|
Source: (consider it)
|
Thread: Downton Abbey Howlers
|
Kaplan Corday
Shipmate
# 16119
|
Posted
Yes, I know we've had Downton Abbey threads previously, but here in Australia we are just seeing the second series, and some of the stuff is pissing me off.
I can just about cope with anachronistic expressions such as "the Devil's in the detail", which I'm pretty sure has only been around for a few deades, but the military/historical detail is more serious.
First, the Irish chauffeur got called up (though rejected for health reasons) despite the fact that when conscription was introduced to Britain in 1916 it did not apply to Ireland.
Secondly, as officer and man, Matthew and William go swanning off around the countryside for several days on a patrol, in which they encounter a German patrol, despite the fact that this was impossible after the completion of the trench system in 1914; the only patrols were carried out at night, into no-man's-land, against the enemy trenches.
And yes, I know it's my own fault for watching soapies, but I've never watched one before - not even a single episode of Neighbours - so I feel I've built up credit which justifies indulgence in just a little bit of harmless escapist crap.
Hosts - you might want to move this to Heaven.
[ 25. June 2012, 07:18: Message edited by: Kaplan Corday ]
Posts: 3355 | Registered: Jan 2011
| IP: Logged
|
|
Stranger in a strange land
Shipmate
# 11922
|
Posted
Did not connscription apply to British Subjects ordinarily resident in Great Britain? .If so an Irishman living in England would then be covered by the act. (Never seen the programme, so not sure whether this applies.)
Posts: 608 | From: UK | Registered: Oct 2006
| IP: Logged
|
|
orfeo
Ship's Musical Counterpoint
# 13878
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by Kaplan Corday:
I can just about cope with anachronistic expressions such as "the Devil's in the detail", which I'm pretty sure has only been around for a few deades,
Why are you pretty sure of this, exactly?
I ask because I'm aware of numerous instances of people being accused of updating Shakespeare to sound modern when the phrase in question is actually in the original. There are plenty of phrases that 'sound' modern but aren't.
And also, as soon as you raised the Irish business, I immediately picked up the same issue: that he's an Irishman in England, not an Irishman in Ireland.
[ 25. June 2012, 08:23: Message edited by: orfeo ]
--------------------
Technology has brought us all closer together. Turns out a lot of the people you meet as a result are complete idiots.
Posts: 18173 | From: Under | Registered: Jul 2008
| IP: Logged
|
|
Kaplan Corday
Shipmate
# 16119
|
Posted
The best biography of C.S. Lewis, Alan Jacobs's The Narnian, explicitly states that Irish nationals living in England, such as Lewis, were exempt, but could choose to volunteer - as Lewis, of course, did.
Posts: 3355 | Registered: Jan 2011
| IP: Logged
|
|
Enoch
Shipmate
# 14322
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by Kaplan Corday:
The best biography of C.S. Lewis, Alan Jacobs's The Narnian, explicitly states that Irish nationals living in England, such as Lewis, were exempt, but could choose to volunteer - as Lewis, of course, did.
I'd query whether at that time the law recognised any concept of an Irish 'nationality'. It would be more likely to have depended on where a person normally lived. C S Lewis was studying in Surrey but domiciled in Belfast. A Scottish person resident in England doesn't get a vote in a Scottish election or referendum. An English person resident in Scotland, does.
--------------------
Brexit wrexit - Sir Graham Watson
Posts: 7610 | From: Bristol UK(was European Green Capital 2015, now Ljubljana) | Registered: Nov 2008
| IP: Logged
|
|
Kaplan Corday
Shipmate
# 16119
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by orfeo:
quote:
Originally posted by Kaplan Corday:
I can just about cope with anachronistic expressions such as "the Devil's in the detail", which I'm pretty sure has only been around for a few deades,
Why are you pretty sure of this, exactly?
Purely subjective, but when I just looked it up on Wikipedia, it suggested that the expression first appeared in print around 1975.
Posts: 3355 | Registered: Jan 2011
| IP: Logged
|
|
Grammatica
Shipmate
# 13248
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by Kaplan Corday:
quote:
Originally posted by orfeo:
quote:
Originally posted by Kaplan Corday:
I can just about cope with anachronistic expressions such as "the Devil's in the detail", which I'm pretty sure has only been around for a few deades,
Why are you pretty sure of this, exactly?
Purely subjective, but when I just looked it up on Wikipedia, it suggested that the expression first appeared in print around 1975.
It has been credited to Aby Warburg; if true, that would be another reason to suppose it was not current in the England of the time.
Posts: 1058 | From: where the lemon trees blosson | Registered: Dec 2007
| IP: Logged
|
|
Augustine the Aleut
Shipmate
# 1472
|
Posted
Kaplan Corday wrote:
quote:
Secondly, as officer and man, Matthew and William go swanning off around the countryside for several days on a patrol, in which they encounter a German patrol, despite the fact that this was impossible after the completion of the trench system in 1914; the only patrols were carried out at night, into no-man's-land, against the enemy trenches.
Not impossible. My grandfather received a commendation for a multi-day patrol in February, 1915, the beginning of a chain of circumstances which took him out of the front line to survive the war.
Posts: 6236 | From: Ottawa, Canada | Registered: Oct 2001
| IP: Logged
|
|
Zach82
Shipmate
# 3208
|
Posted
Solution to everyone's problems- invest in an Upstairs, Downstairs Complete Series DVD box set!
--------------------
Don't give up yet, no, don't ever quit/ There's always a chance of a critical hit. Ghost Mice
Posts: 9148 | From: Boston, MA | Registered: Aug 2002
| IP: Logged
|
|
PaulBC
Shipmate
# 13712
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by Enoch:
quote:
Originally posted by Kaplan Corday:
The best biography of C.S. Lewis, Alan Jacobs's The Narnian, explicitly states that Irish nationals living in England, such as Lewis, were exempt, but could choose to volunteer - as Lewis, of course, did.
I'd query whether at that time the law recognised any concept of an Irish 'nationality'. It would be more likely to have depended on where a person normally lived. C S Lewis was studying in Surrey but domiciled in Belfast. A Scottish person resident in England doesn't get a vote in a Scottish election or referendum. An English person resident in Scotland, does.
Ireland, all of it was a part of the UK , Southern Ireland as an seperate entity doesn't come into existance until 1921. Thus Irishmen were subject to conscription in WW I. ![[Votive]](graemlins/votive.gif) ![[Angel]](graemlins/angel.gif) ![[Smile]](smile.gif)
--------------------
"He has told you O mortal,what is good;and what does the Lord require of youbut to do justice and to love kindness ,and to walk humbly with your God."Micah 6:8
Posts: 873 | From: Victoria B.C. Canada | Registered: May 2008
| IP: Logged
|
|
Kaplan Corday
Shipmate
# 16119
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by PaulBC:
Ireland, all of it was a part of the UK , Southern Ireland as an seperate entity doesn't come into existance until 1921. Thus Irishmen were subject to conscription in WW I.
First sentence historically correct, second one historically wrong.
Posts: 3355 | Registered: Jan 2011
| IP: Logged
|
|
Kaplan Corday
Shipmate
# 16119
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by PaulBC:
Ireland, all of it was a part of the UK , Southern Ireland as an seperate entity doesn't come into existance until 1921. Thus Irishmen were subject to conscription in WW I.
First sentence historically correct, second one historically wrong.
Posts: 3355 | Registered: Jan 2011
| IP: Logged
|
|
Kaplan Corday
Shipmate
# 16119
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by Augustine the Aleut:
Kaplan Corday wrote:
quote:
Secondly, as officer and man, Matthew and William go swanning off around the countryside for several days on a patrol, in which they encounter a German patrol, despite the fact that this was impossible after the completion of the trench system in 1914; the only patrols were carried out at night, into no-man's-land, against the enemy trenches.
Not impossible. My grandfather received a commendation for a multi-day patrol in February, 1915, the beginning of a chain of circumstances which took him out of the front line to survive the war.
I'm sure I'm not the only one who would be fascinated to read a few more details.
Posts: 3355 | Registered: Jan 2011
| IP: Logged
|
|
Twilight
Puddleglum's sister
# 2832
|
Posted
The anachronisms bother me a little bit. The way Lord and Lady G treat Edith bothers me a lot. Still, I can't wait for Part 3.
Posts: 6817 | Registered: May 2002
| IP: Logged
|
|
Baptist Trainfan
Shipmate
# 15128
|
Posted
/slight tangent/
I remember going to see the film "Enigma" some years ago - it starred Kate Winslet and was set in WW2.
During the film she and her beloved drove up to Scotland on "unofficial leave". Virtually the whole cinema cried out, "How did they get the petrol coupons?"
Same film also had a post-1948 British Railways train (complete with BR number). At the risk of sounding nerdy, that's a common fault. Much worse (albeit in model form) on an otherwise brilliant BBC series about the Irish Troubles in the early 1920s.
/tangent ends/
Posts: 9750 | From: The other side of the Severn | Registered: Sep 2009
| IP: Logged
|
|
Sober Preacher's Kid
Presbymethegationalist
# 12699
|
Posted
The Irish Home Rule Bill, 1914 had been passed, but not implemented. It promised a Senate and House of Commons in Dublin, both of which had been dissolved in 1801, and it would have turned the Lord Lieutenant into an office like the Governors General in Canada and Australia; that is it would be ceremonial.
There would have been continued but much reduced Irish representation in Westminster.
It was delayed by the war and made irrelevant by the Easter Rising and the Irish Civil War. During that time The Connaught Rangers, a regular Irish regiment, mutinied while in India. The British saw it as writing on the wall, as they would with the later mutinies in the Indian Army and Navy in 1947.
--------------------
NDP Federal Convention Ottawa 2018: A random assortment of Prots and Trots.
Posts: 7646 | From: Peterborough, Upper Canada | Registered: Jun 2007
| IP: Logged
|
|
ken
Ship's Roundhead
# 2460
|
Posted
SPK and Kaplan are right. The UK government certainly believed itself legally entitled to conscript in Ireland, but chose not to.
Irish residents could volunteer, and many did, from all parts of Ireland. A larger proportion of loyslists than republicans, not surprisingly. It led to some extreme circumstances of divided loyalty - the strangest probably was Erskine Childers (an Englishman, not an Irishman) who simultaneously fought for the British against the Germans, while plotting with Germans to smuggle guns into Ireland to fight the British - and after the war was one of the chief diplomatic negotiators for the new Republic talking to Britain, even though he was a senior British civil servant, and later opposed the "Free State" treaty he had himself negotiated, fought for the IRA, and was shot by the Irish government.
In the Second World War, well after independence, many Irish citizens joined the British Army. (Some still do.) A few thousand Irish soldiers deserted their army to join the British. They are politically controversial in Ireland to this day.
--------------------
Ken
L’amor che move il sole e l’altre stelle.
Posts: 39579 | From: London | Registered: Mar 2002
| IP: Logged
|
|
Enoch
Shipmate
# 14322
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by Baptist Trainfan:
/slight tangent/
I remember going to see the film "Enigma" some years ago - it starred Kate Winslet and was set in WW2.
During the film she and her beloved drove up to Scotland on "unofficial leave". Virtually the whole cinema cried out, "How did they get the petrol coupons?"
Same film also had a post-1948 British Railways train (complete with BR number). At the risk of sounding nerdy, that's a common fault. Much worse (albeit in model form) on an otherwise brilliant BBC series about the Irish Troubles in the early 1920s.
/tangent ends/
I had a slightly similar experience in Out of Africa, except that it was only me that reacted. Robert Redford arrives in his aeroplane and snogs Meryl Streep passionately on the verandah. The rest of the cinema is thinking 'oh, how romantic' and I'm thinking 'not in front of the servants'. Even in the 'are you married or do you live in Kenya?' (pronounced Keenya) era they wouldn't have done that.
I'd love to see a film that seriously replicated the railways of 1920/1 Ireland. It would be just about impossible to get anywhere near the real thing. But I think Brief Encounter is spoilt by all the love interest.
--------------------
Brexit wrexit - Sir Graham Watson
Posts: 7610 | From: Bristol UK(was European Green Capital 2015, now Ljubljana) | Registered: Nov 2008
| IP: Logged
|
|
|
|
Sober Preacher's Kid
Presbymethegationalist
# 12699
|
Posted
On the tangent of other historical howlers, James Caan (an American) stars in the 1968 film Submarine X-1 which portrays the X-Craft raids on the Tirpitz in 1942. In order to fit his accent, they made him a Lt. Commander in the Royal Canadian Naval Volunteer Reserve, the "Wavy Navy". Thus he has the Canada title on shoulder, even though the RCN did not assign individual personnel to the RN like that.
The RCN crewed Canadian ships only, a policy dating back to 1910, the exceptions being the escort carriers Nabob and Puncher, which had British air groups and Canadian crews. These ships suffered from morale problems because Canadian sailors were paid much more than British ones, leading to lots of jealousy and fights below deck on pay days.
The movie was a case of trying to fit an American star into a British film topic by any means necessary.
Don't get me started on D-Day films.
--------------------
NDP Federal Convention Ottawa 2018: A random assortment of Prots and Trots.
Posts: 7646 | From: Peterborough, Upper Canada | Registered: Jun 2007
| IP: Logged
|
|
Sir Pellinore
Quester Emeritus
# 12163
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by Sober Preacher's Kid:
...
Don't get me started on D-Day films.
I'd be interested in your critique of "The Devil's Brigade" SPK.
--------------------
Well...
Posts: 5108 | From: The Deep North, Oz | Registered: Dec 2006
| IP: Logged
|
|
Og, King of Bashan
Ship's giant Amorite
# 9562
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by Baptist Trainfan:
/slight tangent/
I remember going to see the film "Enigma" some years ago - it starred Kate Winslet and was set in WW2.
During the film she and her beloved drove up to Scotland on "unofficial leave". Virtually the whole cinema cried out, "How did they get the petrol coupons?"
Same film also had a post-1948 British Railways train (complete with BR number). At the risk of sounding nerdy, that's a common fault. Much worse (albeit in model form) on an otherwise brilliant BBC series about the Irish Troubles in the early 1920s.
/tangent ends/
/further tangent/See, for me, when Ms. Winslet is on the screen, historical accuracy is generally taking a back seat to other thoughts. ![[Hot and Hormonal]](icon_redface.gif) /tangent ends/
--------------------
"I like to eat crawfish and drink beer. That's despair?" ― Walker Percy
Posts: 3259 | From: Denver, Colorado, USA | Registered: May 2005
| IP: Logged
|
|
Augustine the Aleut
Shipmate
# 1472
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by Kaplan Corday:
quote:
Originally posted by Augustine the Aleut:
Kaplan Corday wrote:
quote:
Secondly, as officer and man, Matthew and William go swanning off around the countryside for several days on a patrol, in which they encounter a German patrol, despite the fact that this was impossible after the completion of the trench system in 1914; the only patrols were carried out at night, into no-man's-land, against the enemy trenches.
Not impossible. My grandfather received a commendation for a multi-day patrol in February, 1915, the beginning of a chain of circumstances which took him out of the front line to survive the war.
I'm sure I'm not the only one who would be fascinated to read a few more details.
Not many details available, and I can delve into his journal to get the exact places etc-- the description is but a few lines. A longtime militiaman, recruited by Sir Henry Pellatt from his father's pharmacy (H Austin, 1486 Queen St West), he was one of the few in his regiment (Queen's Own Rifles of Canada) who marched out of Toronto in 1914 and were alive to march back in 1919. In a numbered battalion, he was in a detachment of a dozen sent out in Flanders in bad winter weather-- Canadians were deemed to be capable of walking in snow-- and came back four days later with 3 prisoners and lots of sketchmaps. Made corporal shortly afterward and, as a pharmacist, he was one of those who in the second battle of Ypres instructed troops to urinate into their handkerchiefs as a way of protecting themselves form chlorine gas. The Canadian line held as the Algerians broke and, recommended for a decoration (never awarded), they made him a sergeant and gas instructor.
As such, he made his way up the ladder to a commission and, after training US troops in gas warfare, found himself a captain in 1919. In 1922, he was permitted to accept a French decoration (médaille militaire) and, on his way to a Remembrance Day parade in 1936, was knocked over by a drunk driver and died later that day.
I have photographs of him and older relations (now passed away) who knew him tell me that I am his double.
Posts: 6236 | From: Ottawa, Canada | Registered: Oct 2001
| IP: Logged
|
|
Augustine the Aleut
Shipmate
# 1472
|
Posted
Enoch asks:
quote:
I'd love to see a film that seriously replicated the railways of 1920/1 Ireland. It would be just about impossible to get anywhere near the real thing. But I think Brief Encounter is spoilt by all the love interest.
Look at The Great Train Robbery (1979), starring Sir Sean Connery, Donald Sutherland, Lesley-Anne Down and (as an extra) Augustine the Aleut. While set in the 1860s, the Irish Railway Preservation Society set up the train for them. The current TEC Rector of Aiken SC, a notorious and scandalous train addict and historian, told me that this was exactly the equipment and set-up which operated in Ireland until WWII.
Posts: 6236 | From: Ottawa, Canada | Registered: Oct 2001
| IP: Logged
|
|
Sober Preacher's Kid
Presbymethegationalist
# 12699
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by Sir Pellinore (ret'd):
quote:
Originally posted by Sober Preacher's Kid:
...
Don't get me started on D-Day films.
I'd be interested in your critique of "The Devil's Brigade" SPK.
The Canadian accents are crap, except the Canadian martial arts instructor. They should have all spoken like him. In actual fact there was no bagpipe march into camp, beats me where such a unit would find a piper anyway. Canadian tartan-wearing regiments kept their pipers for themselves. You had to have a pre-war militia piper because pipers weren't trained during wartime.
The American volunteers were not that bad, in actual fact they were quite good. The Canadian Army still had a high reputation because it had been at war since 1939 and still maintained its all-volunteer status.
The unit itself was real, and was in fact a mixed unit. Other than the usual Hollywood theatrics it wasn't a total howler, but not without its problems and it isn't outstanding. The First Special Service Force was disbanded when it became clear it was simply turning into an American unit at American disposal. Most transferred into the 1st Canadian Parachute Battalion attached to the British 6th Airborne Division.
Portrayals of the Canadian Army in film fiction are very rare, There are a few low-budget CBC productions and glimpses in British or American productions. I look for them as a sport.
One of the best is [I]The One that Got Away[/I} about Franz von Werra. It is one of the only portrayals of a German PoW in Allied hands and what Allied POW practice was, and it accurately shows how Von Werra jumped the train at Brockville and escaped across the frozen St. Lawrence to a still-neutral United States. Astoundingly the film accurately shows an Ontario Provincial Police cruiser in correct colours with the name clearly visible on the side.
My problem with D-Day films is that they simply ignore Juno Beach and 3rd Canadian Division which landed there. My great-uncle was there. In film it is like this division, one fifth of the landing force, does not exist. Interestingly there were only two French-speaking units to land on D-Day. One was a Free French Commando, under the command of the British Army Commandos. The other was the Regiment de la Chaudiere, a Quebec-based regiment in the Canadian Army from Sherbrooke.
They landed mid-morning and some French civilians saw them in British-looking uniforms. "Hey Tommy". The reply came back that this was a French-speaking Canadian regiment. It caused the expected elation.
Four French-Canadian regiments saw combat in WWII: Le Royale 22mme Regiment, Les Regiments de la Chaudie, de la Maisonneuve and Les Fusiliers Mont-Royal.
--------------------
NDP Federal Convention Ottawa 2018: A random assortment of Prots and Trots.
Posts: 7646 | From: Peterborough, Upper Canada | Registered: Jun 2007
| IP: Logged
|
|
PD
Shipmate
# 12436
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by Augustine the Aleut:
Enoch asks:
quote:
I'd love to see a film that seriously replicated the railways of 1920/1 Ireland. It would be just about impossible to get anywhere near the real thing. But I think Brief Encounter is spoilt by all the love interest.
Look at The Great Train Robbery (1979), starring Sir Sean Connery, Donald Sutherland, Lesley-Anne Down and (as an extra) Augustine the Aleut. While set in the 1860s, the Irish Railway Preservation Society set up the train for them. The current TEC Rector of Aiken SC, a notorious and scandalous train addict and historian, told me that this was exactly the equipment and set-up which operated in Ireland until WWII.
Later than that actually. Wooden nodied and wooden framed four and six-wheelers were operating into the early 1950s on CIE. It was only with Bulleid's purchase off railcars from AEC in 1952 that decimated the ranks of the rigid framed passenger stock.
Liveries are the worst think to replicate with the Irish railway scene -especially the pre-grouping liveries of companies such as the Midland & Great Western which were not well documented. Even the largest company's (the Great Southern and Western) carriage livery arouses passionate debate. The consensus the "Irish mob" reached was that they used LNWR Purple Lake, but without the off-white upper panels. Great Southern Railways changed it livery several times 1925-34, but then settled down to LMS Crimson Lake. The locomotive livery was a very dark grey - a "colour" scheme adopted by the GSWR in 1918.
The commonest gaffe with railways is BR Mark 1 stock being used in films set anywhere from the 1920s to 1951. Unfortunately, the Mk 1 is fairly distinctive and. moreover does not closely resemble any pre-Nationalization type. The closest is possibly the LNER Thompson steel bodied stock, but it was only 7 years older than the BR Mk1 design.
PD
[ 26. June 2012, 01:00: Message edited by: PD ]
--------------------
Roadkill on the Information Super Highway!
My Assorted Rantings - http://www.theoldhighchurchman.blogspot.com
Posts: 4431 | From: Between a Rock and a Hard Place | Registered: Mar 2007
| IP: Logged
|
|
Kaplan Corday
Shipmate
# 16119
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by ken:
In the Second World War, well after independence, many Irish citizens joined the British Army. (Some still do.) A few thousand Irish soldiers deserted their army to join the British. They are politically controversial in Ireland to this day.
And at the end of the war, Eamon de Valera visited the German Embassy in Dublin to express his condolences on the death of Hitler.
Posts: 3355 | Registered: Jan 2011
| IP: Logged
|
|
Trudy Scrumptious
BBE Shieldmaiden
# 5647
|
Posted
I'm pretty sure "nitpicking about historical accuracy in TV shows and movies" falls under Heaven's remit rather than ours, so with the blessing of the Heavenly Host(s), I'm putting you all onboard a (very authentic) train to Heaven.
Trudy, Scrumptious Purgatory Host
--------------------
Books and things.
I lied. There are no things. Just books.
Posts: 7428 | From: Closer to Paris than I am to Vancouver | Registered: Mar 2004
| IP: Logged
|
|
Baptist Trainfan
Shipmate
# 15128
|
Posted
Oh yes, in "Downton" itself, a person in 1916 Yorkshire alights from a Metropolitan Railway train (how did it get there?) at a station painted in post-1923 Southern Railway green (Horsted Keynes).
Having said that, the general impression was fine. Anyway, "Downton" itself was in Gloucestershire (if that's where Highclere is).
Posts: 9750 | From: The other side of the Severn | Registered: Sep 2009
| IP: Logged
|
|
Trisagion
Shipmate
# 5235
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by Baptist Trainfan:
Anyway, "Downton" itself was in Gloucestershire (if that's where Highclere is).
Hampshire, actually (although it comes with a Reading postcode).
--------------------
ceterum autem censeo tabula delenda esse
Posts: 3923 | Registered: Nov 2003
| IP: Logged
|
|
Baptist Trainfan
Shipmate
# 15128
|
Posted
I never knew they'd moved it. That was clever. ![[Big Grin]](biggrin.gif)
Posts: 9750 | From: The other side of the Severn | Registered: Sep 2009
| IP: Logged
|
|
Kaplan Corday
Shipmate
# 16119
|
Posted
And another thing.
What connection does an architecturally eclectic retro confection, obviously built by a nouveau riche parvenu in the nineteenth century, have with an abbey?
Posts: 3355 | Registered: Jan 2011
| IP: Logged
|
|
Augustine the Aleut
Shipmate
# 1472
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by Kaplan Corday:
And another thing.
What connection does an architecturally eclectic retro confection, obviously built by a nouveau riche parvenu in the nineteenth century, have with an abbey?
One can hardly complain, as a Tudor-period nouveau riche parvenu likely built a manor house on the grounds of an abbey provided by (or purchased from) the King. There could be a few generations of country houses, given fires and/or money to build a newer version.
Posts: 6236 | From: Ottawa, Canada | Registered: Oct 2001
| IP: Logged
|
|
Albertus
Shipmate
# 13356
|
Posted
Well, quite possibly rebuilt on Abbey lands granted to some Tudor shyster at the Dissolution. cf Woburn, Fonthill, Wycombe, etc Abbeys.
(Cross-posted with Augustine the Aleut.)
[ 26. June 2012, 12:28: Message edited by: Albertus ]
--------------------
My beard is a testament to my masculinity and virility, and demonstrates that I am a real man. Trouble is, bits of quiche sometimes get caught in it.
Posts: 6498 | From: Y Sowth | Registered: Jan 2008
| IP: Logged
|
|
Jane R
Shipmate
# 331
|
Posted
quote:
Anyway, "Downton" itself was in Gloucestershire (if that's where Highclere is).
Depends whether you mean the real or fictional house - Highclere is in Hampshire, but "Downton" is supposed to be in North Yorkshire.
The very first sentence of the first episode of the first series was an anachronism - it's just possible that a respectable middle-aged postmistress would blaspheme upon receiving a telegram with tragic news in 1912, but very unlikely that she would say 'Oh my God!' - this is a modern expression.
I quite like the series, but was disappointed that the death toll among Lady Mary's suitors decreased in the second season (ironically during the First World War when you'd expect them to be dropping like flies).
Posts: 3958 | From: Jorvik | Registered: May 2001
| IP: Logged
|
|
ken
Ship's Roundhead
# 2460
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by Baptist Trainfan:
Oh yes, in "Downton" itself, a person in 1916 Yorkshire alights from a Metropolitan Railway train (how did it get there?) at a station painted in post-1923 Southern Railway green (Horsted Keynes).
Huh! That's nothing! The street scenes in Brief Encounter are clearly set in the South East of England, and pretty much all the characters use south-eastern accents (not just the posh ones), and there are hints that the coal mines they are talkng about are in the Kent coal field - but the railway station is plainly in the north-west at the other end of England and has signs for trains to Lancaster. I doubt if there were many direct services from Kent to Lancaster, even in 1938.
--------------------
Ken
L’amor che move il sole e l’altre stelle.
Posts: 39579 | From: London | Registered: Mar 2002
| IP: Logged
|
|
Albertus
Shipmate
# 13356
|
Posted
All true. But good reason for that: AIUI by that stage in the war it was considered safe to relax the blackout in order to film at night, under lights, in the north west, but still not in the south east. Hence choice of Carnforth rather than, say, Bromley South.
--------------------
My beard is a testament to my masculinity and virility, and demonstrates that I am a real man. Trouble is, bits of quiche sometimes get caught in it.
Posts: 6498 | From: Y Sowth | Registered: Jan 2008
| IP: Logged
|
|
St Everild
Shipmate
# 3626
|
Posted
/tangent/
There are some movies and TV shows set in Victorian times, where a troubled soul wanders into a deserted village church, sits down at the two manual organ and proceeds to play a fiendishly complicated piece on a thing that sounds like Westminster Abbey. And who exactly was pumping the bellows anyway?? Spoils it every time...
//tangent off//
Posts: 1782 | From: Bethnei | Registered: Dec 2002
| IP: Logged
|
|
Enoch
Shipmate
# 14322
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by Kaplan Corday:
quote:
Originally posted by ken:
In the Second World War, well after independence, many Irish citizens joined the British Army. (Some still do.) A few thousand Irish soldiers deserted their army to join the British. They are politically controversial in Ireland to this day.
And at the end of the war, Eamon de Valera visited the German Embassy in Dublin to express his condolences on the death of Hitler.
The latter remains controversial on this side of the Irish Sea to this day.
But to return to Downton, there was one piece of what looked like refreshing accuracy. At that era, several railway companies ran their own buses. If it was set in the North Riding, there's a bus which appears to be in North Eastern livery. I'm not sufficient of a nerd though to know whether it was a genuine North Eastern one or had been repainted to fit.
--------------------
Brexit wrexit - Sir Graham Watson
Posts: 7610 | From: Bristol UK(was European Green Capital 2015, now Ljubljana) | Registered: Nov 2008
| IP: Logged
|
|
Ariel
Shipmate
# 58
|
Posted
They take all sorts of liberties. Inspector Morse drove round Radcliffe Square (which is a cobbled square in the city centre that you can't actually drive round as it isn't open to traffic), making a casual remark to Sergeant Lewis which 2 seconds later was completed in the open countryside. He managed to bypass the entire city centre and all the notorious traffic jams to suddenly get 5 miles away. Pretty amazing car, that Bentley.
Posts: 25445 | Registered: May 2001
| IP: Logged
|
|
Kaplan Corday
Shipmate
# 16119
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by St Everild:
/tangent/
There are some movies and TV shows set in Victorian times, where a troubled soul wanders into a deserted village church, sits down at the two manual organ and proceeds to play a fiendishly complicated piece on a thing that sounds like Westminster Abbey. And who exactly was pumping the bellows anyway?? Spoils it every time...
//tangent off//
On a related theme, a year or two back I saw a television production of Hardy's Tess Of The D'Urbervilles, in which the congregation of a late nineteenth century Anglican village church were singing How Great Thou Art.
This hymn has Russian/Scandinavian origins, was not in Hymns Ancient And Modern, and only became popular when it was taken up by the Billy Graham people around the middle of the twentieth century.
Posts: 3355 | Registered: Jan 2011
| IP: Logged
|
|
busyknitter
Shipmate
# 2501
|
Posted
For anyone who is really interested, listen to this Slate Lexicon Valley podcast about computer analysis of TV scripts comparing them with actual writing from the period in which they were set.
The software writer has looked at Downton Abbey, Mad Men and a few others.
It seems that the writers tend to be far more accurate about some topics than others. The language used to describe technology is generally quite close to the language used at the time, except when it comes to telephony for some reason.
But on the other hand, the language used to describe war and experiences of war is very inaccurate. Also swearwords, mainly because they wouldn't have been written down much in 't old days.
[ 27. June 2012, 08:39: Message edited by: busyknitter ]
Posts: 903 | From: The Wool Basket | Registered: Mar 2002
| IP: Logged
|
|
Alaric the Goth
Shipmate
# 511
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by ken:
quote:
Originally posted by Baptist Trainfan:
Oh yes, in "Downton" itself, a person in 1916 Yorkshire alights from a Metropolitan Railway train (how did it get there?) at a station painted in post-1923 Southern Railway green (Horsted Keynes).
Huh! That's nothing! The street scenes in Brief Encounter are clearly set in the South East of England, and pretty much all the characters use south-eastern accents (not just the posh ones), and there are hints that the coal mines they are talkng about are in the Kent coal field - but the railway station is plainly in the north-west at the other end of England and has signs for trains to Lancaster. I doubt if there were many direct services from Kent to Lancaster, even in 1938.
The railway bits were filmed at Carnforth, the junction station north of Lancaster on the WCML. Unfortunately its main line platforms are now closed (1969 IIRC) but you can still catch a train to Barrow in Furness or Leeds, or going south, Lancaster/Morecambe from it.
Posts: 3322 | From: West Thriding | Registered: Jun 2001
| IP: Logged
|
|
ken
Ship's Roundhead
# 2460
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by Kaplan Corday:
On a related theme, a year or two back I saw a television production of Hardy's Tess Of The D'Urbervilles, in which the congregation of a late nineteenth century Anglican village church were singing How Great Thou Art.
The famous 1941 film of How Green Was My Valley (which beat both Citizen Kane and The Maltese Falcon at the Oscars - that was a good year for films!) has them singing Arglwydd, arwain trwy’r anialwch (AKA Guide Me, O Thou Great Jehovah) to Cwm Rhondda. The story is undated, but Queen Victoria is still on the throne when the main character has left school and worked a couple of years in the mines, so most of the action is probably meant to be in the 1880s or 1890s. The tune Cwm Rhondda was written in 1905 or maybe even later.
At the end they also use the tune to which we usually sing Here is love, vast as the ocean (another translation of a Welsh original) This is at least possible because the tune had been published but it didn't become well-known till the early 20th century. It is now, like Cwn Rhondda, the sort of thing you would put on a soundtrack to say "We are in Wales" but it would not have been back then.
--------------------
Ken
L’amor che move il sole e l’altre stelle.
Posts: 39579 | From: London | Registered: Mar 2002
| IP: Logged
|
|
BroJames
Shipmate
# 9636
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by Ariel:
Pretty amazing car, that Bentley.
And disguised to look exactly like a Jaguar ![[Biased]](wink.gif)
Posts: 3374 | From: UK | Registered: Jun 2005
| IP: Logged
|
|
Augustine the Aleut
Shipmate
# 1472
|
Posted
If SPK was has Rogers Cable coverage (priced by Vampires), he might have enjoyed the Purple Plain, set in Burma with Gregory Peck as RCAF S/L Bert Forrester DSO DFC. The Vancouver Island chapter of the Burma Star Association, which I think has now had its final meeting, comprised an odd collection of RCAF who served in Burma, a few remittance men, at least one member of the Gold Coast Division, and a posse of retired Sikhs who fleshed out to their pensions with a few hours a week with the Canadian Corps of Commissionaires (I did a ministerial briefing note on them about 20 years ago).
He had his Canada flashes on the usual RAF tropical kit, and spoke with a passible middle-upper anglophone accent, as one runs into with Bishop's University types of that period. Possibly because it was shot in 1954, the film avoids the styled haircuts of our era, which infest many WWII-period films.
Posts: 6236 | From: Ottawa, Canada | Registered: Oct 2001
| IP: Logged
|
|
Banner Lady
Ship's Ensign
# 10505
|
Posted
Oh, don't get me started on hairstyles and make-up - or even the way women comport themselves about on the sets. Almost every Shakespearean play put on to screen is guilty of some dreadful historical inaccuracies. But then, at its heart, its still fiction, ain't it?
As is Downton Abbey. The willing suspension of belief is expected of the viewer in order to just enjoy the story. I figure it's a bit like science fiction. You just enjoy the other-worldliness of it, because once you start to look hard, you find all sorts of holes.
--------------------
Women in the church are not a problem to be solved, but a mystery to be enjoyed.
Posts: 7080 | From: Canberra Australia | Registered: Oct 2005
| IP: Logged
|
|
Kaplan Corday
Shipmate
# 16119
|
Posted
I was also surprised at Daisy's uncovered hair at her deathbed marriage to William.
While not claiming any expertise in the areas of women's fashions and wedding etiquette, I am very aware of the general truth that people in the past were obsessive, to a degree which can seem to us fetishistic, about the necessity for headgear, especially in public, outdoors, or on formal occasions, and particularly in the case of women.
This point is ignored in countless film and television historical productions.
Wouldn't Daisy have been expected to wear a hat or veil for such a solemn ceremony?
Posts: 3355 | Registered: Jan 2011
| IP: Logged
|
|
Enoch
Shipmate
# 14322
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by Kaplan Corday:
Wouldn't Daisy have been expected to wear a hat or veil for such a solemn ceremony?
Probably. It was almost universal for women to cover their heads in church until well into my adolescence. It was also still fairly widespread for them to wear hats indoors, particularly when not in their own house. We were taught at primary school that a boy removed his hat indoors but a girl did not need to.
A woman would probably have worn a hat when visiting a hospital patient during the Great War. She would also have had a natural instinct to cover her head so as to 'church' even the unusual location. However, we also have to allow for the slight possibility that the writer or producer knew this and made the omission intentionally or instinctively so as to express the drama of the situation.
It would be interesting to know whether most of those women who got married in Registry Offices at that time wore hats to do so. I suspect they did.
I've a sort of recollection that the vicar in that scene wore a coloured stole - the wrong colour by modern standards - in that scene rather than a black scarf, and am not sure how likely that would have been before at least the 1930s in a rural parish dominated by a peer who was almost certainly the patron.
--------------------
Brexit wrexit - Sir Graham Watson
Posts: 7610 | From: Bristol UK(was European Green Capital 2015, now Ljubljana) | Registered: Nov 2008
| IP: Logged
|
|
Firenze
Ordinary decent pagan
# 619
|
Posted
quote:
Originally posted by Kaplan Corday:
I am very aware of the general truth that people in the past were obsessive, to a degree which can seem to us fetishistic, about the necessity for headgear
I remember some period enactment in which a gardener (possibly Capability Brown) is talking to his ducal employer, outdoors. Not only is the Duke not wearing a hat (on top of his admittedly OTT wig) but Brown keeps his on while addressing him.
Posts: 17302 | From: Edinburgh | Registered: Jun 2001
| IP: Logged
|
|
|
Printer-friendly view
