything in hunky-dory?
Posted by Roseofsharon (# 9657) on
:
quote:
Originally posted by Welease Woderwick:
As there has been no action on this thread for some months can I assume that all problems are solved and everything in hunky-dory?
Looking forwsrd
to new problems for the family with Elder Grandson's approaching change of school, and the beginnings of puberty.
Can't be the only one!
Posted by Jane R (# 331) on
:
Little J's migraines are still being kept at bay by the magical glasses, so as far as I'm concerned you could close the thread down. I can't speak for anyone else though.
Posted by Haydee (# 14734) on
:
I'm at the beginning of the process of finding out my younger (adoptive) daughter's needs, now she's settled enough to see past the 'moving in' unsettled period. Plus as she's 5 she's moving into a more formal and less accommodating school environment (or will next year - her pre-school is wonderful). So the longer term issues are getting more visible.
It looks like sensory processing difficulties, especially vestibular. Sitting still is almost impossible for her. Plus the general developmental delay of 5 years in an impoverished (in all respects) environment and insecure attachment. I seem to be gathering more and more of a team around us, though, I've been very lucky.
Only difficulty is our local school doesn't want the hassle of a child at the bottom end of the 'mainstream' educationally, even though she has come on tremendously and with the right remedial support has every prospect of catching up over the next couple of years.
Posted by Niminypiminy (# 15489) on
:
Haydee that is outrageous that your local school don't want to be bothered with your daughter, though all too believable. Are you in the UK? If you are you might find IPSEA helpful in getting your head around the SEN maze and especially fighting for inclusion and extra support at school.
Nimlet 1 (my child with special needs) is going though a good phase at the moment -- happy at school because he is well supported, and so not acting out all his stress at home. But I am well aware that things can and probably will change at the start of next school year, or when something new developmentally happens and he has to integrate it. So for now I am just enjoying, well, enjoying him.
Posted by PeteC (# 10422) on
:
School bells are soon ringing and problems arise anew
Posted by Niminypiminy (# 15489) on
:
Yes indeedy. We are probably going to have to move the children to a different school in the middle of this year - so, in addition to all the normal problems of settling in a new school and knowing no one, there will be the extra problems of managing the transition for Nimlet1 and getting his support sorted out. Oh, how I'm looking forward to it!
© Ship of Fools 2016
UBB.classicTM
6.5.0