homepage
  roll on christmas  
click here to find out more about ship of fools click here to sign up for the ship of fools newsletter click here to support ship of fools
community the mystery worshipper gadgets for god caption competition foolishness features ship stuff
discussion boards live chat cafe avatars frequently-asked questions the ten commandments gallery private boards register for the boards
 
Ship of Fools


Post new thread  Post a reply
My profile login | | Directory | Search | FAQs | Board home
   - Printer-friendly view Next oldest thread   Next newest thread
» Ship of Fools   »   » Oblivion   » A challenge: how did you benefit from slavery? (Page 7)

 - Email this page to a friend or enemy.  
Pages in this thread: 1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9 
 
Source: (consider it) Thread: A challenge: how did you benefit from slavery?
Russ
Old salt
# 120

 - Posted      Profile for Russ   Author's homepage     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by Freddy:
If they did benefit then they are a beneficiary by definition.

That said, I can't imagine someone seeing themselves as a beneficiary of something like that.

I don't see anything implausible about the idea that someone whose great-grandfather had a really tough life might find themselves in a better situation as a result.

You are rightly distinguishing between thinking that such a statement is untrue - as a historical / economic proposition - and objecting to the emotional implications that might be read into a word like "beneficiary".

It's the proposition that we should feel some particular emotion - grateful, guilty, sorry, whatever - about events more than a lifetime ago that needs to be examined.

--------------------
Wish everyone well; the enemy is not people, the enemy is wrong ideas

Posts: 3169 | From: rural Ireland | Registered: May 2001  |  IP: Logged
Callan
Shipmate
# 525

 - Posted      Profile for Callan     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
I think what some of us are objecting to is the sleight of hand which says that if a number of disparate events happen sequentially, the first bad and a least some of the subsequent good, it is possible to claim that the persons concerned are beneficiaries of the first event. They are not. They are beneficiaries of the subsequent events.

--------------------
How easy it would be to live in England, if only one did not love her. - G.K. Chesterton

Posts: 9757 | From: Citizen of the World | Registered: Jun 2001  |  IP: Logged
Eliab
Shipmate
# 9153

 - Posted      Profile for Eliab   Email Eliab   Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by mdijon:
And I don't think it is relevant in terms of discussing the economic outcomes. The fact that if I hadn't been robbing the corner-shop I might have been engaged in much more fruitful industry and been better off and mixing with better society isn't relevant to discussing my gains from the robbery.

But the more abstract, indirect, and involuntary the 'benefit', the more natural it is to consider counterfactuals.

What's my gain from robbing the store? You can get that answer by counting the cash I stole. What I might have done instead (and deliberately chose not to do) is, as you say, irrelevant.

What's my gain from having a robber as a father? You can, indeed, perform a similar calculation and ask how much of the money he stole got spent on me and my upbringing. But it would not be unreasonable for me to point out that he contributed nothing for long periods while imprisoned or on the run, and despite the gains, I would, on the whole, have been better off as the son of an honest man.

What's my gain from robbery in society as a whole? Here it seems to me positively bizarre to count up how much cash I have only because someone far-removed from me in the chain of transactions once stole it, and not also consider the social costs to me that also result from such crimes. To get the full picture of what robbery as a social institution means to me, you really do need to conjecture some sort of alternative reality in which it is at least provisionally assumed that no one ever robbed anyone.


The problem with the "what's your benefit from slavery?" question is that the "compared to what?" supplemental question hasn't been answered, and there even seems to be an objection in principle to the idea of asking that.

I see the answer much as I would the general question about robbery. Yes, some of the cash in my wallet probably has been stolen before it came to me. Some of my ancestors possibly were robbers. The wealth of my country is to some significant extent built on stolen goods. But adding up my net personal gains, and weighing them against the social costs, I think that I'm a net loser from the institution of theft. I'd rather have been born in a world where stealing had not so much as been imagined.

Likewise slavery. Likewise racism. I didn't and don't benefit from it.

[ 28. July 2016, 12:27: Message edited by: Eliab ]

--------------------
"Perhaps there is poetic beauty in the abstract ideas of justice or fairness, but I doubt if many lawyers are moved by it"

Richard Dawkins

Posts: 4619 | From: Hampton, Middlesex, UK | Registered: Mar 2005  |  IP: Logged
lilBuddha
Shipmate
# 14333

 - Posted      Profile for lilBuddha     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by Marvin the Martian:
Part of the problem for me is that people are very happy to claim even tangential things as benefits white people have gained from slavery, while not accepting that black people have also benefitted from them.

Once again; black people do not benefit equally. Laws and practices were developed to specifically exclude them from doing so. More pronounced in the US, but not exclusive to them.

--------------------
I put on my rockin' shoes in the morning
Hallellou, hallellou

Posts: 17627 | From: the round earth's imagined corners | Registered: Dec 2008  |  IP: Logged
cliffdweller
Shipmate
# 13338

 - Posted      Profile for cliffdweller     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
apparently the myth of the benevolent slaveholder runs deep: plantation tour guide speaks out

--------------------
"Here is the world. Beautiful and terrible things will happen. Don't be afraid." -Frederick Buechner

Posts: 11242 | From: a small canyon overlooking the city | Registered: Jan 2008  |  IP: Logged
Marvin the Martian

Interplanetary
# 4360

 - Posted      Profile for Marvin the Martian     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by lilBuddha:
quote:
Originally posted by Marvin the Martian:
Part of the problem for me is that people are very happy to claim even tangential things as benefits white people have gained from slavery, while not accepting that black people have also benefitted from them.

Once again; black people do not benefit equally. Laws and practices were developed to specifically exclude them from doing so. More pronounced in the US, but not exclusive to them.
NOBODY benefits equally. Some have more, others have less.

To repeat what I said before: it's not as simple as saying white people have benefitted and black people haven't. There's a whole host of factors at play, and everyone in America, Britain, etc. has benefitted. I'll grant you that some have benefitted more and others less, but race is only one factor among many in determining who falls into which category, and any discussion about how to make our current society fairer that uses slavery to justify a starting point of "white = oppressor, black = victim" is missing several points.

--------------------
Hail Gallaxhar

Posts: 30100 | From: Adrift on a sea of surreality | Registered: Apr 2003  |  IP: Logged
lilBuddha
Shipmate
# 14333

 - Posted      Profile for lilBuddha     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by Marvin the Martian:
quote:
Originally posted by lilBuddha:
quote:
Originally posted by Marvin the Martian:
Part of the problem for me is that people are very happy to claim even tangential things as benefits white people have gained from slavery, while not accepting that black people have also benefitted from them.

Once again; black people do not benefit equally. Laws and practices were developed to specifically exclude them from doing so. More pronounced in the US, but not exclusive to them.
NOBODY benefits equally. Some have more, others have less.

To repeat what I said before: it's not as simple as saying white people have benefitted and black people haven't. There's a whole host of factors at play, and everyone in America, Britain, etc. has benefitted. I'll grant you that some have benefitted more and others less, but race is only one factor among many in determining who falls into which category, and any discussion about how to make our current society fairer that uses slavery to justify a starting point of "white = oppressor, black = victim" is missing several points.

I understand that you think that what you are saying is reasonable, but it is also bullshit.
No one is saying that only black people have any disadvantage or that race is the only disadvantage one can have. What is being said is that being black is an intensifier to every other disadvantage. Take Stephen Frye. Would anyone doubt that he is British? Or even, English, the most quintessential element of Britishness. And yet one side of his family has only been in the UK since the mid-20 Century and the other for barely 200 years.
Many Brits of Afro-Carib descent have a UK white parent, some of whose families have been on the bloody island for more than a thousand years. Who do you think is considered more British? Who do you think, everything else being equal, will have more disadvantage? This, in countries built on brown backs, is what we are discussing.
"Wah, everybody suffers" is willfully ignorant at best.

--------------------
I put on my rockin' shoes in the morning
Hallellou, hallellou

Posts: 17627 | From: the round earth's imagined corners | Registered: Dec 2008  |  IP: Logged
SvitlanaV2
Shipmate
# 16967

 - Posted      Profile for SvitlanaV2   Email SvitlanaV2   Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by Marvin the Martian:
quote:
Originally posted by lilBuddha:
quote:
Originally posted by Marvin the Martian:
Part of the problem for me is that people are very happy to claim even tangential things as benefits white people have gained from slavery, while not accepting that black people have also benefitted from them.

Once again; black people do not benefit equally. Laws and practices were developed to specifically exclude them from doing so. More pronounced in the US, but not exclusive to them.
NOBODY benefits equally. Some have more, others have less.

To repeat what I said before: it's not as simple as saying white people have benefitted and black people haven't. There's a whole host of factors at play, and everyone in America, Britain, etc. has benefitted. I'll grant you that some have benefitted more and others less, but race is only one factor among many in determining who falls into which category, and any discussion about how to make our current society fairer that uses slavery to justify a starting point of "white = oppressor, black = victim" is missing several points.

I think the problem is that race frequently impacts on and even overrides class (which is probably what you're hinting at). For people of colour, it's not straightforward to separate the two.

For example, in the Americas, middle class black people are frequently those who come from relatively light-skinned (i.e. noticeably mixed) families. This is not a coincidence. Yes, there's less 'shadism' now (although the canny can still spot it), but it has left its mark.

Black people are not 'victims', destined to be blown about by the vagaries of life. But for them, in a 'white' society, success is far less likely to be down to 'social capital' inherited smoothly from one generation to another. Even black children with qualifications and from middle class families may find themselves (as some research shows) less successful at 'getting on' than their white middle class counterparts. Skin colour can still be an unspoken factor in social acceptance, and career progress.

There are indeed internal barriers which seriously need to be addressed (and every black parent ought to address them explicitly as they raise their children) but the point is that those internal barriers, like the external ones, come from somewhere. They have currency for historical reasons.

Posts: 6668 | From: UK | Registered: Feb 2012  |  IP: Logged
Marvin the Martian

Interplanetary
# 4360

 - Posted      Profile for Marvin the Martian     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by lilBuddha:
No one is saying that only black people have any disadvantage or that race is the only disadvantage one can have.

Could have fooled me.

quote:
What is being said is that being black is an intensifier to every other disadvantage.
All disadvantages intensify each other.

quote:
Who do you think is considered more British?
By whom?

quote:
Who do you think, everything else being equal, will have more disadvantage?
"Everything else being equal", you could say the same for any disadvantage. That's what "everything else being equal" means.

[edited coz iPads are hard to type UBB code on]

[ 28. July 2016, 21:27: Message edited by: Marvin the Martian ]

--------------------
Hail Gallaxhar

Posts: 30100 | From: Adrift on a sea of surreality | Registered: Apr 2003  |  IP: Logged
lilBuddha
Shipmate
# 14333

 - Posted      Profile for lilBuddha     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by Marvin the Martian:
quote:
Originally posted by lilBuddha:
No one is saying that only black people have any disadvantage or that race is the only disadvantage one can have.

Could have fooled me.
The deception you feel may come from a more proximate source than you imagine.

quote:

quote:
What is being said is that being black is an intensifier to every other disadvantage.
All disadvantages intensify each other.
I've enough interaction with you to refuse to believe you as stupid as this statement is.
If all things are the same, save race, the darker skinned person will face greater adversity.
quote:

quote:
Who do you think is considered more British?
By whom?
I've never seen, nor heard of, a white, UK born person being told to "go back where they came from" or being called a "bloody foreigner" just on the basis of appearance. Definitely happens to tan, brown and black UK born.

--------------------
I put on my rockin' shoes in the morning
Hallellou, hallellou

Posts: 17627 | From: the round earth's imagined corners | Registered: Dec 2008  |  IP: Logged
Kaplan Corday
Shipmate
# 16119

 - Posted      Profile for Kaplan Corday         Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by mdijon:
The accidental murder of some Jews while others escaped?

No, the very deliberate (certainly after the 1942 Wannsee Coference, at any rate) attempt to murder all Jews, while others escaped, some as a result of accidents of luck.
Posts: 3355 | Registered: Jan 2011  |  IP: Logged
Kaplan Corday
Shipmate
# 16119

 - Posted      Profile for Kaplan Corday         Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by Golden Key:
You don't think that my description of slavery as an "obscenity" might just possibly have implied as much?

Not when you keep saying that people are better off because it happened.

The fact that the African-American descendants of transported slaves are generally better off than the descendants of those who were not transported does not make one iota of difference to the fact that the original slave trade was obscene.

You are clutching at straws.

Posts: 3355 | Registered: Jan 2011  |  IP: Logged
mdijon
Shipmate
# 8520

 - Posted      Profile for mdijon     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by Eliab:
What's my gain from robbery in society as a whole?...

Likewise slavery. Likewise racism. I didn't and don't benefit from it.

Imagine that the robbery was committed by one group on another group in a sustained and systematic manner. And that I bear an external mark which indicates some relationship with the group that were robbed. And that this external mark continues to be a stigmatizing sign and to disadvantage me.

How can someone in the group that is not stigmatized say there is no benefit to them? I don't know how many jobs I've missed out on because of colour and you don't know which you have got because of colour. But the law of averages says there have been some. We could say the same about police stops, friendships, access to social groupings. You might not personally be responsible for any racism, there may be no need to feel guilt or any particular emotion, but to deny the benefits of privilege seems unsustainable to me.

--------------------
mdijon nojidm uoɿıqɯ ɯqıɿou
ɯqıɿou uoɿıqɯ nojidm mdijon

Posts: 12277 | From: UK | Registered: Sep 2004  |  IP: Logged
mdijon
Shipmate
# 8520

 - Posted      Profile for mdijon     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by mdijon:
The accidental murder of some Jews while others escaped?

quote:
Originally posted by Kaplan Corday:
No, the very deliberate (certainly after the 1942 Wannsee Coference, at any rate) attempt to murder all Jews, while others escaped, some as a result of accidents of luck.

That's certainly more carefully worded than "...an accidental process whereby some Africans were transported and others were not".

[ 29. July 2016, 06:51: Message edited by: mdijon ]

--------------------
mdijon nojidm uoɿıqɯ ɯqıɿou
ɯqıɿou uoɿıqɯ nojidm mdijon

Posts: 12277 | From: UK | Registered: Sep 2004  |  IP: Logged
Russ
Old salt
# 120

 - Posted      Profile for Russ   Author's homepage     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by Callan:
I think what some of us are objecting to is the sleight of hand which says that if a number of disparate events happen sequentially, the first bad and a least some of the subsequent good, it is possible to claim that the persons concerned are beneficiaries of the first event. They are not. They are beneficiaries of the subsequent events.

The main difficulty here is establishing clear cause-and-effect relationships. Which events were caused by slavery and which would have happened anyway ?

One approach is cross-sectional comparison. If we"re saying that race-based slavery is something unique to the USA, then things that are common between the USA and other countries cannot have been caused by slavery.

So for example any likeness between Ferguson-style policing and policing in other countries is not an effect of slavery.

The other difficulty seems to me to be confusion between benefiting from an event - assessed by a comparison against counterfactual which has no moral implications - and choosing to collude in or being an accessory to an event, which takes upon oneself some of the moral responsibility for that event.

--------------------
Wish everyone well; the enemy is not people, the enemy is wrong ideas

Posts: 3169 | From: rural Ireland | Registered: May 2001  |  IP: Logged
mdijon
Shipmate
# 8520

 - Posted      Profile for mdijon     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
I understand that in law the liability for damages is assessed partly in terms of foreseeablity.

For instance if you make a bicycle with brakes that don't work and I go into a truck then that is foreseeable and you are liable for my injuries. If on the other hand the accident delays my travel and I end up missing a train and being mugged hanging the station looking for another train then that isn't foreseeable and it doesn't count for assessing damages.

Maybe we should attach a similar concept to benefits, particularly at a population level. Chaos theory applied to social science presumably leads to all manner of unpredictable unassessable consequences, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't look at the foreseeable consequences.

--------------------
mdijon nojidm uoɿıqɯ ɯqıɿou
ɯqıɿou uoɿıqɯ nojidm mdijon

Posts: 12277 | From: UK | Registered: Sep 2004  |  IP: Logged
SvitlanaV2
Shipmate
# 16967

 - Posted      Profile for SvitlanaV2   Email SvitlanaV2   Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by Russ:
quote:
Originally posted by Callan:
I think what some of us are objecting to is the sleight of hand which says that if a number of disparate events happen sequentially, the first bad and a least some of the subsequent good, it is possible to claim that the persons concerned are beneficiaries of the first event. They are not. They are beneficiaries of the subsequent events.

The main difficulty here is establishing clear cause-and-effect relationships. Which events were caused by slavery and which would have happened anyway ?

One approach is cross-sectional comparison. If we"re saying that race-based slavery is something unique to the USA, then things that are common between the USA and other countries cannot have been caused by slavery.

Race-based slavery happened throughout the Americas, not just the USA, and one can see racial, social and cultural commonalities in all of those societies - certainly as far as the descendants of slaves are concerned.

There are also differences, naturally, depending on how slavery was implemented, whether there were large numbers of white settlers and/or indigenous inhabitants, the laws governing the interaction between black and white, the religions involved, etc.

Posts: 6668 | From: UK | Registered: Feb 2012  |  IP: Logged
Marvin the Martian

Interplanetary
# 4360

 - Posted      Profile for Marvin the Martian     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by lilBuddha:
quote:

quote:
What is being said is that being black is an intensifier to every other disadvantage.
All disadvantages intensify each other.
I've enough interaction with you to refuse to believe you as stupid as this statement is.
If all things are the same, save race, the darker skinned person will face greater adversity.

That is true. But as I said before: "everything else being equal", you could say the same for any disadvantage. That's what "everything else being equal" means.

If all things are the same, save wealth, the poorer person will face greater adversity.

If all things are the same, save gender, the woman will face greater adversity.

If all things are the same, save social class, the lower-class person will face greater adversity.

I could go on, but you get the point. Do you disagree with any of those statements? If not, then what exactly is so stupid about my original statement?

quote:
quote:

quote:
Who do you think is considered more British?
By whom?
I've never seen, nor heard of, a white, UK born person being told to "go back where they came from" or being called a "bloody foreigner" just on the basis of appearance. Definitely happens to tan, brown and black UK born.
So your answer to "by whom" is "racists"? I can't argue against that, but I thought you were making a more general point about Britishness.

--------------------
Hail Gallaxhar

Posts: 30100 | From: Adrift on a sea of surreality | Registered: Apr 2003  |  IP: Logged
Pottage
Shipmate
# 9529

 - Posted      Profile for Pottage   Email Pottage   Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by mdijon:
I understand that in law the liability for damages is assessed partly in terms of foreseeablity.

For instance if you make a bicycle with brakes that don't work and I go into a truck then that is foreseeable and you are liable for my injuries. If on the other hand the accident delays my travel and I end up missing a train and being mugged hanging the station looking for another train then that isn't foreseeable and it doesn't count for assessing damages.

Maybe we should attach a similar concept to benefits, particularly at a population level. Chaos theory applied to social science presumably leads to all manner of unpredictable unassessable consequences, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't look at the foreseeable consequences.

Yes, that's a fair analogy and the underlying principles of that - the sheer remoteness of the loss from the first person's fault - is one of the reasons why it is difficult to identify what the cost of the slave trade has been to remote descendants of slaves alive now. There are similar legal principles around the involvement of a new cause of loss, a new act intervening in the sequence of events which reduces or overwhelms the extent to which the person initially responsible for the first wrongful act can fairly be held responsible for all events which follow. In 200+ years a lot of subsequent events interfere with the sequence of events.

This is one reason why it is relatively uncontentious for Germany to agree to pay compensation to individual victims of the Holocaust and their immediate next of kin, but raises many issues of fairness and justice for modern day Portugal to be asked to compensate modern day Brazilians for the wickedness inflicted on Africans trafficked from the Kingdom of Kongo in the sixteenth century to a place that later became Brazil.

Posts: 701 | From: middle England | Registered: May 2005  |  IP: Logged
mdijon
Shipmate
# 8520

 - Posted      Profile for mdijon     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by Pottage:
...and the underlying principles of that - the sheer remoteness of the loss from the first person's fault - is one of the reasons why it is difficult to identify what the cost of the slave trade has been to remote descendants of slaves alive now.

I don't think remoteness is the principle, rather foreseeability is. Although there's a correlation something could be very remote but foreseeable (i.e. the painting your great-grandfather stole from my great-grandfather is still in your possession - remote but foreseeable) or very proximate but not foreseeable (e.g. the day after the painting was stolen my great-grandfather's wife flew into a rage at his carelessness and divorced him).

Likewise if you take human labour worth billions of dollars away from a nation it is entirely foreseeable that there is a loss. The difficulty here though becomes identifying what the nation states involved are, who the most deserving population might be and who the complicit parties are.

--------------------
mdijon nojidm uoɿıqɯ ɯqıɿou
ɯqıɿou uoɿıqɯ nojidm mdijon

Posts: 12277 | From: UK | Registered: Sep 2004  |  IP: Logged
lilBuddha
Shipmate
# 14333

 - Posted      Profile for lilBuddha     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by Marvin the Martian:

I could go on, but you get the point. Do you disagree with any of those statements? If not, then what exactly is so stupid about my original statement?

As hard as conservatives are trying to make it, the possibility of changing one's level of wealth exists. Gender does come closer, but that is changing rapidly.
Analogies are difficult and I must admit to being a bit nonplussed at the moment.
Assuming sincerity in your argument, I wish to express my point in the most edifying manner possible, but cannot at the moment. Frustration and incredulity cloud my mind.
One thing that does come to mind is the wage gap. White workers with the same qualifications will get better jobs, and receive better pay, than black people. Again, gender is the only thing that comes close, but black women will have less opportunity than white women.

quote:
So your answer to "by whom" is "racists"? I can't argue against that, but I thought you were making a more general point about Britishness.
I am. Well, perceived Britishness, anyway. NOt going to go into a definition of racism tangent. But there is also the near mythical people who dislike immigrants of any stripe. Children of white immigrants blend better than those of colour.
Type "Quintessential Briton" into a search engine and it is a long way to brown. Even for those who truly accept anyone born in the UK as British, melanin doesn't come to mind equally.

--------------------
I put on my rockin' shoes in the morning
Hallellou, hallellou

Posts: 17627 | From: the round earth's imagined corners | Registered: Dec 2008  |  IP: Logged
cliffdweller
Shipmate
# 13338

 - Posted      Profile for cliffdweller     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by lilBuddha:
I've never seen, nor heard of, a white, UK born person being told to "go back where they came from" or being called a "bloody foreigner" just on the basis of appearance. Definitely happens to tan, brown and black UK born.

And then, on the other side of the pond, there's the whole birther movement... of which Trump was a ringleader.

--------------------
"Here is the world. Beautiful and terrible things will happen. Don't be afraid." -Frederick Buechner

Posts: 11242 | From: a small canyon overlooking the city | Registered: Jan 2008  |  IP: Logged
Pottage
Shipmate
# 9529

 - Posted      Profile for Pottage   Email Pottage   Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by mdijon:
I don't think remoteness is the principle, rather foreseeability is. Although there's a correlation something could be very remote but foreseeable (i.e. the painting your great-grandfather stole from my great-grandfather is still in your possession - remote but foreseeable) or very proximate but not foreseeable (e.g. the day after the painting was stolen my great-grandfather's wife flew into a rage at his carelessness and divorced him).

Likewise if you take human labour worth billions of dollars away from a nation it is entirely foreseeable that there is a loss. The difficulty here though becomes identifying what the nation states involved are, who the most deserving population might be and who the complicit parties are.

I don't think you can divorce remoteness from the equation though. Certainly if you take human labour with a value of billions of dollars away from one part of the world then in the following generation or two there will be a deficit in that place that can be directly attributed to the absence of that labour. Move on another ten generations though, with the intervening years affected by wars, famines, disease, migration and so forth, and it becomes much harder to see what current deficits affecting that place still flow from that original wrongful act.

And, as you say, even if you accept that some part of the deficits affecting that place now must necessarily still be attributable to that wrong, albeit that you can't really measure it, what do you do about that? Who is responsible now for these ancient wrongs? Who should be recompensed? How should that be calculated?

Posts: 701 | From: middle England | Registered: May 2005  |  IP: Logged
mdijon
Shipmate
# 8520

 - Posted      Profile for mdijon     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by Pottage:
...Move on another ten generations though, with the intervening years affected by wars, famines, disease, migration and so forth, and it becomes much harder to see what current deficits affecting that place still flow from that original wrongful act.

Slavery in the US ended in 1865. That's 6 generations. Difficult to know where to draw the line, but with the stolen painting example how many generations down would you say the robber's family don't have to give it back?

This is a question for all those artifacts in British museums from Egypt, Greece, South America and all over the world. Should they be returned or was it too long ago and possession has been transferred?

It's quite a perverse incentive for just kicking the discussion along really.

--------------------
mdijon nojidm uoɿıqɯ ɯqıɿou
ɯqıɿou uoɿıqɯ nojidm mdijon

Posts: 12277 | From: UK | Registered: Sep 2004  |  IP: Logged
Marvin the Martian

Interplanetary
# 4360

 - Posted      Profile for Marvin the Martian     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by lilBuddha:
Gender does come closer, but that is changing rapidly.

Race is changing too. Not as quickly as I'd like, and with further to go, but it is changing.

quote:
Analogies are difficult and I must admit to being a bit nonplussed at the moment.
Assuming sincerity in your argument, I wish to express my point in the most edifying manner possible, but cannot at the moment. Frustration and incredulity cloud my mind.

For one thing, I'm not using analogies. Nor, for that matter, am I disagreeing with you that race is still, despite the best efforts of decent human beings, a disadvantage. I'm just disagreeing with the suggestion that race is such a disadvantage that it always outweighs any other advantage/disadvantage someone may have.

quote:
One thing that does come to mind is the wage gap. White workers with the same qualifications will get better jobs, and receive better pay, than black people. Again, gender is the only thing that comes close, but black women will have less opportunity than white women.
Do you think you're disagreeing with anything I've written here?

quote:
I am. Well, perceived Britishness, anyway. NOt going to go into a definition of racism tangent. But there is also the near mythical people who dislike immigrants of any stripe. Children of white immigrants blend better than those of colour.
Type "Quintessential Briton" into a search engine and it is a long way to brown. Even for those who truly accept anyone born in the UK as British, melanin doesn't come to mind equally.

Speaking only for myself, I could make a pretty long list of the traits that make a "quintessential Briton" before skin colour featured at all. If it featured at all.

--------------------
Hail Gallaxhar

Posts: 30100 | From: Adrift on a sea of surreality | Registered: Apr 2003  |  IP: Logged
mdijon
Shipmate
# 8520

 - Posted      Profile for mdijon     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
Love of cricket*, beer and chicken tikka masala seem to be the key boxes to tick.

* need to support the right side though.

--------------------
mdijon nojidm uoɿıqɯ ɯqıɿou
ɯqıɿou uoɿıqɯ nojidm mdijon

Posts: 12277 | From: UK | Registered: Sep 2004  |  IP: Logged
Pottage
Shipmate
# 9529

 - Posted      Profile for Pottage   Email Pottage   Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by mdijon:
Slavery in the US ended in 1865. That's 6 generations. Difficult to know where to draw the line, but with the stolen painting example how many generations down would you say the robber's family don't have to give it back?

This is a question for all those artifacts in British museums from Egypt, Greece, South America and all over the world. Should they be returned or was it too long ago and possession has been transferred?

It's quite a perverse incentive for just kicking the discussion along really.

We were talking about the deficit in Africa arising from the abduction of the slaves, which stopped in 1807. A large number of those taken as slaves had been trafficked across the Atlantic as much as 200 years earlier than that.

The stolen painting is a poor analogy for these purposes. Even 20 generations later it may still be able to be returned as recompense if a rightful heir could be identified.

It's not really a question of whether the wrong was done 2 generations ago or 10. What is relevant is whether you can do anything about it, and in most circumstances (other than those involving a specific identifiable stolen item that isn't perishable) the practicality of putting right that wrong diminishes over time.

In the case we are considering here, nobody is arguing that the Atlantic slave trade was anything other than a shocking crime, an obscenity. The guilt of those who did this is accepted without quibble. But aside from acknowledging this, what in practice can you do about it which doesn't involve perpetrating modern injustices?

Posts: 701 | From: middle England | Registered: May 2005  |  IP: Logged
Crœsos
Shipmate
# 238

 - Posted      Profile for Crœsos     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by lilBuddha:
I am. Well, perceived Britishness, anyway. NOt going to go into a definition of racism tangent. But there is also the near mythical people who dislike immigrants of any stripe. Children of white immigrants blend better than those of colour.
Type "Quintessential Briton" into a search engine and it is a long way to brown. Even for those who truly accept anyone born in the UK as British, melanin doesn't come to mind equally.

This interview [warning: video auto-play] seems a good illustration of this phenomenon.

Longer, written analysis here.

--------------------
Humani nil a me alienum puto

Posts: 10706 | From: Sardis, Lydia | Registered: May 2001  |  IP: Logged
mdijon
Shipmate
# 8520

 - Posted      Profile for mdijon     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
One thing at a time. My point was to say that remoteness by itself wasn't an issue here. I agree there are some practical difficulties to address, but first off is the desirability of doing something about it.

--------------------
mdijon nojidm uoɿıqɯ ɯqıɿou
ɯqıɿou uoɿıqɯ nojidm mdijon

Posts: 12277 | From: UK | Registered: Sep 2004  |  IP: Logged
cliffdweller
Shipmate
# 13338

 - Posted      Profile for cliffdweller     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
I think the practical difficulties is what is hampering progress in the discussion of race and privilege. Because, consciously or unconsciously when we start talking about the benefits white Americans or Europeans still receive from past slavery our minds immediately leap ahead (as we've seen on this thread) to the question "how could we ever repay such a debt/right such a wrong?" But the answer is too daunting to consider, but so is the notion of leaving the debt unpaid. So we rationalize it away because to do otherwise is far too uncomfortable

--------------------
"Here is the world. Beautiful and terrible things will happen. Don't be afraid." -Frederick Buechner

Posts: 11242 | From: a small canyon overlooking the city | Registered: Jan 2008  |  IP: Logged
Eliab
Shipmate
# 9153

 - Posted      Profile for Eliab   Email Eliab   Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by mdijon:
How can someone in the group that is not stigmatized say there is no benefit to them?

I'm trying to approach this with caution because "You are arguing with mdijon about race" is really very high up on my personal list headed "Signs that you are probably wrong", but I honestly don't get that.

Unless you're starting from the assumption that we begin life as personal rivals, how do I benefit from you being stigmatised? I like a lot more people than I hate, so having a characteristic that functions as an entirely arbitrary social disadvantage is going to hurt more people who I might be persuaded to care about than it will people who might become my enemies. Unless and until life brings us into direct conflict, I find it very easy to wish you well and desire your prosperity. I gain nothing from your ambitions being frustrated until I have a rational cause to dislike you.

So I can see the disadvantage to you from racial prejudice. I completely fail to see the benefit to me.

quote:
I don't know how many jobs I've missed out on because of colour and you don't know which you have got because of colour. But the law of averages says there have been some. We could say the same about police stops, friendships, access to social groupings. You might not personally be responsible for any racism, there may be no need to feel guilt or any particular emotion, but to deny the benefits of privilege seems unsustainable to me.
Trying to unpick that a bit, yes, OK, if I got a job because racial prejudice helped clear the field, then that is an advantage I got from racism. I'm not arguing with that.

But that's only half of the balance sheet. The rest of your post gives the other side. There are, from a quick google, about 2 million people in Britain (2011 census) identifying as "Black". Is it good for me that 2 million of the citizens of my country aren't given a fair scope to develop their talents? Obviously not. That will make my country less prosperous. I could easily be selfish enough to want every transaction involving me to be grossly unjust in my favour, but I want every other employment decision in the world to be fair, because it benefits me when the people I deal with are as competent as possible.

Is it good for me that 2 million of my neighbours get harassed by the police and consequently, many of them will view the police with suspicion? No. That clearly makes me less safe. I want the police to be impartial, and (deservedly) trusted.

Is it good for me that 2 million Britons are discouraged from socialising with me, are tempted to view me as at least a potential racist and adversary, and are people whom I might be tempted to see as marginalised, and therefore threatening? No. That's quite blatantly a shit way to organise a society.

Obviously it would be daft for me to claim that I'm as much of a victim of racism as some who could from personal experience multiple that list of disadvantages many times, but nonetheless it is true that racism works overall to my disadvantage. I don't even need to add that it's morally wrong. I can be as self-interested as all hell, and racism still acts against my best interests as a comfortable middle-class white guy. Therefore it probably works against everyone's best interests.


When talking about benefits, are we giving different answers to the "Compared to what?" question?

I'd agree, of course that in a racist society, whites will be "better off", considered as a class, compared to notionally-equivalent-in-all-other-respects blacks. But it is also true, that whites in a racist society are as a class "worse off" compared to white (or black, because it wouldn't matter) people in a notionally-equivalent-in-all-other-respects non-racist society. Racism hurts me compared to non-racism. It hurts other people much worse, but that is not enough to make it an net benefit to me.

In that sense, it's like any other targeted disadvantage. Afflictions like cervical cancer, sickle-cell anaemia, and (in the UK at least) HIV disproportionately affect certain demographic groups, which I happen not to be in. I have the advantage, compared to those groups, of a much reduced risk of those conditions. But its not really an "advantage" in absolute terms. I'd much rather those conditions didn't exist. It is much more likely - overwhelmingly so - that they will hurt people I care about, and that they will damage my society, than that I will ever be a net beneficiary of them. Clearly I'm not a "victim" of any of those illnesses in anything like the same way as someone who actually has the condition, but they still, overall, make me worse off than I would be in a world in which they had been completely cured.

Racism's like that, isn't it? Even though I'm in the group least hurt by it, it's still bad for me, and it would still be in my selfish best interests to eradicate it if I could.

--------------------
"Perhaps there is poetic beauty in the abstract ideas of justice or fairness, but I doubt if many lawyers are moved by it"

Richard Dawkins

Posts: 4619 | From: Hampton, Middlesex, UK | Registered: Mar 2005  |  IP: Logged
mdijon
Shipmate
# 8520

 - Posted      Profile for mdijon     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
The problem with my argument Eliab is that you are just too far gone in enlightened self-interest. If one is aware as much of the indirect harm to one's own existence as a result of dysfunctionality in society then I think that clinches it and there is little to be gained by looking at the direct benefits.

However the indirect benefits of a non-racist society are much harder to quantify than the direct benefits of the privileged group. In a zero-sum world there are x jobs available and therefore white applicants have a benefit as a result of racism. Arguably a non-racist society would have everyone richer and, as you say, the comparison should be whites in non-racist vs whites in racist society.

I'm sure I remember reading that some in the American North argued slavery was detrimental to society in producing a work-force orientated around unskilled, untrained and oppressed workers with violent oppression as a primary output of the more "skilled" workers. A society with waged workers with the motivation to progress was a healthier model. Hence the prediction was that the North would industrialize and develop but the South would stagnate.

I certainly want to believe all that about the indirect effects, but it is very hard to prove and even harder to quantify. Whereas the direct effects are more tangible and easier to describe.

A more complete statement of the problem might be to say that a member of the privileged group benefits in the here-and-now zero-sum world, albeit at the expense of being in a dysfunctional and impoverished society which, the more enlightened they are, eclipses any selfish zero-sum benefit.

It's a tricky point to balance though, especially when talk to a member of the discriminated-against group in direct response to a statement regarding the direct benefits. It doesn't really fit in 140 characters.

--------------------
mdijon nojidm uoɿıqɯ ɯqıɿou
ɯqıɿou uoɿıqɯ nojidm mdijon

Posts: 12277 | From: UK | Registered: Sep 2004  |  IP: Logged
cliffdweller
Shipmate
# 13338

 - Posted      Profile for cliffdweller     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by mdijon:
I'm sure I remember reading that some in the American North argued slavery was detrimental to society in producing a work-force orientated around unskilled, untrained and oppressed workers with violent oppression as a primary output of the more "skilled" workers. A society with waged workers with the motivation to progress was a healthier model. Hence the prediction was that the North would industrialize and develop but the South would stagnate.

I certainly want to believe all that about the indirect effects, but it is very hard to prove and even harder to quantify. Whereas the direct effects are more tangible and easier to describe.

A more complete statement of the problem might be to say that a member of the privileged group benefits in the here-and-now zero-sum world, albeit at the expense of being in a dysfunctional and impoverished society which, the more enlightened they are, eclipses any selfish zero-sum benefit.

David Chappell gives an extraordinarily well researched and documented exploration of American history from the time of slavery thru Jim Crow in his book A Stone of Hope.

Chappell's interest is more in social change-- how did social change occur and why-- more than economics, but the economic aspect of it is obviously a factor so gets significant attention in this highly detailed book.

One of the interesting things he notes, along the lines of what you suggest, is that slavery and Jim Crow were quite detrimental to poor whites who were competing with slaves/lowly paid blacks for low-wage jobs. It was advantageous to upper-class whites, obviously especially landowners/ slaveowners, some of whom were able to become fabulously wealthy.

Even more interesting, perhaps, was his observation that defense of slavery/Jim Crow/discrimination was even stronger among poor whites, despite the fact that it was contrary to their economic interests, than it was among the wealthy whites who directly benefitted from these systems that suppressed wages of both blacks and whites. Chappell observed that there is a psychological motive at play where humans like to feel they have the edge up on someone. Being the "2nd lowest" instead of lumped in with the lowest disadvantaged group in the south was of greater psychological benefit to poor whites than the economic benefit of joining with blacks to raise all wages.

Arguably, I think you can see this dynamic still at play today among certain segments of American voters-- particularly Trump supporters.

--------------------
"Here is the world. Beautiful and terrible things will happen. Don't be afraid." -Frederick Buechner

Posts: 11242 | From: a small canyon overlooking the city | Registered: Jan 2008  |  IP: Logged
mdijon
Shipmate
# 8520

 - Posted      Profile for mdijon     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by cliffdweller:
It was advantageous to upper-class whites, obviously especially landowners/ slaveowners, some of whom were able to become fabulously wealthy

That does sound like a very similar argument to the one I was trying to reach for. One could extend further with the point that probably only a few were that fabulously wealthy and likely would have been fabulously wealthy even in a alternative system with waged workers - but perhaps without the surety that their children's children would remain on top of the pile in a quasi-feudal society.


quote:
Originally posted by cliffdweller:
.....his observation that defense of slavery/Jim Crow/discrimination was even stronger among poor whites, despite the fact that it was contrary to their economic interests

That does sound familiar. We also saw during the introduction of Obama-care that vociferous opposition and Obama-Hitler posters were often carried by people who likely couldn't afford health insurance and could have benefited most from Obama-care.

--------------------
mdijon nojidm uoɿıqɯ ɯqıɿou
ɯqıɿou uoɿıqɯ nojidm mdijon

Posts: 12277 | From: UK | Registered: Sep 2004  |  IP: Logged
Curiosity killed ...

Ship's Mug
# 11770

 - Posted      Profile for Curiosity killed ...   Email Curiosity killed ...   Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by mdijon:
quote:
Originally posted by cliffdweller:
It was advantageous to upper-class whites, obviously especially landowners/ slaveowners, some of whom were able to become fabulously wealthy

That does sound like a very similar argument to the one I was trying to reach for. One could extend further with the point that probably only a few were that fabulously wealthy and likely would have been fabulously wealthy even in a alternative system with waged workers - but perhaps without the surety that their children's children would remain on top of the pile in a quasi-feudal society.
In UK society, those families with land and properties in the UK would have remained wealthy whether or not they were involved in the slave trade. Some younger sons of those families and slave traders could have built fortunes on the slave trade. It is very difficult to disentangle what was built with the proceeds of slavery at this distance.

It's not just Liverpool, but Bristol too is built on the proceeds of the slave trade. Some of the West Country estates were built by slave traders. One of the houses I know has the heads of slaves on the top of the gateposts instead of the more traditional pineapples or other symbols. The original house has gone; all that remains is the home farm, now in other hands.

A local house to here, near London, was an estate as given to one of William the Conqueror's men that was absorbed into the local monastic lands. In Tudor times it was given to Henry VIII as part of the wheeler dealing as part of the dissolution of the monasteries. QEI gave it to a royal favourite and it was inherited by his daughter. It fell into disrepair and was sold on to someone who made his money from slavery and he rebuilt a Georgian pile on the same estate grounds in a slightly different position. It was then bought by a family who made their money in the railways who extended in Victorian excess before being burned down in Edwardian times and sitting as a ruin ever since.

Very difficult to split out how much benefit from slavery there.

--------------------
Mugs - Keep the Ship afloat

Posts: 13794 | From: outiside the outer ring road | Registered: Aug 2006  |  IP: Logged
SvitlanaV2
Shipmate
# 16967

 - Posted      Profile for SvitlanaV2   Email SvitlanaV2   Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
A project at UCL several years ago found that when slavery was finally abolished in the British Caribbean, a large amount of compensation was paid to British people who had inherited slaves. Many recipients were not the fabulously wealthy, but members of the gentry and middle classes. A large number were widows.

This research is just one way of engaging with the question of who benefited from the British trade in slaves.

Posts: 6668 | From: UK | Registered: Feb 2012  |  IP: Logged
Russ
Old salt
# 120

 - Posted      Profile for Russ   Author's homepage     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by mdijon:
In a zero-sum world there are x jobs available and therefore white applicants have a benefit as a result of racism.

The short-term zero-sum argument is more often heard in terms of "immigrants are taking our jobs" - not an argument I'd expect to hear from your good self.

Seems to me that yes you probably can point at jobs that would have gone to a black person if not for racism and jobs that would have gone to an indigenous person if not for immigrants. But that in both cases the longer-term impact is the other way - that society gains from immigration and loses from racism.

But it's not clear to me that racism as such is a legacy of slavery. Arguably, that legacy is the extent to which racism is worse in societies which had slavery (at whatever point in history you want to take as a reference point) than in comparable societies which did not.

--------------------
Wish everyone well; the enemy is not people, the enemy is wrong ideas

Posts: 3169 | From: rural Ireland | Registered: May 2001  |  IP: Logged
Russ
Old salt
# 120

 - Posted      Profile for Russ   Author's homepage     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by Pottage:

The stolen painting is a poor analogy for these purposes. Even 20 generations later it may still be able to be returned as recompense if a rightful heir could be identified.

Seems to me that the return of a stolen painting

- is restitution rather than compensation. Not sure how much of what one can say about one carries over to the other, but they're not quite the same thing

- requires the item to be identifiable. Even if great-great-grandfather left a written confession to having stolen a print of "Girl with a pearl earring", no-one is going to "return" anything unless there's some evidence as to whether it's the one on your wall or the one on your cousin's wall that was previously stolen.

-should be to the estate of the long-deceased owner and thence to the nearest living relative rather than trying to construct an alternate history in which it wasn't stolen. Such a history might conclude, for example, that in the absence of the theft the painting would have been destroyed when the house burned down.

- needs to be in response to new information (rather than seeking to overturn a historic legal decision on any other grounds). I don't know the legal details, but it seems to me that when someone dies, the process of law is supposed to settle all the debts of the estate and confirm that the heirs have good title to the inheritance that remains. If no-one at that time knew that "the contents of the house" included a stolen painting, then that's new information and a reason to revisit the question of who is the rightful owner. If on the other hand the original owner knew perfectly well that the deceased had borrowed a painting of his and raised no objection to it being included in the estate, then it's not clear that the heirs of the original owner have any right to reopen the question (perhaps in the knowledge that it has subsequently become valuable).

--------------------
Wish everyone well; the enemy is not people, the enemy is wrong ideas

Posts: 3169 | From: rural Ireland | Registered: May 2001  |  IP: Logged
lilBuddha
Shipmate
# 14333

 - Posted      Profile for lilBuddha     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by Curiosity killed ...:
In UK society, those families with land and properties in the UK would have remained wealthy whether or not they were involved in the slave trade.

Benefit from the slave trade does not just reside in the people directly involved. The overall wealth of the nation was fed by slavery and the dependent and beneficiary industries as well. The sun that wasn't setting shown on many exploited backs. That the descendants who benefit would exclude the descendants of the exploited is a sad state.
quote:
Originally posted by SvitlanaV2:
A project at UCL several years ago found that when slavery was finally abolished in the British Caribbean, a large amount of compensation was paid to British people who had inherited slaves. Many recipients were not the fabulously wealthy, but members of the gentry and middle classes. A large number were widows.

This research is just one way of engaging with the question of who benefited from the British trade in slaves.

ISTM, compensation is too limited a window to see much. The benefit of slavery and other exploitation goes far beyond those who participated directly.

--------------------
I put on my rockin' shoes in the morning
Hallellou, hallellou

Posts: 17627 | From: the round earth's imagined corners | Registered: Dec 2008  |  IP: Logged
mdijon
Shipmate
# 8520

 - Posted      Profile for mdijon     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by Russ:
Seems to me that yes you probably can point at jobs that would have gone to a black person if not for racism and jobs that would have gone to an indigenous person if not for immigrants. But that in both cases the longer-term impact is the other way - that society gains from immigration and loses from racism.

That is very close to what I did argue. Some individuals are more interested in their own short-term gain than in society and vice versa.

Between the immigrant vs indigenous and racist benefit vs non-benefit arguments there is one crucial difference. In the first the desired output is to prevent immigration. In the latter the desired output is to make a privileged group aware of it's privilege.

If the argument is followed through in the first case then society becomes poorer for the sake of preserving jobs for the locals. That is a choice that societies can make.

In the latter the privileged group might become aware of the harm it is doing to society by hanging on to privilege.

quote:
Originally posted by Russ:
But it's not clear to me that racism as such is a legacy of slavery.

Of course it isn't clear that it is *a* legacy as in an a=>b model. However I think it should be considered straightforward to argue that the legacy of slavery is a dehumanising and stigmatizing of slaves and ex-slaves and those who look like ex-slaves and their offspring.

--------------------
mdijon nojidm uoɿıqɯ ɯqıɿou
ɯqıɿou uoɿıqɯ nojidm mdijon

Posts: 12277 | From: UK | Registered: Sep 2004  |  IP: Logged
Curiosity killed ...

Ship's Mug
# 11770

 - Posted      Profile for Curiosity killed ...   Email Curiosity killed ...   Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
lilBuddha, the benefits to the UK and other countries from using the resources and manpower of the developing world are much wider than slavery. It's one of the problems of cheap anything, something somewhere has been abused: any or all of the land, the people or the animals involved in the production of those goods. But that is a continuing ill.

--------------------
Mugs - Keep the Ship afloat

Posts: 13794 | From: outiside the outer ring road | Registered: Aug 2006  |  IP: Logged
lilBuddha
Shipmate
# 14333

 - Posted      Profile for lilBuddha     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by Curiosity killed ...:
lilBuddha, the benefits to the UK and other countries from using the resources and manpower of the developing world are much wider than slavery.

That is a point I have been making at various points on this thread. But the main point I was making in this exchange is that tracing the benefit to slave owners is too limited. The country as a whole benefits from such a massive influx of cash. Though, then as now, the majority of that benefit resides with the rich.
quote:

It's one of the problems of cheap anything, something somewhere has been abused: any or all of the land, the people or the animals involved in the production of those goods. But that is a continuing ill.

The thing that sickens me is that those we exploit could be paid a decent wage and work in safe conditions and we could [i]still[i/] have cheap goods and the importers and manufacturers make healthy profit.
Greed and apathy.

--------------------
I put on my rockin' shoes in the morning
Hallellou, hallellou

Posts: 17627 | From: the round earth's imagined corners | Registered: Dec 2008  |  IP: Logged
Russ
Old salt
# 120

 - Posted      Profile for Russ   Author's homepage     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by mdijon:
it should be considered straightforward to argue that the legacy of slavery is a dehumanising and stigmatizing of slaves and ex-slaves and those who look like ex-slaves and their offspring.

Sounds plausible. Are you suggesting that this stigmatizing happened primarily in the countries that had slaves ? Or that the whole world saw the US first having black slaves and then becoming the world's most powerful country so that the stigma is universal ?

--------------------
Wish everyone well; the enemy is not people, the enemy is wrong ideas

Posts: 3169 | From: rural Ireland | Registered: May 2001  |  IP: Logged
Jay-Emm
Shipmate
# 11411

 - Posted      Profile for Jay-Emm     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
There's a middlish option as well.
Stigma happening in countries that had slaves (even if not on mainland). Then as these countries become powerful in other countries they apply the stigma.

Posts: 1643 | Registered: May 2006  |  IP: Logged
Penny S
Shipmate
# 14768

 - Posted      Profile for Penny S     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
About eight years ago I was astonished to hear or read an American saying of Obama that he was advantaged as a black man by not having the taint of slavery.

And a Caribbean student doing teaching practice at the school I taught in revealed that African immigrants looked down on the Caribbeans because they had been slaves.

Posts: 5833 | Registered: May 2009  |  IP: Logged
mdijon
Shipmate
# 8520

 - Posted      Profile for mdijon     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by mdijon:
it should be considered straightforward to argue that the legacy of slavery is a dehumanising and stigmatizing of slaves and ex-slaves and those who look like ex-slaves and their offspring.

quote:
Originally posted by Russ:
Sounds plausible. Are you suggesting that this stigmatizing happened primarily in the countries that had slaves ? Or that the whole world saw the US first having black slaves and then becoming the world's most powerful country so that the stigma is universal ?

I would say inevitable rather than simply plausible within the countries that engaged in a racially-based slave trade, and plausible for the wider world. Even in parts of Africa there remains a stigma surrounding descendants of slaves where these can be defined as a separate ethnic group.

In Liberia there was a curious circle of history where the freed African-American slaves established dominance over Liberian African populations, and in East Africa among the mission societies the freed slaves were regarded as superior in status to the local African population. (Today they are rather stigmatized, although that is fading).

--------------------
mdijon nojidm uoɿıqɯ ɯqıɿou
ɯqıɿou uoɿıqɯ nojidm mdijon

Posts: 12277 | From: UK | Registered: Sep 2004  |  IP: Logged
SvitlanaV2
Shipmate
# 16967

 - Posted      Profile for SvitlanaV2   Email SvitlanaV2   Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by lilBuddha:
ISTM, compensation is too limited a window to see much. The benefit of slavery and other exploitation goes far beyond those who participated directly.

Certainly. But I said it was just one way of looking at it.

I was also thinking of Curiosity killed...'s previous post, in which he referred to the difficulty of establishing exactly how much individuals and families benefited financially from slavery. The research I linked to showed that in some cases this can actually be proven, at least at the point of abolition.

Out of interest, were slave owners in the USA compensated upon the abolition of slavery there?

With regard to another of Curiosity's points, it should also be said that a number of trading families and businesses in Birmingham and wider the West Midlands also gained financial advantages as a result of the slave trade. The metal trades benefited especially, e.g. guns, nails, shackles, manillas (a form of currency).

Lloyd's Bank was set up in Birmingham as a result of finances gained in such trades. Ironically, the Lloyd family were Quakers, as were a number of other families that made their living from selling potentially destructive metalware. The Galtons, for example, made guns designed for the West African market.

Posts: 6668 | From: UK | Registered: Feb 2012  |  IP: Logged
mdijon
Shipmate
# 8520

 - Posted      Profile for mdijon     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
Compensation for slave owners was being discussed in the US government just before the civil war. I believe Lincoln was in favour, but plans were overtaken by events (i.e. secession).

Slave owners were compensated in British colonies in East Africa in the early 1800s, although the implementation was a bit fraught with the need to prove current enslavement to avoid being scammed.

--------------------
mdijon nojidm uoɿıqɯ ɯqıɿou
ɯqıɿou uoɿıqɯ nojidm mdijon

Posts: 12277 | From: UK | Registered: Sep 2004  |  IP: Logged
Pottage
Shipmate
# 9529

 - Posted      Profile for Pottage   Email Pottage   Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by SvitlanaV2:
With regard to another of Curiosity's points, it should also be said that a number of trading families and businesses in Birmingham and wider the West Midlands also gained financial advantages as a result of the slave trade. The metal trades benefited especially, e.g. guns, nails, shackles, manillas (a form of currency).

Lloyd's Bank was set up in Birmingham as a result of finances gained in such trades. Ironically, the Lloyd family were Quakers, as were a number of other families that made their living from selling potentially destructive metalware. The Galtons, for example, made guns designed for the West African market.

The connections between Taylor's and Lloyds Bank and the slave trade are fairly thin I think, unless you count the fact that a number of their first customers may by implication be assumed to have derived some unknown proportion of their income from supplying the trade. Members of the two families were abolitionists in fact.

Galton's involvement in the slave trade was significant, and caused tension with the Society of Friends from which I think he had to withdraw at least for a time. Birmingham supplied a lot of the guns and other ironware that were traded for slaves; Manchester much of the cloth. Other manufacturing centres also got in on the act - copper bracelets and trinkets were mass produced in Swansea for example.

It's certain that the slave trade contributed to the Industrial Revolution and to the development of the huge colonial trading enterprises of the north European countries. But it's easy to overstate that contribution. Throughout the period when the Atlantic slave trade was at its height it only ever represented a tiny proportion of Britain's overall export trade in manufactured goods for example. Even within the trade across the Atlantic (so disregarding the far larger and more profitable markets in Europe and Asia) more manufactured exports went directly to the North American colonies than ever went to West Africa.

http://www.nuff.ox.ac.uk/economics/history/paper113/harley113.pdf

Posts: 701 | From: middle England | Registered: May 2005  |  IP: Logged
Crœsos
Shipmate
# 238

 - Posted      Profile for Crœsos     Send new private message       Edit/delete post   Reply with quote 
quote:
Originally posted by SvitlanaV2:
[QB]Out of interest, were slave owners in the USA compensated upon the abolition of slavery there?

Slaveowners in the District of Columbia were compensated for the emancipation of their slaves. I believe this is the only example of the federal government compensating individual slaveholders for a mass emancipation.

--------------------
Humani nil a me alienum puto

Posts: 10706 | From: Sardis, Lydia | Registered: May 2001  |  IP: Logged



Pages in this thread: 1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9 
 
Post new thread  Post a reply Close thread   Feature thread   Move thread   Delete thread Next oldest thread   Next newest thread
 - Printer-friendly view
Go to:

Contact us | Ship of Fools | Privacy statement

© Ship of Fools 2016

Powered by Infopop Corporation
UBB.classicTM 6.5.0

 
follow ship of fools on twitter
buy your ship of fools postcards
sip of fools mugs from your favourite nautical website
 
 
  ship of fools