|
Source: (consider it)
|
Thread: Purgatory: Syria and the U.K. Parliament
|
Pottage
Shipmate
# 9529
|
Posted
quote: Originally posted by mr cheesy: Then he says some guff about the need to stand up to evil. Which nobody can disagree with, obviously - but clearly the question is whether an expensive bombing campaign launched largely because the French are reacting to the pain of a terrorist attack will actually achieve as much as - say - dealing with the bank accounts, the funding, the oil movements, the antiquities smuggling and the other ways that IS gets money. This is not a proven point.
Is there any suggestion that bombing IS targets throughout the territory they have laid claim to rather than just in part of it (which is what was authorised) will replace whatever would otherwise be done to target them in other ways: attacking their bank accounts and their sales of oil and smuggled antiquities, curtailing their flow of volunteers, taking down their propaganda, challenging their narrative amongst those likely to be susceptible to it etc? It seemed to me that it was implicit in everyone's arguments on both sides of the debate that all of this good stuff would continue, regardless of the bombing mandate.
Posts: 701 | From: middle England | Registered: May 2005
| IP: Logged
|
|
Humble Servant
Shipmate
# 18391
|
Posted
quote: Originally posted by Pottage: curtailing their flow of volunteers
Well bombing will certainly do the opposite of that. Every civilian killed is another family of willing volunteers for ISIS. Has ISIS bombing of Paris curtailed the number of advocates of war in Syria?
Posts: 241 | Registered: Apr 2015
| IP: Logged
|
|
Pottage
Shipmate
# 9529
|
Posted
quote: Originally posted by Humble Servant: quote: Originally posted by Pottage: curtailing their flow of volunteers
Well bombing will certainly do the opposite of that. Every civilian killed is another family of willing volunteers for ISIS. Has ISIS bombing of Paris curtailed the number of advocates of war in Syria?
Yes, that's a risk. Sadly there aren't possible courses of action that are free from risk. Even doing nothing at all has consequences. After all, IS aren't looking to kill us because of what we've done, but because of what we are. As the Shia, Yazidi, Christian and Kurdish populations of both Iraq and Syria can confirm. Those of them who can still be reached for comment.
Posts: 701 | From: middle England | Registered: May 2005
| IP: Logged
|
|
Barnabas62
Shipmate
# 9110
|
Posted
mr cheesy, I'd like to pick you up on a couple of points from your analysis of Hilary Benn's speech. quote: The problem is that every single phrase Hilary Benn used in his speech is complete bollocks.
The first sentence asserts a conclusion which you seek to prove.
quote: This speech was 15 minutes of emotional rhetoric with about 1 decent point. The rest was total waffle.
The last sentence asserts that the presentation was not complete bollocks.
Which is it? A speech devoid of any sensible content. Or a speech with marginal sensible content? Or did you just realise while writing the post that "complete bollocks" didn't stand up even to your own subjective analysis of content?
It was a subjective analysis, wasn't it? You recognise that point a couple of times. quote: Then he says that the Kurdish leader has said that airstrikes have helped. OK, but this doesn't really help much given that Turkey, our allies, see the Kurds as more of an enemy than Daesh/IS. One could also point to lots of people who say that airstrikes are making things worse - who may or may not be believable, depending on your own point of view.
Of course it depends on your point of view! It's about a balanced judgment of conflicting evidence. Good people can disagree without calling "bollocks".
quote: Then he says some guff about the need to stand up to evil. Which nobody can disagree with, obviously - but clearly the question is whether an expensive bombing campaign launched largely because the French are reacting to the pain of a terrorist attack will actually achieve as much as - say - dealing with the bank accounts, the funding, the oil movements, the antiquities smuggling and the other ways that IS gets money. This is not a proven point.
Guff is of course loaded language to demean what was said. That's a rhetorical flourish also. But you finish up with "This is not a proven point". Of course it isn't. It isn't a disproven point either. Again good people can disagree about what constitutes balanced judgment without calling "bollocks".
In passing, I note without enthusiasm the following argument by John McDonnell
quote: Shadow chancellor John McDonnell has compared Hilary Benn's well received Commons speech advocating airstrikes against Isis in Syria to Tony Blair's pre-Iraq War speech in 2003.
"I thought Hilary, his oratory was great. It reminded me of Tony Blair’s speech taking us into the Iraq War and I’m always anxious about the greatest oratory is going to lead us to the greatest mistakes as well," he said.
Source; Huffington Post article
That's really playing the man, rather than the ball. No analysis anywhere in sight. Instead its this; "Let's assert first that it was just the power of the rhetoric then remind ourselves of another occasion. Then let's tar Benn with the "Bliar" brush." I smell sour grapes.
This from Jess Phillips, Labour MP for Birmingham Yardley (who voted against the motion) strikes me as a much better response. [ 03. December 2015, 13:04: Message edited by: Barnabas62 ]
-------------------- Who is it that you seek? How then shall we live? How shall we sing the Lord's song in a strange land?
Posts: 21397 | From: Norfolk UK | Registered: Feb 2005
| IP: Logged
|
|
chris stiles
Shipmate
# 12641
|
Posted
quote: Originally posted by Gamaliel:
If it's wrong to bomb within Syria then surely it must be wrong of us to bomb ISIS targets in Iraq?
In Iraq bombing is largely happening in support of the Iraqi Army - i.e targeting is being done in support of ground forces, and from intelligence provided by ground forces in some cases.
This isn't the case in Syria. One you've hit the obvious military sites there isn't much else to do that won't involve hitting civilians as collateral. There were reports - prior to Britain joining this effort - of planes coming back with bombs because they couldn't find targets to hit.
Posts: 4035 | From: Berkshire | Registered: May 2007
| IP: Logged
|
|
mr cheesy
Shipmate
# 3330
|
Posted
quote: Originally posted by Barnabas62: The first sentence asserts a conclusion which you seek to prove.
Correct, I've been to rhetorician school too - you state your conclusion, you state the reasons for getting to the conclusion and then you state the conclusion again.
quote: The last sentence asserts that the presentation was not complete bollocks.
Right. For avoidance of doubt, let me state that half a point and half a point does not add up to a point. He had no points.
quote: Which is it? A speech devoid of any sensible content. Or a speech with marginal sensible content? Or did you just realise while writing the post that "complete bollocks" didn't stand up even to your own subjective analysis of content?
I'm obviously not using the same book of cynical phrases that you are used to using. Let me repeat: none of his statements held up to any scrutiny in my opinion. You are, of course, free to believe otherwise.
quote: It was a subjective analysis, wasn't it? You recognise that point a couple of times.
Well, I'm not sure asking for evidence - and showing that none has actually been given - of statements is, in fact, subjective.
But, OK, if you like - the fact that I think the man was talking total shite was subjective. You are free to believe he is talking slight shite, talking sense or the Queen's inerrant brother, if you like. I'd rather stick to thinking about whether his rhetoric has any basis in fact, thanks all the same.
quote: Of course it depends on your point of view! It's about a balanced judgment of conflicting evidence. Good people can disagree without calling "bollocks".
It was fairly clear that Mr Benn thought that quoting the Kurdish leader was some kind of knock-out blow for his argument. I don't believe it is - having heard a range of quotes on the subject from the messages that have somehow emerged from Raqqa, from the Russians, from the Syrian regime, from a bunch of other people - it is clear that one could find equal-and-opposite phrases to quote. Therefore this is not any kind of knock-out blow in argument.
Incidentally, I didn't say anything about Mr Benn personally, I just said his speech was bollocks. You are free to believe differently.
quote: Guff is of course loaded language to demean what was said. That's a rhetorical flourish also. But you finish up with "This is not a proven point". Of course it isn't. It isn't a disproven point either. Again good people can disagree about what constitutes balanced judgment without calling "bollocks".
As above.
quote: In passing, I note without enthusiasm the following argument by John McDonhell
quote: Shadow chancellor John McDonnell has compared Hilary Benn's well received Commons speech advocating airstrikes against Isis in Syria to Tony Blair's pre-Iraq War speech in 2003.
"I thought Hilary, his oratory was great. It reminded me of Tony Blair’s speech taking us into the Iraq War and I’m always anxious about the greatest oratory is going to lead us to the greatest mistakes as well," he said.
Source; Huffington Post article
That's really playing the man, rather than the ball. No analysis anywhere in sight. Instead its this; "Let's assert first that it was just the power of the rhetoric then remind ourselves of another occasion. Then let's tar Benn with the "Bliar" brush." I smell sour grapes.
Nope. I'm not sure why, but you seem unable to see a difference between attacking an argument and attacking the person.
Let me spell it out for you: claiming that someone is an apologist for IS is attacking the man. Saying that the speech he just made which so many are claiming was the best since 1945 is, by definition, not.
quote: This from Jess Phillips, Labour MP for Birmingham Yardley (who voted against the motion) strikes me as a much better response.
That's nice.
-------------------- arse
Posts: 10697 | Registered: Sep 2002
| IP: Logged
|
|
mr cheesy
Shipmate
# 3330
|
Posted
quote: Originally posted by Barnabas62:
This from Jess Phillips, Labour MP for Birmingham Yardley (who voted against the motion) strikes me as a much better response.
On this, I'd say that a politician who does not understand the consequences of standing on a point of conscience should not be a politician. A party is free to deselect a sitting MP, just as consistuents are free to vote them out.
If you, as an MP, decide to make a stand on an issue that does not have overwhelming support locally, then that's all well-and-good, but as the system is set up you have to live with the consequences: which could including deselection and losing your seat. Deal. [ 03. December 2015, 13:14: Message edited by: mr cheesy ]
-------------------- arse
Posts: 10697 | Registered: Sep 2002
| IP: Logged
|
|
Gamaliel
Shipmate
# 812
|
Posted
Sure - which is surely better than them dropping them anyway, irrespective of whether there are targets or not ...?
But I take the point you're making - it's hard to see which ground troops the air strikes in Syria are meant to support ... Assad's? Any of the 100 or so factions on the rebel side?
I appreciate it's tricky. One would hope, though, that if there are insufficient ISIS targets for the RAF and other coalition air forces to strike, then they'd call off the air strikes - rather than going through with them as a matter of course or - as Russia appears to be doing, bombing ISIS targets and any other target that isn't Assad's forces.
I'm uncomfortable with the whole situation but I can't say I'm upset by ISIS oil-wells being hit - provided that could be done without collateral damage if at all possible.
I'm not a hawk. I'm largely a pacifist but I'm not a total pacifist - I do think there are occasions when force is necessary and in the case of ISIS I believe the line to have been crossed long ago. If there were no ISIS bases in Syria we wouldn't be having this discussion ... we'd presumably (most of us) be concerned - but broadly in favour - of limited action to hold back ISIS in Iraq.
The trouble is, Iraq's in a mess (of our making) and its own forces crumpled very quickly when put under pressure by ISIS. Sure, air strikes aren't the best thing to do but they have helped contain ISIS in Iraq - in support of the Kurdish peshmerga and others.
Unless we conclude that there is no case whatsoever for some kind of military response against ISIS by France, the UK, US, Russia or anyone else from outside the region, then what are the alternatives?
It can't be a one-shop-stop solution. There has to be action against the funding of ISIS in some way - and also the long, hard slog to prevent their toxic ideology from spreading.
What other military options might there be? Send in SAS style snatch-squads to take out the leaders? Large scale Russian invasion with hundreds of thousands of boots on the ground and the prospect of another Afghanistan?
There's no obvious neat solution. If there was someone would have come up with it by now.
-------------------- Let us with a gladsome mind Praise the Lord for He is kind.
http://philthebard.blogspot.com
Posts: 15997 | From: Cheshire, UK | Registered: Jul 2001
| IP: Logged
|
|
mr cheesy
Shipmate
# 3330
|
Posted
quote: Originally posted by Gamaliel:
It can't be a one-shop-stop solution. There has to be action against the funding of ISIS in some way - and also the long, hard slog to prevent their toxic ideology from spreading.
During the debate, many MPs asked for evidence that these kinds of actions (bank accounts, oil, etc) have been undertaken. And nobody could provide any.
Yes, it is all very well to say now "OK, listen this bombing will be undertaken in co-ordination with various other activities to choke off IS funds.." but the reality appears to be that very little of these former activities have been done. Perhaps because, as others have said (by MPs during the debate and on this bulletin board), we might find a few skeletons in that particular cupboard if we looked hard enough.
Past performance in conflict shows that we're prepared to spend £multimillions on dropping a few bombs and £pennies on reconstruction. Because, y'know, we live in a military-industrial-political world where we actually need to have regular wars to keep everyone employed.
Yes, I do really believe that.
-------------------- arse
Posts: 10697 | Registered: Sep 2002
| IP: Logged
|
|
Gamaliel
Shipmate
# 812
|
Posted
I've often heard that argument, mr cheesy, particularly from people in the US of both left-wing and right-wing persuasions ... I'm not sure I buy into it ...
It seems rather too neat. 'The Government and Powers That Be are out to shaft us - that's why they bring us to the brink of WW3 and mutual mass destruction ... in order to feather their own nests and support the military-business combine ...'
It's an argument that suits both right-wing libertarians as well as those who consider themselves cuddly lefties. But hey ...
Similarly, Hilary Benn has been accused of supporting the bombing simply as a way of undermining Corbyn and enhancing his own career.
Whatever his reasons might have been I'm not so cynical as to believe that Benn would advocate killing people simply to further his own self-interest ... I can be cynical, but I'm not that cynical ...
I've also seen it suggested that whilst France is brokering necessary Russian and Iranian support for the Vienna talks - with a view towards ending the Syrian civil war in some way - the West is treading carefully in terms of the obvious sensitivity involved.
However, I've also seen it suggested that it's more than that - and involves a lack of transparency about Sunni financial support for ISIS among individuals in the Gulf States and among some of the West's allies in the region. The finger points to some of the Gulf States in this respect.
I confess myself to be ambivalent about the Syrian/Iraqi border issue - as ISIS clearly operates across it as if it didn't exist. Arguably, the extension of bombing across that border is marginal militarily - but it is significant politically.
What happens next? It's going to be messy whatever happens. But is anyone realistically saying that there is some kind of simple, clear-cut solution that doesn't involve force or military action in any way, shape or form?
Of course, military intervention doesn't in and of itself defeat ideologies like that of ISIS ... combating that will take time, effort and years and years of patience ...
On the issue of embargoes, sanctions and other means of stemming the funding of ISIS - yes, nobody in the debate was able to outline any measures in that direction and that's a woeful omission.
I'm squeamish about military action, I really am ... but what are the chances of persuading/nailing those individuals (or systems/governments) which are apparently supporting ISIS financially to do so without resorting to some kind of military threat there too - sooner or later?
Do we bomb ISIS bases in Syria or do we bomb Riyadh or Ankara or Dubai, perhaps, because there are individuals there who trade with ISIS?
Where do we draw the line?
-------------------- Let us with a gladsome mind Praise the Lord for He is kind.
http://philthebard.blogspot.com
Posts: 15997 | From: Cheshire, UK | Registered: Jul 2001
| IP: Logged
|
|
mr cheesy
Shipmate
# 3330
|
Posted
Sort of interesting that an "exclusive" interview had Hilary Benn on 15 November 2015 (yes, that is a few weeks ago) saying that the "Government should drop plans for a new House of Commons vote authorising military attacks in Syria to concentrate on peace talks and providing humanitarian support for refugees."
A lot of things happen in a couple of weeks, I guess.
-------------------- arse
Posts: 10697 | Registered: Sep 2002
| IP: Logged
|
|
mr cheesy
Shipmate
# 3330
|
Posted
In that vein, it is quite interesting what Philip Hammond is quoted (in the Mail, mark you) as saying in September 2014
‘Let me be clear – Britain will not be taking part in any air strikes in Syria. We have already had that discussion in our parliament last year and we won’t be revisiting that position.’
Have things really changed with respect to IS between September 2014 and now?
-------------------- arse
Posts: 10697 | Registered: Sep 2002
| IP: Logged
|
|
betjemaniac
Shipmate
# 17618
|
Posted
quote: Originally posted by mr cheesy: In that vein, it is quite interesting what Philip Hammond is quoted (in the Mail, mark you) as saying in September 2014
‘Let me be clear – Britain will not be taking part in any air strikes in Syria. We have already had that discussion in our parliament last year and we won’t be revisiting that position.’
Have things really changed with respect to IS between September 2014 and now?
Without getting down off the fence as to if it's a good idea or not, since September 2014 the UK has had a general election (so technically we now have a different parliament to 2013 and 2014). Over the same time period ISIS have (not exhaustive):
blown up a Russian airliner massacred over 100 people in Paris massacred multiple Britons (and others) on a Tunisian beach
Alongside this, Russia and France have piled into the conflict.
I can see why things might just be worth revisiting (even if the decision had been taken to do nothing differently) given all that.
The big thing since Mr Benn's quote is of course Paris. [ 03. December 2015, 15:34: Message edited by: betjemaniac ]
-------------------- And is it true? For if it is....
Posts: 1481 | From: behind the dreaming spires | Registered: Mar 2013
| IP: Logged
|
|
mr cheesy
Shipmate
# 3330
|
Posted
quote: Originally posted by betjemaniac: Without getting down off the fence as to if it's a good idea or not, since September 2014 the UK has had a general election (so technically we now have a different parliament to 2013 and 2014). Over the same time period ISIS have (not exhaustive):
blown up a Russian airliner massacred over 100 people in Paris massacred multiple Britons (and others) on a Tunisian beach
Alongside this, Russia and France have piled into the conflict.
Yes, that's all true. But I don't think it follows that therefore there was more call for attacking IS today than there was in 2014.
quote: The big thing since Mr Benn's quote is of course Paris.
I could be reading it incorrectly, but I think the text makes it clear the interview was conducted since the Paris attacks.
-------------------- arse
Posts: 10697 | Registered: Sep 2002
| IP: Logged
|
|
Barnabas62
Shipmate
# 9110
|
Posted
mr cheesy
I didn't say you were playing the man. You were asserting your opinions about his speech, which is fair game.
As it happens, I don't think Benn's speech was all rhetoric. It's a fact that France's socialist government has asked for help. It's a fact that Labour is, historically, an internationalist party. It's a fact that Karwan Jamal Tahir wrote the words that Benn read out about the effectiveness of air strikes and the fictional nature of the Iraq/Syrian border so far as the Daesh are concerned. Benn simply used those facts in support of his argument. Others in the debate used them the other way.
Clearly your mileage varies, but this from Jess Phillips struck a real chord with me.
quote: What I am certain of is that those who are so certain that they are right are certainly not as clever or good as they think they are.
I'm an old guy, and maybe an increasingly old-fashioned guy, but this from the beginning of Hilary Benn's speech speaks to me much louder that his conclusions.
quote: Before I respond to the debate, I would like to say this directly to the Prime Minister: Although my right honourable friend the Leader of the Opposition and I will walk into different division lobbies tonight, I am proud to speak from the same Despatch Box as him. My right honourable friend is not a terrorist sympathiser, he is an honest, a principled, a decent and a good man and I think the Prime Minister must now regret what he said yesterday and his failure to do what he should have done today, which is simply to say ‘I am sorry’.
Now Mr Speaker, we have had an intense and impassioned debate and rightly so, given the clear and present threat from Daesh, the gravity of the decision that rests upon the shoulders and the conscience of every single one of us and the lives we hold in our hands tonight. And whatever we decision we reach, I hope we will treat one another with respect.
So far as John McDonnell's comments are concerned, they would have got him a pass from me as a Purg Host if he and Benn were Shipmates. So in Ship's terms, what he said was not the equivalent of a Commandment 3 offence.
But as a long term observer of political life in this country (not a Host in this discussion forum) I'm sure he was playing the man, rather than the ball in terms of RL politics.
Benn is the news today. Nobody really thought he had that sort of speech in him. By reputation, he's a rather diffident, serious, earnest and courteous man. Not too different from Jeremy Corbyn in that respect. In House of Commons speechifying terms, he is a rhetorical lower order batsman who hit a six out of the ground. In sharp contrast to his leader, who really did not have a good day. Something clearly had to be done about that.
What McDonnell came up with was something like this. "You can't trust a man who has great rhetorical skills - just look at Bliar". That's called guilt by association isn't it, given Tony Blair's current status as demon. Of course you can argue that I'm just being cynical, but that's what I saw. [ 03. December 2015, 15:47: Message edited by: Barnabas62 ]
-------------------- Who is it that you seek? How then shall we live? How shall we sing the Lord's song in a strange land?
Posts: 21397 | From: Norfolk UK | Registered: Feb 2005
| IP: Logged
|
|
betjemaniac
Shipmate
# 17618
|
Posted
quote: Originally posted by mr cheesy: quote: Originally posted by betjemaniac: Without getting down off the fence as to if it's a good idea or not, since September 2014 the UK has had a general election (so technically we now have a different parliament to 2013 and 2014). Over the same time period ISIS have (not exhaustive):
blown up a Russian airliner massacred over 100 people in Paris massacred multiple Britons (and others) on a Tunisian beach
Alongside this, Russia and France have piled into the conflict.
Yes, that's all true. But I don't think it follows that therefore there was more call for attacking IS today than there was in 2014.
quote: The big thing since Mr Benn's quote is of course Paris.
I could be reading it incorrectly, but I think the text makes it clear the interview was conducted since the Paris attacks.
no, I think that's the chronology in my head being slightly off - you're right. OTOH, there are an awful lot of other things in that article which I rather think he might row back from now - particularly his "hailing" of Corbyn. That suggests 4 options to me (YMMV):
1) he's a complete opportunist 2) he believed it when he said it 3) almost everything he said in the interview was taking the party line at the time 4) what he's seen of decision making since November 15th within the Corbyn bunker/shadow cabinet has convinced him he was wrong at the time
I think the truth is probably somewhere between 2,3,and 4, with 4 probably the most likely. That's just gut feel though. [ 03. December 2015, 15:51: Message edited by: betjemaniac ]
-------------------- And is it true? For if it is....
Posts: 1481 | From: behind the dreaming spires | Registered: Mar 2013
| IP: Logged
|
|
Gamaliel
Shipmate
# 812
|
Posted
Yes, mr cheesy, I had noticed that Benn had changed his tune since that interview with The Independent - I would have provided a link to it myself to balance out my earlier comments if I hadn't been dashing around and posting at the same time ...
People do change their minds - but granted from November 15th until now isn't a great deal of time to go through a paradigm shift ...
I'm not sure about a lot of this - but like Barnabas62 I wouldn't dismiss Benn's speech as purely rhetorical - nor, I suspect, did it swing the balance from a 'nay' to an 'aye' in favour of bombing within Syria - although I wouldn't be surprised if it convinced a few waverers within his own and other parties or those tempted to abstain.
-------------------- Let us with a gladsome mind Praise the Lord for He is kind.
http://philthebard.blogspot.com
Posts: 15997 | From: Cheshire, UK | Registered: Jul 2001
| IP: Logged
|
|
Barnabas62
Shipmate
# 9110
|
Posted
I heard that Benn's speech may have persuaded around 15 Labour undecideds to join the Ayes. So you're quite right. It didn't materially affect the result. A comfortable majority became a very comfortable majority.
There was low farce on the Daily Politics programme today, during which a member of the Socialist Workers Party attacked a Labour MP for being Blairite because he protested about some of the deselection moves being made (by her and others). Apparently she had joined the Labour Party to vote for JC so had at least for the time being dual party membership. What made it funny was that she assumed he'd voted for the motion when he had voted against it!
I had a good laugh, but her language and approach were very reminiscent of the Militant Tendency infiltration approach which almost killed the Labour Party a couple of decades ago. Up til then I hadn't really got on board the 'mixed bag' dimension of those who joined the party before the vote on the leader.
-------------------- Who is it that you seek? How then shall we live? How shall we sing the Lord's song in a strange land?
Posts: 21397 | From: Norfolk UK | Registered: Feb 2005
| IP: Logged
|
|
quetzalcoatl
Shipmate
# 16740
|
Posted
I wonder how many Western politicians realize that you can destroy IS physically, but they will come back again and again, until the political issue of Sunni representation is solved.
In both countries, the Sunni tribes and groups keep moving towards extremism, because they feel shut out. Al Qaeda were destroyed in Iraq, and the tribes helped in this, but then again the Iraqui govt shut the tribes out, and some of them turned towards IS.
Of course, Assad has no intention of giving them any kind of political autonomy.
You can kill every IS member, but they will regenerate, until this is solved.
-------------------- I can't talk to you today; I talked to two people yesterday.
Posts: 9878 | From: UK | Registered: Oct 2011
| IP: Logged
|
|
Ariel
Shipmate
# 58
|
Posted
quote: Originally posted by Barnabas62: I had a good laugh, but her language and approach were very reminiscent of the Militant Tendency infiltration approach which almost killed the Labour Party a couple of decades ago. Up til then I hadn't really got on board the 'mixed bag' dimension of those who joined the party before the vote on the leader.
Someone else was making a similar point in one of the news sources this morning. I think it was with reference to Momentum, which he said was increasingly beginning to resemble the Militant Tendency.
Posts: 25445 | Registered: May 2001
| IP: Logged
|
|
agingjb
Shipmate
# 16555
|
Posted
Apparently there were 66 Labour MPs who supported the Cameron line, and they are being told they have no place in the Corbyn Labour party.
I remember the Gang of Four, who never become much more than about the Gang of 20. But they came close, and probably only the intervention of General Pinochet stopped them.
This could be the Gang of 66. One sufficient atrocity and they could end up, without much enthusiasm on any side, a bigger and more effective gang - although, FPTP being what it is. a Tory one-party state will still likely see me out.
-------------------- Refraction Villanelles
Posts: 464 | From: Southern England | Registered: Jul 2011
| IP: Logged
|
|
Barnabas62
Shipmate
# 9110
|
Posted
agingjb
Well, there will be pressure but since one of those who would be deselected (Tom Watson) is the elected Deputy Leader of the Labour Party, you can pretty much guarantee that something else will happen.
There was another media farce this evening. Adam Boulton (Sky News) interviewed a spokesperson for Left Unity, a group which has used social media to list all MPs who voted for the motion, and have urged local constituency parties to deselect those MPs.
It turned out that the spokesperson was not a member of the Labour Party, but was a supporter of Corbyn's views. She seemed to have a limited understanding of MPs' constituency responsibilities or the difference between representatives and delegates. She sounded pretty 'Militant Tendency' as well. The only polls that mattered were the ones that supported her viewpoint. She seemed not to appreciate the significance of the decision to allow a free vote. All in all it was a pretty bizarre performance.
Clearly a good deal of fun can be had with this, but there is a serious dimension as well. Some of the social media and other means of intimidation has been bad enough to justify reference to the police.
I think Jeremy Corbyn and Tom Watson are acting together to put a stop to abuse and intimidation. That's good. The Labour Party has enough problems at present. It really doesn't need these kinds of 'help' from some of its self-declared 'friends'. It's up to the local constituency parties to form their views in accordance with their constitutional responsibilities and freedoms. That's also a part of the processes of representative democracy. [ 03. December 2015, 21:11: Message edited by: Barnabas62 ]
-------------------- Who is it that you seek? How then shall we live? How shall we sing the Lord's song in a strange land?
Posts: 21397 | From: Norfolk UK | Registered: Feb 2005
| IP: Logged
|
|
chris stiles
Shipmate
# 12641
|
Posted
quote: Originally posted by quetzalcoatl: I wonder how many Western politicians realize that you can destroy IS physically, but they will come back again and again, until the political issue of Sunni representation is solved.
I do not think this is true. Iraq's government is largely Sunni yet ISIS exists in Iraq.
There are a number of problems across a lot of the Arab World that allow ISIS to exist. Weak and authoritarian governments, Governments and states being coterminous, regional loyalties being stronger than national ones, and the export of extreme forms of Islam from Saudi that tend to set the agenda elsewhere.
Posts: 4035 | From: Berkshire | Registered: May 2007
| IP: Logged
|
|
Martin60
Shipmate
# 368
|
Posted
How is that possible when the population is 65% Shia?
-------------------- Love wins
Posts: 17586 | From: Never Dobunni after all. Corieltauvi after all. Just moved to the capital. | Registered: Jun 2001
| IP: Logged
|
|
Barnabas62
Shipmate
# 9110
|
Posted
There is a clear overlap between this thread and the one on hypocrisy.
This one has probably reached the end of its natural life with the vote having been taken. It seems reasonable to allow a bit of time for post-vote reflection; meanwhile I'll consult with other Purg Hosts not as involved in this thread as I've been over the best course of action. Meanwhile, feel free to carry on discussing the post vote ramifications here.
Barnabas62 Purgatory Host
-------------------- Who is it that you seek? How then shall we live? How shall we sing the Lord's song in a strange land?
Posts: 21397 | From: Norfolk UK | Registered: Feb 2005
| IP: Logged
|
|
Barnabas62
Shipmate
# 9110
|
Posted
Meanwhile ....
This looks like a decent move.
I don't think it's possible in practice to stop social media dogpiling. There are some fringe body non-party-member Militant Tendency types out there who have decided to flex their social media freedoms in pretty appalling ways. With "friends" like that, who needs enemies?
All the more reason, therefore, to establish decent standards of conduct by party members. Leadership disapproval needs to be clear and ongoing.
-------------------- Who is it that you seek? How then shall we live? How shall we sing the Lord's song in a strange land?
Posts: 21397 | From: Norfolk UK | Registered: Feb 2005
| IP: Logged
|
|
Sioni Sais
Shipmate
# 5713
|
Posted
I participate in a couple of Leftist FB sites and some of the posts have been appalling. On our Hell board they would have had the Hellhosts asking whether they should be allowed. Lots have been passionate and a few have been reasoned, cool and calm. About 90% in the "passionate" zone I'd say.
Some of the abuse, but not a lot, has been worse than what was said by the Prime Minister in the House of Commons, but no one expects him to apologise. He, ministers and other members of both houses should set an example first.
-------------------- "He isn't Doctor Who, he's The Doctor"
(Paul Sinha, BBC)
Posts: 24276 | From: Newport, Wales | Registered: Apr 2004
| IP: Logged
|
|
Barnabas62
Shipmate
# 9110
|
Posted
quote: Originally posted by Sioni Sais:
Some of the abuse, but not a lot, has been worse than what was said by the Prime Minister in the House of Commons, but no one expects him to apologise.
I did. I think he will live to regret that he didn't.
quote: He, ministers and other members of both houses should set an example first.
Too right. And a similar argument applies to Labour re some of its "friends". Different circumstances, different responses, but I still remember Neil Kinnock's confrontation of Militant Tendency. I think it saved the Labour Party.
-------------------- Who is it that you seek? How then shall we live? How shall we sing the Lord's song in a strange land?
Posts: 21397 | From: Norfolk UK | Registered: Feb 2005
| IP: Logged
|
|
Doublethink.
Ship's Foolwise Unperson
# 1984
|
Posted
I am pleased with Tom Watson's suggestion. I think Corbyn has also been very clear in his condemnation.
It certainly isn't unique to Labour, the conservatives are still dealing with the fallout of that young activist's death - which is thought to have been due in part to bullying from within the party. Whilst the Lib dems have had significant issues over allegations of sexual harrassment.
I think social media are exposing elements of political culture that have been around for a long time - and I think that exposure may lead to it being better addressed. [ 04. December 2015, 10:57: Message edited by: Doublethink. ]
-------------------- All political thinking for years past has been vitiated in the same way. People can foresee the future only when it coincides with their own wishes, and the most grossly obvious facts can be ignored when they are unwelcome. George Orwell
Posts: 19219 | From: Erehwon | Registered: Aug 2005
| IP: Logged
|
|
Enoch
Shipmate
# 14322
|
Posted
It's a very like the two sides in Northern Ireland. The other lot, be they the Provos or various loyalist groups of plug-uglies, are terrorist savages, beyond the pale of humanity, blowers-up of babies etc.
Of course some of our lot go a bit too far, but they're still our boys. It's understandable since they feel so strongly about the cause - which of course, unlike the other lot's, is a good one. And anyway, even if we don't like some of what they do, we've got to stick up for them because they're on our side. Anyway, if we don't, nobody else will, and there's got to be some sort of threat to maintain group loyalty.
-------------------- Brexit wrexit - Sir Graham Watson
Posts: 7610 | From: Bristol UK(was European Green Capital 2015, now Ljubljana) | Registered: Nov 2008
| IP: Logged
|
|
|
|
quetzalcoatl
Shipmate
# 16740
|
Posted
Most wars are stupid, but recent wars in the Middle East have put military solutions before political ones, with predictable ghastly results.
Syria is now such a criss-cross of proxy forces, that it's difficult to predict what any action will lead to.
For example, Russia seems to want Assad to rule Syria again, but this could set off a Sunni uprising, which would make IS look quite mild, and could spread across the whole region.
I guess in the background, they are trying to negotiate some kind of withdrawal by Assad - but followed by what? Extremism will flourish in such situations, and military action can easily exacerbate it.
I don't think politicians think that far ahead.
-------------------- I can't talk to you today; I talked to two people yesterday.
Posts: 9878 | From: UK | Registered: Oct 2011
| IP: Logged
|
|
Enoch
Shipmate
# 14322
|
Posted
There's no prospect of a political solution from outside the region. Alas at the moment theres no very obvious place from which one within the region appears to be likely to emerge apart from the truly horrible nightmare of the Daesh taking over the lot and imposing on it their Islamic version of North Korea.
Nor is there any point in the well-meaning talking about working for peace if the people they'd need to work with are totally determined that they don't want to be facilitated.
-------------------- Brexit wrexit - Sir Graham Watson
Posts: 7610 | From: Bristol UK(was European Green Capital 2015, now Ljubljana) | Registered: Nov 2008
| IP: Logged
|
|
Barnabas62
Shipmate
# 9110
|
Posted
quote: Originally posted by Doublethink.:
I think social media are exposing elements of political culture that have been around for a long time - and I think that exposure may lead to it being better addressed.
Yes. The Big Issue may be the future of representative democracy in the communication age. The ease and rapidity of mass communication and mass response seems to give the option of greater levels of consultation with all voters than have been possible up to now.
-------------------- Who is it that you seek? How then shall we live? How shall we sing the Lord's song in a strange land?
Posts: 21397 | From: Norfolk UK | Registered: Feb 2005
| IP: Logged
|
|
Sioni Sais
Shipmate
# 5713
|
Posted
quote: Originally posted by mr cheesy: Telling that the academics at the War Studies department of King's College London are calling this Britain's stupidest war.
I'll give that argument more credit when it isn't the current war, because the current war is at best uncertain.
If the professionals at RUSI give an opinion, that will be worth a read. In any case the competition for "Britain's stupidest war" is pretty stiff. The three Afghan wars in the 19th century were all pretty bad, many aspects of the Zulu and Boer wars were hardly better. Mind you, had we lost a carrier in the South Atlantic in 1982 that would have been a military disaster and subsequent events would have been very different.
-------------------- "He isn't Doctor Who, he's The Doctor"
(Paul Sinha, BBC)
Posts: 24276 | From: Newport, Wales | Registered: Apr 2004
| IP: Logged
|
|
rolyn
Shipmate
# 16840
|
Posted
quote: Originally posted by quetzalcoatl: Most wars are stupid, but recent wars in the Middle East have put military solutions before political ones, with predictable ghastly results.
Syria is now such a criss-cross of proxy forces, that it's difficult to predict what any action will lead to. .... ....I don't think politicians think that far ahead.
Putting a brutally cynical overview on this whole predicament I would say the West, (and Russia if their willing to fall in), are seeking to gain control over the oil bearing areas . It may well be a continuous task to keep anti-democracy fighters at bay these areas until the oil's gone. It might even be possible to buy them off one day when warfare and martyrdom has fallen out of fashion. One thing's pretty certain, this is going on for decades. The ME is awash with arms and our dependency on oil is such that military activity is a price worth paying. The collateral damage at home will fall where it falls.
-------------------- Change is the only certainty of existence
Posts: 3206 | From: U.K. | Registered: Dec 2011
| IP: Logged
|
|
Martin60
Shipmate
# 368
|
Posted
Russia isn't interested in oil except in containing the wealth generated by its proselytizing enemies, Sunni Islam, owning it.
95% of the Soviet empire is being Salafized by Saudi money. By the time the oil runs out Arabized Turkestan threatening Russia and China and India through Pakistan will be a fait accompli. India will have Bangladesh, drowning due to India's exponential coal consumption, to contend with.
The have-nots will all have Islam.
10,000 years.
-------------------- Love wins
Posts: 17586 | From: Never Dobunni after all. Corieltauvi after all. Just moved to the capital. | Registered: Jun 2001
| IP: Logged
|
|
itsarumdo
Shipmate
# 18174
|
Posted
quote: Originally posted by Humble Servant: quote: Originally posted by Pottage: curtailing their flow of volunteers
Well bombing will certainly do the opposite of that. Every civilian killed is another family of willing volunteers for ISIS. Has ISIS bombing of Paris curtailed the number of advocates of war in Syria?
I get the uncomfortable feeling from comments by Syrians that ISIS has been allowed to expand and directly assisted by Assad as a way to win his own war - he seems to have a policy of depopulating the country so that only his own supporters remain. As each small group falls, it will eventually be between him and ISIS, and the west/russia will not allow ISIS to win.
As said above, every single civilian death as a result of western bombing is a potential recruiting call for ISIS/A Quaeda et al. And even the mere presence of western and russian intervention is also a recruiting poster for them.
-------------------- "Iti sapis potanda tinone" Lycophron
Posts: 994 | From: Planet Zog | Registered: Jul 2014
| IP: Logged
|
|
Stetson
Shipmate
# 9597
|
Posted
quote: Originally posted by itsarumdo: quote: Originally posted by Humble Servant: quote: Originally posted by Pottage: curtailing their flow of volunteers
Well bombing will certainly do the opposite of that. Every civilian killed is another family of willing volunteers for ISIS. Has ISIS bombing of Paris curtailed the number of advocates of war in Syria?
I get the uncomfortable feeling from comments by Syrians that ISIS has been allowed to expand and directly assisted by Assad as a way to win his own war - he seems to have a policy of depopulating the country so that only his own supporters remain. As each small group falls, it will eventually be between him and ISIS, and the west/russia will not allow ISIS to win.
As said above, every single civilian death as a result of western bombing is a potential recruiting call for ISIS/A Quaeda et al. And even the mere presence of western and russian intervention is also a recruiting poster for them.
I dunno. Assad would have to be COMPLETELY INDIFFERENT to the well-being of his own Alawite religious group, to allow ISIS, which hates their guts and would probably like to kill all of them(along with Shiites generally) a free hand in grabbing territory. Much less to give them outright assistance.
That would be like Obama helping the KKK to take over major American cities and start lynching black people, in order to get sympathy from the world. [ 06. December 2015, 14:09: Message edited by: Stetson ]
Posts: 6574 | From: back and forth between bible belts | Registered: Jun 2005
| IP: Logged
|
|
Enoch
Shipmate
# 14322
|
Posted
I'm with Stetson on this one. I've heard Syrian groups being interviewed in the UK in the last few days who say what Itsarumdo has cited them as saying. However, I suspect they've got their own particular kite to fly, and that's the way they are putting their case.
That case is that their enemy is the Assad/Baathist regime. They think the Daesh has alarmed the West so much, which was anti the Assad/Baathist regime, that it is now about to change its collective mind on that. That's a fair worry for them to have. We might be. From where we are, that might even be unavoidable. But it doesn't mean they are objective or the sort of people we want to be persuaded by.
Even right back when the civil war started in Syria, a lot of these groups were fairly committed to a strongly Islamist world view, Islamist rather than Alawist or Baathist. This was clear from what European based volunteers were not saying when they were being interviewed on television here. The Daesh is so extreme that one can be what most of the rest of us would regard as fairly extreme but still regard the Daesh as a potential enemy.
-------------------- Brexit wrexit - Sir Graham Watson
Posts: 7610 | From: Bristol UK(was European Green Capital 2015, now Ljubljana) | Registered: Nov 2008
| IP: Logged
|
|
chris stiles
Shipmate
# 12641
|
Posted
quote: Originally posted by Enoch: I'm with Stetson on this one. I've heard Syrian groups being interviewed in the UK in the last few days who say what Itsarumdo has cited them as saying. However, I suspect they've got their own particular kite to fly, and that's the way they are putting their case.
I tend to agree. I think part of it is a case of regional (to Syria) priorities.
[The government seems to be intent of keeping an enclave along the coast at the very least - and are supported in this by Russian air strikes.]
Posts: 4035 | From: Berkshire | Registered: May 2007
| IP: Logged
|
|
itsarumdo
Shipmate
# 18174
|
Posted
Well, somehow they have managed to sell oil. Lots of it. Difficult for a landlocked region without somebody's cooperation.
-------------------- "Iti sapis potanda tinone" Lycophron
Posts: 994 | From: Planet Zog | Registered: Jul 2014
| IP: Logged
|
|
|
|
chris stiles
Shipmate
# 12641
|
Posted
quote: Originally posted by itsarumdo: Well, somehow they have managed to sell oil. Lots of it. Difficult for a landlocked region without somebody's cooperation.
Well, we know that they ship oil via Turkey - which they have a direct border to.
Posts: 4035 | From: Berkshire | Registered: May 2007
| IP: Logged
|
|
|