Thread: MW: Liturgy of Christian Unrest Board: Limbo / Ship of Fools.


To visit this thread, use this URL:
http://forum.ship-of-fools.com/cgi-bin/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic;f=11;t=000873

Posted by sacredthree (# 46) on :
 
[Posted to MW and SF]

Simon and I recently had lunch, and over coffee discussed the idea of Ship-of-Fools writing it's own Liturgy; a Liturgy of Christian Unrest.

This is a follow on from the recent txt message competition and How Great Thou Aren't; the idea being to produce a set of prayers that reflect the reality of our lives, and the nature of Christian Unrest.

The aim would be to produce Ship of Fools very own Office. A typical formulation could be:

Preparation
Greeting
A Prayer of Preparation / Confession
A Collect of Christian Unrest

Liturgy of the Word
An Expression of Faith
Space for Readings
Psalms (perhaps our own "translation")
A meditation / canticle (perhaps our own "translation")

Prayers
Intercessions and Thanksgivings
The Lords Prayer (perhaps our own "translation")

Conclusion
Dismissal

That isn't really a lot of work, and I'm sure that the SoF has many fine budding liturgists on its MW, SF and main boards. In time we would hope to have enough material to produce variations for different days of the week; different collects, meditations, or canticles.

Simon says:

quote:
The idea is to start developing worship resources which give expression to Christian unrest... the kind of prayers you might expect to find on Ship of Fools. Edward suggested (only half-jokingly, I think) a dismissal prayer of: "Now get us off our arses to actually do something."
Providing an online daily office of our own really appeals. We could also develop our own lectionary, too, to run in parallel with the western lectionary... I'm sure we could fairly easily put together 52 weekly readings on foolishness in the Bible, for example.

So would people here be interested in contributing to the project on this thread?

[ 10. March 2003, 01:47: Message edited by: Erin ]
 
Posted by The Happy Coot (# 220) on :
 
Why do I have a gut feeling that this request will be more successful at Small Fire ie. I don't think such an office will lend itself to absurd amounts of exalted tat. (That which is necessary to lure your average MW devotee out of hiding).

And even if there was the promise of an orgiastic tat festival, well, it still wouldn't be, you know, the real thing.

So actually, help a dense little coot out, is the object to create a humorous and make-believe 'office' (in which case you're in with a chance) or um, is it, oof! I can't bring myself to say it.

(Repeats in the manner of a Litany: Gregory of Nyssa Gregory of Nyssa)
 


Posted by sacredthree (# 46) on :
 
As my good friend Fr.Tony(RC) recently reminded me being "catholic" isn't about what you wear or what you do, but about a living tradition of spirituality. I would expect that a "catholic" of any sort is likely to keep a daily office, especially those in the Priesthood.

I accompany my office with incense and icons if at home. If I am in town I may well visit LSM and pray some devotions to Mary, if near my church I will go into the chapel where we reserve the most holy sacrament, genuflect (of course) and say my office.

Take the tat, the ceremony, and the processions, but do not take away from me what truly makes me "catholic".

Before I get this thread sent to Hell perhaps we ought to think about the sort of office that would be a Liturgy of Christian unrest.

For ideas why not have a look a oremus to give you a starting place.
 


Posted by The Happy Coot (# 220) on :
 
[If I can make a quick response without getting us sent to purgatory: my idea of a catholic spirituality involves continuity of worship eg. the orthodox concept of continuity of worship. ie. they still faithfully use the Liturgy of St John Chysostom]

But it was a real question - I genuinely was unsure as to whether the idea of a Ship of Fools liturgy was a joke idea or not. Ahem. Your response leads me to conclude it is serious - but even this I can't reconcile with a dismissal prayer of: "Now get us off our arses to actually do something."
 


Posted by sacredthree (# 46) on :
 
Sorry got carried away before...

quote:
Originally posted by The Happy Coot:
So actually, help a dense little coot out, is the object to create a humorous and make-believe 'office' (in which case you're in with a chance) or um, is it, oof! I can't bring myself to say it.

(Repeats in the manner of a Litany: Gregory of Nyssa Gregory of Nyssa)


Well, think about the SoF. It is kind of funny, but also very serious. Something serious enough to use at a meet, but with a sharp edge to it ...

Is that clearer ... perhaps not ...
 


Posted by sacredthree (# 46) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by The Happy Coot:
[If I can make a quick response without getting us sent to purgatory: my idea of a catholic spirituality involves continuity of worship eg. the orthodox concept of continuity of worship. ie. they still faithfully use the Liturgy of St John Chysostom]

I think the term "Living Tradition" sums up my approach. I would expect the SoF liturgy to include elements of tradition, but also new content that followed a Liturgical form. Common Worship has adopted this approach I feel. New Liturgies in this form have been created by various neo-monastic communities, such as Northumbria and Iona.

quote:
Originally posted by The Happy Coot:
But it was a real question - I genuinely was unsure as to whether the idea of a Ship of Fools liturgy was a joke idea or not. Ahem. Your response leads me to conclude it is serious - but even this I can't reconcile with a dismissal prayer of: "Now get us off our arses to actually do something."

Well the dismissal prayer is a Joke in my mind, but represents a tradition of dismissals that can be seen in the following Post-Communion prayer

quote:
Almighty God,
we thank you for feeding us
with the body and blood of your Son Jesus Christ.
Through him we offer you our souls and bodies
to be a living sacrifice.
Send us out
in the power of your Spirit
to live and work
to your praise and glory.
Amen.

In short ... get off our arses.

I think Simon and I were hoping for something usable but unusual.
 


Posted by babybear (# 34) on :
 
I have found that when I have been worshipping in a tradition that is not my own things surprise me, and cause me to think. When the NT was published in Scots I found the Lord's Prayer to be very challenging, and very fresh.

Is there a way of creating a new liturgy that would make others think a bit deeper, or surprise them. Some people need to pray that God would get them off their arses and start doing things. Others will heed "Go into the world, and be an example of compassion and justice as Christ was."

Can you think of something that is meaningful to you, that might aid another?

bb
 


Posted by sacredthree (# 46) on :
 
Well the answer is no. Are there really no liturgists on MW? Do with love Liturgy, or just one Liturgy?

One of the elements of the SoF Office would be a Expression of Faith. Should we use a creed, or something like this from the northumbria community?

I am rather fond of the Tirechans Creed. How do other people feel?
 


Posted by Dyfrig (# 15) on :
 
I'm up for it, Tedward. Count me in.
 
Posted by The Happy Coot (# 220) on :
 
Hm. S3, I just checked the Small Fire version of the thread... I think you minced up the 'dispute' a bit. It wasn't a dispute! It was me trying to establish the exact nature of the beast; and gently and jokingly conveying my suspicions that MWers would be a bit reserved in partaking.

Modern thematic liturgy doesn't turn me on. In fact. I hate it. However. The Ship is such a cool place that I feel obliged to offer some sort of support - if only feedback or my prayers that you will create something that others will find edifying.

The Coot,
Who says what others only think.
 


Posted by sacredthree (# 46) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by The Happy Coot:
Who says what others only think.

Me 2.

Sorry for mincing. I find its the only way to swing (a thurible).
 


Posted by Siegfried (# 29) on :
 
What level (high, motr, low) is being aimed at?
 
Posted by sacredthree (# 46) on :
 
well being an office it should be fairly broad in its appeal. I know some low types don't use complin and such, but i generally find a variety of churchmanships can sit and share a basic liturgy fairly well.
 
Posted by Joan Rasch (# 49) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by sacredthree:
well being an office it should be fairly broad in its appeal. <snip> I generally find a variety of churchmanships can sit and share a basic liturgy fairly well.

It seems to me that before writing a listurgy [sic :-)], we need to do some work of discernment. Are we being called by God to pray together as a group? About what? Is this calling one that needs to be answered with collective and corporate prayer? If so, are there already existing forms which will serve to allow us to answer the call?

I'm suggesting here that creating a liturgical form divorced from a community need to pray it may be rather an empty exercise. It might have modest virtues as an aesthetic work or as a didactic device, but it's not likely something that will be of much help to building the body and supporting our prayer.

Please don't consider this cold water, however. We may well indeed be called to pray together in someway - but we first need to determine if we are called to journey together to a particular destination before making travel plans and building a vehicle.

Cheers from Boston - Joan Rasch
 


Posted by sacredthree (# 46) on :
 
Joan the SoF is an online community. We live, laugh and suffer together. We are united by the sense of unrest we feel.

Liturgy should flow like water from that interaction.
 


Posted by Joan Rasch (# 49) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by sacredthree:
Joan the SoF is an online community. We live, laugh and suffer together. We are united by the sense of unrest we feel.

Liturgy should flow like water from that interaction.


I completely agree - but we still need to do the work of discernment. If we are indeed "united by the sense of unrest we feel", we still need to work together to articulate the content of that 'unrest' and hear how God might be calling us to respond. I will confess to being a relative newbie here, but I'm not yet clear in my mind on either the content or the calling.

But I do look forward to doing this work if others are so inclined.

Cheers from Boston - Joan Rasch
 


Posted by Ann (# 94) on :
 
To match the tone of the dismissal, a greeting of "Ready or not ... The Lord is with us"

More seriously and because I feel that a general confession taken at breakneck speed and an absolution which follows hard on the heels smacks of "let's get this out of the way and not associate it with our lives as we lead them": a confession

"Lord, we have said too much and said too little." (pause to reflect on insensitive remarks and lack of comfort/encouraging remarks)

"Lord, we have done too much and done too little." (pause to reflect on being too busy and procrastinating)

"Lord, we have prayed too much and prayed too little." (pause to reflect on praying to change the order of things to suit ourselves and ignoring real injustice)

"Lord, we have thought too much and thought too little." (pause to reflect on hair-splitting and prejudice)

"Lord, we have loved too much and loved too little." (pause to reflect on infatuation or smother-love and ignoring those who don't interest you)

(it needs a conclusion, anyone?)
 


Posted by sacredthree (# 46) on :
 
Brilliant Ann.
 
Posted by Adrian (# 298) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Ann:
(it needs a conclusion, anyone?)

how about:

Lord, we have confessed too much, and confessed too little. Enough already.

The Lord forgives (we hope). Any guilt you still have is your own problem. Move on.
 


Posted by babybear (# 34) on :
 
I don't like that. Sounds far too much like "Hitchhikers guid to the galaxy". It is too dismissive and abrupt.

The Lord forgives; never too much, never too little. In the Lord there is perfection and peace. Be still and receive the forgiveness and peace of the Lord.

bb

[ 21 August 2001: Message edited by: babybear ]
 


Posted by Adrian (# 298) on :
 
hmm. not sure that's restless enough for me. we get told stuff like that all the time in church. exactly what does it mean? why should i accept it?

(and what is this website's obsession with the hitchhikers guide? it's a good radio program and book which gradually ended up as a series of poor sequels. get over it people)
 


Posted by Siegfried (# 29) on :
 
Combine them:

[add this to the end of Ann's contribution]
Lord, we have confessed too much, and confessed too little. (reflect on the minor transgressions that you've blown up so that they obscure the major transgressions.)

[use this as a bridge]
Lord, You know all that is said and unsaid,
done and undone,
prayed for and unprayed for,
thought and ignored,
loved and unloved,
confessed and hidden.

[end with BabyBear's contribuation]
The Lord forgives; never too much, never too little. In the Lord there is perfection and peace. Be still and recieve the forgiveness and peace of the Lord.
 


Posted by Tubbs (# 440) on :
 
That is just wonderful

Tubbs
 


Posted by Ann (# 94) on :
 
Works for me. Thanks Siegfried.
 
Posted by Stephen (# 40) on :
 
Brilliant, Siegfried!
Thanks....
 
Posted by babybear (# 34) on :
 
I think that I might well print that off tonight and use it just before bed.

bb
 


Posted by Stephen (# 40) on :
 
I must admit to using Compline before bed.I'm a fan of the opening lines of Ps 91
 
Posted by Siegfried (# 29) on :
 
Thanks folks, but I didn't really do anything other than put your pieces together!
That, and I misspelled 'receive' in the last line!!

Sieg
 


Posted by babybear (# 34) on :
 
Lord, we have said too much and said too little.
(pause to reflect on insensitive remarks and lack of comfort/encouraging remarks)

Lord, we have done too much and done too little.
(pause to reflect on being too busy and procrastinating)

Lord, we have prayed too much and prayed too little.
(pause to reflect on praying to change the order of things to suit ourselves and ignoring real injustice)

Lord, we have thought too much and thought too little.
(pause to reflect on hair-splitting and prejudice)

Lord, we have loved too much and loved too little.
(pause to reflect on infatuation or smother-love and ignoring those who don't interest you)

Lord, we have confessed too much, and confessed too little.
(reflect on the minor transgressions that you've blown up so that they obscure the major transgressions.)

Lord,
You know all that is said and unsaid,
done and undone,
prayed for and unprayed for,
thought and ignored,
loved and unloved,
confessed and hidden.

The Lord forgives; never too much,
never too little.
In the Lord there is perfection and peace.
Be still and receive the forgiveness and peace of the Lord.

 


Posted by Siegfried (# 29) on :
 
Thanks for posting the compiled version.

I typed it up and have it stuck to the wall in my cube at the moment.
 


Posted by TonyK (# 35) on :
 
Thanks guys - I really like that confession and absolution

Will try and work on a Collect of Unrest while I'm on holiday

For a psalm - how about Fiona-Jane's version of Psalm 34 (I can provide a copy if required)
 


Posted by babybear (# 34) on :
 
Where is FJ's Psalm? If it is something that she wrote 'off-ship' then we need to ask for her permission to use it. If it was written 'on-board' then it would be polite to ask for it to be included.

Since Tony is currently unemployed I commission him to contact FJ about the psalm.

bb
 


Posted by TonyK (# 35) on :
 
bb - FJ contacted as ordered, o great one

She originally posted it on the Ship in 1999, and gave me permission to use it, provided I named her as the author - but I have referred her to this thread
 


Posted by Fudge (# 425) on :
 
Tony, and all, I have given permission. My version of Psalm 34 was written in the beginning of me having a nervous breakdown because of being bullied at work and more or less being forced out of the job because no-one would stand up to the bully.

Also had to face up to lots of unresolved problems and unconfessed sins. Funny, had a terrible week this week in a job that I love and there are only decent workmates. The management are a bit hypersenstive and I really stood on someone's toes this week and was terrified that I might get sacked. All the old paranoia was back and the devil was laughing at me again.

this time it wasn't the shipmates who rallied round, cos I haven't been on the boards lately, but my non-xtian workmates! God used them to show me that there is no way I'm going to lose this job cos He put me in it, and I just gotta stop and trust!

So it's a Psalm written out of unrest, just like David did. I had my own "Saul" to be frightened of, and that which I wrote was the result.

If it helps, have it. I've lost my copy so I'd appreciate the chance to retrieve it from Tony to go on my poems page on my own website at Fudge's marshmallow World

FJ (managers!?)
 


Posted by TonyK (# 35) on :
 
... and here it is....

Psalm 34, or otherwise

I cried unto the Lord and He heard me,
And sent me the love of all my dear friends,
The Angel of the Lord encamps round about them that fear Him,
And creates a shield from the prayers of those closest to me.


Such kindness and friendship in a wicked world,
Was indeed a treasure to discover.
An oasis in the boiling seas of life,
Where all my shipmates came to gather round me.
I had not thought such love
Still existed in this fast decaying time,
But you all care more than any
A balm to a troubled spirit and frightened heart.
Reminded me who holds the chart,
Who the pilot of my ship is,
Who has the answers and listens when I scream and stamp.
Who puts the sun behind the clouds
To burst through a billion times brighter
When the storm passes.


My guardian angels were the hearts of my friends,
There in the time of need,
Let me praise you and the Captain,
Whose sons and daughters we all are,
For giving such clear assurance,
He's still in charge.
----------------------------
Land ahoy, me lads,
The Journey won't be much longer,
Press on towards the shore,
To gain an eternal harbour secure.


Author: Fiona-Jane Brown, SoF
 


Posted by sacredthree (# 46) on :
 
Thank you everybody for the contributions so far. They are brilliant.

It's great to see something like this grow.

What directin do you think we should go with as an expression of faith. Should we go for a creed or something else?
 


Posted by sacredthree (# 46) on :
 
Sorry to double post, but the expressions of faith found here may help us think.
 
Posted by babybear (# 34) on :
 
I have just shown the bit that we have done to a friend. She was very impressed and asked to use it in a service.

bb
 


Posted by babybear (# 34) on :
 
I suggest that the next task be a re-working of the Lord's Prayer.

bb
 


Posted by sarkycow (# 1012) on :
 
something to put in the creed...

we believe in unrest, to separate the chaff from the wheat.
we believe in doubt, in questions, in opinions. god has them; jesus has them, why shouldn't we?
we believe in ourselves - the only people who can change things.
we believe in jesus, the subversive, the rebel. he regarded people rather than laws as important. he felt all feelings, including anger, pain and abandonment.
we believe in a god who uses misfits, oddballs, unlikely, ordinanry people to tell his story.

it's late, and i'm running dry. will maybe add more later.....

any one else?

viki
 


Posted by da_musicman (# 1018) on :
 
I like that.Mind if I nick and Use?
 
Posted by Campbellite (# 1202) on :
 
I recently attended Community Christian Church (Disciples of Christ) in Kansas City, MO. During the passing of the peace, they said something which I liked so much I have started using it in my congregation:

"God loves you, and there is nothing you can do about it."
 


Posted by sacredthree (# 46) on :
 
So this is what we have ....


Preparation

Greeting:
God loves you, and there is nothing you can do about it

A Prayer of Preparation / Confession:
Lord, we have said too much and said too little.
(pause to reflect on insensitive remarks and lack of comfort/encouraging remarks)
Lord, we have done too much and done too little.
(pause to reflect on being too busy and procrastinating)

Lord, we have prayed too much and prayed too little.
(pause to reflect on praying to change the order of things to suit ourselves and ignoring real injustice)

Lord, we have thought too much and thought too little.
(pause to reflect on hair-splitting and prejudice)

Lord, we have loved too much and loved too little.
(pause to reflect on infatuation or smother-love and ignoring those who don't interest you)

Lord, we have confessed too much, and confessed too little.
(reflect on the minor transgressions that you've blown up so that they obscure the major transgressions.)

Lord,
You know all that is said and unsaid,
done and undone,
prayed for and unprayed for,
thought and ignored,
loved and unloved,
confessed and hidden.

The Lord forgives; never too much,
never too little.
In the Lord there is perfection and peace.
Be still and receive the forgiveness and peace of the Lord.

A Collect of Christian Unrest:
TonyK? Anything yet?


Liturgy of the Word

An Expression of Faith:
we believe in unrest, to separate the chaff from the wheat.
we believe in doubt, in questions, in opinions. god has them; jesus has them, why shouldn't we?
we believe in ourselves - the only people who can change things.
we believe in jesus, the subversive, the rebel. he regarded people rather than laws as important. he felt all feelings, including anger, pain and abandonment.
we believe in a god who uses misfits, oddballs, unlikely, ordinanry people to tell his story.

Space for Readings:

Psalm:
Psalm 34, or otherwise

I cried unto the Lord and He heard me,
And sent me the love of all my dear friends,
The Angel of the Lord encamps round about them that fear Him,
And creates a shield from the prayers of those closest to me.

Such kindness and friendship in a wicked world,
Was indeed a treasure to discover.
An oasis in the boiling seas of life,
Where all my shipmates came to gather round me.
I had not thought such love
Still existed in this fast decaying time,
But you all care more than any
A balm to a troubled spirit and frightened heart.
Reminded me who holds the chart,
Who the pilot of my ship is,
Who has the answers and listens when I scream and stamp.
Who puts the sun behind the clouds
To burst through a billion times brighter
When the storm passes.

My guardian angels were the hearts of my friends,
There in the time of need,
Let me praise you and the Captain,
Whose sons and daughters we all are,
For giving such clear assurance,
He's still in charge.
----------------------------
Land ahoy, me lads,
The Journey won't be much longer,
Press on towards the shore,
To gain an eternal harbour secure.


Prayers
Intercessions and Thanksgivings
The Lords Prayer (perhaps our own "translation")


Conclusion
Dismissal:


So that leaves us the collect of unrest, a pattern for intercessions, and a dismissal, and maybe a lords prayer translation?
 


Posted by Joan the Dwarf (# 1283) on :
 
Possible dismissal:

Go with God, and stay with God.

?
 


Posted by babybear (# 34) on :
 
This is a dismisal that I really like.

quote:
Paul Sheppy from "Prayers for a New Millennium".
The worship is over; the service begins.
Go, people of Go, into God's world.
Mett Christ in friend and stranger,
serve him in all you meet.
And may the blessing of God,
Father, Son and Holy Spirit fill you
and the whole of creation,
now and always.


bb
 


Posted by Joan the Dwarf (# 1283) on :
 
On second thoughts, mine's not a v. good dismissal.

Possible addition to the creed:

We believe in love, that comforts and challenges, that never lets us stay still but always draws us towards God.

The Lord Prayer will be quite hard, je pense. Interestingly, though, I think the Our father/hallowed be your name dichotomy will fit in quite well with the restless tension there seems to be in the rest of what's been written... How about starting:

God, whose home is heaven, who we on Earth love, and laugh with, and revere...

And for the 'forgive us our sins':

Challenged by the knowledge of your complete forgiveness, help us to forgive others.
 


Posted by babybear (# 34) on :
 
I love the simplicity of Joan's dismissal. Please don't just dismiss it.

bb
 


Posted by Joan the Dwarf (# 1283) on :
 
bb - after looking at it a bit, I got the feeling of a scolding mother letting a little child out with a family friend saying "and mind you stay close to God"!!! Maybe that's just to my mind, thought . I do like 'the worship is over, the service begins'.

Here's an offering for the Lords Prayer:

God, whose home is heaven, who we on Earth love, and laugh with, and revere, may we help to build your Kingdom right here and now, uniting Earth with Heaven in one creation centred on you and living by your light and your love.

You became an embodied spirit, like us, and you know our needs of body and soul. May we have what we need to live so that we may give ourselves wholly to you.

Challenged by the knowledge of your complete forgiveness, help us to forgive others. Forgive us that we are afraid to receive only the forgiveness we have given.

We believe you will not break us, but if we must be tested for your glory and our growth then give us strength.

Do not abandon us in the darkness that is sometimes our own minds, and stand between us and others who may try to imprison us in the darkness of the world.

We ask this of you because from you comes all goodness and love, all strength and all the light that pierces the darkness, for all time and outside time.
 


Posted by sacredthree (# 46) on :
 
I like Lords prayer very much. As for the dismissal how about something short and sweet like:

The worship is over; the service begins.
Go with God, and stay with God.

or some other fusion?

I also like the creed additions too.
 


Posted by Siegfried (# 29) on :
 
I definitely like Joan's version of the LP, and sacredthree's dismissal.
 
Posted by Joan the Dwarf (# 1283) on :
 
Right at the top S3 suggested "A meditation / canticle ". I'm not sure about the copyright issues involved, but I think the story 'God's Mischief' from Trevor Dennis' book 'Speaking of God' would be very appropriate. It's not very long, so I could type it up and post it if it's not going to get the Ship nailed for breach of copyright...

NB would it be possible to have a REAL silence in the liturgy? ie something more than an 'Anglican silence' which is the time it takes the priest to draw breath between saying "Let us pray" and starting the collect
 


Posted by babybear (# 34) on :
 
Please be careful with copyright issuse. The reason that I was able to post the Dismissal was because "This resourse (is) for personal and corporate use.." It had no copyright notice, but expressed the wish that the material would be used in different situations.

bb
 


Posted by Joan the Dwarf (# 1283) on :
 
Yes, copyright's a thorny one... I'm basically waiting for S3 to say yay or nay before I post it. Maybe it'd be too much trouble to get permission to use it, I just thought it would be an appropriate story.
 
Posted by sacredthree (# 46) on :
 
My preference would be to steer away from copyrighted materials. I have posted links to materials to give an ideas, but in general we have produced our own stuff.

Any other thoughts anyone?
 


Posted by sarkycow (# 1012) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Joan the Dwarf:
NB would it be possible to have a REAL silence in the liturgy? ie something more than an 'Anglican silence' which is the time it takes the priest to draw breath between saying "Let us pray" and starting the collect

i thoroughly agree. that irks me, especially in the confession, when we are given barely a minute to think over our sins and previous week. so can we incorporate a decent length silence (possibly in the intersessions?) during the service?

viki
 


Posted by Joan the Dwarf (# 1283) on :
 
One more thing, then I'll shut up -

Could we add something to the absolution, to reflect the fact that forgiveness doesn't just give peace, it can also be hugely challenging as we can't use the excuse "I'll just get it wrong" to not do something? I'm not 100% happy with the following, but it's all I could come up with for this:

Following on from bb's absolution,

The Lord forgives; never too much,
never too little.
In the Lord there is perfection and peace.
Be still and receive the forgiveness and peace of the Lord.

{pause}

Accepting that forgiveness we must now move on,
to try again where we have fallen, no matter how often.
In offering forgiveness before we can even ask for it,
the Lord calls us beyond the safety of our failures,
into the unknown depths of God's disturbing love.


One final final thing (honest!) - I've noticed there is only one pronoun outside of the psalm that refers to God. Could we do the whole liturgy with no 'he' or 'she' referring to God? Then it's comfortable whatever gender you perceive God as being.
 


Posted by Stephen (# 40) on :
 
To begin with I'm not a liturgist so perhaps I shouldn't post....
I like very much what Joan wrote;yet I'm a little bit uneasy.....it reads a bit like a sermon.....I feel that once absolution (so to speak) is pronounced one should move on to the next par of the liturgy of unrest
Would it be possible to have Joan's contribution before the absolution do you think???Or even in another part of the service....like an alternative dismissal?
But I have to admit I feel like a bumblimg amateur here in the presence of professionals.....Just ignore me!!
 
Posted by Siegfried (# 29) on :
 
You feel like an amatuer Stephen? Heck.. I'm from a non-liturgical tradition!!!
 
Posted by Joan the Dwarf (# 1283) on :
 
Stephen - like I said, I'm not happy with it myself: it's not really liturgically phrased. I can't say why not, it just feels wrong. I put it so that someone else can re-word it!

NB I'm certainly an amateur too - the idea of anyone describing me as a professinal liturgy writer struck me as very funny!

Maybe I should have a gin and try again...
 


Posted by Stephen (# 40) on :
 
Yes,I do actually Siegfried.To give you an example from my personal life
I play in an amateur orchestra.....but there's the world of difference between listening to music and actually playing it.Or (to give another example) looking and appreciating pictures and painting them.Or looking at the night sky and being a cosmologist
Do you see what I'm getting at?I can understand liturgy,because I'm in a liturgical (MOR,believe it or not!) tradition.But that's not the same as creating it,the way S3 or Adrian,or BB seem able to do
Hence my diffidence
And I liked what Joan wrote;my query was whether it was the best place for it....I wasn't trying to shoot it down....
 
Posted by TonyK (# 35) on :
 
Back from holiday - but no further advanced with collect.

I'll work on it
 


Posted by sarkycow (# 1012) on :
 
We believe in unrest, to separate the chaff from the wheat.
We believe in doubt, in questions, in opinions. God has them; Jesus has them, why shouldn't we?
We believe in ourselves - the only people who can change things.
We believe in Jesus, the subversive, the rebel. He regarded people rather than laws as important. He felt all feelings, including anger, pain and abandonment.
We believe in a god who uses misfits, oddballs, unlikely, ordinary people to tell his story.
We believe in love, that comforts and challenges, that never lets us stay still but always draws us towards God.

had some more thoughts in church tonight.....

We believe in Jesus Christ who dies for us, so that we might live for him. He is the divine fool, who spoke against the wisdom of the world, and turned the worldy order topsy-turvy. He calls us to be fools for him now, although not idiots!
We believe in one God; Creator, Saviour, and Helper, a divine mystery we cannot comprehend.
We believe in a God who cradles our weaknesses in the palm of his hand, whilst inspiring us with his strength.


not sure whether this is now making sense, had a long day...

viki
 


Posted by Joan the Dwarf (# 1283) on :
 
I do like that creed - especially the bit about being fools not idiots... seems to sum up the ship quite nicely
 
Posted by TonyK (# 35) on :
 
First draft of collect herewith
--------------------------------------
O Lord our God, who uses the foolish things of the world to confound the
wise, and sent our Lord Jesus to be a stumbling-block and a challenge to the world;

grant that we, trusting in your everlasting love for us, may be prepared to defy the conventions of our age, to expect to find your presence in unlikely places and to use the skills and resources you have given us to spread the Gospel message;

through Jesus Christ Our Lord, who,defying the expectation of his enemies, is alive and reigns with you in the unity of the Holy Spirit, one God, now and for ever. Amen

-------------------------------------

I'm not over-happy with it yet - the language is rather formal compared with the other material, but that's just how I am!

Please feel free to make alterations - but not please to the actual structure. A collect is not just a prayer - it is a prayer with a specific structure (which I have tried to follow) and a specific purpose (in this case to spell out some of the theme of the service).

Over to you guys!
 


Posted by sarkycow (# 1012) on :
 
thanks joan

tonyk, i like it. it's not hugely formal. and (within my church anyhow) the collect for the day is usually a bit more formal than our service structure and responses etc.... my 3.58340893pence for what it's worth

viki
 


Posted by Siegfried (# 29) on :
 
I see what you mean about the formality, Tony. I have an idea or two, but let me toss them about a bit first.

Sieg
 


Posted by TonyK (# 35) on :
 
... and a bump to bring the thread back up!

I know things haven't been easy recently and we've all had many more serious concerns to address - but I'd hate to see this mini-project fade away!

Ideas, guys?
 


Posted by sarkycow (# 1012) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by TonyK:
Ideas, guys?

how about someone pulls up what we have so far, both the bits that are definite, and the bits people have written, saying 'well i thought this might be a starting place...'

that would make it easier (in my mind at least) to see what we have/haevn't figured out, and therefore what we needed to think on

is this possible?

viki
 


Posted by sacredthree (# 46) on :
 
Okay I'm gonna pull this together now (unless someone else has already done it) and we'll have a look at it as a whole. I'll also wave it at Simon (but won't let him read it ....)

Now we have the basics if anyone has any new ideas they can be always be alternatives and extra resources ... kinda like in most books of liturgy.
 


Posted by babybear (# 34) on :
 
I was having a wonder about doing something Harvest or Advent related. any takers?

bb
 


Posted by Late Quartet (# 1207) on :
 

And baby bear, yes, I'd love to assist with Harvest / Advent stuff ... shall we start with Advent to give us time to get it ready ... new thread ?
 


Posted by TonyK (# 35) on :
 
LQ - I'm happy with that - can't think how is missed the double use myself - doh!!
 
Posted by Joan the Dwarf (# 1283) on :
 
I'm working on a 'God's foolishness' story for a meditation, and I've also got some ideas for the collect - Sieg, are you still working on that, I don't want to tread on any toes?
 
Posted by Siegfried (# 29) on :
 
Not actively at the moment. I'm one of the 'liturgically challenged', coming from a non-liturgical background and was hoping for that follow-up post on what bits of the collect were required and which bits could be tinkered with.
 
Posted by Angel of the North (# 60) on :
 
OK - collected so far:

Lord, we have said too much and said too little.
(pause to reflect on insensitive remarks and lack of comfort/encouraging remarks)

Lord, we have done too much and done too little.
(pause to reflect on being too busy and procrastinating)

Lord, we have prayed too much and prayed too little.
(pause to reflect on praying to change the order of things to suit ourselves and ignoring real injustice)

Lord, we have thought too much and thought too little.
(pause to reflect on hair-splitting and prejudice)

Lord, we have loved too much and loved too little.
(pause to reflect on infatuation or smother-love and ignoring those who don't interest you)

Lord, we have confessed too much, and confessed too little.
(reflect on the minor transgressions that you've blown up so that they obscure the major transgressions.)

Lord,
You know all that is said and unsaid,
done and undone,
prayed for and unprayed for,
thought and ignored,
loved and unloved,
confessed and hidden.

The Lord forgives; never too much,
never too little.
In the Lord there is perfection and peace.
Be still and receive the forgiveness and peace of the Lord.
{pause}
Accepting that forgiveness we must now move on,
to try again where we have fallen, no matter how often.
In offering forgiveness before we can even ask for it,
the Lord calls us beyond the safety of our failures,
into the unknown depths of God's disturbing love.


Collect
O Lord our God, who uses the foolish things of the world to confound the
wise, and sent our Lord Jesus to be a stumbling-block and a challenge to the world;

grant that we, trusting in your everlasting love for us, may be prepared to defy the conventions of our age, to expect to find your presence in unlikely places and to use the skills and resources you have given us to spread the Gospel message;

through Jesus Christ Our Lord, who,defying the expectation of his enemies, is alive and reigns with you in the unity of the Holy Spirit, one God, now and for ever. Amen


Psalm 34, or otherwise (Fiona Jane Brown)

I cried unto the Lord and He heard me,
And sent me the love of all my dear friends,
The Angel of the Lord encamps round about them that fear Him,
And creates a shield from the prayers of those closest to me.


Such kindness and friendship in a wicked world,
Was indeed a treasure to discover.
An oasis in the boiling seas of life,
Where all my shipmates came to gather round me.
I had not thought such love
Still existed in this fast decaying time,
But you all care more than any
A balm to a troubled spirit and frightened heart.
Reminded me who holds the chart,
Who the pilot of my ship is,
Who has the answers and listens when I scream and stamp.
Who puts the sun behind the clouds
To burst through a billion times brighter
When the storm passes.


My guardian angels were the hearts of my friends,
There in the time of need,
Let me praise you and the Captain,
Whose sons and daughters we all are,
For giving such clear assurance,
He's still in charge.
----------------------------
Land ahoy, me lads,
The Journey won't be much longer,
Press on towards the shore,
To gain an eternal harbour secure.


Credo (Sarkycow, Joanthedwarf)
we believe in unrest, to separate the chaff from the wheat.
we believe in doubt, in questions, in opinions. god has them; jesus has them, why shouldn't we?
we believe in ourselves - the only people who can change things.
we believe in jesus, the subversive, the rebel. he regarded people rather than laws as important. he felt all feelings, including anger, pain and abandonment.
we believe in a god who uses misfits, oddballs, unlikely, ordinanry people to tell his story.
We believe in love, that comforts and challenges, that never lets us stay still but always draws us towards God.
We believe in Jesus Christ who dies for us, so that we might live for him. He is the divine fool, who spoke against the wisdom of the world, and turned the worldy order topsy-turvy. He calls us to be fools for him now, although not idiots!
We believe in one God; Creator, Saviour, and Helper, a divine mystery we cannot comprehend.
We believe in a God who cradles our weaknesses in the palm of his hand, whilst inspiring us with his strength.

The Peace (Campbellite)
God loves you, and there is nothing you can do about it."


Lord's Prayer
God, whose home is heaven, who we on Earth love, and laugh with, and revere, may we help to build your Kingdom right here and now, uniting Earth with Heaven in one creation centred on you and living by your light and your love.

You became an embodied spirit, like us, and you know our needs of body and soul. May we have what we need to live so that we may give ourselves wholly to you.

Challenged by the knowledge of your complete forgiveness, help us to forgive others. Forgive us that we are afraid to receive only the forgiveness we have given.

We believe you will not break us, but if we must be tested for your glory and our growth then give us strength.

Do not abandon us in the darkness that is sometimes our own minds, and stand between us and others who may try to imprison us in the darkness of the world.

We ask this of you because from you comes all goodness and love, all strength and all the light that pierces the darkness, for all time and outside time.

Dismissal (Paul sheppy)
The worship is over; the service begins.
Go, people of Go, into God's world.
Mett Christ in friend and stranger,
serve him in all you meet.
And may the blessing of God,
Father, Son and Holy Spirit fill you
and the whole of creation,
now and always.

The Worship is over, the service begins
Go with God, Stay with God
 


Posted by Angel of the North (# 60) on :
 
[Call to prayer]
We come to receive the grace of God, that we may be humbled by it, and live in it. We come to renew our friendships, our works, and our hope in Christ.

[bidding prayer]
Spirit of the living God, As we pray Open in our hearts the unrestful spirit within, that as you come among us, we will accept you. We come expecting much, let us go away refreshed and thankful.You know our secrets, and our lives. Let us lay them before you, that we which we do too much and too little. You who are embodied in us now, show your spirit through our hands and feet, our lips and lives.

Lord, hear our prayer[ans] And when you call, let us come unto thee.

In rest and quietness, we watch and pray.
 


Posted by Angel of the North (# 60) on :
 
grrh - that should be:

let us lay our lives before you, those things that we do, too much and too little.

And the last bit should be in "thee/thou" - I was trying to write in the dialect I used for many years, where thee and thy are the personal pronouns, and you is the impersonal, or the plural.
 


Posted by seasick (# 48) on :
 
quote:
The Worship is over, the service begins

Please no! Anything but that . . . it's sooo cheesy . . .
I think it works better just omitting it . . .
 


Posted by Joan the Dwarf (# 1283) on :
 
Here's a second draft of the collect... I hope I haven't changed the meanings, TonyK. I've tweaked it for formality and repeated words.

Lord God, who uses foolishness to confound the wise, and who sent our Lord Jesus as a stumbling-block and challenge for the world;

may we, trusting in your everlasting love for us, be prepared to defy the conventions of our age, to expect to find your presence in unlikely places and to use the skills and resources you have given us to spread your message;

through Jesus Christ Our Lord, who, frustrating the expectation of his enemies, is alive and reigns with you in the unity of the Holy Spirit, one God, now and for ever. Amen
 


Posted by sacredthree (# 46) on :
 
Hm, we now have two versions of this floating around, the one I compiled and sent to Simon, and the one here.

Never mind, we can continue to tweak it anyway.
 


Posted by babybear (# 34) on :
 
Argh, no 'thee's and 'thou's. People (with a very few local exceptions) have not spoken like that for years and years.

And why make things more 'formal'? I thought that this was to be for personal use.

bb
 


Posted by Joan the Dwarf (# 1283) on :
 
bb - I 'tweaked it for formality' to make it less formal... unless my grasp of the English language has gone completely haywire...
 
Posted by babybear (# 34) on :
 
Nope, just mine.

bb
 


Posted by Carys (# 78) on :
 
Just caught up on this thread.

Re: a canticle what do people think of the following which I wrote at the end of last term. It wasn't written specifically with Christian unrest in mind but it might fit.

God, Creator of all that is,
You cannot be pinned down
Defined, caged in, summed up;
We might try in theology or religion,
To say God is x or y;
He belongs to us;
But you ARE;
Beyond our exclusiveness,
Our cliques, our firm boundaries
Always leading us on,
Pillar of fire or cloud
The wind blowing where it wills
A butterfly calling us onwards
Fluttering just out of our grasp

And yet,
On the cross you were pinned down
Or rather up.
Nailed there, left to die
Dead and buried.
Out of sight,
Gone.

Or so we thought
But, Unpinnabledown God
You could not be contained in that cage of death
Burst from the tomb
Rose Again

Carys
 


Posted by Siegfried (# 29) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Angel of the North:
OK - collected so far:

(The Confession)
...
The Lord forgives; never too much,
never too little.
In the Lord there is perfection and peace.
Be still and receive the forgiveness and peace of the Lord.
{pause}
Accepting that forgiveness we must now move on,
to try again where we have fallen, no matter how often.
In offering forgiveness before we can even ask for it,
the Lord calls us beyond the safety of our failures,
into the unknown depths of God's disturbing love.


I got the sense earlier that the view on this thread was that the section in italics was a bit out of place--I think Joan (who wrote it) said as much her(?)self. I'm just not sure where. But I agree it doesn't quite fit where it is.
 


Posted by Joan the Dwarf (# 1283) on :
 
Yup, and yup
 
Posted by TonyK (# 35) on :
 
Joan - very happy with your adjustments to the collect. Thanks
 
Posted by Carys (# 78) on :
 
Did anyone read my post of 15th October? Or did I just join the thread after everyone had lost interest. I'd like some feedback, please.

Carys
 


Posted by Joan the Dwarf (# 1283) on :
 
I'm sorry Carys, that was rude not to respond to your post. I will do when my brain isn't so completely fried.
 
Posted by Carys (# 78) on :
 
That's okay Joan, I think it some how just got missed but it felt as though I was being ignored and the thread was slipping down the board so I thought I'd kick it up again.

Carys
 


Posted by Stephen (# 40) on :
 
My apologies,too,Carys...I'd completely forgotten about this thread....
FWIW,I think it's quite good....seems to express a lot of what I feel....what do the others think?
 
Posted by sarkycow (# 1012) on :
 
i like what carys wrote, as a piece of writing unfortunately i have no idea what a canticle is (though i prolly would if you started to explain). so i can't really have an opinion on whether it is a good canticle or not - sorry

what is the function of a canticle? where does it fit into the service/liturgy? is it just for the leader to say, or does everyone join in?

thanks,

viki
 


Posted by Carys (# 78) on :
 
quote:
what is the function of a canticle? where does it fit into the service/liturgy? is it just for the leader to say, or does everyone join in?

Not sure I can define a canticle but as no-one else has tried, I'll give it a go.

They tend to be like a psalm but not from the book of psalms (but the Venite is a psalm and used as a canticle in Morning Prayer). Some are biblical, for instance at Evening prayer the commonest canticles are the Magnificat and Nunc Dimitis (they're named after their beginning in Latin, they Mary's song (My soul magnifies the Lord) and the Song of Simeon (Lord now you let your servant depart in peace)). But others were written by the early church like the Te Deum. Not quite sure I'd like to say what makes something a canticle. I've never worked out what to call 'Unpinnabledown God' I just wrote it. It's not exactly a poem nor a meditation.

As too use, they are often sung, either to Anglican chant or to settings. . When chanted often by the whole congregation (not necessarily well) but settings tend to be choir only, but can also be said, often responsively.

Carys
 


Posted by Angel of the North (# 60) on :
 
I was told that canticles are psalms that aren't in the book of psalms, and ought to be - from the apocrypha.

And, babybear, some of us are comfiest with the old forms at times. I've said what I wrote, in thou form, and it feels nicer. Given most of this is in modern english, and is meant to be a fusion of traditions - basically what each of us brings to it.

I use thee and thou, unconsciously, in speech. Trying to think it into coherent written english doesn't happen often, hence the blunder.

I love Carys's piece - I've seen it before, hence not commenting here before now.

Angel
 


Posted by Carys (# 78) on :
 
quote:
Argh, no 'thee's and 'thou's. People (with a very few local exceptions) have not spoken like that for years and years.

No, but they have remained in the liturgy (what does it say about the English that we've lost our familiar pronouns?) and I for one feel that you is colder when someone has 'modernised' something and taken the thee's and thou's out. It is a problem, I just wish English hadn't lost the distinction. Using 'ti' (the Welsh familiar form) to God really brought his nearness home to me, we can be familiar to him. Unfortunately people (like the Trinitarian Bible Society) miss understand this in English.

Carys
 


Posted by babybear (# 34) on :
 
A hostly request:

If people would like to discuss 'thee' and 'thou' then please take it elsewhere for the time being. I really do not feel able to cope with this discussion, yet again, right now.

These particular words tend to bring out the dogmatic side of people (including me). Let's put language issues onto the back burner for a few weeks.

This is merely a request from this particular host.

bb
----
MW Host
 


Posted by Carys (# 78) on :
 
Sorry bb, didn't mean to touch a sore spot. I'll shut up about language (well round here at least, can't escape it most of the time!)

What is happening with the liturgy? s3 has been very quiet round here of late.

Carys
 


Posted by Angel of the North (# 60) on :
 
In the context of the liturgy of unrest only - is the language meant to be in modern english usage, or is it in terms of what we bring to the piece?

Angel
 


Posted by Huw (# 182) on :
 
I was completely unaware of this thread until Angel drew my attention to it. I have really enjoyed reading the contributions - no, enjoyed is not the right word, I have found them inspiring. I didn't know this sort of creativity was on board Ship - I'm very slow sometimes.

How about this as a possible Advent Collect?

Lord Jesus the Christ,
who was content to be born of a woman,
laid in a trough,
and honoured by outcasts,
and who has promised to come again on the clouds
when every eye shall see you;
come to us now.
Open our eyes to see those people that the world casts out,
open our hearts to care for those issues that make us uncomfortable,
open our hands to do the work that you set before us.
Come and disturb us in our comfortable complacency
that we might strive for your righteousness and your kingdom,
and so glorify your holy name.
All this we ask for your love's sake. Amen.

Looks a bit wordy to me - but what do the rest of you think?
 


Posted by Huw (# 182) on :
 
Anyone else out there interested in creating an Advent liturgy? Should a new thread be started? Or has everyone moved on from this area by now?
 
Posted by babybear (# 34) on :
 
<kick>
 
Posted by Lou Poulain (# 1587) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Joan the Dwarf:
One more thing, then I'll shut up -

Could we add something to the absolution, to reflect the fact that forgiveness doesn't just give peace, it can also be hugely challenging as we can't use the excuse "I'll just get it wrong" to not do something?


At our parish the rector adds at the end of absolution words to the effect: "And now, forgive one another.... and forgive yourself.", which think drives to one of the points you made. Self forgiveness IS a challenge.

Lou
 


Posted by MaryO (# 161) on :
 
I once knew a South African priest whose absolution included, "May Almighty God forgive you your sins and set you free from them..."

I really rather like that.
 




© Ship of Fools 2016

Powered by Infopop Corporation
UBB.classicTM 6.5.0